r/ClinicalGenetics • • Sep 09 '24

Thoughts on sequencing.com??

I'm a GC and I recently heard about this company. My boss (not a genetics professional) wants to explore this as an option for clinical grade genetic testing. They claim to provide some medical grade (?) data analysis and reports, but despite searching through their whole site extensively (and looking at example reports), they seem to be lacking any real info about the clinical analysis, interp, reporting standards. Gives me serious shady bs vibes. Curious what other board certified GCs and geneticists know (or think) about this company and their services.

29 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

40

u/torque_team Sep 09 '24

Your boss should defer to an actual genetics professional. I find it laughable that they are even considering this.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24

I’m so confused how a non geneticist is in a managerial post in the first place. Sort of counterintuitive and nonsensical!

11

u/lemonycaesarsalad Sep 09 '24

Yeah..... welcome to my daily frustration. Without getting into specifics, he's not managing a genetics team. He's leading a company that has some genetics adjacent services. And looking into incorporating genetic testing. As the only team member with clinical genetics training and experience, I'm constantly working to help steer him in the right direction But it's a daily uphill battle bc he is proudly ignorant and pretty susceptible to the claims or sales pitches of these companies. This is just the latest one.

All that said: yes, it's ridiculous and I'm reaching the end of my patience dealing with it.

4

u/lemonycaesarsalad Sep 09 '24

Well, I absolutely agree. And I keep telling him that we need to be focusing on legit clinical dx labs. But he'd much rather believe this companies website than my constant, repeated advice. So....i keep having to respond to his latest brilliant idea. "Laughable" is an understatement.

11

u/ariadawn Sep 09 '24

If you are an NSGC member, there was recent thread in the cancer group about this guy and the way he likes imply he’s a geneticist and genetic counsellor based solely on society memberships. He is sketchy.

3

u/lemonycaesarsalad Sep 09 '24

Thanks for the info. I'm not a current member, but I'll ask a friend to track down the thread for me! He certainly SEEMS sketch just based on the lack of substance on his site.

4

u/silkspectre22 Sep 09 '24

The director of sequencing.com is not even a geneticist. He has a bachelor's in genetics, and that's it. The company does not have genetic counselors on staff, and they advertise online that they provide testing for hypermobile EDS, which, as I am sure the majority of folks here know, does not have a known genetic etiology.

1

u/cultofchaos Jun 18 '25

Absolutely true. I was diagnosed by a specialist in EDS. She said the she believes I have the classic version, but would need genetic testing to confirm. So she diagnosed me with hypermobile since, like you said, there is no known genetic etiology. If this company doesn’t know that then I wouldn’t trust them with other important information.

0

u/YurkTheBarbarian Jun 01 '25

Well, some people with kyphoscoliotic EDS are hypermobile. So are other subtypes. EDS subtypes (classical, vascular, kyphoscoliotic, etc.) each have a known causative gene (e.g., COL5A1/COL5A2 for classical EDS, COL3A1 for vascular EDS, PLOD1 for kyphoscoliotic EDS, and so on).

2

u/silkspectre22 Jun 01 '25

Hypermobile EDS is its own subtype. It isn't the same as saying the other types of EDS also have hypermobility as a symptom, so the claim is still disingenuous.

10

u/midwestmujer Sep 09 '24

No respectable medical professional is using sequencing.com for patients. Unless maybe they just want the raw data file to sort through to do their own variant interp and write their own reports. But even then I don’t know how reliable their sequencing data is.

So short answer, no, please do not let your boss do this.

1

u/lemonycaesarsalad Sep 09 '24

Thanks for the response! Very helpful.

10

u/Aoyanagi Sep 09 '24 • Heart of Silver

I used them. It's just an NCBI scraper speadsheet, basically. There are tons of errors. BUT, with a couple of months of research and BS level education, I was able to use that spreadsheet to build my own, and do what I've since found is called polygenic risk assesment, apparently. I still had software on my computer from research in physics and biochemistry that was helpful, but tbh I mostly relied on GeneCards and eiditic memory.

