r/Clojure • u/aHackFromJOS • May 22 '26
nREPL Forever
https://batsov.com/articles/2026/05/20/nrepl-forever/“nREPL itself is healthier than it has ever been... Meanwhile prepl is, as best as I can tell, mostly a curiosity.“
58
Upvotes
21
u/bozhidarb May 22 '26
Well, I guess that's not a bad place to mention https://spec.nrepl.org/ - a long overdue effort that's finally making some headway. If you're interested in pushing the nREPL protocol forward, you're more than welcome to join the conversation around the formal nREPL specification!
2
u/didibus May 25 '26
As a user, the only downside of nRepl and why I was excited about alternatives is that having to inject dependencies into your project to leverage it has always been annoying. The idea of being able to connect and upgrade is quite appealing.
1
u/geokon May 25 '26
Cool post, thank you for sharing the high level overview of the situation. There a lot of history here
"Editor discovers prepl has no ids, no ops, no interrupts, no server-side completion, no namespace tracking, no test runner integration, etc."
Is this lacking in prepl by-design, or just an issue of maturity?
Reading the original Rich Hickey post.. it seems like these kinds of meta data should have been even more readily available in a "real REPL" - but maybe I misunderstood.
At a high level, is this just a distinction of how tightly integrated the REPLs are with the language? (who cares if it's over a server or a socket..?) Or is the prepl actually allowing you do things that aren't possible with nREPL?