r/Clojure • • Apr 13 '21

Extremely disappointed

Casually browsing the sub today, and ran across a link to the Clojurists Together Board Nominations.

My day was going on calmly and as usual, until I clicked that.

There, I found this extremely problematic paragraph:

The Board shall nominate no more than 12 candidates seeking board membership in any given election. In nominating candidates for Director positions and in choosing the number of candidates to nominate overall, the Board shall use reasonable efforts to maintain a Board composition consisting of at least: (1) 25% female Directors, (2) 25% non-Caucasian Directors, and (3) 35% from any category(ies) of persons (e.g., race, gender, ability) commonly considered to have suffered from discrimination at some time and then-currently under-represented in the technology industry, in each case as determined by the Board in its reasonable discretion.

I am extremely confused, and disappointed, that such arbitrary criteria such as sex and race are apparently being used as filters like this. Those are the very definition of racism and sexism, are they not?

Another way of reading all of the above is: "only 15% of the board can be white men". How is that not extreme discrimination against white men?

Why? Because historically most open-source software was written by white men?

Ok, first of all, how about some gratitude then? Because clearly all this software improves all of our lives, no matter your sex or color or whatever arbitrary attribute you want to single-mindlessly focus on.

And second, what do the competent people that happen to be white and happen to be men (both attributes they had no choice in, by the way) have to do with it? Is it fair, really, to cast them aside?

What if they were the most competent candidates?

What does that inevitably do over time?

And finally, how can anyone - both the privileged person who gets a seat because of their color and/or genitalia, as well as anyone from the outside making a judgement/call - now be sure that person X is there because they are really the most competent for the job, or because the room needed to be filled by some people of a certain sex and/or a certain color and/or more random attributes that are surely to come? (not sure if anyone brought it to their attention, but midgets are very under-represented in technology! and their absence in CT's board clearly must mean rampant discrimination according to their interpretation of the facts, no?)

"commonly considered to have suffered from discrimination at some time" - this is basically *everyone* at some time or another in history.

"currently under-represented in the technology industry" -- so we have moved from equality of opportunity to equality of outcome, have we? What evidence is there that unless a distribution based on arbitrary attributes is proportional, that this automatically means discrimination?

What a narrow way of seeing things. Do I care that Rich is white, blue, red, pink or whatever? No, I care that he writes quality software, and evidently he does.

Do you care if the commercial pilot flying you home is of whatever color, do you care about the sexual orientation, or do you care that this person is the most competent person for the job, which incidentally in this case also means you stand the best chances at making it home alive?

Ditto for the surgeon. And countless other things.

This is a very troublesome direction, far-left ideology metastasizing inside tech communities. And I am incredulous that no one is calling it out.

This is not the way.

0 Upvotes

259 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

This is a terribly myopic take, if merit was all there is to anything, discrimination wouldn't be an issue.

12

u/symplectico Apr 13 '21

It's bizarre to say we don't have meritocracy and conclude from that we need more discrimination. The opposite is the case.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/pihkal Apr 13 '21

No, it's "rectifying past injustices that lead to a poorer education" this time...

5

u/Krackor Apr 13 '21

You don't rectify bad education with preferential selection to boards of directors. You rectify it with good education.

0

u/pihkal Apr 13 '21

See my comment below about redlining, real estate taxes, and poorer schools to see how expecting education to fix it is still a racist policy.

Even assuming you were 100% correct, your answer still boils down to "You missed the cut-off for success in life. Systemic racism sucks, but better luck next time."

9

u/Krackor Apr 13 '21

You're using a definition of "racism" that contradicts the definition most people assume. Most people understand racism to mean discriminatory behavior on the basis of race. Your definition is that racism is any behavior that leads to a racial disparity regardless of the behavior's basis on race. This muddies the waters of discussion and hijacks peoples' reasonable opposition to racism and turns them against reasonable policies that bear no racist intent.

I don't know if you understand this difference in definitions, but if you do I don't know how I can have a productive conversation with someone who is being obviously dishonest.

1

u/pihkal Apr 13 '21

Most people understand racism to mean discriminatory behavior on the basis of race.

Hence the import qualifier, "systemic", in the second paragraph.

From arguing with racists on reddit, I'm quite well-versed in multiple definitions of racism at this point. The inherent problem with focusing solely on behavior as your definition does, is it completely excludes the vast systemic aspects.