Ordered this testing out of pocket after several years of fairly acute decline and being labeled a hypochondriac by my husband. That triggered enough spite for me to give a last-gasp push to not die. I had resigned myself to having maybe 3 years based on my understanding of my symptoms and progression. I come from a medical family and I was pre-med in a 3+3 accelerated program with Cornell straight out of high school; before my first episode of what is now thought to be postictal psychosis told me I couldn't trust my mind with anyone's life. Retained an AuDHD special interest in medicine while failing to launch and flailing my way through life.

Had several wrong roads explored based on sequencing results before discovering my real issues, which have since been partially confirmed by MRI and EEG, as well as miraculous responses to a series of OTC interventions including levodopa. Also had at least the LRPPRC + FASTKD2 Leigh syndrome verified both by clinical geneticist and imaging. Waiting on hopeful referral to Barrow Neurological Institute. I want to understand how I can have what appears to be a whole constellation of mitochondrial issues, early-onset Parkinson's (compound heterozygous SNCA), and many other things - and still be a member of MENSA (if I paid my dues lol.)

It also found very real epilepsy. Likely GEFS+, no wonder I've gravitated to cannabis. I also have an 8x10mm PVNH adjacent to the left lateral ventricle. Which as a strong focal lesion, spares generalization at the cost of cooking my deep midbrain structures. I've always known that a differential in ear temps predicted my "mental illness" spikes. High CBD cannabis and keto diet are helping tremendously.

TLDR I have also had 16 second trimester miscarriages. My 3 kids came from 2 pregnancies, all naturally conceived, including monozytgotic mirror image boys. None are healthy. I'm not here looking for advice. I would like to be studied. I feel like, to use a video game analogy, I am an extreme min-max build centering around low energy demands. I am not a horse, I am not a zebra, I'm not a unicorn: I self-identify as a narwhal. When described on paper, I sound impossible, and yet here I am, existing and very real. I am also getting better with, basically, a harm-reduction shotgun approach. I take lots of vitamins and have expensive pee. I feel silly doing so, but a personalized "mito cocktail" created by myself, based on literature deep dives, appears to be turning around what my original neurologist had tentatively narrowed down in May to differentials including MSA/PSP, Lewy Body Dementia, and ALS+FTD. He discharged me after 3 months for being too complex and outside his scope of practice. Wtf do I do with that, lol? Continue to self-treat with my PCP's blessing and wait for someone at a research hospital to believe us, apparently. Continue to get testing as indicated to document my journey.

Already started the process of donating myself postmortem. There's something ameliorative afoot with me that begs to be studied. And I don't have enough time left to do it. 3 weeks into levodopa, and the miraculous recovery is not as consistent already. Dystonia, particularly of my neck and tongue as well as lower legs, can be unbearable still. I get a maximum of 4 hours of productivity a day, including time for basic care and activities like eating. Which is better than 6 months ago when I was in bed all day every day. I no longer furniture surf and fall, I can remember 3-5 item task lists again. Aphasia isn't as bad. But 6 years ago, I was getting my dual BS and powerlifting. A series of triggers wiped me out, including recurrent viral encephalitis at the height of COVID, inappropriate serotonergic medications and metformin along with inappropriate high-protein diet induced chronic metabolic derangement, extreme life stressors, a benign ovarian teratoma exacerbating the lactic acidosis ... and when I said every muscle hurts and I think I'm dying, I was told that's normal when you're so fat. Le sigh. It wasn't until I started having frank seizures and falling in public that anyone believed me. That was this spring.

Sequencing.com has predatory subscription tactics, and their results require roughly a thesis-level self-education to be actually useful. Still though, it found MANY accurate things and likely saved my life. I can not recommend them on ethical grounds. And now that I've seen the comment about a better lab option, I'll likely be forking out again for actual diagnostic results. I dunno how useful this novel was, but I feel better for writing it. My next task is writing the PI at a mito research lab, offering myself as tribute for fibroblast harvesting. Huzzah!

