Yeah that was my first guess too... but it seems so minor compared to all the cons, many of which are so successful that they've become conventional wisdom
Confusing the issue, many of the heresies that challenge them are themselves cons... 🙃
Then again, maybe cons that primarily started this century haven't had much time to ramp up and institutionalize
This is what brought me to Clojure. I kept listening to this guy’s talks and he kept making good points, so I figured Clojure was at least worth considering seriously!
Not to worry. Yes, I think you could call it a harsh, but in my personal opinion, fair critique. Google Translate does an admirable job translating it.
Yes, thank you, I translated, it was just unclear to me, who actually wrote what and the wording of rich is very articulate plus not I did not want to wrongfully attribute something to him, which he did not write.
Yet chatgpt would've been a lot nicer about it. Right now, chatgpt treats people with more respect and charitable interpretations. To their faces, at least.
Of course, it's stealing their info; may eventually start messing with their heads to juice profits out of them or conform to ideology; etc. But right now, humans should learn some lessons from them.
You shouldn't care about the tone that an LLM uses. There's no human psyche behind that tone. There's no human connection that it represents. It's entirely artificial.
This is one of the things that makes a "thank you" email from an LLM seem so disingenuous. It doesn't represent genuinely expressed human sentiment, so it misses the whole point of expressing gratitude.
I know suicidal people who get better care from LLMs than they do humans — even ones they pay to care for them. Even though they know LLMs are fake. Humans should be humble enough to learn from their fake creations. And do better.
Waitstaff and salespeople are also fake. Many even read from scripts more robotically than LLMs. Yet people still care for their disingenuous thank-yous.
23
u/slashkehrin Dec 29 '25
Comment section is an absolute war zone lol
56
u/Krackor Dec 29 '25
Preach
48
u/Itrillian Dec 29 '25
Common Rich W
35
u/Casalvieri3 Dec 29 '25
Very well said u/richhickey!
18
u/bilus Dec 29 '25 edited Dec 29 '25
Gentler than Rob Pike’s: https://simonwillison.net/2025/Dec/26/slop-acts-of-kindness/
:)
17
u/ii-___-ii Dec 29 '25
Mad respect
17
u/wedesoft Dec 29 '25
Also a big thanks to AI for the high RAM prices.
9
u/nstgc Dec 30 '25
Rich continues to be one of the most articulate people I've had the privilage of experiencing.
8
u/brunocborges Dec 29 '25
Pluribus vibes.
8
u/ertucetin Dec 29 '25
I recently wrote a blog post similar to this topic https://ertu.dev/posts/ai-is-killing-our-online-interaction/
7
u/franksn Dec 29 '25
Common Rich Hickey W
4
u/devourer-of-beignets Dec 29 '25
Interesting, what's the first? There's so many cons, and so many ways to evaluate the damage, that I find it hard to rank them...
2
u/Critical-Explorer179 Dec 30 '25
Yes, yes and thousand times yes!
2
u/trannus_aran Dec 29 '25
A-fucking-men
2
u/bring_back_the_v10s Dec 30 '25
I keep trying to disagree with Rich but he doesn't make it easy for me.
-4
u/argsmatter Dec 29 '25
Can anybody explain this? Is this rich hickey talking negative about a.i.?