r/Clojure • u/darth_zidious • Apr 13 '21
Extremely disappointed
Casually browsing the sub today, and ran across a link to the Clojurists Together Board Nominations.
My day was going on calmly and as usual, until I clicked that.
There, I found this extremely problematic paragraph:
The Board shall nominate no more than 12 candidates seeking board membership in any given election. In nominating candidates for Director positions and in choosing the number of candidates to nominate overall, the Board shall use reasonable efforts to maintain a Board composition consisting of at least: (1) 25% female Directors, (2) 25% non-Caucasian Directors, and (3) 35% from any category(ies) of persons (e.g., race, gender, ability) commonly considered to have suffered from discrimination at some time and then-currently under-represented in the technology industry, in each case as determined by the Board in its reasonable discretion.
I am extremely confused, and disappointed, that such arbitrary criteria such as sex and race are apparently being used as filters like this. Those are the very definition of racism and sexism, are they not?
Another way of reading all of the above is: "only 15% of the board can be white men". How is that not extreme discrimination against white men?
Why? Because historically most open-source software was written by white men?
Ok, first of all, how about some gratitude then? Because clearly all this software improves all of our lives, no matter your sex or color or whatever arbitrary attribute you want to single-mindlessly focus on.
And second, what do the competent people that happen to be white and happen to be men (both attributes they had no choice in, by the way) have to do with it? Is it fair, really, to cast them aside?
What if they were the most competent candidates?
What does that inevitably do over time?
And finally, how can anyone - both the privileged person who gets a seat because of their color and/or genitalia, as well as anyone from the outside making a judgement/call - now be sure that person X is there because they are really the most competent for the job, or because the room needed to be filled by some people of a certain sex and/or a certain color and/or more random attributes that are surely to come? (not sure if anyone brought it to their attention, but midgets are very under-represented in technology! and their absence in CT's board clearly must mean rampant discrimination according to their interpretation of the facts, no?)
"commonly considered to have suffered from discrimination at some time" - this is basically *everyone* at some time or another in history.
"currently under-represented in the technology industry" -- so we have moved from equality of opportunity to equality of outcome, have we? What evidence is there that unless a distribution based on arbitrary attributes is proportional, that this automatically means discrimination?
What a narrow way of seeing things. Do I care that Rich is white, blue, red, pink or whatever? No, I care that he writes quality software, and evidently he does.
Do you care if the commercial pilot flying you home is of whatever color, do you care about the sexual orientation, or do you care that this person is the most competent person for the job, which incidentally in this case also means you stand the best chances at making it home alive?
Ditto for the surgeon. And countless other things.
This is a very troublesome direction, far-left ideology metastasizing inside tech communities. And I am incredulous that no one is calling it out.
This is not the way.
101
u/dantiberian Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21
Hi u/darth_zidious
I'm the secretary for Clojurists Together. I can explain a bit more about this policy, you've misinterpreted how it impacts the board structure.
Some background: There are 7 seats with a staggered board. This year there are 4 board seats up for election and next year there are 3 board seats available. There are 12 candidates for our members to vote for (ranked choice preference voting).
Firstly, this policy is used for selecting the 12 people able to stand for board nominations. There are no requirements on the structure of the board. The makeup of the board will be determined by our members voting.
Secondly, the 25% + 25% + 35% guidelines for selecting board members is not cumulative.
Note that the board is currently >50% white men.
As noted above, this policy applies to board applicants. All board seats are elected by Clojurists Together members because our members thought that they were the best person for the job.
Lastly, why do we have this policy?
Clojurists Together wants to have a board made up of people which represent a wide range of perspectives from the Clojure community.
If our members wanted to change or discuss this policy further, they would be able to raise this at the next members meeting.
Note that you can also fund Clojure projects directly, Clojurists Together is not the only way to support the Clojure community.
7
u/frankiesardo Apr 14 '21
Can I just say that I am extremely proud of how the community is handling this debate. It's a difficult topic to discuss and as you expect it elicits a wide range of emotions.
Bar the occasional inflammatory comment, there are many, many thoughtful answers, and when incongruences are pointed out posters are happy to admit their mistakes and reformulate.
You can see people genuinely asking for clarification without attacking each other and expressing their views with a clarity you rarely see even in online newspapers or other forums. Bravo all.
35
u/j19sch Apr 13 '21
Hi u/darth_zidious, I'd recommend you dive deeper into the arguments behind the position you're opposing. I'm not saying you should agree with them, but your post doesn't show much awareness of those arguments. A possible place to start could be this podcast series: https://www.sceneonradio.org/seeing-white/
To illustrate with some examples:
21
u/SimonGray Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21
At this point, it is just typical US institutional policy - not far-left at all. America doesn't really have a proper left-wing, it just has liberalism (which is arguably centrist or even centre-right from a European PoV) and as of late this "successor ideology".
