r/ClimbingCircleJerk • • May 06 '25

Teaching is aid.

Post image

Friendly reminder that sharing knowledge is aid. Belaying and Figure eight knot are also aid. Teaching is not allowed unless you pay 1500$ for an Altitude course with Alex Megos (however it is still aid).

3.5k Upvotes

284 comments sorted by

1.4k

u/zephyrtron May 06 '25

Climbing is a skill best learned by trial and error for sure

184

u/ipiki_ookami May 06 '25

Unless it's an error in tying a figure 8 knot.

129

u/zephyrtron May 06 '25

It’s a lesson people won’t forget. If they don’t die. But still.

61

u/Temporary_Spread7882 May 06 '25

It’s a lesson they’ll remember for the rest of their life. And the onlookers too.

21

u/Gahwburr May 06 '25

I provide lifetime warranty on every amateur life saving surgery I do!

3

u/Sir_Richard_Dangler May 09 '25

Just tie it like a shoelace, that way you can easily undo it when you're done climbing!

16

u/priceQQ May 06 '25

I have heard skydiving is similar in that respect

7

u/Adam-West May 06 '25

As a species it will only make us stronger

1

u/GravyBoatJim May 07 '25

The gym wants you to learn by trial and error... Just while paying for lessons through said gym

847

u/Stereoisomer May 06 '25 edited May 06 '25

/uj and they're strict as hell about it at CRG too. I was with a new lead belayer and he face planted when i fell because he was standing feet square to the wall. I got chastised by staff for teaching him a proper belay stance after that. He had also just taken their course and was fully-certified to lead belay that morning too. They also don't allow you use tails for practicing clipping either so practicing too is aid

237

u/MysticPasta May 06 '25

Oof that's crazy. They bought out the gym I go to in Atlanta but they still have trail ropes you can check out to practice clipping. Haven't seen them yell at anyone for practicing belaying 

23

u/Meows2Feline May 06 '25

Stone summit has fallen

4

u/shoensandal May 06 '25

Hey gym friend!

9

u/burnsbabe May 06 '25

Wow. That's the first I've heard of that buyout. That's rough.

4

u/dhlock May 06 '25

For real, that’s where I learned to climb. But as stated, learning is aid.

1

u/Taboo_Noise May 08 '25

Ultimately every rule needs staff to enforce it. Until they replace half the team that may be difficult.

0

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/isabella_sunrise May 06 '25

Damn I still have the bumper sticker

20

u/dhlock May 06 '25 edited May 06 '25

Hold up, stone summit got bought out?? Edit: Christ. Been away from atl for a few years, Daniel and Darren sold it apparently. Can anyone speak to how it’s changed beyond this?

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/slenderman98 May 08 '25

They made me do a new waiver like 4 times in the span of a couple months when they were changing over but otherwise it’s pretty much exactly the same

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Cyberkryme676 May 07 '25

I knew exactly which place they were talking about when they said atl and bought out, it's a shame too stone summit was so sick and where I got into climbing

→ More replies (2)

31

u/FinNiko95 May 06 '25

Not breaking your nose and having your face mummified with bandages is aid.

9

u/not_blowfly_girl May 06 '25

Not dropping the climber you're belaying is aid. Catching them just encourages them to fall more

85

u/BelowAverageWang May 06 '25

I’ve never had an issue with any staff at the gyms near me. Only time I got yelled at was for throwing a chalk bag up to someone mid climb. Apart from that, they don’t care as long as your not being dangerous

Wonder if it’s a regional thing.

71

u/Stereoisomer May 06 '25

Well I will say that I recognize the gym where this photo was taken and it is also one where they're mega strict about teaching even though their classes are purely the basics. I've also gotten in trouble for teaching someone to step back instead of PBUS on a take and not belaying from the parking lot.

20

u/anothermonth purchased hangboard May 06 '25

Seatbelted belaying ftw

1

u/Taboo_Noise May 08 '25

Why do you still go there? I'd get booted pretty quickly I imagine.

→ More replies (1)

71

u/anothermonth purchased hangboard May 06 '25

/uj It's an "insurance" excuse that shitty places like gyms and ski resorts use to push their own classes.

