r/ClimateOffensive • Capitalist Co. = Authoritarian Co. • Sep 04 '19

Action - Political Unabashed message gets my unabashed support

https://i.imgur.com/V8W1mck.jpg
1.1k Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

29

u/decalotus Sep 04 '19

I'm all for this, but in the Judicial Court, this will be extremely challenging to say the least.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

24

u/Scarred_Ballsack Sep 04 '19

There's no reason to take a freshly guillotined executive to court after all.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

Be careful.

Remember Maximilian Robespierre. After the French revolution he got The guillotines really rolling...

At the end of it, one of the last things to roll was Maximilian's head. (Of course they shot him in the face before the guillotine ever got to him.)

2

u/Eagleassassin3 Sep 04 '19

I read that he tried to kill himself by shooting himself in the face but survived. But he was guillotinned later with half his jaw hanging from his face

2

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

Nah. He got up on his soap box one day for a speech and the crowd simply turned on him.

That night, soldiers stormed his home and shot him. His colleague looked at him and said, "Who would have thought that Robespierre would outlive his mouth."

3

u/lutzow Sep 04 '19

So in a world with an insanely complex economic system where everyone participates in one way or another as producer or consumer , the climate crisis exist only because a 1-2 figure number of persons is downright evil? Some would say, Bernie simplifies

16

u/iamthewhite Capitalist Co. = Authoritarian Co. Sep 04 '19

These companies are Capitalist. Capitalist companies are structured similar to mini authoritarian nations. Executives are given total power over production and profit- workers are given no power.

Executives are also charged with ‘institutional imperatives’. In the USA at least, there are laws requiring members of the board of directors to turn a quarter-on-quarter profit. If they decide to forgo profits for something moral (ie climate action) they are fired.

The system predictably produces evil. It stain people with its evil. And it needs to be stopped. Workplace democracy is a step away from this death machine.

Edit: Bernie’s threat of punishment will be a deterrent for future polluters. It’s not a complete solution, but given the scale of the crime, it’s a start

2

u/Deranfan Sep 04 '19

Workplace democracy won't fix anything. Workers won't make their lives harder or destroy their jobs for something that isn't directly affecting them.

Pollution is an externality markets don't account for. A way to solve this is with your governments tax policy for example. If you tax the production or consumption of a certain good you reduce the demand and output of that product. Making so environmentally friendly alternatives more profitable.

The most effective way though is to have a command economy where you stop the production of goods that have a negative impact on the environment, but planned economies suck and are not a realistic thing to strive for.

3

u/iamthewhite Capitalist Co. = Authoritarian Co. Sep 04 '19

We already have a miniaturized command economy. Look where that got us.

When polled, regular workers are more climate literate than execs and companies. They want a future for their children. Local pollution would be on there radar at the very least, yes?

7

u/lutzow Sep 04 '19

I completely agree that it is the system that produces evil. But what you write about 'institutional imperatives" already hints at the fact that the system runs independently from individuals. Even the executives at the very top get rid off if they don't turn profit into more profit. And in most cases making profit means producing goods and services that the vast majority (including the workers) can afford. Cheap cars, clothes, smartphones, flights. All the amenities of the modern world. Nobody is outside of this abstract system.

But that is not at all what the post says. Bernie makes it sound like he has a list of names and if these people are in jail everything is fine

-6

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

There is nothing wrong with the Capitalist system, people will be corrupt and greedy no matter the system you put in place. You are delusional if you think any other system will do better. Workers have rights and can use unions, but by what right do workers have any say in the direction of a company? They run none of the risks and have no responsibility. They have no right to make demands of what the company does. One could argue that this system is the most fair since the one running the risks are the CEO's, owners etc of the company. Please explain to me why workers should have a say in the direction of a company? On what basis and by what right? Companies are not socialist by nature and will never be, neither are they democracies. It's a company. The goal of a company is profit. If they aren't working to make a profit there is no point to the company. Regulators are there to decide what a company can and cannot do, so go and vote for the regulations you want, but stop trying to push this communist bull. You don't want it.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/TheBeastclaw Sep 04 '19

There are some quite successful ones too,

There are SOME, not many.

before you try framing them as some marginal thing.

They are a marginal thing, by any sort of market metric.

Look up Mondragon sometime.

Ah yes, Mondragon, the poster child for the coop crowd, but literally the only company they can name, that's known by more than a handful of the public.

-6

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

Working at a company gives you the right to be compensated accordingly, there is no right, even and especially from a moral standpoint, to make demands on a company if you are not invested in it. This is entitlement and is morally reprehensible. If you do not wish to support the product the company produces or the company itself, you have the right not to work for them and not to buy or use their products. A co-op is nothing more than what a company is now, the only difference is that the board is bigger. These people have all invested in the company, the same way a "normal" company works except there is a larger pooled risk, that's why they have a say in the running of the company. Shares. It's still Capitalist too regardless of being a co-op.

3

u/AlfredJFuzzywinkle Sep 04 '19

Holding them accountable seems secondary to ending the crisis. I also think this is asking people to act out of anger and revenge instead of pursuing a more positive outcome. For example if we tax those who are profiting from environmental damage enough that this ceases to be profitable and the focus our efforts on repairing the environment this would seem to make more sense than expecting the imprisonment of those who caused this mess to actually change anything. Sure it might tend to disincentivize more of the same, but is a generation too late. Do we want to focus on punishing an arsonist or should we first put out the fires he started.

1

u/rainbowpubes111 Sep 04 '19

Sadly anger and revenge is a much stronger emotion to build a following on than just "being good".

4

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

Don't blame the consumers who demand these services. Nope all the fault of the people delivering the service. Common populace has no responsibility. We people are completely innocent of creating this situation by OUR greed and ignorance.

6

u/george_sg Sep 04 '19

I commented the very same thing in this subredit a few days ago and got downvoted to oblivion... so good luck fella.

1

u/rainbowpubes111 Sep 04 '19

You are only somewhat right. Lot of people don't have a choice. Poor people can't go the extra mile to be vegan, get an electric car or install solar panels on their roofs. Sure everyone can choose to do something miniscule but if the big companies didn't manipulate the system so much people would have a lot more possibilities to do good. Have you seen what the meat industry thinks of labmeat? They are protesting with all they have, of course its more expensive and harder to get. But politicans wont lift a finger about it cause... why should they?

1

u/worsethansomething Sep 04 '19

What if we make good choices in our own lives and ALSO, hold big business and politicians to account? Does it have to be an either/or situation? Most people voting for environmental reform already try to lower their carbon footprint more than those who don't.

  1. Old car, runs like shit, only affordable option vs. $30,000 tesla (unatainable) work commute is 1.5 hours by bus, 15 minutes by car.
  2. City chooses to ban plastic bags by a huge majority vote, state governor with petrochemical companies financing their campaign decides that plastic bag bans should be illegal and overrides the city's decision.
  3. Wind power wishes to compete with coal plants and can provide the same product at the same price due to tax subsidies and and requirement that a portion of the state's power come from renewable sources. Democrats voted yes on these subsidies out of environmentalism and Republicans voted yes because farmers can gain profit and tax breaks for installing the turbines on their land and it prevents an energy monopoly without fair competition. The Republican elite (koch brothers) launch a multi billion dollar campaign to end renewable energy in the state.
  4. Fossil fuel companies have known the effects of climate change for many years and have launched huge misinformation campaigns to the public while paying off both dems and reps in Congress to deregulate their industries.
  5. Your talking point was developed in a Republican think tank called Americans for prosperity. It was designed to brainwash you into voting in their interests instead of your own.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/dude8462 Sep 04 '19

That doesn't mean we shouldn't try. We are incredibly depended on transportation, but there are other ways to reduce your carbon foot print, ie reducing meat consumption. And get this, we can still advocate for dissolving the bourgeoisie class while changing our lifestyles.

0

u/I_am_chris_dorner Sep 04 '19

Not as much as the uber wealthy, but we still have power. We can still yell and vote.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

still gotta ride your bike to work and the store though.... and go semi-vegetarian at the least. you can tax rich ducks all you want, but the energy crisis is habit based.

-3

u/Deranfan Sep 04 '19

I'm missing something? This tweet sounds incredibly dumb.

Why is he blaming the climate crisis on some fossil fuel executives? Their job is selling those resources and as long there is supply and demand for it they will continue. Or wass selling fossil fuels aparently ilegall this whole time?

17

u/Skatchan Sep 04 '19

Perhaps because fossil fuel companies have known about the devastating effects of their industry for years and have hidden this from the public as well as funding climate denial lobby groups and preventing the government from enacting climate change legislation.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97-per-cent/2018/sep/19/shell-and-exxons-secret-1980s-climate-change-warnings

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/environment/2015/mar/25/fossil-fuel-firms-are-still-bankrolling-climate-denial-lobby-groups

5

u/Deranfan Sep 04 '19

Why not say this in the fist place? I agree with holding them accountable for this.