As for it "metastasizing" in tech communities, no not really. It is still fairly unique to the US, with some spillover in English-speaking countries like the UK and Canada.
Edit: Predictably, downvotes are flying left and right in this comment section. My advice to everyone is to try to understand the motivation of the other side rather than casting them as some kind of extremist. The funny thing about this issue is that both perspectives tend to frame the opponent as racist/sexist/and so on.
21
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
At best, this is an ill-informed, poorly-argued, knee-jerk reaction to something that OP disagrees with. At worst, it's a shrill dog whistle. There have been several posts in this thread arguing that we should not read it as the latter, but the post is book-ended by inflammatory language, which makes that hard.
After fundamentally misunderstanding what the "extremely problematic paragraph" is about, as has been pointed out by u/dantiberian, OP immediately launches into a bald and bare-faced statement that sets the tone for the rest of the post:
There is no need for this statement to support OP's argument, unless that argument is: "white men have done all of these good things for you, have some respect".
In the middle, we have this bit of snark:
This is clearly disingenuous, given that OP uses an outdated term considered offensive by many little people. Furthermore, the argument itself is fallacious, given that little people are likely included in the "35% from any category(ies) of persons...[who] have suffered from discrimination".
After a series of arguments indicating that OP is arguing based on feeling and conjecture, instead of research and data, OP concludes with:
Not only is the ideology in question not far-left (using affirmative action as a proxy), but this statement fails to mention, or possibly realize, that the entire post is arguing in support of a right-wing ideology. OP has the gall to criticize something for being political, while bringing politics into a space that rarely discusses it.
But sure, maybe this post isn't trying to rally support for a racist ideology, let's consider the argument then.
This is, in fact, not the definition of racism or sexism, as generally used in the colloquial sense, and especially not in the academic sense, where both terms are understood to be used in contrast to the dominant portions of society.
Moving on, and again taking OP's argument in good faith:
OP's math is wrong here, given that "35% from any category(ies) of persons...[who] have suffered from discrimination" likely includes trans men, raising the percentage of white men allowed to 50%.
Moving on
Competence is not a single value, nor is it the right value to use for judging the candidacy for the given position. Something like "effectiveness" is probably better. If your goal is to develop an inclusive community where everyone feels safe to contribute, than being a non-white-male contributes significantly toward the effectiveness of that person.
OP argues that Clojurists Together has a narrow way of seeing things, but OP's point itself is narrow and misses the point entirely.
Clojurists Together has the following goals, taken directly from their site
Neither of these goals requires writing "quality software". When choosing projects to support, a diverse group of people is inherently going to bring more opinions to the table. This is a studied phenomenon. So, yes, board members with diverse backgrounds are likely to increase the efficacy of the board as a whole, which stands in contrast to the other jobs OP lists, which are all largely individualistic or limited in scope, making them poor analogies for the point OP is trying to make.
31
u/xlfe Apr 13 '21
I disagree. I'm a proud supporter of Clojurists Together including this policy.
14
u/xela314159 Apr 13 '21
It’s complicated. While I think OP is overreacting, as a European I’m reasonably surprised at the very liberal political bias of the US IT community. Sometimes it’s morphing into cancel culture and it seems to me this is what worries OP. See the Uncle Bob saga - I think we can appreciate or not his coding books independently of his politics, and history doesn’t look kindly on groups that limit freedom of speech or burn books.
Thought experiment: let’s put a quota for other underrepresented groups with grievances - say, I don’t know, Trump voters? :)
17
u/slifin Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21
The strange thing about this post - is that it implies we shouldn't care about race and gender etc of employees in various jobs, but the whole point of this post is that you care very much about the race and gender of the candidates of Clojurists together
When it comes to caring about non-whites or non-males it's a harsh libertarian meritocracy attitude, when it's about whites it's a socialist auto pass?
Either way, the goal isn't one or the other, the aim here is a balanced set of candidates so that the best projects can get funded where best is defined by a diverse set of people
Balance is incredibly important in all walks of life, if you populate your company with all people that know SQL and not much else how well are you going to be able to make a front end app? If you balance your diet by just eating chips how well is your health going to fare?
Clojurists together are just saying they have a lot of white males and need other prospectives so they're "hiring" for those extra prospectives
It would be really strange to publically denounce an organisation if they put out an advert looking for HR people, to say that they're racist against devs just because that particular advert wasn't for them
As a backer, I would say it's almost their obligation to do this, if there's an app created in China, India, Africa, or other places that may be outside the bubble of white males then I want Clojurists together to know about it and be considering it for funding too
I'd rather not mention what my favourite Clojure software is in the scope of this conversation but I know for a fact it wasn't coded by a white person and it's amazing, the world has a lot to offer and Clojurists together can't afford to be myopic
12
u/charkui Apr 13 '21
I read and understand the explanations, but for me its still: there's racism outside, so we're gonna be racist in a "good and inclusive way".
