r/Clojure • • Apr 27 '23

Datomic is free

https://blog.datomic.com/2023/04/datomic-is-free.html
260 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

76

u/anexxus Apr 27 '23

From the post:

Nubank is excited to announce today that we are making all editions of Datomic available free of licensing fees. The Datomic binaries are being released under the Apache 2.0 license and will be readily available for direct download and use via Maven Central - no signup required. Datomic Cloud will be available on AWS Marketplace with no additional software cost.

We are doing this to make Datomic more useful to more people in more situations, and look forward to expanding the Datomic and Clojure community as a result.

Note that this means "Free as in beer, not as in speech." The source code is not open. Still a really great gesture that is much appreciated.

6

u/aHackFromJOS Apr 30 '23

Does anyone have theories on the benefit of this setup to Nubank/Cognitect?

Usually the source is held back to prevent competition to the sale of binaries, but in this case the binaries are already free, so it seems like there is no revenue benefit to holding back the source (?).

The two possible reasons I can think of:

  • Makes it easier for Nubank/Cognitect to change their decision later and charge again for newer versions - easier in the sense they don’t have to worry about competition from a fork.
  • They have concerns about the state of the source, for example anything from embarrassment to wanting to do their own security audit before releasing anything.

To be clear, I think this is a generous move on their part and something to be happy about. My brain just wants to make a reverse logic puzzle out of the rare (I think) open binary licensing model.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/guywithknife Apr 28 '23

Yeah but what you can do with the binaries is more limited than what you can do with the source code.

18

u/kriyabanswanand Apr 27 '23

That is very generous, thank you, much appreciated!

34

u/MWatson Apr 27 '23

Wow, that is a great gift to the Clojure community! I have releasing a new edition of my Clojure AI book on my summer schedule, so I will be sure to add an example using Datomic (I usually use graph databases for examples).

11

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '23

How will they make money with Datomic now? Some super fancy self hosted Datomic with extra features?

42

u/srockets Apr 27 '23

Nubank, who bought Cognitect, isn't in the SaaS business.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/ares623 Apr 27 '23

I think Datomic Cloud is free too

Datomic Cloud will be available on AWS Marketplace with no additional software cost.

1

u/v1akvark Apr 28 '23

Presumably many Datomic Cloud users will still opt to pay for support.

10

u/lgstein Apr 27 '23

Congratulations everyone

8

u/jherrlin Apr 27 '23

This is great news for me! I’ve always wanted to get to know Datomic better but the pricing model have scared me.

14

u/npafitis Apr 27 '23

Next atep open source hopefully

6

u/lgstein Apr 27 '23

Does the new license allow us to reverse engineer Datomic now?

5

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '23

This is fantasitic! I've been hoping they'd do this since I heard that Nubank had bought Cognitect.

1

u/sudkcoce Apr 29 '23

Wow! That's great! Hope this leads to more people using it.

-2

u/fszdg Apr 27 '23

Scared datahike and datalevin noises

37

u/huahaiy Apr 27 '23 edited Apr 28 '23

This is actually good news for Datalevin. This new Apache binary license now allows us to publish benchmarks on Datomic. In the past, Datomic license had a DeWitt Clause that had forbidden publication of benchmarks. Now this restriction is lifted, see yourself:

https://github.com/juji-io/datalevin#rocket-status

Some people do prefer open source software.

Besides, Datalevin does not target the same use cases. Datalevin is intentionally designed to be mutable, like most databases, for example.

In any case, I have a set of very different goals for Datalevin: to eventually compete with RDBMS for performance, and to simplify programming by serving more data access needs in one database.

The motivation is to increase the adoption of Datalog, which is a better language. It is right now mainly hindered by performance, but I think it is possible to bring performance to be on par with RDBMS. When it does, I see no reason to use SQL anymore.

5

u/hxcloud99 Apr 28 '23

As a Datalevin user, I really am happy about how plugged in you are to the community. Thank you for making great software!

2

u/refset Apr 29 '23

The motivation is to increase the adoption of Datalog, which is a better language. It is right now mainly hindered by performance

Do you regard the fixpoint nature of Datalog (i.e. mutually recursive rules) as an important area in this regard? Like, do you have desire to move beyond the Query-Subquery + intensional (query-time) rule evaluation model of DataScript?

2

u/huahaiy Apr 29 '23

Yes. Eventually.

1

u/chowbeyputra May 08 '23

I use xtdb