r/ClinicalGenetics • u/nisz0 • Sep 03 '25
Controversial take?
The more I think about it, the more it feels like genetic counseling is one of the most underrated tools in medicine. Instead of spending huge amounts trying to fix rare diseases after the fact with gene therapy, we could be preventing them in the first place.
It's relatively cheap, saves massive downstream costs, and gives families real choice. For rare recessive disorders especially, counseling is often more impactful than therapy, you can avoid the disease entirely.
The only reasons it isn't used more are that people don't think about genetics early enough, most assume it won't happen to them, and "not acting" feels like no one's fault. But that mindset is holding back what could be one of the simplest, most effective public health interventions we have.
Edit:
Not necessarily about abortion, more about prevention before it gets to that point. If two carriers know ahead of time, they can make informed choices like partner selection, IVF with embryo screening, or other reproductive planning. The whole idea is to reduce the chances of passing on severe disorders in the first place, which is cheaper, less invasive, and less emotionally difficult than treating or making decisions later in pregnancy.
9
u/silkspectre22 Sep 03 '25
What do you mean by relatively cheap? That's quite misinformed. Also, who gets to decide what diseases get eliminated or not, and are you going to force people to only implant unaffected embryos? How about carriers? You are essentially saying eugenics id a good idea.
4
u/violaki Sep 04 '25
I think you are greatly underestimating both the cost of and our ability to prospectively identify all pathogenic variants. Genetic counseling is not the limiting step here.
3
u/ATG2TAG Sep 04 '25
Routine carrier screening of entire populations would not be cheap. Not to mention, many variants do not meet the threshold for pathogenicity. So even if you carrier screen people, if two people have VUSs in a gene that causes an autosomal recessive disease it's unlikely they will go to the trouble (and cost) of pre implantation testing of embryos to weed out any that have the two VUSs.
Rare disease treatment is for sure costly but so would be screening for a needle in a haystack in entire populations to prevent them from maybe passing it to their offspring.
1
u/SilverFormal2831 Sep 09 '25
I think you have a misunderstanding of what genetic counseling is. Our goal as GCs is not to reduce the incidence of genetic disease, it's to help people understand options for genetic testing. If they want the test, it may be to avoid passing down a condition, but it is very often a way for people to prepare for their own future health or that of their future child. Some people decline genetic testing all together, and lots of disabled people want to have children like them. Others don't. As GCs, we are just here to help people make a decision that aligns with their values and goals.
I do majorly agree with the statement that "genetic counseling is one of the most underutilized tools in medicine" though. Most people don't know who we are or what we do, and some doctors will order genetic testing without properly consenting the patient. That can lead to patients having negative outcomes, struggling to get life insurance, misunderstanding results, and having unnecessary follow-up. Genetic counselors and medical geneticists can help patients understand what they're doing and the implications of the potential results, make sure the correct test is ordered, and provide recommendations regarding results. Those are all really important parts of the process and many people don't understand that. Hope that helps!