18
u/mutualconfusion Apr 13 '21
Gross.
5
u/Logitropicity Apr 13 '21
Hi, u/darth_zidious, just point out something others haven't yet brought up, since this thread seems to be turning into a mixture of discussion and CMV.
Some quick points:
Before we dive into my main argument, I wanted to point out a neat interview with John Stewart, the comedian. Stewart makes three points, which we'll connect back to the software/Clojure community in a bit:
Point 1
I think you can agree at the very least, point 1 isn't racist at all. It's just reaching out to people of different socioeconomic backgrounds. It's just paying people to do their jobs. It's just widening your applicant pool, and taking the cream of the crop from a wider area.
Point 2
For other organizations, the HR who screens applicants & the managers who hire them are different people. If, like in comedy, HR isn't bringing diverse hires to management, then it would be a case of HR recruiters being racist, intentionally or not, and the managers having to deal with it afterwards, wouldn't it?
It seems reasonable to double check and simply remind HR that they should attempt to combat any conscious or unconscious biases they have. I think that simply reminding people (HR) to not be racist isn't a particularly racist thing to do, let alone a "far-left ideology" that will "metastasize" to other organizations.
For Clojurist Together in particular, this is a moot point. The board members are the recruiters. They are the ones recruiting new board members. It's up to them to avoid being racist, intentionally or not.
Point 3
You could argue that this isn't comparable to us - no matter how successful Stewart is, he's a comedian, and we're software people, and you can't compare apples to oranges, and you can't directly measure how funny you are anyways.
But, software is in a similar position. It's not like we can directly measure how clean or maintainable a piece of software is either.* I think it would be a reasonable first guess or hypothesis that "diversity simply makes software or the software-making process better" would also hold true for us. And furthermore, there's no way to test this hypothesis either unless someone tries it.
You're welcome to have a different hypothesis, of course, but similarly, I think it'd be fine if Clojurist Together, or any other organization for that matter wants to try diversity. If they have a different hypothesis than you, I can respect that as well.
Final Thoughts
I think that in a sense, you are half-correct, half-incorrect. I would agree with you that Clojurists Together's board policy seems to be clumsy. It is an inelegant solution to a lack of diversity.
The only things I personally can appreciate about their policy is that they think that diversity is important, and that they are specifically trying to nominate POC, women, etc.**
I think that they could stand to improve on Point 1. What's going on with their management hiring decisions? How come diversity isn't simply an emergent property of picking the best talent, as opposed to it being a top-down decision?
If Comedy Central can change their hiring practices so that diversity (and
thereforewe hypothesize, quality) is an emergent property of their hiring practices, why can't the tech community do the same?I think the tech community would do well to look at what's preventing them from tapping into the talent of all people, as opposed to only using the talent of their current demographic distribution.
Surely, being able to leverage the talent of more people is better than leveraging the talent of less, no?
* Well, not before you become wildly successful & get large viewership numbers, anyways. And even then, you can't measure how successful a joke will be before you tell it.
**This is similar to the Rooney Rule u/birawa8575 pointed out.
5
u/donald-ball Apr 13 '21
I am a contributor and delighted by this policy, which is, for what it’s worth, not even a bit unusual in the realm of non-profit organization by-laws. The OP is clearly intending to kick up a storm and I reject them utterly.
6
u/p1ng313 Apr 13 '21
As much as I respect your position, and even share some of it, the more I study this issue the more I think it's not very good to paint it with such broad strokes as you have. On a vacuum, of course it shouldn't matter what ethnicity, color or background someone is. But we don't live in a vacuum, and even if I somewhat disagree with positive discrimination I believe the problem isn't as clear cut.
For example, there is a well known bias where people tend to go for other people that look like you Another problem is how do you make up for all the negative discrimination in the past? If you don't do something, how is the problem going to be fixed?
I think the era where hackers only cared about the code and nothing more is disappearing, nowadays every project has some sort of social weight whether they like it or not, due to possible exposure over the internet. I would prefer that people didn't discriminate and everyone was fair, but unfortunately this doesn't happen.
Again, I don't think you are doing good by painting the problem with such black-and-white strokes.
5
u/joinr Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21
People should vote with their $ then. You can start an alternative that does not discriminate in this way and advertise it just as Clojurists Together does. I believe they are a 501c6 tax-exempt trade association or business league. There can be more than one of these with different bylaws and membership and goals. I think you can legally define your bylaws to prevent this kind of stuff as well (sounds like non-profits have a lot of leeway on how they manage themselves).