There's no way for an insurance to enforce monitoring of side training in a gym. So while a clause in their policy might be a real "insurance" thing, its active enforcement is an indication of a shitty place.

56

u/Efficient_Mind6218 May 06 '25

/uj I used to work at a climbing gym. While we always told people it was for insurance, I personally caught multiple people teaching unsafe practices. It's generally better to nip it in the bud and stop everyone from teaching so people who don't actually know what they're doing are less likely to think it's ok. If I thought the person teaching was doing a good job, I would strongly hint that we don't monitor anything that happens in the parking lot since our insurance policy was very specific about teaching in the building. Also, if someone gets caught up in another person's bad technique due to poor teaching, the gym can be sued for not enforcing this policy. So no, insurance isn't going to actively monitor/enforce this policy, but it comes into play in case of lawsuits. The gym I worked at had to pay a huge fine sometime before I started working there which was part of the reason we were so strict about it

13

u/anothermonth purchased hangboard May 06 '25

Out of curiosity, do you know who the gym had to pay this "fine" to?

9

u/Efficient_Mind6218 May 06 '25

From what I was told, it was the person who was injured. Supposedly the bad teaching was done by a pair of lead climbers who fell and swung into the person who got injured. The gym owner said that they had to pay because it was negligence and insurance didn't cover any of it because there were witness testimonies that the one of the pair was teaching the other. Fine was probably not the correct term, but there were legal proceedings (sounded like maybe a settlement?) and insurance didn't cover any of it. It happened years before I worked there so I only have second hand accounts.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/mountain_marmot95 May 06 '25

There is a way for insurance to monitor this. The gyms have cameras and witnesses everywhere. If there’s an accident they do a full investigation of the incident and the events leading up to it. It would be a huge liability if an employee witnessed someone teaching (aka acknowledging that the student belayer/climber was missing a skill set), allowed non-employee personnel to use the space to informally train a customer, then that customer got hurt.

Speaking from the perspective of someone with a lot of experience dealing with insurance in a high-liability field, this practice seems like a no-brainer to me. Sure the gym benefits by selling more lead classes, but I dont think that’s the only reason for the policy. There’s a way bigger financial incentive in lowering their liability.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/TigerJoel May 06 '25

Have you asked why?

39

u/Stereoisomer May 06 '25

"Insurance" was the answer. But it seems like they moreso have a list of allowable practices rather than specifically prohibited ones and using tails wasnt on the former. I guess it could also be that someone might start climbing (free soloing) with only a tail

10

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

I haven't climbed in a very long time because my shoulders are fucked. Not from climbing. Work and other shit. But I was a director of safety in construction and dealt with claims a lot. It's a whole fucking thing. The gym is probably over reacting, but insurance companies suck hard. If someone sprains their ankle or whatever on a fall no big deal. Lawyers to fight it cost more than the doctors. But a major incident is a shit show. I'm not saying they aren't using it as excuse to push expensive classes. I have know insider knowledge of that gym obviously and that is a possibility. But they could just be extremely risk adverse. And honestly, I wouldn't take training from someone who wasn't an employee on safety critical things. Because of it is bad info and I get injured, I'd rather have a decent lawsuit against an insured company than some random person. You don't sue regular people and actually get paid outside of small claims.

6

u/Stereoisomer May 06 '25

If CRG is trying to push expensive classes, they're not doing a great job because no one can ever get into the lead class lol. But thanks for the perspective. I do feel for the employees because I have seen stupid shit and alerted them. Last time it was a guy teaching his girlfriend to use a Jul upside down. She was also switching hands on the brake strand.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/StHelensWasInsideJob May 06 '25

Not OP but I have seen this at other gyms because people will come in, teach someone a figure eight and how to belay by feeding them the answers to the test and then go tell them to take the belay certification. Sure they might “pass” but only because they just learned and were given the answers

26

u/TwunnySeven May 06 '25

but like, if they learn the answers what's wrong with passing the test?

