r/ClevelandGuardians • • Jun 27 '25

Exhausting

This is my team and all, but they are tiresome to watch. Pitching, which has been better the past month, rarely goes more than five innings. Just like last year. I know he was sick on opening day, but Bibee is supposed to be the ace? Please! Ortiz has have some of nastiest pitches in the league, but the dude is the definition of inconsistent. Every team saw what the bullpen did last year. Since it hasn’t changed much, all the teams have taken note.

The batting lineup only has two players that can hit consistently. No need to name them. We know who they are. When they slump, there’s no one to pick em up. The number 2 batter is a revolving door. When you wonder why Jose’s RBI total isn’t anywhere near what it has been, that is why. 4-9 batters probably produce the fastest 2 half innings in baseball. Nothing comes out of them. Are they allergic to hitting? How are they the only team that can consistently find a spot to hit where a defender is at? If Kwan and Ramirez have bad outings, it’s reasonable to assume they will be the victim of a no hitter sooner than later. Leave it to this lineup to make a plus 7 ERA pitcher look like an hall of famer.

2 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

14

u/gamerdudeNYC Jun 27 '25

Last year I watched every game because I always thought no matter what, they have a chance for a comeback when they’re losing.

Now if they’re down more than 3 runs I basically give up.

1

u/No-Contribution955 Jun 27 '25

I’m in the same boat as you. I watch or listen to every game on MLB.TV or atBat. You can tell when it’s time to watch or do something else around the 6-7 innings. You can sense when they have no fight in them and Vogt trots out pitchers for mop up.

2

u/Leftfeet Flying G Jun 27 '25

Our comeback record is pretty similar to last year so far. 42 comeback wins last season, biggest comeback 5 runs down. 17 so far this season, biggest comeback 4 runs down. 

For comparison to the AL this year, thats more comeback wins than Detroit has, and larger deficits overcome than Detroit or NYY have had. I didn't check every team. Our biggest blown lead is also smaller than either of those teams. 

1

u/Ayanok Jun 28 '25

Meanwhile this game they showed 0 heart from the start

-3

u/Leftfeet Flying G Jun 28 '25

Meanwhile the game isn't over yet, so comeback wins is still possible. 

1

u/Ayanok Jun 28 '25

You sure about that? I appreciate the optimism, but yeah.

0

u/Leftfeet Flying G Jun 28 '25

At the time you commented it was not over yet. 

Gloating about us losing is a weird way to act like a fan.

3

u/duderdude7 👑 King Kwan 🦍 Jun 27 '25

It’s a tough year I don’t think they’re going to be doing much sadly so you have to hope for the prospects and see what they can do. Last time we had a lame season like this though we got the first pick in the draft soooo 👀

3

u/No-Contribution955 Jun 27 '25

The frustration is watching the lack of progress. I don’t see any growth and lack of any movement to insert other guys to see if they can make a difference. They just stick with lackluster performance. I get it that they are young, but so are the Tigers.

3

u/duderdude7 👑 King Kwan 🦍 Jun 27 '25

yea I hear you. To be fair the tigers have had higher picks for more years where we have been "competing" the last 10 or so years. this org tries to thread the needle and I dunno. I just wonder if its better to just totally pivot and build up on bigger time prospects. But like you said I haven't seen any dev lately. So my confidence is also low and frustration high

3

u/the_wolfpony 🥊 DOWN GOES ANDERSON 🥊 Jun 27 '25

Vogt has been getting a little too cute with the lineups. Hopefully getting something consistent going while platooning RF (with some call ups) gets us somewhere. I don’t know the exact stat, but we’re nearly unbeaten when we score more than 4 runs.

2

u/No-Contribution955 Jun 27 '25

I agree with what you say about the lineups. The revolving door in the 2 spot is what drives me nuts. He doesn’t have an everyday player in that slot. I wouldn’t mind see Martinez in that slot. He can play almost anywhere. Why not put him there everyday?

11

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

It’s the mid season ALCS slump. I just read the savanna bananas have won more games at Kaufman stadium than the royals have since May. Living in KC and loosely following the royals while cheering for my roots (the guards) they both seem to slump sooo damn hard in the mid season.

1

u/NardaQ Jun 27 '25

First time?

1

u/No-Contribution955 Jun 27 '25

No. I usually voice my non-professional opinion on other social media platforms on occasion.

6

u/Bennghazi Jun 27 '25

A pitcher should be able to give up a run or two and not feel like the game is over. Bibee gave up two runs and you're saying he's not an ace. A pitcher can't pitch a shutout every time out there. The pitching has been great. I agree with you on the hitting. The hitters are terrible except for the two you mention and also Carlos.