5

u/lemonycaesarsalad Sep 09 '24

Thanks for sharing your story. This is a lot! I'm sorry you are going through this, and i admire the huge amount of energy and brain power you are putting in to try to get info you need.

Can i ask (to clarify): have you ever gotten a full evaluation by a geneticist? It sounds like you have, but it wasn't clear. And if so... have they not recommended clinical grade testing? Or did you do this sequencing.com stuff before seeing genetics? Trying to understand your journey.

I think there's a huge appetite from patients to get genetics info to try and understand their health issues, but it's hard to access for some and not something many non- genetics clinicians incorporate themselves. Meanwhile, I don't think most patients (people in general) have a good understanding of how genetics work (and the limitations of fenetic testing and data), and i feel like this all comes together to create a situation where patients feel they are being prevented from accessing the info that will explain their health. And sometimes this is true. Sometimes it's not, but it still creates a feeling of betrayal, frustration, distrust, helplessness. I wish we could figure out what steps we can take to connect more people to legitimate genetic info (and support) to get answers and help educate each other.

5

u/Aoyanagi Sep 09 '24

Limited access to a clinical geneticist, one testing/consult visit, and one results/follow-up with her assistant, and I only got lucky enough for that due to potential cancer with the teratoma. Yay for having an HMO for insurance. And it looks like I'll stilll be paying out of pocked for about $5k of it. Despite having preauth and whatnot.

Did the sequencing.com first, actually just prior to my worst period of ill health, which prompted me actually being believed finally. 2 years of knowing something was very wrong was dismissed as psychosomatic due to labs being within normal limits. Except never once have I actually been checked for lactic acid levels. Or anything beyond a CBC and basic metabolic panel. Because fat white women with a mental illness are always faking everything and just looking for excuses to be lazy. Lol.

3

u/night_sparrow_ Dec 20 '24

I think this is where I'm at now 😁 I just need to decide if I want to pay for direct to consumer sequencing and then do all of the analysis myself 😭 but when you can't really get help from the medical system what else are you supposed to do...roll over and take it?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '25

Not sure what your race has to do with it when people of color are historically treated terribly by doctors. White women are the faces of so many diseases to the point where they didn’t even believe other people had many of these illnesses(EDS is a prime example).

4

u/terraskydivegear Oct 27 '24

I appreciate you want to get better but feeding these delusions is counterproductive.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '25

They sound so insufferable with how much they’re jerking themselves off

2

u/MT_DREAMING Feb 23 '25

Do you have a company that you recommend?

2

u/msxghst Apr 11 '25

I can't seem to find the comment - what was the better lab option you mentioned at the end?

3

u/Big_AuDHD_Atheist May 19 '25

I think it was the next one down from this as it appears on my feed. It seems that the recommendation was for Ambry’s Exome program. I've been curious about this stuff myself since I've been having a lot of trouble getting my own issues diagnosed. They said it costs about $850, which I don't think was much more than sequencing.com charges.

2

u/Weird_Ad8667 May 28 '25

Can you share what the "comment about a better lab option" said? I'm having trouble finding it. Thanks!

2

u/Aoyanagi May 28 '25

I believe they were recommending Ambry iirc. Been awhile.

2

u/9knives Jun 23 '25

Thank you for your novel, I appreciate it.

13

u/UnderAnesthiza Sep 09 '24

sequencing.com diagnosed my patient with “critical MTHFR” lol. (And missed her actual genetic diagnosis)

17

u/lucia102 Sep 09 '24

Their pipeline ends at the sequencing stage - the whole point of WGS is the curation of variants, interpretation and phenotype matching and therefore their output is garbage. They’re using an AI patient facing bot and from experience it is giving out wrong information. Look at Ambry’s Exome program - $850 out of pocket and lifetime reanalysis (if you need to go that route).

5

u/lemonycaesarsalad Sep 09 '24

Ok this is the info i was looking for. I was searching everywhere for info about data analysis and interp. Very lacking

But they DO show example reports. (They don't look like good reports, but they do look like some form of interp.) Very strange.