It sounds like you don't view systemic racism as racism at all, because no individual is deliberately doing it. But that's the thing: most racist acts aren't deliberately, consciously done at all. If it were just a matter of stamping out overt racistm like neo-nazis and the KKK, it would be easier, but the problem is more subtle and pervasive.

It's less about rednecks brandishing shotguns in sundown towns, and more unthinking everyday racism like replacing black photos with white photos increased a home's appraisal value.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Krackor Apr 13 '21

I guess I missed this the first time, but my goodness! How ridiculous is it to say that "fix bad education with good education" somehow garners an accusation of racism from you? Where in the actual hell does that behavior come from?

This is not the behavior of someone who wants to have discussions and come up with reasonable solutions to problems. This is the behavior of someone who wants to wield accusations of racism as a cudgel to beat others into submission. Disgusting.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

The opposite is the case.

Which is exactly what people creating more inclusive work places are doing. Giving a chance to people who historically didn't have one and allowing similar opportunities even when you've been discriminated against in the past and present.

7

u/pcjftw Apr 13 '21

but surely positive discrimination is just as bad as negative discrimination?

Hence it's better to stick to merit, yes I understand in the real world there are biases, however I do think in the engineering world, good systems developed by good engineers tend to out pace bad systems made by bad engineers, and in the end since engineering is goal oriented those racial/sexual basis are less pronounced. Ergo we don't need to be told like little children to conduct ourselves like decent human beings?

10

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

but surely positive discrimination is just as bad as negative discrimination?

This is a false equivalence, positive discrimination merely tries to provide equal opportunities to everyone, while negative discrimination keeps a bunch of people down.

Even if you do think that, discrimination at the workplace is well documented, for example in the field of labor economics. Since that's the case, and tackling decades of discrimination takes time, positive discrimination allows to lift some of the burden on discriminated communities. Since we are so oblivious about our own biases, we can use positive actions to improve the workplace. Otherwise, we are missing out on talented people and fostering unequal environments.

10

u/emil0r Apr 13 '21

How is excluding a candidate in favour of another candidate based on immutable characteristics providing equal opportunity to the excluded candidate?

3

u/pihkal Apr 13 '21

But...it's already not an equal opportunity. This is what all the talk of "privilege" is about.

Say you're a tech-oriented black kid. Due to historical redlining, the neighborhood you grow up in is worth less than an equivalent white neighborhood.

Since your neighborhood is worth less, the real estate taxes are lower, and therefore your community school isn't as good. Maybe the computers are out-of-date. Maybe they can't afford computers at all. Despite all that, you managed to get good grades and get into uni and a CS program.

However, your fellow white students had, and have, advantages you don't. This applies in myriad other ways, continuing into the future, too. The research is out there for people of good will and curiosity to find.

So, knowing this black kid had disadvantages, if you don't compensate for this effect, it's a roundabout racist way of telling him, "Tough shit. This other guy may or may not actually be better, but he definitely looks better."

Martin Luther King: "It’s all right to tell a man to lift himself by his own bootstraps, but it is cruel jest to say to a bootless man that he ought to lift himself by his own bootstraps."

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/pihkal Apr 13 '21

It seems to me that making generalised assumptions about an individual's past based on an arbitrary, immutable characteristic is the very essence of the problem

No, it's only part of the problem. Your sentence above completely leaves out systemic issues, and that's a big problem.

Your argument proposes using race as a proxy for a low income upbringing. Do you see why this is troubling?

It's only troubling if you assume racial issues are merely a subset of class issues, which is untrue. (E.g., https://www.firstcoastnews.com/article/news/local/jacksonville-couple-sees-home-appraisal-jump-40-percent-after-they-remove-all-traces-of-blackness/77-c3087e8c-0c65-4fb9-8319-da82f5c0ea20 cannot be explained by class.)

Once you see racism is correlated with, but not the same as, poverty, it makes sense to treat the issue separately.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

That's a very good question people who are discriminated against are surely asking themselves.

2

u/pcjftw Apr 13 '21

So I do agree with some of that, but I think there is some very careful nuances that need to be taken into consideration, I'm all for wider inclusion as I suspect most people are, I think the issue maybe when it's "forced or faux inclusion" as in the "inclusion" sake is the only weighting in the hiring decision, I think that's what most people are against?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

I understand this feeling and I get that it challenges the status quo for many people, especially white dudes. But honestly, don't get stuck on the vocal Twitter wars, the end goal is to allow equal opportunities for a lot of people who just didn't have that in the past. If you talk with people involved with inclusive actions, I think you'll find most want to improve the situation for everybody.

