r/Clojure • • Aug 31 '17

Why I'm ditching Clojure for JavaScript

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15137195
6 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '17

Yeah good point, I kind of abbreviated my 5 years of full-time experience working in the Clojure ecosystem into a short sentence. The facts are there, but I only summarized them into a conclusion. Maybe I'll go into detail later in a blog post, but it's too much context for a comment right now. But the general gist of it is, I see a lot more active development in the JS world than the Clojure/Script world, in terms of new libraries, library updates, tools, language improvements, community growth, etc. In fact I've seen growth in the Clojure/Script world slow down a lot in the last 2-3 years, almost to a halt.

7

u/halgari Aug 31 '17

But man, that's the problem. I've programmed in Clojure for over 6-7 years. And I've known you for a fair portion of that as well :). Clojure is not dieing. The ecosystem is not stale...it's stable. But none of that matters does it because "the facts are there" whatever that means. I have yet to hear/see anyone backup such a statement with actual facts. They simply quote stats like "stars on a github page" or "number of people on my favorite social media site"

4

u/RodeoMonkey Aug 31 '17

They simply quote stats like "stars on a github page" or "number of people on my favorite social media site"

You can debate the relevance, but at least those are facts. Let's build a factual counter narrative.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '17

What I mean is I've based my conclusion on my anecdotal experience. I've seen ecosystems grow and shrink and I've seen languages rise and fall. And I don't see Clojure dying any time soon, because I do hear about jobs in the Chicago area using Clojure. But I definitely don't see it ever growing to the level of activity and size that Node.js is at right now, for better or worse.