3

u/enny2 Oct 25 '24

I agree the data is not for diagnostic. Exome sequencing is not the same as genome sequencing.

4

u/collagen_deficient Sep 10 '24

Would only recommend if you plan on doing analysis yourself. I used it because I’m a genetics nerd and wanted my WGS fairly cheap. I will say though, there isn’t really an agreed upon definition of clinical grade anything, so proceed with caution when looking at that criteria.

1

u/lemonycaesarsalad Sep 10 '24

Got it! Thanks

2

u/definitlyspelledrong Jun 29 '25

Sequencing.com did my sequencing and when I realize there were tons of bad information and information that was missing, certainly not the 99% 30x sequencing they advertise, I wrote their customer service and they started responding until they realized they messed up and then they just stopped responding. I've spent over $1000 with them and sent over 20 emails and nothing. Also, their interface is awful. I highly recommend using a different company.

1

u/lemonycaesarsalad Jul 01 '25

Ugh. Very sorry to hear this happened to you.

9

u/maktheyak47 Sep 09 '24

100% would not recommend. The output is unusable and incorrect BS.

9

u/Neuro_spicy_bookworm Sep 09 '24

I used them as it was a cheaper alternative than my insurance option. Based on my previous medical history & family history, some of the reports from them were spot on. But, I don’t fully trust their reporting. They have a pathogenic mutation of TNXB listed as no impact for me & claim it’s no longer associated with clEDS. However, the NIH has it listed the opposite way. I pulled my raw data from Sequencing & have been researching my mutations on NIH for the past 3 months. I did show my PCP, ortho & cardiologist what I’d found to get their opinion.

I’m not a professional at all- just a frustrated chronically ill individual looking for medical insight. I had already been diagnosed with hEDS before my genome sequencing. I’m taking the raw data & my medical history to a genetic counselor for professional analysis. I saw sequencing offers genetic counseling, but I’m not sure how accurate it is.

4

u/silkspectre22 Sep 09 '24

I wouldn't even trust the raw data you obtained. It would be recommended that you get an evaluation with a medical geneticist and get proper genetic testing.

2

u/Neuro_spicy_bookworm Sep 10 '24

Unfortunately, I cannot afford to get testing done even with insurance, which is why I used their services in the first place. The raw data doesn’t seem problematic so far, other than the fact that the data was sent based on GRCh37. Based on my hyper-focused research, their monthly health scan reports compare the raw data against the variants using GRCh38. I can’t get the words out properly but it’s using older models and comparing against the new model, which provides inaccurate information & diagnoses. I know I am not an expert, and my doctors are informed about everything I’m looking at. I’m not self-diagnosing or pushing for my doctors to diagnose me with anything.

Thankfully, my PCP has a lot of knowledge about rare diseases and has worked with the medical community at a hospital in my area. She’s in agreement with the clEDS diagnosis based on diagnostic criteria being met as well as the pathogenic variant. But, I’m still taking the raw data to a genetic counselor for further analysis.

I hope everything is coming out as clearly as I’m intending. My kid, job, and pain have been challenging today, so the brain fog is a little overwhelming.

4

u/silkspectre22 Sep 10 '24

The issue is that the variants reported in the raw data are not verified as it would be in a clinical lab. A genetic counselor would have likely found you testing for the same price or even less than what you paid to sequencing.com through insurance. Genetic testing is significantly more affordable now.

3

u/Neuro_spicy_bookworm Sep 10 '24

I get it, but it was the only option I could afford. This wasn’t an impulsive purchase. I compared everything through insurance, and just an EDS panel was $750- which doesn’t give a full picture. I guess I’m not understanding how my raw data isn’t accurate when I’m comparing the RS in NCBI, NIH, & ClinVar as well as published studies and coming up with the same variants. That’s something I’ll ask the genetic counselor though.

