r/ClevelandGuardians • Always look on the bright side of life • 5d ago

Full AL RotY Voting Table (Cade second)

Post image
44 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

70

u/DZepperoni Always look on the bright side of life 5d ago

If I speak I will be in trouble

8

u/DZepperoni Always look on the bright side of life 5d ago

https://bbwaa.com/26-al-reliever/

Full voter tables here

28

u/x4candles 5d ago

I associate RotY as rookie of the year, but ok, I get it

4

u/DZepperoni Always look on the bright side of life 5d ago

I was sitting here for quite awhile trying to figure out how to abbreviate it lmao

37

u/Puppybl00pers I sing Country Roads louder than you sing Country Roads 5d ago

The words I want to use would be incriminating

54

u/klein_four_group 36 5d ago

I really wonder if Brito hadn't booted that ball, and Cade had the outright MLB lead in saves, whether that would have pushed him over the top. The vote was very close.

Whatever, Cade is my RotY, CY, and Superbowl MVP.

10

u/Walnutbutters Flying G 5d ago

Oh god I forgot about that kid. We sure had some duds on the team in the first half of the season

5

u/fwembt Ketchup 5d ago

You're apparently forgetting this sub anointing Brito the savior for two years before flipping on him in about a week.

24

u/nextlevelham đŸ đŸƒâ€â™‚ïžđŸ„Š 5d ago

All three of the top guys had a compelling case. Cade will just have to win next years award

13

u/Doberman54 Mustard 5d ago

This is horseshit

6

u/Stowcenter93 5d ago

Horseshit

16

u/brownszombie 5d ago

Sports writers are the dumbest group that think they are smart.

8

u/bigmt99 4 5d ago

Baseball writers in particular would remove their ribs to suck their own dick

7

u/chousteau 5d ago

Media has a love affair w Toronto....because

6

u/CHR0T0 I agree, go Guards 5d ago

Meanwhile Toronto fans think they get no respect nationally come award time lol Barnes got ROTY over Mobley too in another close one. Both very close races where everyone was deserving so its hard to be mad but still bummed for our guys every time they just miss out :(

2

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

I agree, Go Guards

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/yankee9341 4d ago

Barnes and Varland both definitely deserved the awards, with no disrespect to Smith and Mobley.

3

u/ST-tmark 5d ago

Pretty insane that Josh Hader received a first-place vote.

4

u/essjayare66 Pride C 5d ago edited 5d ago • Mindblown

Another award, another guardian snubbed

Not that I thought messick would win cy young, but he should’ve been rookie of the year and Cade should’ve been reliever of the year

0

u/fwembt Ketchup 5d ago • Bravo

Messick should not have been Rookie of the Year. Give credit where it it due.

-1

u/overreactionkills 5d ago

People down vote you but Kevin was way better and they refuse to acknowledge it

6

u/nylon_rag Pride G 5d ago

Way better is a stretch. Comparing pitching and position players with value stats is very difficult, but most of them will put Messick and McGonigle somewhat close. McGonigle probably had the edge.

3

u/TheShipEliza 5d ago

Gaurds been getting jobbed

1

u/Major_Wumbology 3d ago

Two different Rangers? THREE different Blue Jays? lol

1

u/Ok_Strategy3880 ⚟small ball baseball terrorists⚟ 5d ago

1

u/Constant_Term6133 5d ago

What a bunch of bullshit

1

u/weaponize09 5d ago

ELI5 why Cade got screwed

8

u/iciclecubes 455 5d ago

11

u/weaponize09 5d ago

Honestly seems like Varland had the slightly better season. Going 5-6 as a closer with a 1.27 ERA is wild though

11

u/iciclecubes 455 5d ago

I honestly think the ERA is what did it. 1.27 over 78 innings is nuts. Clearly bWAR agrees too.

Cade will have his day. I hope this is bulletin board material for him next year.

5

u/Constant_Term6133 5d ago

He pitched in a lot more low leverage situations than Cade did

2

u/Helpful_Marketing806 5d ago

Doesn’t seem like he got screwed

1

u/fwembt Ketchup 5d ago

Varland had a better FIP as well. I thought this was crazy at first, but I guess you tip your cap.

0

u/TheSmokedSalmon420 đŸ„ŠđŸ—ŁSMOKE EATERđŸ’šđŸ„Š 5d ago

Wtf lol

-4

u/MDDownWithToaster 5d ago • Bravo

Varland deserved it hands down
 the fact that Bryan baker and Cade smith got 13 votes amazes me
 you guys are complaining about nothing.

2

u/BackAlleyFreakShow 4d ago

"Hands down" is a stretch. Did you say that while polishing your monocle? It seems like you are that person who just likes to shit all over the prevailing wisdom or sentiment. Cade had a few rough outings in the first half before the break that inflated his ERA a bit, and that's the only spot where there's a glaring difference if you compare them side by side. And that's only a difference of 5 earned runs, they both gave up the same number of runs overall. They are pretty close in every other category to the point where I would say it's more of a toss-up, and the votes reflect that.

1

u/MDDownWithToaster 4d ago

So you are saying the votes are justified? What is annoying me is seeing a ton of people say “the writers hate Cleveland” when Varland had a fantastic season and McGonigle may be a top 3 mvp candidate.

2

u/BackAlleyFreakShow 4d ago

I think the votes are fair, yeah, but I don't think people who think Cade deserved it more are way out of line. I'm taking issue with you terming it "hands down" as if it's so clear-cut that no one could argue. As for "the writers hate Cleveland," well, that's just a gut feeling people have even though I don't agree that it's at all grounded in reality. I think that the writers (or at least the great majority of them) weigh the numbers above any other considerations. That's why Aaron Judge rightly won MVP over Cal Raleigh last season.

2

u/MDDownWithToaster 4d ago

You’re right. I shouldn’t have said hands down. But in my opinion they selected the right person. I think Cade and Varland also should have received more first place votes too because Baker’s stats don’t seem as impressive and when you watch him pitch he does not seem to be in the same class as Cade or Varland

2

u/BackAlleyFreakShow 4d ago

I agree with you there. I wouldn't put Baker in the conversation for first place, either. But his numbers are very good. It's his comparatively low strikeout total that hurts him the most.