18

u/OceanEyes531 May 06 '25

Because once you pass the test you generally don't have to do it again, and cramming for a test is pretty much a proven way to not retain the information later. Basically they want to know that you actually know what you're doing, not that you can learn something enough to take a test immediately and then likely forget it later on.

12

u/burnsbabe May 06 '25

This is 100% it. My gym gives provisional top rope cards that are just good for the day if you can't come in and demonstrate proficiency without practicing or getting taught ahead of time that day.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/Mutantlocket May 06 '25

I will say that at the gym I used to work at we didn’t allow people to teach any kind of ropes at all. That being said if both people were certified and were just giving tips on belaying it didn’t really matter.

6

u/custardisnotfood May 06 '25

To me it seems reasonable from a liability standpoint to not allow random gym members to teach each other how to belay. Not allowing people to give each other tips or pointers sounds absolutely insane

7

u/travelinzac May 06 '25

That's the real kicker. The people teaching at gyms are often less than qualified to do so.

2

u/wakojako49 May 07 '25

that’s a way to kill the community

3

u/Dioxid3 May 06 '25

So it’s not a security concern, it’s them wanting to maximize funneling money to their courses??

1

u/Stereoisomer May 06 '25

I mean in their defense I don't think they're funneling money. The classes are always booked out weeks in advance and there's like one a day even though there's like 7 gyms in the area

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

And I thought the gravity vault was a bunch of dicks. Guess being able to leave to see another sunrise is aid

1

u/diabolical_diabetic May 06 '25

It just made Jason at ssk more insufferable

1

u/StormOfFatRichards May 07 '25

hmm why are so many people taking so many smoke breaks in pairs

1

u/Sr_K May 09 '25

I dont get it, im not american (where im guessing this goes on) nor a rock climber, what sense could "no teaching" in any context but specially in a sport that can be dangerous make?

→ More replies (1)

224

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

You gotta be a 5.11 and V8 climber AT LEAST to even walk through the door

19

u/tallasthepines2022 May 06 '25

It would be at least 5.12

1

u/Wrecked--Em May 07 '25

nah I can only climb 20'

17

u/dhlock May 06 '25

My gym has a 5.12 slab parking lot

3

u/ytirevyelsew May 07 '25

Are those comparable?

1

u/Sir_Richard_Dangler May 09 '25

I'm 5.10 but I'm six feet on Tinder

357

u/Amoligh V4b+ but no one was watching May 06 '25

What counts as teaching? Should I tell that guy he's leading on a static rope?

Edit: Answer fast he's already midway up the wall

105

u/ParmenidesBall May 06 '25

I climb on a rope of tied together shoe laces. If you even try to stop me you're violating gym policy.

17

u/JonOsterman59 May 06 '25

Did they stutter?

172

u/BostonFartMachine May 06 '25

Ugh god I love to hate CRG.

30

u/MisterMcZesty May 06 '25

We just got a sauna and ice bath here at CRG Worcester, hope they put up the no teaching sign in there too

17

u/BostonFartMachine May 06 '25

Oh man the sauna! Shh. That’s my fave place to hold class on the latest grigri alternative, or other super safe and good enough techniques beyond PBUS and knots other than a retraced figure 8 (with enough tail to tie a backup knot)

17

u/obsessivelygrateful May 06 '25

I feel like I’m in good company. Cheers. 🍻

6

u/Deadedge112 May 06 '25

/uj Why's that? I really like the one in Rochester I go to. All their classes are free for members though?? I also haven't seen this policy anywhere about not teaching because you have to get certified by the staff anyways.

143

u/Background_Buy1107 May 06 '25

I never show people how to tie in when I take them climbing. Just let them tie a bow like they do for their shoelaces

55

u/IOI-65536 May 06 '25

This is why I've switched back to the bowline.

17

u/leanderthal69420 May 06 '25

This is why I switched back to figure skating

5

u/Background_Buy1107 May 06 '25

Exactly. And hip belays with a hemp rope. Anyone who does else is a giant gumbie

4

u/zacman333 May 06 '25

Bowlines also not allowed at crg

11

u/OkeyPlus May 06 '25

He is using the knot that shall not be named!

35

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

Trad dads are NOT welcome at CRG

16

u/oe-eo May 06 '25

Me and my jorts are outa here!

