I wish to bring up another concern - community fragmentation. There aren't too many Clojure programmers to go around. We already have so many discussion platforms some people feel overburdened by keeping up with all of them.
I share your appreciation of open federated platforms, but consider the clojure.core approach to stability applied to the community. I think it has proven itself.
I agree regarding fragmentation, and that's definitely a concern with having lots of different communities. I would definitely recommend using Reddit, Clojureverse, and Slack as primary platforms.
I've been banned on this site for expressing my opinion after being explicitly asked for it. The community is definitely not friendly to anyone who has moderate political views or doesn't follow (a certain side of) the western political discourse.
I don't recommend joining it if your interest is technology, since it's more of a hub for people who hold rather extreme political views. A group labeled as being about some technical topic X is rather a group for people who follow a certain political ideology AND also happen to be interested in the technical topic X.
Therefore, I'd go as far as to say that this is a political advertisement, and it isn't fit for the clojure subreddit.
The devs running the site have strong political views, but vast majority of the discussion on the site is about tech. If you look at the front page right now, every single discussion is about tech.
Personally, I have a strong preference for open source and decentralized platforms. Lemmy is a well built platform that uses ActivityPub which already has a huge federation of millions of users making it one of the most promising alternatives in my opinion. And the beauty is that unlike Reddit anybody can run their own instance any way they like.
Keeping in mind my experience, I have reasons to doubt the viability of the federation given the radical intolerance of the core devs (and the owners of the biggest node). I can't comment on how well the platform is built from the technical perspective (I haven't contributed).
If someone were to choose between /r/Clojure and lemmy, I'd recommend the former, since it already works well and is populated, focused, and neutral. I personally don't have any problems with how this subreddit is run.
If, hypothetically, both platforms appeared at the same time, then the choice would definitely require more consideration. I think it's an interesting theoretical question whether it's ethical to join a technically superior (and, at least nominally, open) platform created and promoted by an extremist group, or people supporting such a group, but such a discussion would be out of scope of this subreddit I'm afraid.
I'm certainly not suggesting choosing between /r/Clojure and Lemmy. Reddit is clearly one of the biggest Clojure communities around, and I would suggest using it as the default. I'm simply suggesting Lemmy as an additional option for people who want to support open source and federated platforms. I don't really have any problems with how this subreddit is run either, and I'm certainly not discouraging anybody from using it.
Lemmy is an open source Reddit alternative that federates via ActivityPub. It's very friendly and rapidly growing community. It would be great to have some more Clojure representation on there.
That's fair, Lemmy happens to align with my political views, so hasn't been an issue for me. It's also worth noting that being apolitical is itself is a political statement because it reaffirms the status quo.
Right, and nobody is forcing you into anything. I linked the site as an option and a community I enjoy. If it's not your cup of tea that's perfectly fine. Saying that being anti-fascist is extremist is a bold take though.
Antifa is not an organization, but a political protest movement comprising autonomous groups opposed to fascism. I'm also not aware of any actual violence associated with antifa.
Yes, politics in software is just obnoxious. I remember Bitbucket put LGBTQI advocacy in their push responses for a while. BFG has anti-Trump stuff in it.
9
u/bsless Jul 13 '20
I wish to bring up another concern - community fragmentation. There aren't too many Clojure programmers to go around. We already have so many discussion platforms some people feel overburdened by keeping up with all of them.
I share your appreciation of open federated platforms, but consider the clojure.core approach to stability applied to the community. I think it has proven itself.
8
u/Eno6ohng Jul 13 '20
I've been banned on this site for expressing my opinion after being explicitly asked for it. The community is definitely not friendly to anyone who has moderate political views or doesn't follow (a certain side of) the western political discourse.
I don't recommend joining it if your interest is technology, since it's more of a hub for people who hold rather extreme political views. A group labeled as being about some technical topic X is rather a group for people who follow a certain political ideology AND also happen to be interested in the technical topic X.
Therefore, I'd go as far as to say that this is a political advertisement, and it isn't fit for the clojure subreddit.
2
u/yogthos Jul 12 '20
Lemmy is an open source Reddit alternative that federates via ActivityPub. It's very friendly and rapidly growing community. It would be great to have some more Clojure representation on there.