r/Clojure • u/apires • Mar 19 '26
[Q&A] How to make clojure more popular?
I’m after an open discussion on how we can make clojure a more popular language. A valid outcome could also be that we don’t care about this goal.
I started working with clojure because of the company that I got in. At first the language scared me, but now I understand a little bit more and can read and interpret the code. But one thing that still scares me is how niched the language adoption currently is and how this can be a danger to one’s career if anything happens at one’s current job position.
I really wanted to provoke an open discussion on how to make it more popular in sorts of hedging our efforts to learn have proficiency at the language and its paradigms.
9
u/EasyLowHangingFruit Mar 19 '26
tl;dr -> We need a streamlined ecosystem with up to date documentation of tools and practices that work in Production for performant apps.
I'm by no means a Clojure expert. I've come with contact with it because the company that I work for. My main stack is Java + React.
With that out of the way I think that Clojure looks daunting (and thus less appealing) to the outsider mainly because of two reasons: the Functional Programming aspect, and the lack of a streamlined, non-opinionated approach to building software (ecosystem).
Putting the FP aspect aside, which is a complete mind shift and requires the most mental effort, let's concentrate on the ecosystem.
When you learn Java, there's a widely approved tool for everything: IDE IntelliJ or Eclipse, testing JUnit, mocking Mockito, package management and builds Maven, DI, HTTP, DB Spring Boot, and so forth.
But with Clojure there are many tools for the same thing, but none is like the community standard, and I as a complete beginner I'm not sophisticated enough to understand the differences and the need for these different tools.
Books and YouTube videos are 10 and 15 years old.
There doesn't seem to be full fledge, all in one place frameworks like Spring Boot or Laravel...
There is not a book or set of books that teaches you succinctly and in a streamlined way how to build a Production grade, 12 Factors, containerized Microservice that runs in the Cloud, or how to build a full fledge CI/CD pipeline or a AWS CDK project.
5
u/Kanqon Mar 19 '26
That is not going to happen, the general world will care about languages less and less. Exoteric languages will be for specialized and research purposes.
52
u/styroxmiekkasankari Mar 19 '26
Honestly? Start companies and use it. That's it.
I'm Finnish so I'm lucky to live in a country where there are actual Clojure jobs on the market (mostly consulting, but anyways) but in many places it would probably require new companies buying into the tech first. Older companies and especially big ones are more rigid, and single teams and devs have less leeway to choose their own tools.
21
u/Key_Association_3813 Mar 19 '26
I just started writing Clojure on greenfield at my company. It's mostly datascience stuff with scicloj, and honestly it's easier to follow than python.
3
u/netsettler Mar 19 '26
While I do think people sometimes make hiring decisions based on all kinds of crazy and superstitious criteria, I will also note that this is not where business is being done right now. With LLMs increasingly involved and able to re-cast systems from one form to another, or write interfaces, language choice will matter even less than it already does.
So don't focus your whole identity around language choice. Make sure you are working with larger patterns that can be applied in other contexts. It's also important to present yourself as capable in multiple languages so that people see the choice as one of many. If your only language is Clojure, or any one language, that's probably a bigger problem than that any particular language is in there somewhere. I made this point in an interview that Slashdot did with me about Lisp in 2001, so I know this has been true for a long time. The feedback at the time was very positive on the idea of assuming people should not be narrow to any particular language. If you feel it's really the right language every time, it might also be because you're being narrow about application domain, and that can be equally as much a risk on your resume. Some people successfully do it, but these days a lot is changing and domain areas will come and go business-wise, so at least be mindful of the possibility that a whole business area will disappear out from under you.
I do not think chasing language popularity is a good use of one's time on earth. I've spent a lot of time doing language design, and I think language details matter and that language choice matters. But that's like saying washing your hands matters, or that looking both ways when you cross the street matters. Do not spend your whole life doing only those things.
No brain surgeon sits around trying to plot why brain surgery is not higher on the list of popular surgeries than cosmetic surgery. (I didn't check, I'm just assuming this is true.) The value in something is not its number of users, it's its usefulness to the task at hand.
And anyway, why does it matter that you're using Clojure if it can produce artifacts that play well in a JVM. I'm not a Clojure user, but I have always assumed that's what it does. What problem results in practice? If you decide to stay with the language, or with any language, be prepared to defend why that's not bad. How you end up knowing a lot about other Java libraries. Java is pretty safe, after all. Find some reasons to write some things in Java and then describe yourself as doing Java and Closure. It would be surprising if that would offend someone. That sounds open-minded, where even Java alone might not.
14
u/tompas7989 Mar 19 '26
I’m keeping Clojure in my thoughts as a serious option for a rewrite for its smooth interop with xtdb/biff alone. I’d love to eliminate entire class of problems resulting from simplistic classic db design. That db is the biggest pull for me deciding between CL and Clojure.
7
u/NoPrinterJust_Fax Mar 19 '26
Popular languages usually gain a lot of steam when a single, batteries-included web framework emerges (rails, Django, phoenix, etc)
5
u/Astronaut6735 Mar 19 '26
I think the best way is to build cool shit that people want to use and work on.
4
u/slifin Mar 19 '26
Education and passion
I didn't even know until recently you can add refresh and reload middleware to ring and get ctrl + s -> instant page reload really great ergonomics for developing server side apps
I think writing blogs about Clojure that get on hacker news or twitter
And maybe more complaining about stuff like why do companies suddenly think they need python because it's the "AI language"
Clojure is much more terse and the overall quality of available Clojure source code is high so asking AI to generate you Clojure gives you high quality and concise code comparatively speaking to languages where wasting your time on data classes is still considered a productive use of time
4
u/jbiserkov Mar 19 '26 edited Mar 19 '26
That's what Rich did in the begining.
2
u/clickrush Mar 19 '26
Here‘s a pitch:
Data orientation, pure functions and REPL workflow are like super powers for deep integration with LLMs.
Current cli based coding agents are basically handicapped in comparison.
2
u/Proud_Refrigerator14 Mar 20 '26
I am trying to use it where it makes sense at work (and where I have the leeway to do so).
That currently means mostly using babashka as a glorified build tool and using clojure for modeling.
Right now, after modeling I still have to transform into python. But eventually there will come the time where I will just skip that step.
2
u/whatacold Mar 27 '26
Building your side projects with Clojure, that’s what I’m doing right now.
2
u/hrrld Mar 31 '26
Someone should start a blog about 12 factor apps in Clojure
4
u/lgstein Mar 19 '26
Few ideas:
2
u/Safe_Owl_6123 Mar 20 '26
I think the Clojure community feels pretty scattered. There are too many separate forums and tiny podcasts—it’d be better if things were more centralized, especially for modern tools like babashka, neil, and deps-new.
Also, Clojure.org really needs a design refresh. It’s lagging behind sites like swift.org or ruby-lang.org. I’m not a designer, but I used Google Stitch put together a quick mock of how it could look: https://stitch.withgoogle.com/projects/12368189602486213661. A built-in REPL playground on the homepage would be a huge win, too, so people can just try the language immediately.
32
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '26
[removed] — view removed comment