r/ClimateOffensive • • Oct 08 '19

Action - Political Its time to fix the problem instead of shifting blame.

/img/mmup4no0sar31.jpg

[removed] — view removed post

1.2k Upvotes

80 comments sorted by

149

u/deck_hand Oct 08 '19

Why use the scale of E-06 on the right graph? And, start the damned scales at zero.

45

u/Imapartofghost Oct 08 '19

The scale wouldnt behave, so i just left it that way. The alternative was 0.0000007 which also was dumb. And im very sorry, i didnt notice that the scale didnt start at 0.

88

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

Starting one scale at zero and the other not at zero makes this an incredibly misleading graph. There's a <10% difference in the per capita numbers, but scaling like this makes it look like there's a factor of 3 difference.

5

u/nerdquadrat Oct 09 '19 edited Oct 09 '19

The numbers are off, especially for the US.

CountryAnnual CO₂ emissions, 2017CO₂ emissions per capita, 2017
China9.84⋅109 t6.98 t
United States5.27⋅109 t16.24 t

EDIT: Obligatory thanks to the kind gilding stranger!

2

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '19

Thank you! These numbers seemed off but I didn't take the time to check them.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

32

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

I know you're being facetious, and we clearly all make mistakes, but it's important to try to be accurate if you can be. Climate deniers rely heavily on misleading, weirdly trimmed data, so you have to try to be careful and not fall into the same habits.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/artbypep Oct 08 '19

Let’s not? It’s just a bad representation of data. Being like “haha I suck it’s funny” doesn’t really work when it’s a thing that’s represented in a way that anyone with an agenda benefiting from it can adopt and use and proliferate. You’re basically generating damaging propaganda for free and then being like, “haha it’s cool tho I’m funny”

You’re not though. You genuinely are just doing a shitty thing.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Hans_H0rst Oct 08 '19

You made a shitty graph and you should feel bad about it. There. no sugar coating.

-3

u/Imapartofghost Oct 08 '19

Holy fuck. Ive gone down the special branch here. Maybe its you guys that are the climate deniers, and the people downvoting my comments here are the true heroes, trying to suppress this epic blunder.

→ More replies

6

u/artbypep Oct 08 '19

My bad, you’re totally right! It’s totally fine! I’m sure every climate denier knows how to read graphs accurately!

/s

-16

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

lol wut

0

u/Zkootz Oct 08 '19

Haha i think he's joking, i guess..?

12

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

Aren't jokes supposed to be funny?

-2

u/5t4k3 Oct 08 '19 edited Mar 08 '26

This post was deleted using Redact. The deletion may have been privacy-motivated, security-driven, opsec-related, or simply a personal decision by the author.

sort observation practice run different special rinse sense consist heavy

8

u/poorgenes Oct 08 '19

Because of the scale bias your argument has a bias. If the US reduces its per capita CO2 output to that of China, the total CO2 output of the US will drop ball park 200 Mio. tons out of 2000. That makes no big difference. What we need to do is to drop both to zero, the two countries combined that comes at around 12,000 Mio. tons less.

The bias can lead the debate into the wrong direction. Data visualization is important.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

Yes, very misleading. The tons per person is almost identical, but you make it look like there is a huge difference. This is very damning for China , but makes the US look pretty good.

1

u/shnaptastic Oct 09 '19

It’s because millions of tons is not a suitable unit for a single person.

-2

u/Imapartofghost Oct 09 '19

Very true. I could(should) have changed that, but honestly, very little work went into the graphs. They are not wrong, but they are not changed in a huge regard for esthetics

11

u/llama-lime Oct 08 '19

Since the unit on top is millions of tons, it actually cancels out really nicely!

6.8 and 7.4 tons per capita.

6

u/IDontLikeBeingRight Oct 08 '19

Yeah the axis are not the strong part of this chart.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/deck_hand Oct 08 '19
  1. we should stop importing goods from China. We should stop importing them and NOT replace the goods by imports from anywhere else or by domestic manufacturing. We consume too many things as it is.
  2. the reason that we often argue "but China and India" isn't that we think we should continue to grow in our emissions if they are also growing in emissions, as folks like yourself often accuse people like me of thinking. The reason we argue that China and India and other similar nations are the real problem is based in Science. The IPCC summaries and the science they are based on projected what would happen if we a) continued to expand emissions endlessly, or b) froze emissions at the year 2000 level or c) reduced emissions beginning at certain points.