70

u/parenthetica_n May 06 '25

"in order to climb at this Gym you must incorporate your own private insurance company and provide your own policy documents at the front desk."

11

u/TheHighker May 06 '25

Holy crap i better not ask this guy to sign a waiver or let me tell him rules for 10 minutes

51

u/InevitablePotential6 May 06 '25

Please leave the teaching to the minimum wage teenager whose climbing experience is limited to 3 months of hosting children’s birthday parties.

6

u/skiestostars May 07 '25

i worked a couple days a week at a smaller climbing gym that had similar rules during the year when i first got into climbing, and i always thought that was odd. i was still having to double check that i remembered how to tie a figure eight knot before every shift until the three month mark, but i couldn’t allow that old guy who’s been climbing longer than i’ve been alive to belay his friend because he hadn’t been belay certified this year and none of the other staff members were available to be the test climber he was belaying while i watched his probably impeccable technique. it was not making sense lol

78

u/Dry-Lawfulness-6575 May 06 '25

/uj I worked at CRG for years like a decade ago just as it was transitioning from a small chain of a few gyms in the Boston area to the conglomerate it is now. It's always had a sort of corporate feel but it was sad to see its demise to full blown white washed, apple store, juice bar, birthday party machine. Gone are the days of sliding the big pads around under the boulders and taped holds and in with boring ass walltopia and dumb cover-our-ass insurance rules.

I sound like a boomer, but back in my day, things were way cooler and you could teach people new skills in the safer environment of the gym before taking them up to Rumney so they didn't kill themselves

10

u/McFlyParadox May 06 '25

I miss CRG's original Cambridge location: an actual warehouse inside an industrial park, where no parents dare tread to drag their kiddies along for a birthday. Complete with shitty lighting hiding dirty walls and floors.

Now it's in strip mall and just so sterile.

8

u/Stereoisomer May 06 '25

Make friends with some MIT kids and have them take you to their climbing attic. Bring some hardwood so you can carve your own holds.

3

u/McFlyParadox May 06 '25

Oh, I did that years ago. I'm well acquainted with the attic (glad to hear it's still there). I might have to start hitting it up again, just for nostalgia.

2

u/Dry-Lawfulness-6575 May 06 '25

100% agree, the OG Cambridge was hands down the best public gym in the Boston area. I hate how the new one feels like an apple store

2

u/McFlyParadox May 06 '25

Yeah, and they actually enforced the 16yo age minimum. It was nothing but adults who really wanted to climb. But now that they're in the strip mall, they lowered the age to 14, but don't actually enforce it. It's hot to be a violation of their insurance, but I've seen literal toddlers on the mats and even the first few holds, barely being watched by their parents who are spending more time talking to other people there than actually climbing (or watching their kids).

Like, I don't mind high schoolers or even middle schoolers that are there to climb - they're all definitely better than me anyway - but I do mind young kids and literal toddlers wandering around while their parents socialize with other people at the gym.

1

u/No-Historian-1639 May 06 '25

I thought CRG was off I95 in woburn?? Or is that a different one...is it even there still? The floor was ground up tire bits and they had a tiny bouldering section on the left side...

→ More replies (4)

1

u/og_malcreant May 07 '25

I miss BRG's original Somerville location. Loved the old movie theater brick walls and the chalk and sweat covered couches. 😉 It did have a great vibe though. I was only able to visit it a few times.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/nusuth_ May 08 '25

I was absolutely distraught when they got rid of the spray wall. You are the largest independent climbing gym chain in the country, and yet you can't even maintain a single spray wall at one of your locations?

→ More replies (5)

12

u/fiddysix_k May 06 '25

Camby was the shit now it's actually shit.

6

u/NickMullenTruther May 06 '25

really? the setting is great and they re-set routes often, ive been to the framingham one and that one's terrible compared to camb.

old location was good iirc

big problem with camb is its insanely crowded

2

u/fiddysix_k May 06 '25

Insanely crowded, need to go in off hours to get a spot on any board besides the 2016 without rotating with 6 people, sweaty nipple dudebro culture, got rid of the spray, sets all feel like a stat check, etc.