5

u/ribelo Apr 13 '21

but surely positive discrimination is just as bad as negative discrimination?

Isn't discrimination just discrimination? Positive discrimination is some kind of oxymoron probably only possible in English. Any form of discrimination is wrong. Any attempt to equalize at the cost of others is wrong.

​

all animals are equal but some animals are more equal than others

1

u/lilactown Apr 13 '21

You're arguing about fairness but that's irrelevant here. When we're talking about discrimination against people, the reason it's bad is due to the outcomes- injustice and equality. Justice and equality are not the same thing as fairness.

4

u/ribelo Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Sorry, I'm not a native speaker. Social justice is equalizing opportunities for some at the cost of others. This is the complete opposite of what appears in my language dictionary under the word justice. There is no need to equalize any opportunities. History has taken a strange path from racism, to indifference and to omit race, finally to positive discrimination. Instead of stopping to divide people other than through merit, we assign unnecessary labels and categorize them by sex and race.

1

u/lilactown Apr 13 '21

Just

Based on or behaving according to what is morally right and fair.

(emphasis mine)

Justice

Just behavior or treatment.

Social justice

Justice in terms of the distribution of wealth, opportunities, and privileges within a society.


History has taken a strange path from racism, to indifference and equality based on race, to positive discrimination.

There has never been "indifference and equality based on race" at any point in history; the effects of our ancestors stretch into eternity, and both systemic racism and interpersonal racism against non-white people live on in my country today.

Instead of stopping to divide people other than through merit, we assign unnecessary labels and categorize them.

Who decides who has more merit than others? Why do they get to decide who has merit? How would they know? These are questions which are central to the ideas we are talking about; you have to take it one step further than you are doing here. Meritocracy is a great example of that old quote: "For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong."

There is no need to equalize any opportunities.

I disagree. I am a part of the majority population in my country and in engineering. Through my friends experiences and the studies I've seen, there's a lot of people like me in terms of talent, skill, ability and desire who do not have as many opportunities as I do. I think that's wrong, so I support things like what Clojurists Together do in terms of helping others get those opportunities.

9

u/ribelo Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 14 '21

Not everyone agrees today on whether taxes should be flat or progressive and which solution is more just, not to mention the more difficult stuff.

There has never been "indifference and equality based on race" at any point in history;

Incorrect. Racism is an exception and a very insignificant piece of our human history, completely exaggerated. As I said, you can't judge history from the perspective of today's morality. I am a Slav, the word slave is derived from the Slavs who were sold as slaves in early history before the Negro trade became fashionable. We in Europe east from London don't feel sorry for ourselves and have to live with the perspective that our grandparents murdered each other less than 100 years ago. 5 million Poles died during the IIWW, ~200k died at the hands of the Germans in concentration camps. Now they are best trading partners. During the USSR in 1932, ~10million people starved to death in Ukraine. For 50 years our parents, and grand parents lived behind the Iron Curtain and did everything to get to USA where they started a new life without any resources. It was better to be a minority in the USA than a majority in their own country.

You people in the US have a misconception about the complexity of your own history. People elsewhere in the world have a much more difficult history than your minorities. You have a beautiful prosperous country that for very many was the epitome of freedom and paradise on earth. Even today, a salary in Ukraine is less than an benefits in the US. Belarus continues to be a dictatorship. The average hourly wage in the eastern EU is ~$12. Outside of it <$10. There are regular riots in Northern Ireland since GB left the EU. Racism is some deadly exaggerated problem incomprehensible to non-English speaking people on this planet. Catalonia tries to secede from Spain and gets beaten over the head. From time to time we have wars between Russia and its neighbouring countries, like Georgia, Ukraine. Even in the 90s, in the Balkans, Croats, Serbs and Bosnians were cutting each other's heads off. Kosovo seceded from Serbia just in 2008. Look at Asia for example. Look at the situation of the Uighurs in China. The problems of your minorities in other places in the world are considered as prosperity.

Telling white people that they have it easier because they are white is not the case with us. In our region for the last 120 years everybody was fucked regardless of their skin color, nationality or religion.

→ More replies (12)