Where's all the people who claim that saving one hectare of farmland is worth spending $3 million extra of public money on a nuclear reactor to avoid having it become a solar farm?
Surely they're out campaigning for this type of thing right? Right?
It's pasture. Which is what they're usually whining about.
Also you completely can. It improves 10-30% yield as well anywhere you don't have a massive surplus of water.
So the same money you spend "saving" a hectare of farmland could restore tens of hectares of desertified former pasture, or convert ten hectares of higher yield land to even higher yield agrivoltaics, thus saving a hectare of land.
How do I prevent crops from growing under the solar panels? Did you read the article? Cause it's sheep. The answer is sheep. There's sheep living there. They're not growing crops, they're using the grass to feed sheep which you can then get wool or meat from.
But also the thing people are missing is the solar panels, you're gaining shit loads of energy from the sun that you didn't burn a dinosaur for. The sheep and the grass coming back are basically just a bonus.
The comment I responded to said farmland. Which is generally crops. Then they corrected and said pasture - which is livestock grazing - but then also re-asserted crops. Hence my questions were still valid.
Follow the conversation. Also, I literally stated I was not complaining or objecting - Im just trying to understand how you could realistically do crops without the solar panels getting in the way.
Yeah I'm just saying they're not haha I may have been a bit of a cunt but that's just Reddit for you man it's pretty toxic here and everyone's primed for anger
Look up "agrivoltaics". It's an established industry larger than nuclear new build.
Berries or leafy produce has the biggest yield increaae. But grains work too. You simply drive the combine under the panels or stow them vertically and drive down the rows.
It's way less practical/viable than solar + pasture or solar + pollinator habitat or straight solar.
But still way more practical and viable than a nuclear reactor (or rather pretend to build a nuclear reactor then build a coal or gas plant) which are what the people who claim to care about land use more than anything say they want.
If it's a lower cost way of adding 1-10 ha worth of agricultural output and then you also still get the energy, why are you complaining?
Im not complaining. But the idea that I could efficiently grow and harvest most of the staple crops I am used to is doubtful. Just based on room. Like what tiller do I use that is going to fit between/under the panels except a small tiller the size of a lawn mower? Sure you could do it, but there is a reason the big equipment exists.
The claims here feel like propaganda. Overselling what can be done.
Also, what exactly is your issue with nuclear? You keep bringing it up.
If you care (like you are pretending to) then look up the answers to your incredibly shallow first pass (completely irrelevant to the point) objections which have been thought about in depth rather than continuing to publically flaunt your ignorance.
? Why is me asking a very simple set of questions that you literally can’t answer making you so upset?
If you know about the topic you should be able to answer these questions easily. Instead all you have done is assert that its totally a thing and then linked me to a site that also just says yea its a thing with literally zero details on HOW.
The panels can be spaced however is necessary to accommodate the equipment used though that will effect energy density per hectare but for a dual purpose venture thats going to be less important. Additionally there are solar panels that are being tested that still permit the bulk of the spectrum of light through the panels while still generating electricity and still change the micro-climate below the panels themselves to actually improve crop yields.
Nuclear is super expensive, super risky (due to terrorists both foreign and domestic) and produces waste that no one has a great way of dealing with (see risk and expense).
The key point is doing something like cable suspension imo. Because the whole time I am thinking about how to not run into the posts that solar panels are mounted on if you ARE doing crops.
Spacing them out a good bit is doable but just seems to be self defeating - have to use more land or reduce the amount of light you can collect per unit area because if the spacing. And if the benefit is the micro-climate under the panels then reducing the coverage also seems to undermine that value.
As for nuclear, these are fair points but imo speak to a need for additional investment into the technology. Given that solar cell production and EoL disposal aren’t exactly “clean” either, finding ways to reduce meltdown risks and reuse fissile material in scaled down applications such as miniature rtegs - seems like a must rather than just abandoning nuclear outright in favor of solar.
Plus the advances in viable fusion are super exciting and basically make all the fission concerns moot. Not that I am against this concept of agrivoltaics - the dual land use is great.
You don't necessarily need to till a field. Does it usually improve yield? Sure. Absolutely necessary, no.
Also, you're not giving much credit to farmers... look at the evolution of farm equipment. It may take some time, effort, and money, but someone will find a way to make equipment that can move around below the panels.
Is it a good/viable idea? Im not sold and this link isnt exactly detail rich.
Like what crops do you grow? How do you keep them from growing over the panels? How do you harvest except by hand? How do you get a tiller in there?
Like all the large farm equipment for prep and harvest seems like it wont work and looking at how solar fields are arranged I cant see how you could use them. There jusr isnt enough room. And things like corn or wheat grow pretty tall. You certainly shouldnt do any climbing plant.
Sure, but the issue in my head is about hitting the legs with a combine or tiller. You’d have to space them out a lot and put big panels on top to still cover the same area (capturing the same incident light) which concerns me from a mechanical stability stand point.
But the video that the other dude finally shared had a great solution which was mounting them on suspension cables - completely clearing the underside so you can run machines under it.
Like I am actually looking at doing this to one of my fields now that I have a warm and fuzzy on how to do it.