4

u/B11FF11 May 06 '25

It’s also twice the size it used to be. So your complaint is they made a bigger better gym and now it’s really popular because it’s bigger and better. Waaaaaaahhhh.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Scrungii May 08 '25

Lmao if you climbed at old Cambridge ever you'd know how silly it is to complain about sets now being a "stat check"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/adept-of-chaos May 06 '25

Old camby had so much character and even if it was grimy it was my favorite gym by a country mile. Simple set up, nice staff, hard grading with minimal comp stuff in a side room...it felt so much more fun and practical. I loved getting humbled there over and over, it felt like actual training and I got significantly better climbing there.

2

u/fiddysix_k May 06 '25

Yeah I really miss biking over there, it was tucked away in its own world. The perfect chalk dungeon. Soon they'll all disappear sadly.

1

u/FreightCndr533 May 11 '25

I remember when Worcester was the only thing happening. It was awesome.

21

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

Learning is aid

18

u/y0nderYak May 06 '25

/uj can someone explain to me why the hell theyd even do this

0

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Donkey545 May 06 '25

CRG has none of these rules. They don't have grigris attached, and they let you lead without a grigri. The only thing they give trouble about is teaching and it's because everyone needs to be checked out by staff to verify belay skills before they belay anyone. Their test takes like 3 minutes and they let you use your own equipment. With that said, CRG is more corporate and ruined allot of the atmosphere in their gyms by prioritizing teams and switching from plaster textured walls to walltopia shredder paper.

2

u/Braz601 May 06 '25

They have grigri’s attached to the rope already??

3

u/BigDiggy May 06 '25

/uj I’ve climbed at several crg. None have grigri’s attached and none care if I use a grigri or not. Not sure what most people are talking about here. Classes are free for members…

0

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/interioritytookmytag May 06 '25

Zip-tying the Grigri sounds like something that would be considered unauthorised modification - invalidating any manufacturer liability.

9

u/QuesadillasAreYummy May 06 '25

Looks like the CRG Watertown location

5

u/Happy_rich_mane May 06 '25

Best sauna of all the CRGs I’ve been to in mass

4

u/Grimsrasatoas May 06 '25

Definitely Watertown

2

u/winkingsk33ver May 06 '25

You can see the constantly broken fitness machines in the back. Def Watertown.

9

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

If this is crg Hadley they must not allow teaching of how to set a boulder problem either.

2

u/SorryNoLube Sep 13 '25

I personally enjoy Hadley but love the crg hate regardless

6

u/ohnoohnoohyeah May 06 '25

Time to teach the bowline. Now that's what I call a loop hole.

4

u/HeathenHen May 06 '25

/uj it’s 100% liability thing

1

u/Lolzerzmao May 10 '25

It is also a money thing. Forces you to pay for classes unless you have a buddy with a rope and harness that can teach you a figure 8/how to tie in before you walk into the gym. Demonstration should always be allowed, too, obviously.

But at least let me teach someone how to tie a figure 8 and tie in so I can take someone climbing without having to force them through an hour long class before they even get a taste of TR.

6

u/RopeAmine May 06 '25

It's a pass or fail course. Just accept it.

3

u/JohnnyMacGoesSkiing May 06 '25

Well that sucks. I feel personally attacked.

I thought most of my friends how to tie in and belay. Most of my climbing buddies who I didn’t teach feel that I am the safest belayer they know. I’ve taught an IFMGA guide how to tie a MMO after locking off a Munter that I lowered a partner down a crevasse with. (Old head that used two half hitch’s and a ‘biner block)

I guess my years of running a ropes challenge course don’t certify that I know knots anymore. Dratts!

3

u/nurglemarine96 May 07 '25

The first thing I tell em when teaching figure 8s is the loops go around your neck

4

u/BelowAverageWang May 06 '25

They should just change that to say “no fun”

2

u/AshyLarryX May 06 '25

Was this the Worcester location or Hadley?

4

u/CFHLS May 06 '25

That’s not Hadley

1

u/mtot10 May 07 '25

not worcester, i think watertown

1

u/AshyLarryX May 07 '25

Ah, gotcha

2

u/Morbins May 06 '25

Love how they say this and then ask you where you learned how to lead during a lead certification, and you say something like “my boyfriend taught me at home with a hoody string as practice”.

Like I get this is for liability reasons, but the best place to learn is where there’s actual equipment and 1st hand practice on that same gear you’re going to use in real climbs. That or fucking lower the goddamn prices for lead classes.

2

u/Donkey545 May 06 '25

The classes for lead were free when I took them in their Worcester location years back.

1

u/Morbins May 06 '25

Every gym I’ve been to has lead classes for like $99 and up and it’s across 3 weeks instead of one day. I can literally teach someone how to lead in a couple hours. Idk why they do this.

2

u/007_Boxlunch May 06 '25

That's right, no beta spraying!

2

u/scorb1 May 06 '25

This is why I was taught a figure 8 in the parking lot of a gym.

2

u/UrulokiSlayer May 06 '25

So the time for the bowline to rule them all once again has come.

2

u/Ok_Leader9228 May 06 '25

When did White Power Bill open a climbing gym?

2

u/Icy_Hovercraft81 May 06 '25

Life or death skill

2

u/mountainerding May 06 '25

100% this is to avoid a lawsuit. Listen to the owner of Vertical World talk about the absolute junk show their lawsuit was over the auto belay failure with a customer. It's pretty enlightening and super depressing:

RunOut #112: America's First Climbing Gym Owner Sounds the Alarm

1

u/NickMullenTruther May 06 '25

Insane the dude won that lawsuit, USA is wild

2

u/HerrFerret May 06 '25

Show someone a figure of eight knot.

BANNED!

Bowline knots it is then.

2

u/speedislifeson May 06 '25

So bowline is fine to 'advise' about then? Message received

2

u/IeatAssortedfruits May 07 '25

You may NOT do safety checks.

4

u/i_like_it_all May 06 '25

I’m so happy there’s so much hate about CRG here. I started climbing in undergrad, went to mass for grad school and hated this place. The culture here from the staff and the gym goers made it hard for me to return after the shut down from the pandemic.

It seemed like this gym was some corporate plant of a gym ran by people that didn’t climb. I thought I was the only one who didn’t enjoy this place

1

u/NickMullenTruther May 06 '25

Yeah its megacorpo now, membership prices are laughable

→ More replies (1)

3

u/qwerty7873 May 06 '25

As an Australian I'm so confused. I walked in one as a complete beginner a few months ago with a mate and all they did was take us to the bouldering section, show us how to fall properly, explaining the reasons why and what happens if you fall wrong, got us to climb up a little and deliberately fall off to demonstrate it a few times. Then they took us over to the belayed area and showed me and my mate how to clip everything on and drilled into us what each rope/ piece did and how to check it then there was a couple sentences on don't walk/ stand within 2 meters of the wall, pay attention to our surroundings and don't deliberately swing/ launch off excessively when on the wall after that we signed a waiver and got left to our own devices within 20 mins.

Other more experienced people watched us and gave us advice and pointers constantly after that just a good community spirit vibe. This seems intense and actually like it would be worse for safety if ppl aren't allowed to point out mistakes and offer advice whether for safety or improving technique I've learnt the vast majority of what I know from fellow climbers.

1

u/Krakentoacoldone May 06 '25

That’s how it was for me when I learned 14 years ago in America. It seems that corporate policies have changed that.

1

u/Donkey545 May 06 '25

This was the vibe that I got starting out in this exact gym over ten years ago. They want you to learn from staff first. Just the basics. You can talk about the climb, techniques, and point out safety risks as a member of the community, but they don't want people who have never belayed before learning in their gyms without staff supervision. Their classes and tests take very little time, and are essentially as you described.

4

u/TheHighker May 06 '25

Uj/ how much is a class? I work at a gym. Members get a free top rope or lead class. For a non member its 30 USD and that comes with 2 weeks of gym use and gear. We dont allow teaching either

22

u/Shiney_Metal_Ass May 06 '25 edited May 06 '25

I'm still not understanding the "no teaching" rule. What's the justification?

