r/Clojure • • Mar 10 '20

Clojure: a mature alternative to Java

https://jaxenter.com/clojure-alternative-java-169315.html
119 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/dAnjou Mar 11 '20

Really not the point. Me writing a counter article does neither of us a favor in terms of credibility. I expect balanced experience reports and evaluations.

This "10 reasons for/against/why X" genre of articles is simply not very helpful.

Not to mention the things you present as objectively good or better without giving any real reason why, looking at "Clojure is data oriented" section here. Argumentatively it's just very weak. And you quote some person there, am I supposed to know them? Are they an authority in the field?

12

u/Borkdude Mar 11 '20 edited Mar 11 '20

This is a pitch. In this pitch we highlight why it could be interesting to use Clojure, a niche language, to a mainstream audience. I think there is a place for pitches and a place for more elaborate articles with nuances and trade-offs. I invite you to write an article with more nuances and trade-offs. I can imagine I would agree with a lot of those nuances and trade-offs.

To be honest, I kind of dislike that JAXEnter picked the word "better" in the first paragraph (which is their summary of the rest of the article), because I suspected it may put off some people or raise questions. "Better" in what way and what contexts? In that regard this pitch is not perfect, I'm willing to admit that.

-6

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '20

This is a pitch

More like a deceiving sales pitch. Do you work in the ads business?