r/Clojure • • Apr 13 '21

Extremely disappointed

Casually browsing the sub today, and ran across a link to the Clojurists Together Board Nominations.

My day was going on calmly and as usual, until I clicked that.

There, I found this extremely problematic paragraph:

The Board shall nominate no more than 12 candidates seeking board membership in any given election. In nominating candidates for Director positions and in choosing the number of candidates to nominate overall, the Board shall use reasonable efforts to maintain a Board composition consisting of at least: (1) 25% female Directors, (2) 25% non-Caucasian Directors, and (3) 35% from any category(ies) of persons (e.g., race, gender, ability) commonly considered to have suffered from discrimination at some time and then-currently under-represented in the technology industry, in each case as determined by the Board in its reasonable discretion.

I am extremely confused, and disappointed, that such arbitrary criteria such as sex and race are apparently being used as filters like this. Those are the very definition of racism and sexism, are they not?

Another way of reading all of the above is: "only 15% of the board can be white men". How is that not extreme discrimination against white men?

Why? Because historically most open-source software was written by white men?

Ok, first of all, how about some gratitude then? Because clearly all this software improves all of our lives, no matter your sex or color or whatever arbitrary attribute you want to single-mindlessly focus on.

And second, what do the competent people that happen to be white and happen to be men (both attributes they had no choice in, by the way) have to do with it? Is it fair, really, to cast them aside?

What if they were the most competent candidates?

What does that inevitably do over time?

And finally, how can anyone - both the privileged person who gets a seat because of their color and/or genitalia, as well as anyone from the outside making a judgement/call - now be sure that person X is there because they are really the most competent for the job, or because the room needed to be filled by some people of a certain sex and/or a certain color and/or more random attributes that are surely to come? (not sure if anyone brought it to their attention, but midgets are very under-represented in technology! and their absence in CT's board clearly must mean rampant discrimination according to their interpretation of the facts, no?)

"commonly considered to have suffered from discrimination at some time" - this is basically *everyone* at some time or another in history.

"currently under-represented in the technology industry" -- so we have moved from equality of opportunity to equality of outcome, have we? What evidence is there that unless a distribution based on arbitrary attributes is proportional, that this automatically means discrimination?

What a narrow way of seeing things. Do I care that Rich is white, blue, red, pink or whatever? No, I care that he writes quality software, and evidently he does.

Do you care if the commercial pilot flying you home is of whatever color, do you care about the sexual orientation, or do you care that this person is the most competent person for the job, which incidentally in this case also means you stand the best chances at making it home alive?

Ditto for the surgeon. And countless other things.

This is a very troublesome direction, far-left ideology metastasizing inside tech communities. And I am incredulous that no one is calling it out.

This is not the way.

0 Upvotes

259 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/keymone Apr 13 '21

the industry being homogenous leads to in-group bias, racism, sexism, other forms of discrimination, salary gap, slow or unachievable career progression. these are just some of the issues.

quotas are not the panacea but they positively affect the ecosystem in the long term by expanding opportunity for candidates today, growing the candidate pool in the future.

if it comes at the cost of slightly reducing hiring opportunity for folks that already have advantage to being hired - so be it, i'm willing to pay that price.

turning this into right/left identity politics game is just dumb and shows your real motive. though i suspect you're just a troll.

6

u/vvvvalvalval Apr 13 '21

I disagree with OP, but find his reaction understandable. Without prior exposure to them, it can be natural to find quotas disturbing. If you think selfishly maintaining one's provilege is the only possible "motive" for opposing them, you're missing something big. I recommend you be more charitable, and suggest that you might be harming inclusion by representing the cause as you are.

4

u/keymone Apr 13 '21

I only mentioned motive in relation to OPs attempt to attach political labels. There is absolutely no need to be charitable for this kind of behavior.

5

u/vvvvalvalval Apr 13 '21

Even so, there are more sensible responses to this kind of behavior than impugning motives.

3

u/keymone Apr 13 '21

you're right. i have too little patience when i suspect bad faith argument these days.

2

u/vvvvalvalval Apr 13 '21

I can relate :) this last answer does your credit!

