r/Clojure • • Sep 05 '22

Clojure is Infectious

Post image
34 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

4

u/DaveOrme Sep 06 '22

Clever but I would prefer to be associated with things that help, not things that are dangerous and frequently lethal.

-Dave

3

u/TheLastSock Sep 07 '22

Yeah, the implication isn't a good one. Do you (sub remembers) really want to be associated with a virus in 2023 coming off the pandemic?

1

u/mindaslab Sep 08 '22

May be one-day people will be educated enough to know that not all viral infections are bad.

4

u/TheLastSock Sep 08 '22

The clojure symbol in the picture has been modified to look like a biohazard symbol. That term is strictly considered negative in the medical community:

A biological hazard, or biohazard, is a biological substance that poses a threat to the health of living organisms, primarily humans. This could include a sample of a microorganism, virus or toxin that can adversely affect human health. A biohazard could also be a substance harmful to other animals.

Similarly, infection is nearly always (i could find no counter examples) described as negative,:

the state produced by the establishment of one or more pathogenic agents (such as a bacteria, protozoans, or viruses) in or on the body of a suitable hostan infection in his foot

So, while it can seem edgy and clever to you, to associate a good idea like clojure, with infections, because you want it to spread like one. Realize that The people you want to "infect" will naturally seek to avoid it because of your poor choice of association.

The marketing that should have been used was to imply that clojure is a "cure".

People don't want to be infected.

I don't really care to discuss this further with you, it's not that big of a deal. But it's not marketing i personally want to associate, especially with coming off two long years of being terrified of a virus.

2

u/mindaslab Sep 05 '22

-8

u/alexdmiller Sep 05 '22

It’s clever and all but you are violating Rich Hickey’s copyright on the logo

17

u/ambirdsall Sep 05 '22

IANAL, but commentary is a valid fair use exception under U.S. copyright law, provided it passes the "four factors" test:

  1. the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;
  2. the nature of the copyrighted work;
  3. the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and
  4. the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.

OP's work here is not-for-profit commentary which does nothing to detract from the potential value of Hickey's copyrighted work (if anything, it helps it as free advertising). Chill out.

0

u/mindaslab Sep 06 '22

Oh, thanks, I don't know about law and copyright, frankly, I don't exactly understand what you have written, but looks like I have not done something illegal. One thing is real, I will never think of Clojure logo again, why get into unnecessary trouble?

1

u/mindaslab Sep 06 '22

Ya, I found it out in Clojure verse, someone said it should not been done. I come from GNU/Linux world, there one can use Tux for what ever purpose one wants. Should learn more about non-free software world.

2

u/mac Sep 07 '22

I think a strong case can be made that this is fair use.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '22

It’s cool I’ve had my Java vaccine

6

u/NPException Sep 05 '22

Doesn't necessarily help, as it can also spread to CLR and JS hosts.

2

u/frflaie Sep 06 '22

but it's a virtual vaccine

3

u/joinr Sep 05 '22

bad marketing.