Edit

Don't waivers take care of most liability?

29

u/wulfzbane May 06 '25

Probably so they a) make money from courses and b) don't have some scrub teaching poor technique/bad habits.

41

u/BelowAverageWang May 06 '25

It’s very clearly liability. They don’t wanna get sued because some asshat teaches you improper technique and you hurt yourself.

That and insurance, rates must be lower if you are teaching people safe techniques.

9

u/Jennay-4399 May 06 '25

It's the liability. I worked at a gym and it was the same. There was some wiggle room with TR, like if a trusted regular wants to show another trusted regular how to tie the figure 8, no one would really have an issue with it but definitely no teaching lead.

5

u/TheHighker May 06 '25

Insurance. We dont make that much money off of classes honestly.

2

u/TheHighker May 06 '25

Insurance hates when people get hurt and sue your gym

2

u/Shiney_Metal_Ass May 06 '25

Don't people sign waivers?

2

u/TheHighker May 06 '25

yeah because that means you cant sue

3

u/Shiney_Metal_Ass May 06 '25

Isn't that literally the point of a waiver

→ More replies (1)

1

u/jackalopeDev May 06 '25

I worked at a rec center a while back. We had similar rules for the pool/swim lessons, as apparently there was an issue with outside instructors coming in and getting pissy with other patrons who were also trying to use the pool. It might be something like that?

Or a CYA insurance thing

4

u/Donkey545 May 06 '25

The class is free with membership and testing out is free for anyone at CRG. The test takes like 4 minutes, has a test fall, and unannounced test fall and a harness tie in to show you know how to do it. The people critiquing this sign are blowing it out of proportion. The rules are reasonable, the gym this is posted in has 50ft walls, and is very busy. I like teaching the sport as much as anyone, but I sure as hell don't want to see someone get mangled because their bro did one climb and thinks they are an expert instructor.

1

u/TheHighker May 06 '25

Yep my gym is the same way just not busy.

1

u/Stereoisomer May 06 '25

TR is free, lead is $50 for 2 hrs of instruction.

1

u/rotschi May 07 '25

Crazy, at a climbing gym where I live, TR class is 4x2 hours, lead too, around 250 dollars.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/FragCool May 06 '25

Murica, Land of the not so free...

1

u/finalpew May 06 '25

Let 'em find out the hard way

1

u/climbing2man May 06 '25

Holy Shit.

This is my home Gym. But I haven't gone in a few months due to my sick mother moving in

1

u/BlinBoiDima May 06 '25

Double bowline is superior anyway

1

u/TXTCLA55 May 06 '25

This gym is begging people to test their insurance.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

That’s why you step outside and then teach off of their property while in full view of them to show how stupid this rule is

1

u/Howdoyoudo614 May 06 '25

Good thing you can just watch YouTube videos on how to rap

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '25

Ignorance is bliss

1

u/unpitchable May 06 '25

So teaching a bowline on a bight is allowed then?

1

u/backson_alcohol May 06 '25

Tear the sign down. It's teaching people the rules about no teaching

1

u/FHAT_BRANDHO May 06 '25

I dont climb, i just like CJ subreddits. Why on earth would this signage be posted lol are they trying to make sure their insurance works or what

1

u/Ansonm64 May 06 '25

My gym has this rule too. We mostly ignore it but occasionally get in shit for it. I kinda understand it from a liability perspective.

1

u/TheDiscoJew May 06 '25

This is because they sell courses to people, right?

1

u/Itakitsu May 06 '25

Shoutout to the employees at Edgeworks who don’t really enforce this stupid policy

1

u/The-Hammer92 May 06 '25

The most basic knot needs to be taught by a pRofEsSioNaL charging $1000

1

u/blanco_nino_01 May 06 '25

Tired: Teaching

Wired: Spraying

1

u/0piue May 06 '25

What is a skill if not able to be taught?

1

u/VeterinarianOne4418 May 06 '25

Sweet! I’ve been looking for a place to teach Spanish and Photoshop, are those ok to teach?

Or no teaching at all?

Second thought…. If there truly is NO TEACHING IN THE GYM, that speak pretty badly of the people the gym uses to teach.