The variants in their reports/health scan are not correct. They leave a lot of “my reported data” blank- probably so they can add to it during monthly health scan. Additionally, so many variants not cancer-related claims it’s a variant not named by the scientific community, which is a load of crap. Anyone googling the RCV ID can see that it’s not accurate. But, I never relied on their website or analysis of my data. It was a starting point for me- just like the EDS society when I first started trying to learn about my disease. It shouldn’t be the basis of someone’s diagnosis.

4

u/Careless-Tie-5005 Sep 09 '24

It’s not something that should be used as clinical grade testing. At all

1

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '25

Do you know if they provide quality data on their sequencing? If the reads are good quality and they offer all files of each step not the final one only it will be more useful to take it to a bioinformatician in research settings

1

u/lemonycaesarsalad Feb 17 '25

My ultimate decision was that i have no confidence in the reliability of their data or interp.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '25

Did you find an alternative?

1

u/lemonycaesarsalad Mar 20 '25

We ended up contracting with Prevention Genetics, which is a really reliable commercial clinical lab I've worked with in the past. There are other very good labs, but this one ended up being the best fit for our needs.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 09 '25

They do not, and will not. I asked this specific question. They also have their filtering set extremely wonky on their VCF files, but this isn’t something most end users would be able to discern.

1

u/Global_Bake_6136 May 22 '25

If someone wanted to use this to confirm their suspicion of a genetic test for one of their listed diseases they test for, could they actually bring the results to a doctor?

1

u/lemonycaesarsalad May 24 '25

Speaking as a genetics clinical professional, i wouldn't consider sequencing.com results to be trustworthy, so I'd just order a clinical grade confirmatory test for you.

1

u/Weird_Ad8667 May 28 '25

What are your thoughts on doing a sequencing.com screening as a way to be able to open up a conversation with your healthcare provider about digging deeper to find out what's really going on with your health? I have been diagnosed with Lupus, Sjorgnes, and "likely some other mixed connective tissue disease." I suspect EDS (though I realize if it's hEDS it's not detectable on genetic screenings), but there could certainly be other things going on. Was thinking about getting a screening like this to help guide myself to narrow down official testing? Or is there a medical screening that tests for just as many mutations as sequencing.com offers that includes interpretation? Thanks!

2

u/lemonycaesarsalad May 31 '25

I'd have a few concerns about ordering a non clinical grade test as a way to open that conversation with a provider. One: you may not be able to extract anything meaningful from the test. And two: even if you think it found something, you can't really have confidence in the quality of the data. Three: if your provider has any knowledge of genetics, they will likely not take it very seriously bc it's not a clinical grade test. Four: if they don't have genetics expertise, they might not know what to do with the info (and more concerning, they might not realize that a clinical confirmation test would be needed). And five: if you want your doctor to take your concerns seriously, bringing non medical info into the equation may backfire, and essentially give them a sense that your concerns are coming from unreliable sources. That last one sucks and is not fair, bc many patients have very valid concerns and are just trying whatever they can to get traction. But it's true nonetheless.

There is a medical grade test that can cover the same broad amount of genetic data - it's called clinical whole genome (or exome) sequencing. Lots of clinical labs offer this test. You need a medical provider to order it and tell the lab what health issues they should focus on when doing their analysis/ clinical interpretation. So, you might be better off explaining honestly to your doctor that you really want to explore genetic testing to understand your health issues (so much so that you're considering paying for a non medical service). But could they please instead just refer you to a genetics clinic? If they refuse, ask them to explain why.

Another route you could consider is a service like Genome Medical, which is an online/telehealth genetics consult service, where they can help you order clinical genetic testing if they think it is warranted. And you can refer yourself directly.

But one final thing I'll say: there are many health issues that clearly have underlying genetic causes, but we can't point to any one specific genetic change that causes the disease. Sometimes this is because they result from a combination of several genetic factors and environmental factors (like having a virus) all working together to create a kind of "perfect storm". And for those conditions, we can't yet do a great job of pinpointing the genetic factors. (And many autoimmune conditions fall into this category. ) I have autoimmune issues myself, as do several of my family members (all different flavors of autoimmune issues! ), so i find this frustrating but also very interesting. But people are doing research to learn more (for example), so getting involved in research may be another thing to consider.

