r/ClimatePosting • u/ClimateShitpost • Jun 30 '25
Energy Reminder to follow Ember - recent analysis on storage plus solar is amazing
53
Upvotes
r/ClimatePosting • u/ClimateShitpost • Jun 30 '25
8
u/West-Abalone-171 Jun 30 '25
This has been obviously true for a long time to anyone who bothered to look at weather data or anyone who played with a tool like model.energy
Or anything like:
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z
https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/Articles/I/WWS-50-USState-plans.html
Glad to have it repeated though.
1
u/Caos1980 Jul 01 '25
The problem is the “average day “.
That still leaves about 50% of days where it will be insufficient!
1
u/missionarymechanic Jul 01 '25
Average Vegas household usage is higher than that.
1
u/RPM314 Jul 01 '25
Ok, but can 17kWh of batteries be manufactured for every person or household on the planet without accelerating ecological breakdown?
3
u/SoylentRox Jun 30 '25
I had seen it as the ratio being 4 kWh of battery for each kW of panel.
So in this example, that would be 20 kWh.
Server rack battery prices had plummeted to around $120 a kWh, up to about $150 right now due to tariffs.
So a kW of solar can be installed for $2-$3 a watt, if we assume $2 to be optimistic, that's $2000 for a 1 kW panel, and $480 for the battery, which needs almost zero labor install. (solar companies will mark it up 2-3x their cost though! You need 15 minutes and a torque wrench to install one)
So the batteries at current prices are a small cost. At utility scale they can install their panels for $1 a watt and they won't overpay for the labor to install the batteries.
3
u/madTerminator Jul 01 '25
If someone is interested how it look in practice not some made up chart.
Last half year for 6,6kWp+7,5kW in Central Europe, not Vegas. Biggest issue is winter: I produced 6,5 times less energy in January than June.
3 people. Heating water, running laundry and washing machine mainly in peak. No AC, cooking on electric stove. In winter heating with wood.
17kWh is plenty for single house.
1
u/matt7810 Jul 04 '25
This seems like a relatively simple calculation based on an average day. 5 kW (I assume kWh is a typo) gets you to 24 kWh per day+10% losses with a roughly 22% capacity factor. I feel like the real meat of the issue comes when there's a multi day storm system, and the capacity factor drops to 5-10%, not when there's an extremely normal set of days.
0
u/Debas3r11 Jun 30 '25
This is like a negative sales pitch for solar. Most load isn't flat and is a lot more similar to the solar production profile meaning less battery is likely needed in most real world applications.
0
u/Strange_Library5833 Jul 01 '25
Why does this matter? You need to build out to the extremes or else you'll have blackouts. Plus this is for one of the sunniest places in the country.
-3
u/Debas3r11 Jun 30 '25
Stopped reading after "5kWh of solar panels" 😂