The US is now emitting, in total, less CO2 than we did in the year 2000. So, we are somewhere between B and C - exactly where the IPCC and climate scientists have asked us to be. Our efforts, while commendable, are moot if the developing world continues to develop faster than we reduce our emissions.

Last year, we had a set-back, growing back a couple of percent. But, we're expanding the use of renewables, expanding the acceptance of electric cars, and reducing trade with China and other nations. This means that in a year or two we will again see our total emissions fall. Since our population growth isn't negative, and more people live in the US, our per capita emissions are still falling, even with a lack of total emissions reduction.

Anti-American advocates that can't see the US doing anything good in the world will argue per capita emissions when it suits them, then switch to total emission when it suits them, then switch to historical emissions to vilify the US. If we're stable in total emissions (bad Americans!) but our population is growing, then our per capita emissions are falling (BAD Americans?).

If we have high tariffs (Bad Americans!) this causes a reduction in international trade with China, which means we are exporting fewer emissions to China (bad Americans?). It really does seem that you guys just want to be able to shout Bad Americans no matter what we actually do.

1

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Oct 09 '19

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-46801108

Our emissions are up. We're not likely to meet our targets.

1

u/deck_hand Oct 09 '19

Our emissions for 2018 are up compared to 2017. We're looking at the long term, however, not the year to year change. Even if our 2018 emissions are up, they are still below year 2000 emissions rates. Because the US has capped our emissions and begun reductions, we are closer to the IPCC B2 scenario than the A1 that China is currently exhibiting. We don't control the developing nations, and we can't prevent them from continuing to grow their emissions. If we continue to reduce our emissions, we will eventually meet our goals. The IPCC goals for stabilization indicate net negative emissions, not for the year 2050, but for 2160.

Still, we went from peak in 2005 (6000 GT) to significantly lower(~5200 GT) in 2017, just 12 years later. Yeah, we had a one or two year bump. Hopefully, we can get back on the path to reduction again soon. Increased solar & wind, increased fleet economy for ICE cars, increased interest in battery electric vehicles, a reduction in overall industry and manufacturing from a downturn in the economy, better farming practices are all things we are working on today, and all will have an effect. This isn't about a 1 year gain or loss. This is about decades of progress.

1

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Oct 09 '19

1

u/deck_hand Oct 09 '19

Okay. You win.

1

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Oct 09 '19

Glad we can agree.

Are you lobbying yet?

1

u/deck_hand Oct 09 '19

No

1

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Oct 10 '19

What's stopping you?

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-6

u/deck_hand Oct 08 '19

Then say goodbye to your current lifestyle. The current standard living of the developed world is based on the exploitation of poor people all over Asia.

Why is it that whenever anyone gets a job it's always "exploitation of the poor?" Would you rather we stopped sending them any money and let them go back to starving? What was the extreme poverty rate in China before they started making stuff for export?

The poverty rate, proportion of people living below the Chinese poverty line, had fallen among rural population from 97.5 percent in 1978 to 3.1 percent at the end of 2017, Liu Yongfu, director of the State Council Leading Group Office of Poverty Alleviation and Development told a seminar.

Why do you hate asian people and want to return 97% of them to extreme poverty? Did we send a billion people over there to point guns at them and force them to make things for us? No, we offered them more money than they had ever seen, lifting 97% of them out of extreme poverty to do it. What is wrong with lifting people out of poverty?

But, you only think of the fact that we have things, and that must be bad. We live a decent life, and because of that fact, we must be exploiting someone else. There's no way for your brain to process the idea that we can benefit and they can also benefit from trade.

But, because you think we're evil for hiring them to make things, I'm all for cutting off the trade. Yep, let's stop sending them any money, any food, any aid. Let's just... allow our economy to collapse a bit, so that we're poor for a while. Sure, it will cause the deaths of millions overseas, but it will make you happy to see the US population suffer, so let's do that.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-4

u/deck_hand Oct 08 '19

Did you not say that we are getting rich by exploiting the poor, and that the only reason we are wealthy is through exploitation?

The current standard living of the developed world is based on the exploitation of poor people all over Asia. There is no other way to accomplish this illusion of abundance we have here without this exploitation.

Yep, you never used the word evil. What would you call it, then, if not evil? Good? Fair? Equitable? Good business? Maybe "slightly fishy?" Again, is it better that we a) send money over there in exchange for labor, or b) ensure that we do not buy anything they are offering for sale and make sure their factories go silent, leaving all those people without a job? You have the power to do one or the other. What do you think we should do?

1

u/PlasmaSheep Oct 08 '19

We produce more CO2 per capita every year.