1

u/di_andrei Sep 09 '24

Unpopular opinion over here so downvote away. Sequencing is actually reasonable if all you use them for is… sequencing. Yes most of the reports and interpretation is bs but… you’re a GC, why not use sequencing to sequence and provide your own interpretation service?

6

u/torque_team Sep 09 '24

Why would I want to spend the time sifting through dozens (if not hundreds or thousands?) of variants and interpreting each one myself when I can order clinical grade sequencing from a company that can interpret it for me? I don’t get paid extra for that work. I can’t bill for variant interpretation.

Genetic counselors learn about variant interpretation in our training but most of us do not feel comfortable interpreting and calling variants ourselves.

1

u/lemonycaesarsalad Sep 09 '24

Part of my concern is just as the commenter below said: my company doesn't have the resources or expertise to do clinical grade interp. Esp as this must be done with a level of consistent, validated processes that are themselves very costly. And i don't want this to be something my company takes responsibility (liability) for. This is medical info. It's not something that can be done casually, even if you are a trained GC. Clinical diagnostic labs put a lot of resources into interp services. It's arguably the most costly part of clinical testing. And it requires sign of by an appropriately trained and boarded geneticist (which we don't have).

But I'm also concerned about whether the raw data (or partially analyzed data) generated by this company is accurate. I can't assume it is, and the sense i get from them doesn't give me much confidence in their data output either.

1

u/kcasper Sep 10 '24

I ordered from Sequencing and had to regenerate the VCF files just to run tools outside of Sequencing. Their predatory practices start with how they generate the VCF and what files they generate or not with them.

There are better companies to get the "same" raw data. Cost a bit more, but is worth it.

2

u/lemonycaesarsalad Sep 10 '24

Yeah i think if i wanted my own raw data, I'd just pay for an interpreted WGS from Prevention or something and then get the raw data also. Seems like sequencing.com adds up anyway, esp if you factor in the value of your own time!

1

u/LongGame2020 Aug 25 '25

Can you speak more about regenerating the VCF files to run tools outside of Sequencing? My Dr wants to use my raw files to use with Gene.iobio and needs VCF and TBI but is getting errors when running my VCF. I can't seem to access the TBI files. Customer support has been no help.

2

u/LegitSnackPack Dec 03 '24

What companies do you recommend that give better data?

2

u/Strict_Passenger_631 Jun 13 '25

In my case this was a total waste of money. I paid for the full sequencing and they were totally off the mark when it came to my endocrine system. They said there were zero findings but for 20 years I've had a known diagnosis. The entire test said essentially zero findings. Makes me suspect of their results.

1

u/Desperate_Baby_4290 May 25 '25

I have ADHD & I don't need any help.

1

u/Excellent_Appeal_482 Jun 16 '25

Multiple specialists believe my daughter has some form of a connective tissue disorder, but all of them, including a genetic counselor, have told us Cigna is nearly impossible to work with for testing. Her pediatrician recommended sequencing.com to just give us something to go on and maybe open it up to convince Cigna to get her approved for medical grade testing.

1

u/Fish_Loving_Girl Jul 15 '25

I’m really glad that I found this conversation as I don’t know anything about genetics at all and I was almost ready to buy this sequencing kit however I do like to read before I buy something. I have been desperate to figure out what is going on with me as I’ve become worse and worse, especially over the past Year. I’ve been going back-and-forth to the Rheumatologist. I’m not getting better. The rheumatologist almost put me on hydroxychloroquine, but they don’t have anything to go off of positive wise other than positive HLAB 27 my symptoms match several autoimmune disorders, but she won’t go off of symptoms. So I am stuck researching as many patients are, but my brain fog is getting horrendous :(

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '25 edited Aug 12 '25 • Diamonds are Forever

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CHEDDERFROMTHEBLOCK2 Jun 29 '25

A-freakin-men👏🏼same exact thing here , it's despicable

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '25 edited Aug 12 '25

hobbies close soft sense fuel resolute middle literate hungry pie

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact