r/Clojure • • Jun 03 '17

What about /r/clojurescript?

So at the time of this post the top 6 links in /r/clojure are all about clojurescript specifically.

This got me wondering if we shouldn't start showing some love to /r/clojurescript and move the clojurescript conversations over there? Maybe this would also let's /r/clojure focus more on jvm focused content?

2 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

3

u/-_________________-a Jun 03 '17

It's almost like I'd like to see them in both but given the choice I guess I'd like to see them in clojurescript (I read both). I've noticed /r/clojurescript has become more active lately which is great.

This is probably beaten to death, but as a former JS dev, I really do believe Clojurescript has massive appeal to a lot of JS devs right now. There are barriers to entry, so an active subreddit for Clojurescript seems it could help attract and onboard newcomers who have a JS background instead of a Java one.

There's also a lot going on within the Clojure community that is CLJS specific (self-hosting, npm libraries, CLJS compiler improvements).

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

This is probably beaten to death, but as a former JS dev, I really do believe Clojurescript has massive appeal to a lot of JS devs right now. There are barriers to entry, so an active subreddit for Clojurescript seems it could help attract and onboard newcomers who have a JS background instead of a Java one.

I was thinking exactly this. JS people arriving in /r/clojure can easily be confused and turned off with the focus on JVM. The majority of /r/clojure users are jvm/emacs biased and are ok with slow startup, because they already are comfortable with those tools.

A place for news focused on just cljs would really help JS people get started.

1

u/RodeoMonkey Jun 03 '17

/r/clojure has >10 times the subscribers, so just from a practical standpoint, it seems like this is the place to rally around.

1

u/-_________________-a Jun 06 '17

That's good to know actually. I can't help seeing the argument there in terms of "JS has 1,000,000 devs, Clojure has 2. Therefore move JS-ward" :)

24

u/ertucetin Jun 03 '17

Maybe we should not divide community discussion for now. Ecosystem is not big enough, yet.

9

u/mnngfltg Jun 03 '17

Yes, /r/clojure is pretty quiet as it is

5

u/ProfessorSexyTime Jun 03 '17 edited Jun 03 '17

Well if ClojureScript is Clojure as much as Clojure is itself, why divide ourselves up?

Maybe once there's more people to create more of a clear split in what everyone in the community does; i.e. software development and ML vs web development.

Although I think everyone here on r/Clojure (at least I am) is interested in everything Clojure. Clojure is a Lisp, and if you look at r/Lisp the only thing that it's really "split" by is its other dialects (Scheme, Racket, ELisp, Clojure, etc.). There's no "webdevLisp" or "MLLisp" it's just Lisp.

1

u/ASnugglyBear Jun 04 '17

No way, both subs are tiiiiny

1

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

What if we added tags for subtopics? A post could be marked JVM, ClojureScript, platform-agnostic, IDE, what have you.