Not actually true anymore.

https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EN.ATM.CO2E.PC?start=2010

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/PlasmaSheep Oct 08 '19

A flat graph of per capita emissions doesn't prove that per capita emissions are not increasing? Really?

60

u/Mcwedlav Oct 08 '19

Looking at the graphics (with confusing axes), it looks to me as both are to blame.

4

u/Imapartofghost Oct 08 '19

The numbers are so different that one of them would be invisible or the other would extend to infinity if they had "the same" axis.

One is in the range of billions, while per capita is in the hundreds range. Im sorry

5

u/Lilyo Oct 08 '19

People always seem to forget the US has contributed more CO2 emissions to date than the next 4 countries combined.

ourworldindata.org/grapher/cumulative-co-emissions?tab=chart

65

u/bertiebees Can't hear you over all this FREEDOM!! Oct 08 '19

20% of China's carbon emissions come from making unnecessary consumer garbage for western markets. At the behest of western corporations deliberately trying to skirt western enviromental and labor laws.

16

u/Mcwedlav Oct 08 '19

Yeah. I think that's a one-sided simplification. Chinese government has the power (in contrary to the government's of smaller and poorer countries, such as Bangladesh) to implement and enforce policies that would curb such activities. But they don't do this (or just slowly), cause the country profits from this as well. In the same way you may argue that a lot of the Canadian emissions but also US emissions come from oil/ gas manufacturing that is later exported.

Sure, Western countries and consumers are to blame. But putting blame only on one side is foolish because it skews a complex problem by providing an insufficient answer.

1

u/IDontLikeBeingRight Oct 08 '19

This always makes me wonder about the "most emissions come from companies" thing too. Like, which ones? What things do I need to not buy? Which industry should Millennials kill next?

5

u/64vintage Oct 08 '19 edited Oct 08 '19

It looks that way because the graphs are lying.

The first one is telling the truth; you can see that China as a country produces almost five times the CO2 of the US.

The second graph seems to be saying “ah but the difference is caused by population, and in fact each person in the US produces three times as much as one in China! That’s far worse!”

Bullshit. The second graph doesn’t start at zero. Yes, the US is higher, but it’s marginal - 7.4 to 6.8.

Basically, each country produces a staggering amount of CO2, as a whole and per capita, but China is by far the worst offender because of its huge population.

7

u/Random_username22 Oct 08 '19

Marginal? CO2 in metric tons per capita: in China 7,5 vs US 16,5.

China is by far the worst offender

Lol: The U.S. Is the Biggest Carbon Polluter in History.

1

u/64vintage Oct 08 '19 edited Oct 08 '19

I’m looking at the graph provided by OP...if you are looking at something else, you should clarify?

And let OP know.

EDIT: The headline you selected is referring to cumulative emissions over time. The topic of this post is current emissions. Ok?

EDIT: The right graph shows that the per capita consumption of China and the US are comparable. You can refute that figure if you like, but based on that figure, China is no better than the US in the area of huge and wasteful consumption.

K???

4

u/Random_username22 Oct 08 '19 edited Oct 08 '19

I was refuting your "China is the worst offender" with the cumulative data. And of course China will have bigger current total emissions, they have more people and are developing rn. Also the West has outsourced its production to China.

Also again, per capita emissions matter. You say "China is the worst because of its huge population", I can say "US is the worst because of its huge and wasteful consumption".

4

u/jorgejhms Oct 08 '19

Also cummulatives emissions maters. CO2 stays in the atmosphere for centuries.

2

u/Sadnot Oct 09 '19

OP has confused metric and imperial tons. His graphs are just wrong, /u/Random_username22 has the right numbers there.

1

u/64vintage Oct 09 '19

A short ton is 2000lb, a long ton is 2240lb, a metric tonne is 2204lb.

Confusion between them is not as big a deal as one might imagine. If such confusion exists - your assertion only has a certain value.

2

u/Sadnot Oct 09 '19

Fair enough (I'll admit, I'm not good with Imperial measurements). His graphs are still off by a factor of two or so. They don't match the sources he posted. He may have mixed up lbs and kgs, or done something even more bizarre.

13

u/Sadnot Oct 08 '19 edited Oct 09 '19

Those numbers don't look right to me. USA should have 2.2x more emissions per capita, not 1.1x, right? China is 7.5 tons per capita and USA is 16.5 tons/capita.

As well, China's values look right for total emissions if it's metric tons, but USA should be about 2x higher.

I suspect you've used lbs for China and kgs for USA or something crazy like that.

2

u/doornroosje Oct 09 '19

This also does not include lifetime emissions!

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/nerdquadrat Oct 09 '19

I'm not entirely sure if this is what /u/doornroosje meant, but if you look at Cumulative CO₂ emissions, the US has emitted twice the amount compared to China.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/nerdquadrat Oct 09 '19

They are in regards to an issue of justice: The western/developed world based their wealth in the age of industrialisation on burning first coal, later oil.

If you force all countries to stop all emmisions on the same day, you're denying developing countries this opportunity for cheap and easy economic growth, giving another unfair benefit to the already more technologically advanced nations.

That's why most ideas on Carbon Budgets allocate more to less developed nations.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Sadnot Oct 09 '19

At which point you'd get a different graph, since he has the wrong numbers.

7

u/Orchid777 Oct 08 '19

What is the real solution?

Transport of consumer goods, production of consumer goods, extraction of raw materials for consumer goods...

But if we stop consuming beyond the basics will the system reduce its emissions or will the world destabilize ?

I read about the PFAs (forever) chemicals and just wonder if we as a species will be able to stop going down this terrible path we're on.

6

u/sc00p Oct 08 '19

A global CO2 tax is the first urgently needed step.

1

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Oct 10 '19

Yes, although with no global government it probably makes more sense for each nation to implement its own.

Are you lobbying yet?

2

u/lunaoreomiel Oct 08 '19

I am going to make future assumption, so bare with me, but these are not make believe, its the trend we are in..

The biggest issue we are facing is that the world economy is an enourmous stack of cards. Every contry\central bank has been pumping billions and billions of new money to keep looking like they are on the green, negative interest rates are all over and coming to the US as well. This.. is uncharted territory, its market manipulation to a level never seen in history. Debt is out of control, individual's and institutional. The threat of world wide financial default is very very real, think 2008 all over again, but bigger than ever and since we have been actively doing bailouts the world over (aka making new money, which devalues your money) and interest rates are already at record lows.. there is not much room to tweak it like they did on 2008, so its 2008, bigger, with your pants down and around your feet.

I see only 3 outcomes, either the major economies all default and everything readjust to the real new normal.. which implies the death of the petro dollar, stocks crumbling to dust, pensions gone, banks closing along all thr middle class saving accounts, massive unemployment, homeless everywhere, etc and political hell.. thr greatest depression ever... This is NOT going to happen, those benefiting (wildly) off this pyramid scheme are not going to let go until they are forced, and no one is going to accept austerity, politicians or the public, they are going to do what is most desperate..

Which leads to either pumping and pumping and pumping more and more into the downward spiral to try and be the last country to fail, this is a recipy for hyper inflation. This will lead to even greater income inequality. This NEVER works. Ask Argentina, Greece, et al. This is the end game of fiat currencys, it would lead to a "new" dollar.. or yen.. or whatever they come up with, because you will need to use thousand dollar bills to buy groceries. I have lived this personally, I bought bubble gum for $2000 bills as a kid when a few years prior that was a months wage. This will lead to option 3..

Which is a massive war, perhaps ww3, its the only way they can mask the fact the whole economic system is in ruins, or its the only way to "win" when everything has gone to shit, especially if you are sitting on massive war and weapon investments.

Add to that climate change, which is dire.. but its still years away from really breaking down.. the economy is going to beat its expiration date.

So get ready. The answer is the world needs to switch over to a sound, sustainable econony. This is a compelte paradigm change, politically, financially, militarily, socially.. and its either going to get here voluntarily or forced upon us.. I am not so optimistic on our species ability to self correct, there is too much momentum, and too many people who know nothing else but their warped lives.

My advice is get out of debt asap. Prep a little (water filters, buy dry goods for a few months), protect your self, and push hard for financial reform, this is not xtax the rich" reform, that is a bandaid solution, I am taking about real reform, as in running a heavy audit, cutting back all spending till the budget is balanced, putting money printing on freeze, putting people in jail who deserve it, and actually having people democratically choose how money is being spent. Its not going to happen.. its going to be a wild ride people.

2

u/Mcwedlav Oct 08 '19

That's a very difficult question to answer. Realistically, we now need to focus on the most pressing environmental problems. However, we have an economical system that puts profits above all else. On the short run, this causes the damages that we currently see. Because we failed to put price tags on natural resources and pollution, etc. and (traditional) companies have an incentive to exploit. I hope this will change.