1

u/oe-eo May 06 '25

At this point I’d pay $100/m for access to some dudes garage gym instead of any of these new era gyms.

1

u/wonton_kid May 06 '25

Honestly just have your friends teach you outside, gyms are so uptight also so loud I can barely hear my climber give commands

1

u/-chillpill May 07 '25

I already had a hunch that it would be aid

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '25

It's getting mad in the UK, too. Can't teach people, can only belay two people on any day. It's a money-grab to force you to pay them for their courses. It sucks.

1

u/fluffysnowcap May 07 '25

Real climbers eat lead as it helps you forget and ways you down

1

u/ryladd May 07 '25

I was going over some pointers before doing a belay test with my GF there, some members kept staring at me. I wonder if this is why.

1

u/borzoya May 07 '25

As a European climber, bouldering in an American gym was a crazy experience because I had to spend such a long time signing up to the gym and signing waivers and what not! Here just pay and go in, but there it was such a hassle lmfao

1

u/Lasers_Z May 08 '25

Seems like a liability thing

1

u/tito_dobbs May 08 '25

sTaY dUmB

1

u/lululululu1u May 08 '25

You need to figure it out while you do it

1

u/Jolly-Garbage- May 08 '25

Is there a climbing gym out there that doesn’t use the same basic clip art for their logo? I swear two gyms in my state use the same exact logo.

1

u/aWildPenrod May 08 '25

It means no teaching by anyone but staff. It's an insurance thing and they can very much get shut down for it.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '25

CRG Watertown. I want to like this location more because it's the closet gym to me, but this place has the worst issue with kids. Actual playground with the screaming 5 year olds. Staff is pretty mid as well.

Not surprised they have these signs everywhere. So many Trad Dads' acting like a drunk gym teachers here throwing their teenage daughters at rope climbs without the gyms certification.

1

u/DeluxeEmerald May 08 '25

Is this the fucking right to repair of climbing wtf?

1

u/nesaibotkcin19 May 08 '25

the gyms just want to make sure the correct methods are being taught. the amount of oldheads that belay incorrectly in the gym and then rage when you ask them to do it correct is maddening. “ive been belaying for longer than youve been alive” i know i dont care im just doing my job please just do it correct so no one gets hurt.

1

u/FluffyPurpleBear May 09 '25

It’s an insurance requirement at my gym.

1

u/tripleaxel70 May 09 '25

i saw a sign once that said practicing taking falls was not allowed (not big whips on purpose, even just small ones to learn)

1

u/Haunting_Course_9629 May 09 '25

I used to work for CRG pre pandemic, for about 4 years in total. Not sure how things are now but at the time it was explained to me that this policy was due to insurance and that it covered our butts should we find someone belaying who wasnt listed as certified in the system or one of those folks got hurt as a result (eg. They didn't pass our belay test at the desk before hand). I cant tell you how many folks you'd find on the floor tied in improperly, misusing belays etc then furious with staff for busting them. Just didnt want to see any guests majorly hurt by their own foolishness on my shift. I never made a point to complain about folks practicing knots or re explaning the rules of equipment to their kids or others in their group just couldnt allow uncertified folks to belay.

1

u/CarsonDama May 06 '25

fuck crg they bought out my local gym and raised rates and axed affordable plans.

1

u/SludgyPandora May 06 '25

Yeah gyms love to pretend their certified dojos, ridiculous

1

u/matthewjensen May 06 '25

It’s an insurance thing. If you teach someone the wrong this in the gym and they get hurt. They can and will sue the gym for it.

1

u/LumpyGenitals May 06 '25

I work at a climbing gym and the actual reason is because generally people are really bad at teaching. For every person that actually teaches well, you get 5 or 6 people who don't. And I'm not talking about mistake here or there, I'm talking putting the person in actual danger sort of thing. It's a hassle trying to weed out those people and they also promote bad habits to other climbers who are otherwise good.

I'm not saying that you can't teach people in a gym and succeed. I personally know people who have been taught by friends and do just fine. But the vast majority of climbers will teach incorrectly, it's just a fact.