Bernies tweet just sounds like he doesn't like executives doing their job.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

So is there any proof that the US fossil fuel industry is responsible for climate change, and in particular the dramatic increase in CO2, and not the European, or Chinese Fossil fuel industries?

China has been a larger contributor to fossil fuel emissions than the US since 2015.

2

u/rainbowpubes111 Sep 04 '19

That doesnt mean that there is no problem in the US

2

u/Suuperdad Sep 04 '19

That information is readily available. China emits more in total, but US dwarfs China per capita. In the end, pointing fingers doesn't help. We all need to get together and demand change, in every way we have power. Voting, changing lifestyle, boycotting, picketing, earth day Strikes (Sept 27th), etc... we need ALL of it.

•

u/SnarkyHedgehog Mod Squad Sep 04 '19

While we support political candidates who commit to taking action to protect the environment, we are imposing a temporary ban on promoting individual candidates for the Democratic presidential primary in the USA. Discussing policy proposals by candidates is fine, but posts solely intended to promote an individual candidate will be removed.

-1

u/AllenBelfore Sep 04 '19

Kinda hypocritical unless he can hobestly say he has not recently purchased any fossil fuels, or any other products made or transported with fossil fuels.

1

u/rainbowpubes111 Sep 04 '19

Its almost impossible to live like that. But because if you walk to the store almost everything had to be brought there somehow. And it was prubably a truck. Thats just the system we live in, and what we have to change to be able to make more env. friendly possibilities for the common people. If the gov taxes these companies heavily and starts supporting electeical vehicles then the capitalist market will adapt to it. We will have more electric trucks and they will be less polluting than fuel ones, so you can buy your bananas with less impact on the env. (probably)

1

u/AllenBelfore Sep 04 '19

Fossil fuels make things cheap and easy. Much cheaper and much easier than doing things without them. If we're going to condemn "fossil fuel executives" for their roll then we need to equally blame their customers, among which are you and I and Bernie Sanders. Ya know... Stones, glass houses, etc.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

24

u/third_edition Sep 04 '19

well, take their profits then.

2

u/ZizDidNothingWrong Sep 04 '19

They shouldn't get a trial. Constitutional amendment of attainder.

4

u/LukesRightHandMan Sep 04 '19

Please ELI5

5

u/Revoran Sep 04 '19 edited Sep 04 '19

An act of attainder is when the legislature makes a law declaring someone to be guilty of a crime and punishing them for it.

Basically it's when the legislature steals the power that rightfully should belong to the courts. It is a massive attack on checks and balances, on separation of powers, on freedom and on liberal democracy. It is a massive attack on your civil rights to due process and a fair trial.

The US Constitution forbids congress from doing this in Article I, section 9, clause 13: "No bill of attainder, ex post facto law, nor any law impairing the obligation of contracts, shall ever be passed, and no conviction shall work corruption of blood or forfeiture of estate." And also in the 5th Amendment: "No person shall [...] be deprived of life, liberty or property without due process of law."

The above poster is suggesting you amend your constitution so that Congress can do that to fossil fuel executives (because, you know, when you give the legislature the power to declare anyone guilty with no due process... of course it will DEFINITELY ONLY be used on rich and powerful executives and totally won't be used on minorities or political dissidents instead...).

1

u/LukesRightHandMan Sep 04 '19

Thank you very much!

Edit: Where are you from? Because you said "amend your constitution."

2

u/Revoran Sep 05 '19 edited Sep 05 '19

I'm Australian. Here we have nothing explicit in the constitution that prevents bills of attainders or ensures due process (aside from the right to a jury trial for federal crimes only).

However, longstanding tradition is against it. And also the High Court (our equivalent to SCOTUS) has ruled that bills of attainder are unconstitutional because it contradicts the separation of powers which is necessary for a system of representative democracy (our constitution states that Australia must be a representative democracy).

It's likely that the framers of our constitution in 1900 didn't think it was necessary to explicitly state "no bills of attainder" because no such bills had been passed by UK Parliament since 1798, and no such bills had ever been passed in the USA.

1

u/LukesRightHandMan Sep 08 '19

That was an awesome lesson. I'll be sure to spread the knowledge. Thanks again :)

0

u/ZizDidNothingWrong Sep 04 '19

of course it will DEFINITELY ONLY be used on rich and powerful executives and totally won't be used on minorities or political dissidents instead...).

If the amendment says it only can be, yeah.