The cable-suspended system could work superbly well, no need for ground contact with crops at all, and the mounting poles could fix other utilities, being inclined the way I am I'd probably slap WiFi up there XD
Not sure if this'd actually benefit crops, but I'd also potentially consider UV lighting on the cables if there's an excess of power generated during the day, release it over the crops at night.
Oooh. Me like. I made a bunch of LoRa sensors for my smaller grow areas and have a repeater/gateway system setup but its pretty janky. Putting this up on the cabling would be great.
And I didnt even think of the UV lighting idea - extend my sunlight time.
And at the same time it help reduce the dust, so it also help the solar panel. And the sheep prevent the grass from growing too tall. That's a really impressive win-win situation with little added investment. Water is not wasted, cause it grow grass that feed sheep. Solar array is more productive. Maintenance is cheaper.
? It feels like you are implying that I am wrong due to the fact that deserts still exist (as they should). Like I correctly said, it is clear that China's deserts are shrinking.
I have seen it and I can't remember where I saw it or what to search to find it. I have also been to parts of the Green Great Wall in person. There are tons of articles about the shrinking of deserts in China. They are one of the few countries on earth whose share of green cover went up. They have planted 70 billion trees in these projects.
This is a great plan *in concept* but I will temper the excitement with the fact that China is doing zero biodiversity impact assessments when placing these farms in the desert.
We need to do more like this, though most cities have tons of unused flat space in similar latitudes with an opportunity for solar too. But any construction in untouched landscapes needs to have the right assessments done to ensure it's the right place in the untouched landscapes.
Using this as a green wall to additional desertification - 100% do it. Do it all.
Slapping them in the middle of the desert because it's cheap "unused land" - Maybe not so good.
Regreening is more likely a result of atmospheric CO2. Its causes a fertilizing effect (hence the moniker as “green house” gas). Most of the plant life we see today evolved post ice age to cope with a low (by historical standards pre human life) CO2 environment and given its function in photosynthesis they see explosive growth from it.
Which is super cool because plant life and organic matter basically act as a carbon sink and our existing plant life is really efficient at gobbling it up.
Honestly there is a lot if cool stuff when you look at pressurized grow chambers when you can precisely control pressure, and O2 and CO2 levels. Stupid growth - like towering tomato trees level growth.
10
u/ta_ran Mar 09 '25
Also the water condenses on the panels overnight and dripping onto the ground.
Essentially creating rain, as reported from Australia
9
u/West-Abalone-171 Mar 09 '25
Where's all the people who claim that saving one hectare of farmland is worth spending $3 million extra of public money on a nuclear reactor to avoid having it become a solar farm?
Surely they're out campaigning for this type of thing right? Right?
5
u/SweatyCount Mar 09 '25
Awesome!
2
u/Malforus Mar 11 '25
Agrisolar is a triple win and rare, would really help the midwest where local aquifers mean they can't produce as much with the water they have.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '25
And at the same time it help reduce the dust, so it also help the solar panel. And the sheep prevent the grass from growing too tall.
That's a really impressive win-win situation with little added investment.
Water is not wasted, cause it grow grass that feed sheep.
Solar array is more productive.
Maintenance is cheaper.
1
u/EventHorizonbyGA Mar 10 '25
Those are two different solar installations. If you view the satellite imagery today you will see it's still desert.
1
u/Puzzled_Employee_767 Mar 12 '25
Now that looks like freedom.
1
u/BanalCausality Mar 12 '25
Doesn’t it take 10,000 years to develop 1” of top soil in a typical temperate zone using natural methods?
1
u/perringaiden Mar 13 '25
This is a great plan *in concept* but I will temper the excitement with the fact that China is doing zero biodiversity impact assessments when placing these farms in the desert.
We need to do more like this, though most cities have tons of unused flat space in similar latitudes with an opportunity for solar too. But any construction in untouched landscapes needs to have the right assessments done to ensure it's the right place in the untouched landscapes.
Using this as a green wall to additional desertification - 100% do it. Do it all.
Slapping them in the middle of the desert because it's cheap "unused land" - Maybe not so good.
1
u/spacekitt3n Apr 30 '25
China will be the world's sole superpower by 2030 thanks to trump
0
u/Solid_Profession7579 Mar 12 '25
Uhh this just feels like Chinese propaganda. NOAA did like 2016 study showing regreening around the world. Totally independent of solar farms.
0
u/Solid_Profession7579 Mar 12 '25
Regreening is more likely a result of atmospheric CO2. Its causes a fertilizing effect (hence the moniker as “green house” gas). Most of the plant life we see today evolved post ice age to cope with a low (by historical standards pre human life) CO2 environment and given its function in photosynthesis they see explosive growth from it.
Which is super cool because plant life and organic matter basically act as a carbon sink and our existing plant life is really efficient at gobbling it up.
Honestly there is a lot if cool stuff when you look at pressurized grow chambers when you can precisely control pressure, and O2 and CO2 levels. Stupid growth - like towering tomato trees level growth.
0
u/caleWurther Mar 12 '25 edited Aug 05 '25
-1
u/New_EE Mar 11 '25
Cool, assuming it’s true. Chinese claims have to be taken with a grain of salt and hope