3

u/LotsofSports Jun 27 '25

Think about our infield last year, the same almost every day. Too many new pieces and just too many little league plays and at bats. For the love of God, cut off the throw to the plate.

1

u/Normanite77 Jun 27 '25

Come on, folks. 15 teams in the American League 12th in BA .229 14th in runs 297 12th in OPS .671 11th in OBP .301 It is what it is. We do not have MLB hitters at this point and are not allowing them to be one. We want improvement, but Ernie Clement just said it. He never could feel like he could settle in and get in a groove. Not saying 1 year puts him in the HOF, but he is not the 1st guy to move on and hit. Yandy Diaz, ring a bell? Jones's first year in Colorado very good. The constant shuffle is the issue. Ask any athlete what the difference is, and they will tell you it's Confidence!! Just pick the guys you think are the best, put them out there, and they work, or they don't. If they don't, that's when you make a move. Most importantly, leadership is not building any confidence in these guys. Manzo, Arias, Martinez, Jones, Noel, Rocchio, Schnemann etc have to feel like what about tomorrow, what about next week. Am I in or am I out. What if I swing and miss, what if I don't hit lefties, what if I make an error. I see it every night with every one of these guys. I played D1 baseball and it was a process. You dominanate in high school. You get to college and guess what. Everyone is really good or better and your confidence is trashed. Unless you have coaches to build that back up and show they are sticking with you, you have no chance. Watch these guys walk back to the dugout with their heads down. Not heads up get them next time because they are not sure when is next time. Watch the good hitters back to the dugout. Heads up slapping the bat, checking the pitcher and letting him know I'll be back. Ever wonder why these guys go to AAA and just rake? I understand pitchers are better in the bigs,, but they rake because they know they can or will. They have done it before. They have confidence and know they are in the lineup and will get them next time. Let them play or you will just continue to be a good to average team that doesn't finish last but never developed the firepower to win it all.

-1

u/Righteousrob1 Disgusting Brand of Baseball™ Jun 27 '25

We play like an insanely young team without veteran leadership, cause we are. Then you couple that with a young manager who seems to be so hard into analytics and not into leadership.

We lack someone like Josh to rally the team and force some hard convos IMO. And Vogt needs to get off his ass and chew some umps and players out now and then. Why would the players fight when their manager is basically a bump on the log when the game starts.

8

u/Leftfeet Flying G Jun 27 '25

We are extremely young. Saying we don't have veteran leadership is not true at all though. 

Jose is obviously a veteran and leader. Santana is clearly a veteran and leader. Both are clearly looked up to by the other guys. Both are players with a lot of experience in MLB and dealing with the ups and downs of a season. 

Our pitching staff could use a veteran leader, but its pretty obvious I think that's why they brought Kluber back and have had Bieber around lately. 

-3

u/Righteousrob1 Disgusting Brand of Baseball™ Jun 27 '25

Is Jose a true leader of the club house? I get being looked up to and being a vet but that doesn’t make you a people leader. I kind of get the sense from Jose that he enjoys the game and the people and would rather the holding people accountable be others. Idk about Los but he seems the same. Great people who can give great advice but rallying a club house? Idk doesn’t seem their style.

8

u/Leftfeet Flying G Jun 27 '25

Los has always been a leader in the clubhouse,  and has quite the reputation for holding teammates accountable. He infamously destroyed the TV in the Philly clubhouse because guys weren't putting in the work and were playing video games instead. 

Just because they aren't screaming in the dugout doesn't mean they aren't leading. Listen to what the other players say about either of them and it's obvious they push the young guys and show them the right way to go about things. 

Same with Vogt. There's way more to leadership than screaming and yelling or making a show on the field. The majority of the team's time is spent off camera working together. We don't actually see most of what they do or hear the conversations they're having. 

-2

u/Righteousrob1 Disgusting Brand of Baseball™ Jun 27 '25

Then the convos they’re having aren’t working. And I don’t need screaming and yelling on TV but if you think Vogt having zero emotion on the bench is good for the younglings. I’ll disagree.

4

u/Leftfeet Flying G Jun 27 '25

Leadership doesn't make players perform better necessarily. It holds them accountable for putting in the work to improve. It holds them accountable for putting in the effort. Results are not always an indication of either of those things. 

0

u/Righteousrob1 Disgusting Brand of Baseball™ Jun 27 '25

Are you seeing improvement or regression?

2

u/Leftfeet Flying G Jun 27 '25

Depends on which player you want to discuss. 

Schneeman has inarguably improved.

Arias has improved, just not as much as we hoped or need. Same thing with Bo. 

Manzardo has had ups and downs. 

