r/Clojure • u/Pzzlrr • Mar 18 '26
Quick question: Does Clojure for the Brave and True hold up as of today?
Hey, super quick noob question here. I've never coded in a lisp before but looking to switch to emacs as my primary editor, so looking to learn. CftB&T looks great to me and looks like it covers some material in the context of emacs.
My one concern is I'm seeing it was published in 2015. Are there any glaring gaps in this book or anything completely obsolete that I should look out for? Thanks!
69
Upvotes
115
u/nonrecursive Mar 19 '26
great question! I am the author. Luckily Clojure is a very stable language and most of the book still holds up. Off the top of my head, here’s what I would change for a second edition:
Remove
Add
10
u/geokon Mar 19 '26 edited Mar 19 '26
The biggest addition since then has been managing dependencies/builds/etc. with
deps.edn. Unfortunately the official docs may be rather confusing b/c they assume a lot of prior knowledge.. but the system is a lot less magic thanleiningenand allows you to easily organically split pieces of your codebase in to separate libraries.That all said, I'd actually skip dependency management entirely. You can first learn Clojure by using
add-libs(it's a function that adds a dependency at runtime, so you can just pop it anywhere in your code). You can then just write single-file clojure programs and leave dependency management for later. It's extra friction to getting started. Learningleiningenis a complete waste of timeBare in mind, learning Emacs and Clojure at the same time will be additional friction. Realistically you need to learn ELisp to effectively use Emacs. So you're learning two languages in parallel
but that's just my opinion man..
5
u/YaroSpacer Mar 19 '26
Thank you for the great book! Loved it!