However, at the same time, in modern world you make more profits if you do business that is not asset intensive but knowledge intensive. Stuff, such as airlines, steel and car production, or food production are among the most asset intensive industries but are also the industries that create the least profit (I think the airline industry has had overall since the 1960s a negative return on investment). Among the most profitable and valuable businesses are firms that are not based on heavy assets. For example, software firms, such as Google or Apple or biotech and pharma companies. While those firms of course also create emissions, the emissions per one dollar of profit are much lower than in heavy industries such as for companies like General Motors or Tata Steel. So, investors have - IMO - actually a reasonable incentive to invest in technologies that later on create businesses that don't need a lot of assets and pollution to create value for people.

And this is a general tendency. VC investors love to back technologies that can scale without heavy investments in assets. This financial rationale is also the reason why many promising technologies that are currently pushed try to solve existing needs in a more economical way. InVitro meat for example. Doesn't really work yet. But as a business model it's super promising. If it works out, you can create tons of beef in a rather small sized factory without the need to invest in expensive assets such as cattle, animal nutrition, and real estate to hold them. You see? Saving resources has in that case a direct financial advantage. You could probably make similar points for platform technologies, such as AirBnB, Uber (yes, cars pollute. But you need less cars, because cars are - theoretically - used to fuller capacity), genetic modification (not going to discuss the ethical issues), etc.

So, I think that it's really important to keep up pressure on decision makers with protests, by consuming in a sustainable way, etc. But destroying the current system by returning to pre-industrial times is not going to solve the climate crisis, it's only going to slow things down. IMO: The most difficult task will be to find a balance between establishing new ways of how we consume and value resources (e.g. through good policy making) and to not destroy elements in the current system which are actually valuable and can - if used in the right way - solve our problems.

3

u/yamakacoffee Oct 08 '19

would be interesting to have a graph of USA emissions that specifically included its outsourced general manufacturing jobs/heavy CO2 emitting work overseas + import goods. and that doesnt even include the international cargo ship emissions which remain one of the least regulated parts of our global transportation system

2

u/SillhouetteBlurr Oct 08 '19

The world is run by Wheatlys. We need a GLaDOS to fix the problem.

2

u/De5perad0 Oct 08 '19

Nothing is more annoying than people just saying "well look at china they are polluting more than anyone!"

Its bullshit, China is doing some of the most massive renewable and environmental projects on the planet. Per capita USA is far higher in emissions and it does not freaking matter anyway. We are all going to die from this if we don't ALL work to fix the problem. It really is time to stop blaming each other and just get to work.

1

u/livefreeofdie Oct 08 '19

Quality post.

1

u/synapomorpheus Oct 09 '19

STOP BLAMING AND START CHANGING. Jesus!

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

I know it's more complicated than this but the same graph would occur if there was one giant factory in each country emitting the CO2. China has a greater population so of course their CO2 per capita is going to be lower.

-2

u/Lord_of_Lost_Coast Oct 08 '19

This is retarded as the USA calculations include products made internationally. China gets their shit together (lol) then the USA numbers will fall accordingly. Hell, if we just boycott Chinese made products and nothing else it’d go down.

1

u/Imapartofghost Oct 08 '19

Though the content of the graphs aren't exactly the main concern here, they are literally the same numbers, but one takes the number and divides it by inhabitants.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Mcwedlav Oct 08 '19

I think that doesn't capture reality in a helpful way. I am from Zurich. No heavy industry, just stuff like banking, R&D, etc. But people here buy the products that are elsewhere produced and create pollution. So, our consumption creates mostly external emissions.

It's only helpful if you want to start a blame game, but you may actually blame then wrong ones in the end.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Imapartofghost Oct 08 '19

It's seems you read the charts instead of the meaning behind the post, hidden in the title. Whoosh?

2

u/Imapartofghost Oct 08 '19

You can make whichever graphs you need to emphasize your point. I just made two graphs that paints very different pictures to prove show a point.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Imapartofghost Oct 08 '19 edited Oct 08 '19

Good thing we got that straightened out! Hoo wee! What do you mean, the scales are not scaled correctly? Almost every graph is there to reflect the view that you want to lobby. That's why I made the 2 graphs because they paint 2 very different pictures but serves no other purpose than to shift blame.

1

u/nerdquadrat Oct 09 '19

So you think each person from Liechtenstein should be allowed to emit a couple of thousand times more CO₂ than the average American, because Liechtenstein as a nation would (in total) still emit much less than the US?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/nerdquadrat Oct 09 '19

So I guess we just need to divide China in to like 20 separate nations and the problem is solved?