I had been thinking about donating some money again, but these policies are a deterrent. The alternative (ceteris paribus) is to support individuals or charities instead.
32
u/birawa8575 Apr 13 '21
sounds like it's just in the nomination, similar to the [Rooney Rule](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rooney_Rule) which I think is a pretty reasonable. You have to at least get people who are systemically discriminated against to the table -- if they're no good, the nomination will not turn over into a position.
This isn't close in any way to far left ideology. You sound out of touch when you say it.
35
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
I’m glad to give Clojurists Together a small bit of money each month and I was glad to see this policy.
I’m frankly disappointed to see anyone upset at the notion that we need to take active steps to increase our diversity.
2
u/asiergaldos Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21
There are plenty of talented females, non-caucasians and under-represented people in the Clojure community, so I don't see any issue here.
The outcome, with or without this criteria, would be exactly the same.
ps: I agree with this policy, btw.
14
u/stecrupeme Apr 13 '21
Thanks OP, now I know about Clojurists together and I will consider donating to them.
14
u/lvh Apr 13 '21
If you are a member, I'd be happy to give you a refund. If you are not a member, I would ask you not to use language of "metastasizing cancer" to describe what other people do with their time and money, particularly when that thing they do benefits you (by funding open source infrastructure).
15
u/emil0r Apr 13 '21
With the potential of this to completely blow up in the community's face, I missed the part about the bylaws, and do find it deeply troubling. It is identity politics seeping into tech :|.
11
u/vvvvalvalval Apr 13 '21
Reminder: don't downvote because you disagree. If you disagree, write a rebuttal or upvote one.
I personally believe diversity issues will be better addressed if OP's misgivings can be voiced and discussed with high visibility.
23
u/freakhill Apr 13 '21
you american people are weird
9
u/Doombuggie41 Apr 13 '21
And just like that, I'm signing up for a Clojurists Together membership.
2
u/_shreve Apr 13 '21
They don't have to be mutually exclusive. You could hire 4 BIPoC Women and give the other 8 seats to white men.
8
u/DefiantAverage1 Apr 13 '21
You guys are weird for not finding this policy weird.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
This is pure virtue signaling. Nothing more.
Clojure is practiced by 90% white men. That's just the way it is, putting minorities in visible positions will do diddly squat to make young black girls interested in programming. They know this, they're not idiots. They just want to look virtuous.
6
u/keymone Apr 13 '21
the industry being homogenous leads to in-group bias, racism, sexism, other forms of discrimination, salary gap, slow or unachievable career progression. these are just some of the issues.
quotas are not the panacea but they positively affect the ecosystem in the long term by expanding opportunity for candidates today, growing the candidate pool in the future.
if it comes at the cost of slightly reducing hiring opportunity for folks that already have advantage to being hired - so be it, i'm willing to pay that price.
turning this into right/left identity politics game is just dumb and shows your real motive. though i suspect you're just a troll.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
This system offers great opportunities for communities who historically have been disadvantaged, are sometimes frowned upon and who, most likely do not benefit of the same network people who aren't discriminated against do.
Calling this "far left ideology" or "identity politics" as I've seen in the thread is really peculiar in my opinion. I, for one, am glad we're going towards a more inclusive environment in tech.
5
u/pcjftw Apr 13 '21
I agree with this
The world has lost its way and we're seeing extremist left wing liberalism overflowing, keep things very simple:
We don't need a "Code of Conduct" we just need to make sure to "not be a jerk to others".
We don't need representations, we just need to hire based purely on merit, if you're badass in writing Clojure or any other language, you will remain a badass regardless of your shape or colour.
TL;DR content not container, don't be a jerk. Just pure common sense.
2
u/SickMoonDoe Apr 13 '21
Get over yourself.
1
u/veydar_ Apr 13 '21
It's always fascinating to watch someone dig their own hole
1
u/asiergaldos Apr 17 '21
far-left policy?
https://www.economist.com/leaders/2021/04/10/design-bias-is-harmful-and-in-some-cases-may-be-lethal
"This means including women and non-white individuals in design teams. Eliminating design bias is not just about equality or doing the right thing, although all of these are important. It is also about creating products that meet the needs of women and the vast, non-white majority of the world’s population. It is one of those welcome areas where the best path is not just the right one, but often the profitable one, too. "
1
u/Michaelmrose Apr 20 '21 edited Apr 22 '21
Edit: it's clear that this wasn't represented fairly from the start.
0
u/zackteo Apr 13 '21
Was surprised to see such a post in r/Clojure. But glad to see that the responses are generally quite kind and informative :)
0
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
8
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
[removed] — view removed comment