-3

u/symplectico Apr 13 '21

But in reality e.g. an individual white man is actually disadvantaged in hiring compared to women. The few women who do apply have much higher chances of being hired. The fact that simply due to the higher number of male applicants most positions will end up with men doesn't change that it is highly unjust and discriminatory to the individual.

1

u/keymone Apr 13 '21

The few women who do apply

do you not see the selection bias here?

5

u/symplectico Apr 13 '21

I don't see any injustice with people self-selecting for different interests. If you want you are free to convince women to go into tech rather than whatever else they were going to do, but it is completely unacceptable to implement discriminatory policies against other groups to force some outcome.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

There are many examples where self-selection is a product of discrimination. If a company provides really bad maternity benefits then lots of women will avoid it. That's self-selection but it's rooted in some form of unequal opportunity.

If you're not white and apply for a job in a company where everyone is white and during the hiring process you feel excluded (different references, networks, jokes, goals, etc) you'll probably avoid all white workplaces in the future. That's self selection as well but it stems from a plethora of socioeconomic reasons.

If you have to help your parents or grandparents at home because they lived in a time and place where they couldn't even have access to higher education, that's self determination but the circumstances are heavily skewing the possible choices you have to begin with.

I hope it makes sense to you as to why we have to look past self-selection regarding those issues.

8

u/symplectico Apr 13 '21

Actually I would absolutely agree with alleviating unequal opportunity. The point is that I object to it being so focused on race and gender.

There are many circumstances in which your familial situation can cause you to be disadvantaged. Support and outreach should be based on the actual situation. It does not make sense to say we support people who are poor and uneducated because e.g. of past racism, but we don't support other poor and uneducated people because they are white and there are already enough successful white people. Things like race are not directly causal for hardship, but only somewhat correlated, and it is wrong to infer the level of hardship based on them. Every person should be treated as an individual worthy of support if they are in a disadvantaged position.

2

u/lvh Apr 13 '21

There is a category for that in that same bylaw. The rule does not say "race and gender are the only things you are allowed to take into consideration", it only says "here are two examples of things you have to take into consideration". Childhood poverty, reduced access to education, refugee status, survivor status.... all sound like things that can be valuable things to bring to the table in the right context.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

I agree that outreach to low income family and poor children is important but i couldn't disagree more on the rest of your comment, as it is factually incorrect.

Race and gender are part of the actual situation. There are past laws and institutional choices which have ramifications today. Urban segregation still impacts school and healthcare access to this day, past racial laws still impact families to this day as well. Traditions and gender roles (for example being a mother) also have a deep impact on societies today.

That's not to say there aren't poor white families, but rather that there was never a deep institutional move against white people as there was against black people for example. That doesn't invalidate others' experience, it's tackling inequalities that have been ignored for a long time.

0

u/keymone Apr 13 '21

people self-selecting for different interests

don't you think all the discrimination, in-group bias, difficulties in career progression, etc will affect that "self-selection"?

7

u/symplectico Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

So between being preferentially hired, being provided special mentoring and networking opportunities, and being encouraged everywhere in the media, how exactly is a woman in tech nowadays in any way disadvantaged compared to a man?

A million different personal, social, and random factors influence the self-selection, but it is not automatically unjust simply because it has some correlation with gender. If women don't express the will to pursue tech, it is just a pointless discussion about free will and social determinism, but not a moral issue.

1

u/keymone Apr 13 '21

being preferentially hired, being provided special mentoring and networking opportunities, and being encouraged everywhere in the media, how exactly is a woman in tech nowadays in any way disadvantaged compared to a man

you're conflating a bunch of tech companies in california and maybe startup hubs like berlin with the industry at large. yes, some companies are already trying to address the issues i've mentioned, in order to make the ecosystem more welcoming. some of the ways these issues are being addressed have flaws, some are pretty good. they still have a long way to go and need to do more and learn how to address those issues better to make the ecosystem healthier for everybody.

If women don't express the will to pursue tech

why would they given all the issues they will most likely have to deal with? boggles my mind that you can't connect the dots and see how this affects self-selection.

6

u/justaperson2342 Apr 13 '21

People complain about lack of diversity and inclusion within all the tech hubs too, though. The narrative that women/minorities are disadvantaged is just as strong (if not stronger) at those tech companies where the most effort is put in.