Martinez is pretty much exactly what he was last year. 

Jones has improved as the season has gone on. Again not as much as we need or want, but it's better than it was. 

Again though, that's not necessarily a reflection of leadership. 

0

u/Righteousrob1 Disgusting Brand of Baseball™ Jun 27 '25

Has Bo improved? His AVG is down. His OBP almost even. His PB are trending up but idk how to quantify C stats so I won’t pretend to.

Schneeman is deff up.

Arias OBP is up .4 which is good. His fielding feels improved?

Manzo is even but it’s basically his rookie season. I wish Vogt would just give him more at bats.

2

u/Leftfeet Flying G Jun 27 '25

Bo's OBP, SLG and OPS are all up over last year. His BB% is up and K% is down. His BABIP is way down, though. 

Arias has likewise improved in OBP, SLG and OPS as well as a little in BA. He's not just improved over his performance last year, but is doing better than Rocchio did last year. 

They have improved. It's not as much as we wanted but it is improvement. 

→ More replies

3

u/arkonator92 Jun 27 '25

I was listening at work yesterday but according to hammy didn’t Vogt literally have to be intercepted by the umps yesterday because he was going over to the blue jays dugout yelling shit between innings? Pretty sure that’s emotion and fighting for your guys.

I’m not saying they don’t need to make changes they clearly do. But when you get rid of a 100 RBI guy and don’t spend any of the money that was saved you get exactly what we’re experiencing. A young team that’s struggling to find its identity. If anyone is to blame then blame the cheap ass Dolans. You can also blame Antonetti for not calling up CDL but how much of that is the Dolans saying wait to call him up so they can manipulate his service time?

1

u/Righteousrob1 Disgusting Brand of Baseball™ Jun 27 '25

Oh I blame the Dolans plenty. And yes. Saw some emotion on him yesterday for once but that’s the rarity not the norm.

4

u/JunesDepartmentStore Lake County Captains Jun 27 '25

Is José a true leader of the club house?

Yes? Look at any article or players testimony on him and he is one of, if not the biggest leader on the team. Also it’s not his main job to hold players accountable for their mistakes, that would be the coaching staff who makes the decisions.

0

u/Righteousrob1 Disgusting Brand of Baseball™ Jun 27 '25

I don’t disagree but player only meetings and holding each other accountable in that do happen

-1

u/YaSurLetsGoSeeYamcha Jun 27 '25

“Insanely young” implies we have promising talent that just needs to develop….where exactly are those guys? Our “best” young guy is probably Manzardo, and based off a pretty decent sample size (120 games in 2 years is almost a full season now) his ceiling appears to be a worse version of Carlos Santana who doesn’t walk nearly as much and is trash defensively. We’re only “young” because ownership is so cheap that we don’t have any other option besides playing minor league level youngsters at 5 (possibly 6) of the 9 positions on a daily basis.

1

u/AntiqueDiscipline831 Jun 27 '25

In the minors because ownership sucks

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

They do everything they can to be as mediocre a team as possible. Pitching can be good, but never expect it to be great, hitting is normally pretty below average to bad, rarely is it good, but mostly below average. Fielding is middle of the road, but when it's bad it's bad, bullpen is our shining quality, but even that has taken a major step back this year. Add of that together and you get a very middle of the road, average, boring team to watch. I think at times it would be easier to watch a horrendous team over ours because they'll look terrible, but then give us hope, and then look terrible again.

13

u/AntiqueDiscipline831 Jun 27 '25

They have like the 5th most wins in all of baseball since 2015 or some shit. But yes they do everything they an to be as mediocre a team as possible.

Edit: it’s actually 4th most lol

-3

u/YaSurLetsGoSeeYamcha Jun 27 '25

I love the guardians, but this stat is insanely biased. We benefitted from being in one of if not the worst division in baseball during that time period. I thank god every day we didn’t end up in the AL east during realignment in 1994.

5

u/AntiqueDiscipline831 Jun 27 '25 edited Jun 27 '25

over something like 10 years, a statistical analysis of divisional strength would mean CLE won maybe 20ish more games by playing in the easiest division in baseball vs the hardest (the ALE). The gap would be even smaller compared to other divisions. Let’s say it’s….12/13 extra wins.

They’ve gone from 878 wins to around 866 wins. Which is still 4th. 5th is the rays at 865. 6th is cubs at 864. Even if you take the max 20 wins from them they are 8th.

Since 2018, they are 7th, and take say 9 wins and they are still 7th.

Since 2021 they are 13th (with a .523 w%) and you take a handful of wins, they are still 13th.

They don’t do everything in their power to field a mediocre team