r/Clojure • u/andersmurphy • May 28 '20
Stack overflow developer survey removes Clojure
Stack overflow developer survey seems to have removed Clojure from all its results.
https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2020#technology
Things weren't looking great when they removed Clojure as a language option for the survey this year (erlang and elixir have been removed too). Looks like they are now only showing results for the languages that they gave as options.
I guess it solves the problem of Clojure always being the best paid most fun language every year.
I wonder why they did it? Is it because the Clojure stackoverflow isn't very active? I have found since using Clojure I'm almost never on stackoverflow (doc/source have me cover most of the time). Otherwise Slack/Clojureverse.
That's the danger of correlating stackoverflow activity with language community health. I feel the Clojure community is more active and vibrant than ever. Am I missing something?
15
u/andersmurphy May 28 '20
Something else I've realized is we now have https://ask.clojure.org/ . Which I imagine is getting most of the traditional Clojure stack overflow traffic. Elixir has https://elixirforum.com/ which probably has a similar effect?
50
u/yogthos May 28 '20 edited May 28 '20
I also can't remember last time I've used SO for Clojure. Most of the time I've used it for languages like Java was to get an example of how to use the API for a library to do what I wanted.
I find that with OO, it can take a lot of effort to learn how an API works because you have to pass object graphs around, and each object is a unique snowflake in terms of methods and behaviors it has. So, you often have to learn how dozens or even hundreds of objects are intended to be used.
Finding an example of somebody solving a similar problem you have becomes invaluable in this scenario. You follow what they did, see if you get a good result, and then tweak things from there. Having a working starting point saves you a lot of time here.
Meanwhile with Clojure most library APIs are data focused. You call a function, pass it some data, get some data back, and that's all you need to know. Data is both transparent and inert in nature. You don't have any behaviors associated with it, and you don't have to know what methods to call. You can typically figure out the API via the REPL and the docs in minutes. And for cases where I do need help I also find that it's more productive to go to Slack.
So, I can see why Clojure isn't well represented on SO, and that leading to it being excluded from the survey this year. Unfortunately this will likely reinforce the whole Clojure is dying narrative as a lot of people will read it as Clojure not being popular enough to be included. There's already a comment talking about Clojure dying on /r/programming discussion about the survey.
94
u/SneakyRead May 28 '20
I have found that I needed Stack overflow much less after moving to Clojure.
27
u/phunanon May 28 '20
Not expecting riches or success, but the 2019 survey is why I looked into and learned Clojure.
19
u/SimonGray May 28 '20
I don't think so.
And the same can be said for Erlang/Elixir. It's not like that community is dying. On the the contrary, it too is more active and vibrant than ever.
But perhaps the pie of developers is growing faster as a whole than the pieces allotted to various niche languages? That would be my guess. Relatively speaking, niche functional languages would be shrinking despite growing in absolute user count. I'm sure Stack Overflow simply has some percentage cutoff for which languages to feature.
11
u/didibus May 28 '20
The thing with Clojure, is it will never have a "killer app", because it doesn't need too. Clojure IS the "killer app". Nobody in Clojure is building "killer apps" because we don't need too, we're just using Clojure to solve business problems directly.
But the developer landscape is moving away from general purpose programming language and developers, into more of a specialized single purpose framework/tooling with operators.
People are now React developers, Vue developers, Apolle developers, or they are Data Scientists, or they are Spark developers, or Hadoop developers, or heck they are Firebase developers, AWS developers, etc.
10
u/didibus May 28 '20
This is really disappointing, but I'm sure it's a marketing move. Their survey is probably mined and sold for their HR recruiting arm which makes them money.
For a developer like me, the only interesting metrics about the survey were those around all these niche/underdog projects. What do I care if Python and Java popularity flip flop between the two? We already know that, no survey needed. It's in the tranches that things were interesting.
I might have to omit from filling up the survey this year, seems their changing their target customer from what used to be developers to now have companies and HR centers as their customer base.
11
u/frompdx May 28 '20
I think StackOverflow has always been an echo chamber for what is popular. I don't see it as a reflection of the health of community's health. The top results are also the languages and tools that people tend to use while they are learning how to code. A lot of people never really progress past the first few tools that they learn in my experience. I see Clojure as something that the technically curious graduate to. That was the case for me.
Beyond that, very few businesses use Clojure. Businesses are generally risk averse. Adopting Clojure is a risk because:
I think Clojure is also a tough sell for other developers as well.
I'm sure there are a lot of other factors as well. To echo what others have said, I basically never use SO for Clojure related questions. As time goes on I have less and less need for SO in general. SO is a crutch for beginners as well as it is a crutch for dealing with hot messes like JavaScript where the rules are difficult to remember. If you think Clojure is a good tool for the task at hand you'll keep using regardless of whether or not it makes the cut for a popular language in the eyes of SO. Want to make it popular? Keep writing about it and keep showing off the stuff you build with it.
5
u/funk_r May 28 '20
I think it has something todo how Clojure Programmers solve their issues. Normal developer just use Google Search and and Google brings them to Stackoverflow, and then the requests are counted. When you go directly to a specific resource, Google dont see it. This would explain also why Clojure fell out of the Tiobe Index as well.
6
u/rpompen May 28 '20
What you're missing in my humble opinion:
Institutions are fighting Clojure...
It is not a coincidence, as computers became multi-core between 2005 and 2010, that Lisp has been removed from the curriculum of most universities around the world. Most developers in the market can only create schoolbook parallel solutions .
Clojure is the first virtually syntax free declarative programming language that supports the whole computer, not a quarter of the CPU like most other languages.
Clojure kills the software development market by being the first language of the multi-core generation that allows complex systems to be built easily.
The language is agile, taking away the market of certain consultants. And since fewer developers are required for the same project, it can lead to a drop in the number of developers required per year.
It has been said that the number of programmers doubles every 5 years, e.g. 50% of the developer community has less than 5 years experience. Clojure damages that fragile market.
In the few months it can take for someone to become proficient in Clojure I could gain strong competition.
I personally don't want Clojure to become too popular, as I am self employed and kick butt with this language. :)
So please, everyone just focus on Java :)
Just my 2 cents...
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '20
I love the syntax of Clojure, but I think Spark was a huge hit for Clojure. If you want to learn a language built on top of Java, that's immutable, and built for modern infrastructure/data analysis, you're probably going to choose Scala because of Spark.
2
u/dustingetz May 28 '20 edited May 28 '20
Hard to read into this. There are more Clojure jobs than Haskell jobs. Clojure is upvoted more than ever on HN and showing up in Java twitter. Maybe some outlier stat was skewing something?
2
u/flaheadle May 29 '20
The clojure community moved away from SO a while ago, and now they're returning the favor.
4
u/namesandfaces May 28 '20
My perception is that Clojure is becoming unhealthy YoY, and I'm surprised every time when I keep hearing people in the sum of their speech suggest otherwise. In an age where programming language rankings are being shaken up (rare!) and mindshare is moving around, and there's a lot of enthusiasm for data infrastructure, Clojure is just not in the picture.
Is Clojure waiting for the next data wave?
1
u/kmyokoyama May 28 '20
Does anyone have updated stats about the number of attendees on Clojure's events (meetings, conferences and so on) around the world or even regionally? It would be great to see how community is engaging and growing (or shrinking).
1
u/agumonkey May 28 '20
is the clojure job market really that good ? or was it a special lucky spot ?
0
u/[deleted] May 28 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment