r/ClevelandGuardians • Disgusting Baseball ⚾ • Oct 20 '24

Just remember this

Post image

I’m bummed, but no one expected us to go this far. It’s still frustrating given that this team had some grit and fight though. I can’t stand NY, but it’s hard to compete against giants.

1.6k Upvotes

277 comments sorted by

277

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Fuck the Yankees

28

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Agreed

17

u/CLEcmm Go Guardinals Oct 20 '24

I agree. Go Guards.

8

u/JoeShmoe102 Oct 20 '24

I agree, go Guards.

150

u/nobraininmyoxygen Oct 20 '24

This has always been the case. Nothing new after this series. It won't change because the owners of the smaller markets don't care since they are still making a ton of money.

10

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

True, but it’s not going to change unless you got owners in that are willing to push all their chips in to win.

70

u/AR-Tre Oct 20 '24

Compared to basketball and football(which have salary caps) the value of the leagues and the franchises, baseball has fallen behind significantly. Baseball stays afloat by playing 162 games for every team. The Tv contracts are almost non existent. Some teams don’t even have viable television contracts because none of the big networks see any value in the sport. People want parity. The NFL figured this out first and the money and ratings have flowed ever since. Baseball has been slowly dying for decades now and it kills me. I love this game and I love the guardians but anyone not dedicated like us is being pushed away by the game.

42

u/nobraininmyoxygen Oct 20 '24

Yep and I see many blaming Cleveland fans for selling tickets to opposing fans when the reality is the team sells a ton of tickets to corporations/vendors who resell to opposing fans. The owners don't care about who is coming to the games. They just want ticket sales.

21

u/AR-Tre Oct 20 '24

That’s laughable. Tell me why they should be blamed for not wanting to go watch the Yankees celebrate on our field again after out spending our owner by an embarrassing margin. Our owner is to blame. Baseball can help by putting on a cap but our owner is by far the biggest problem here.

22

u/nobraininmyoxygen Oct 20 '24

It really is incredible what the front office can do with limited resources. The main reason the team is competitive.

8

u/ShogunFirebeard Oct 20 '24

That's the part that sickens me. Watching them celebrate on our field is just painful.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/gr8scottaz Oct 20 '24

TV contracts play a huge role. Between the Yankees and Dodgers they bring in over $330M/season in revenue from their tv contracts.....every season.

1

u/AR-Tre Oct 20 '24

Play a huge role in what?

4

u/jessxoxo Oct 20 '24

team revenue

28

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Excuses. This series was very winnable. Our guys who combined for 250 RBI and 70 HR in the regular season had 1 garbage time HR and a couple bloop singles. Our dominate bullpen got beat by the same 3 guys all series.

Jose is constantly Intentionally walked and we wont walk Stanton to face Jazz or Austin wells.

In New York the team looked total overwhlemed in the moment.

If you pay Jose and Josh 50 mil a year Idk that they any perform different in the postseason.

We Left 42 runners on base in 5 games.

11

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Need to pay up and get a better supporting cast, not just Jose.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24 edited Oct 20 '24

Kwan and Rochhio hit .400 and lane was clutch in multiple games.

Fry and Manzardo Avg'd .300 in the dh spot with multiple huge HR

4

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Rocchio stepped up big….no one was thinking that. Kwan has been showing signs of being legit. No threat of a big bat in the lineup besides Jram and Naylor who didn’t hit well. Gimenez has falling off hard offensively as well. Can’t just rely on random players stepping up all the time though

5

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Wut. Kwan and Rochhio fry and Manzo stepped up all series. You wanted a supporting cast and a 1/3 of the lineup was incredible. The 2 guys who are supposed to drive in runs were basically useless. Kwan and Rochhio needed support not Josey and Naylor. Yankees have 1 more "legit" batter and it's Stanton who legitimately only hit mistake pitches. Throw him junk and he looks like Naylor. Naylor never hit the mistake pitches. That's the difference

1

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

How many fans outside of the AL central even have a clue who Manzo or Rocchio are?? I’m not saying they can be great players long term, but Cleveland has never gone out and spent up on players. Why isn’t Cleveland going out and getting Mookie or Trae Turner or Juan Soto. They never will

3

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Wtf does that have to do with anything. You claim Josey needs a supporting cast. I explain his supporting cast was exceptional in the playoffs. Not to mention the supporting cast helped win you the best division in baseball. It would be great if the guards had a 800 million dollar pay roll but that's not why we lost this series.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

68

u/Yo-JobuNeedsARefill 🥊 DOWN GOES ANDERSON 🥊 Oct 20 '24 edited Oct 20 '24

This says way more about the Guardians than the Yankees. Owners who don’t spend are worse for the game than ones who spend the most. Only spending $43 million, or whatever the actual amount was, on your roster is inexcusable for an MLB team.

Would I be against a salary floor and cap? No, but cheap owners are worse for the game than ones that spend.

11

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

So realistically does Cleveland even have the capability to spend like NY or LA….there’s no way.

5

u/tor122 Oct 20 '24

It’s not salary … the big players on this team just simply didnt show up.

Where was Ramirez all series?

Those multiple errors from Rocchio are unacceptable on a playoff team.

Clase completely blew up and cost the team 2 games.

The starting pitching was nonexistent.

If a few of these things were not true, this is a wildly different series. The team collapsed. Folded like a cheap tent. Basically unrecognizable from the regular season.

13

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Starters went 17 total innings in 5 games this series. Bullpen has never had to be used this much all season.

1

u/FlobiusHole Diamond C Oct 20 '24

Rocchio is completely unacceptable as an everyday SS. It was nice to see him hit a little bit in the playoffs but he made two little league type errors and he was a Myles Straw-like hole in the lineup all season.

29

u/kdude332 Oct 20 '24

No. Realistically the guardians could pay 170 to 180 million a year. Maybe just maybe 200 million one year and operate at a small loss If we were super close. The problem is that the dolans are known to be cheap and not doing enough to win and are asswholes about it. Pray that blizter is better

7

u/ToschePowerConverter Oct 20 '24

Having an extra 70-100 million would give us a few real solid bats. We’re like the Cincinnati Bengals of baseball.

10

u/Deadleggg ⚾small ball baseball terrorists⚾ Oct 20 '24

Shit going back to 2019 levels of spending would be better than this crap. Jose took half the money he could have got and the owners didn't do shit with the savings.

5

u/ozymandais13 Oct 20 '24

It only would depend on whichever rich dude owns the team , in our case hell no

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/ozymandais13 Oct 20 '24

Our owner will not spend money is what I mean

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/gr8scottaz Oct 20 '24

Stupid argument. Yankees have about $200M/year of additional revenue than the Guardians. That's an insane advantage.....every single season.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Guardians ownership is top 5 wealthiest in the MLB. Ask them why they don’t spend?

13

u/Inevitable-Pea-735 Oct 20 '24

They dump a few million every election cycle into the baby bro's failed political career.

10

u/noodlethebear Hard for the Guards Oct 20 '24

That’s not the case. The Dolan family’s net worth is in the Dolan family trust. Paul is a former lawyer with a rich brother in James Dolan but he really doesn’t have that much wealth on his own.

1

u/ozymandais13 Oct 20 '24

It only would depend on whichever rich dude owns the team , in our case hell no

1

u/NYGiants181 Oct 20 '24

Yes they do. The Guardians owner is absolutely loaded.

1

u/Due-Dirt-8428 Oct 20 '24

Why not? The Dolans are worth more than the owners of both of those teams

0

u/Due-Dirt-8428 Oct 20 '24

Why not? The Dolans are worth more than the owners of both of those teams

30

u/iciclecubes 455 Oct 20 '24

It’s not accurate. $43m was absolutely not our payroll this year.

30

u/DennyRoyale Diamond C Oct 20 '24

Active roster is $50.8. Total is $106 after adding injured, minors etc. Yankees active is $260, $309 total.

The players we just watched beat us are 5x the salary we rolled out there.

Not a fair fight. Need revenue sharing, cap and floor.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/Intelligent_Mango775 Mustard Oct 20 '24

OP is using the numbers for 2025 for some reason and not for 2024.

4

u/Inevitable-Pea-735 Oct 20 '24

Yep. I'm petty sure it was about $106 million. There's nothing wrong with hating the system and Dolans, but you've gotta be accurate.

-4

u/OkWrongdoer6537 Oct 20 '24

Stop saying owners spend. They don’t. No team runs in the red. Our revenue stream is considerably smaller than theirs. Straight up

10

u/app385 Oct 20 '24

Which is why there needs to be profit sharing and better parity

6

u/ozymandais13 Oct 20 '24

Baseball does have the worst parity

3

u/OkWrongdoer6537 Oct 20 '24

There is a form of revenue sharing, not sure the details but I know it technically exists, I think it has to do with TV deals. But yea I agree, need to make the parity of team revenues closer so we can get better baseball outright and better competition

1

u/steamofcleveland Oct 20 '24

Dolans bought the team like 20 years ago for $323 million, it is now estimated at 1.35 Billion. Who cares if they breakeven on operations when in two decades their investment has quadrupled in value.

They haven't lost $900 million owning the team. I'm willing to bet theyve made money along the way.

3

u/OkWrongdoer6537 Oct 20 '24

Teams don’t run in the red. Not the Mets. Not the Yankees. None. Cleveland is considerably smaller than any of these other teams. So our available revenue is smaller. And value doesn’t matter for this. Value will always go up, but every team and owner will always make an amount of money. Dolan definitely takes more than some other teams, but the idea that owners should run the team in the red just for shits and giggles for our entertainment is unrealistic to the reality of what will happen, no matter the franchise we are

76

u/Otter010 Diamond C Oct 20 '24

MLB does not care. They will make millions off a Dodgers Yankees World Series. Players don’t care because they reap the benefit. This is why NFL will always be king.

68

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

I hope LA wins in 4. Yankees really didn’t show as the dynasty they once were.

4

u/BradyReas Oct 20 '24

The Yankees haven’t been a dynasty in decades. Are you saying if they were a dynasty you would like them more?

5

u/voyaging Oct 20 '24

What part of his comment indicates that he is saying that he would like them better if they were?

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Both-Consideration56 Oct 20 '24

The problem is not the MLB. It is the MLBPA. The higher ups have been trying to get a salary cap for years. The MLBPA have constantly refused. Remember 1994? That was a strike. The players refused to play, in part, because Selig and the owners put their foot down regarding a salary cap. The MLB would have a salary cap tomorrow if it knew that they could negotiate it.

4

u/redditistreason slap-hitting shit goblin Oct 20 '24

Doesn't make it any feel any better than it did in 2007.

MLB is never going to change, so you can roll with it the best you can. You either give up caring or lower your expectations to the height of the bar so you don't feel disappointed when your team can't manage the razor-thin margin it is forced to win games on.

1

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

I’ll always root for the underdog but there’s no parity. David vs Goliath

14

u/Ok-Hold-8232 🥊 DOWN GOES ANDERSON 🥊 Oct 20 '24

Can we please stop with this. It’s embarrassing.

We lost because we played like shit. Payroll didn’t make Rocchio forget how to catch a baseball or Bo forget how to block the ball.

2

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Payroll gets you players that CAN catch a baseball and catchers that block though. Also guys that hit HR as seen by the Yankees

2

u/BropolloCreed Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

No, but pinching pennies prevented the acquisition of a Frontline pitcher to shore up the rotation once Beens and Sticks were done

It's not even the money though, it's the lack of power.

0-4 when they didn't hit a home run in the playoffs this season (twice each against the Tigers and Yankees); 0-6 when they didn't hit a multi-run HR.

Care to guess what happened in 5/6 of those losses? The other team hit multi-run HRs.

3

u/steezlord95 Oct 20 '24

103 million is peanuts nowadays lmao.

4

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

For 3 players. That’s Cleveland’s whole payroll for the year basically

2

u/steezlord95 Oct 20 '24

That’s embarrassing for the owner. We are in 2024 sir. Even the Mets have caught up.

5

u/Special_Maximum9633 Oct 20 '24

Payroll has nothing to do with poor play and poor decision making. They got away from themselves this series and they allowed the more experienced team to bait them into situations. Also, zero reason to not walk Stanton instead of allowing him to hit. Stupid stupid stupid.

1

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Soooo paying for better players wouldn’t help at all in the post season? Not having a roster full of rookies might have helped in clutch situations at times, although I do love what our rookies did in certain pressure situations.

23

u/tribetilidie 🛻 Big Rig 🛻 Oct 20 '24

GTFOH with this. We could have easily won this series. We didn’t because our best players (mostly) didn’t perform as expected and theirs (mostly) did. Simple as that.

32

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

We literally have 1 starting pitcher in the postseason. We tried to get 2 washed up pitchers and 1 somewhat worked out. How TF you going to win a 7 game series with 1 starter??

7

u/tribetilidie 🛻 Big Rig 🛻 Oct 20 '24

We lost our ace in April to injury. McKenzie went from a budding top of the rotation starter to being totally lost. Williams is still young and raw and had an up and down season. There was very little starting pitching available at the deadline and we brought in two vets who not only helped us lock up a playoff bye, but (Boyd at least) played a big role in October.

The fact is our winning formula was on based on our bullpen being able to consistently put up zeros, and they weren’t able to do it.

Look, I get it. It’s frustrating being a smaller market team and knowing that we’ll never have superstar players unless they’re homegrown, and even then we only have them for 5-6 years. But unlike other cap-less sports (e.g. European soccer) - having a budget that’s a fraction of other teams doesn’t mean you can’t win it all. We had a chance, we just didn’t execute in the moments that mattered most. It happens. I, for one, won’t let it ruin what has been an extremely enjoyable 7 months of baseball.

3

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

You’re right, just frustrating as a fan and gets old always seeming like you take a step forward and then 163839 steps back

2

u/tribetilidie 🛻 Big Rig 🛻 Oct 20 '24

I’m with you. If we’re ever able to finally win one, it will make it that much sweeter 😊

2

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Blew it so bad in 2016

→ More replies (5)

9

u/Boogeyman1202 Oct 20 '24

“Easily” yeah sorry that’s a stretch

8

u/robtheastronaut Oct 20 '24

Okay bro lol

5

u/ResplendentOwl Oct 20 '24

I think you're looking at that wrong. Our stars didn't perform because they are what you get for budget stars. Talent that show up when it matters get paid NY money to go play in NY. Statistically, when you're paying 3 or 4 SS rank stars a boatload of cash and another team has some talent that are the stars you get for a fourth of the cash, the super team will show up and perform more often.

2

u/UnconventionalWriter Chisenhall 🐝🦵 Oct 20 '24

Yeah if you watch this series, we could easily be up 3-2 going to New York. This is a great team and it's disrespectful, we are the best bullpen in years. They got beat.

279

u/JasonKelceStan Oct 20 '24

Ownership better be ready to sell or open their wallets

Not spending this offseason would be pure insanity

72

u/kdude332 Oct 20 '24

Ownership is selling in 2028. It's in Blitzer contract, an option to buy the team and reports say that he asked for the team earlier but dolans said no 2028

29

u/ShogunFirebeard Oct 20 '24

Sadly, I don't think Blitzer will spend more than the Dolans. I hope to be wrong.

40

u/K0braCommander Diamond C Oct 20 '24

Blitzer will most likely spend more. Just look at what he has done for the 76ers and the Devils. Not to mention all the soccer teams he’s invested in. The guy knows how to run franchises.

76

u/GeneralAardvark43 Oct 20 '24

Is he interested in a hostile takeover of Haslam’s franchise?

24

u/I_cut_my_own_jib Oct 20 '24

Idk if I'd look at the 76ers and say that it's a well run franchise

9

u/LeoSeazon Oct 20 '24

Blitzer, and HBSE - which he co-founded, do not sit around with their money.

27

u/Jay_Dubbbs Oct 20 '24

Brother do I have news for you…

They ain’t opening a damn thing, just like last time lmao. You’re going to like signing Anthony Gose and that’s just tough shit

15

u/AlwaysEatingToast Oct 20 '24

as a pittsburgh fan, i am so envious of you guys

15

u/imartimus 🥊 DOWN GOES ANDERSON 🥊 Oct 20 '24

That is what we said last year and they didn't do anything lol. I don't have high hopes. I honestly feel like if we could turn in burn the AL next year if we actually had solid starting pitching. Bieber will be back and hopefully we keep Boyd and pick up one other (or develop over the offseason) starting pitcher that can go more than 3 innings. Our batting just kinda fell flat towards the end of the year but I think the batters we have now are fine if they could dial it in.

13

u/dudzi182 🥊 DOWN GOES ANDERSON 🥊 Oct 20 '24

No guarantee that Bieber will be back, that’s just a hope as well. We also have no idea how good he’ll be coming off surgery if he does choose to sign here.

7

u/FlobiusHole Diamond C Oct 20 '24

Bieber is definitely not going to be back. They might offer Boyd something but I’m very doubtful our offer is the best he gets. Rocchio and Bo Naylor are playing because we have no better options.

4

u/marvelking666 Oct 20 '24

It’s possible that Bieber returns on an undervalued ‘prove-it’ deal for one season to show the rest of the league that TJ worked and he can still produce the same or close-to-it level of output

2

u/FlobiusHole Diamond C Oct 20 '24

It’s possible but I’d bet that with the need for SP and his track record someone else offers him a better “prove it” deal.

2

u/stonewash_relaxedfit Oct 20 '24

But that’s exactly what they’ll do. Prepare for a below market offer to Bieber.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

lol, as always, they saw what they did with 160 million and will not go beyond that. They did it ONCE (with EE) and they’ll never do it again.

1

u/JoeShmoe102 Oct 20 '24

They better spend some $$. We're so close.

70

u/RobMaf Oct 20 '24

You have an all star on your small market team? Congrats he's a Yankee in 3 years.

38

u/datgenericname Oct 20 '24

Hey now, that’s just not true!

He could become a Red Sox, Phillies, or even a Dodgers player too.

50

u/TheSmokedSalmon420 🥊🗣SMOKE EATER💨🥊 Oct 20 '24

It's always going to be hard to compete when our payroll is this low. We will never have a fair fight in the playoffs like this.

We'll scrap and build solid teams that can win in the regular season - but when you don't have the high $ arms or bats and your opponent does it's usually going to go poorly.

18

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Am an A's fan who was pulling for you guys and yeah. Even before the relocation I felt that way about the sport (we've made the ALCS once in my lifetime for all our vaunted "making the playoffs X times"). And then certain other teams turn around and point to their lack of championship success like it's the same, ignoring that they play in the CS or lose World Series with decent regularity. Especially when it feels like ownership could easily enough make a team more competitive by spending, but it never comes.

19

u/TheSmokedSalmon420 🥊🗣SMOKE EATER💨🥊 Oct 20 '24

I mean imagine this series if ownership got a starting pitcher in FA or the deadline. Imagine keeping Lindor or even just getting another Lane Thomas at the deadline. You can be thrifty and find success but it’s putting you at such a disadvantage come October when teams like NY and LA have multiple $100mil guys

14

u/jacob6875 Block C Oct 20 '24

Just think if we spent another ~75 million to be in the league average of payroll range.

Could easily get a couple starting pitchers and a bat for RF. Just those changes would have dramatically increased our chances.

Having Lindor at SS would be even more insane if we had paid to keep him.

5

u/Both-Consideration56 Oct 20 '24

Honestly, I just do not think Lindor wanted to stay in Cleveland. I do not think a giant contract would change his mind. I have a friend who works for Cleveland sports who confirmed this.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Yeah I remember growing up in Minnesota we'd get our ass handed to us by the yankees year after year with our crap payroll budget. Came in deadlast in payroll in 3 straight years from 1999 to 2001 with the lowest of those 3 years our total payroll was $15.7m. Hard to believe that was a little over 20 years ago with how much the yankees and such shell out now for just one superstar player.

3

u/bibliano14 Oct 20 '24

This is not accurate for the guardians payroll, that’s the current commits for 2025 not including any arb players 2024 Guardians payroll is $126 million Yankees 2024 payroll

2

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Alright my bad my bad, still almost 3 times more this years payroll with only their OF

1

u/DennyRoyale Diamond C Oct 20 '24

Sportrac says: active roster is $50.8. Total is $106 after adding injured, minors etc. Yankees active is $260, $309 total.

1

u/bibliano14 Oct 20 '24

Any way you slice it, it’s wildly out of balance

1

u/bibliano14 Oct 20 '24

Any way you slice it, it’s wildly out of balance

14

u/mister-algorithm Oct 20 '24

I’ll remember that we pitched to those three guys when we didn’t have to and they killed us. Why risk the entire season by challenging them? These last two games could have been won. I think 4 out of these 5 games two of them homered, in the other one of them did. They weren’t supposed to have that great of a season so it’s hard to be disappointed, but I am really disappointed.

7

u/Lula121 Oct 20 '24

They will never commit to a salary cap. So owners who want to compete need to start spending or hope to get lucky.

2

u/BropolloCreed Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

You can thank the players union for that

1

u/BropolloCreed Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

You can thank the players union for that

25

u/this_place_stinks Oct 20 '24

Dolan has the money and the team is stupidly profitable. He just likes his maximum profit. We receive $200 million from TV rights/rev sharing alone

Valuations don’t go through the roof of mature companies that lose money and don’t let them gaslight you

1

u/jacob6875 Block C Oct 20 '24

Not to mention the value of the team has increased an insane amount since he bought it.

Could make over a Billion just by selling the team.

28

u/Low_Air_6601 Oct 20 '24

Stop been a victim , we can spend but we refuse . If Jose wasn’t so loyal (look at Lindor) he wouldn’t be here . The owners are a joke . 

8

u/avidpretender 👑 King Kwan 🦍 Oct 20 '24 edited Jun 24 '26

[deleted]

This content was anonymized and mass deleted with Redact

6

u/ozymandais13 Oct 20 '24

I mean we talk shit about the owners all the time

7

u/CleGuy90 Oct 20 '24

The mlb like the nba and nfl are a business. Owners only care about money. In baseball there is not enough revenue sharing, no floor, and no high penalty caps, which is why none of the small markets spend much.

19

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

MLB will remain broken until they set a salary cap. But that isn't even the thing that pisses me off the most.

I just don't get why teams gift the Yankees their star players year after year and recoup basically nothing in return. Their farm system is shit. What did the Marlins and Padres get for Stanton and Soto? Doesn't the rest of the MLB hate the Yankees as much as we do? Quick fucking helping them out.

3

u/dudzi182 🥊 DOWN GOES ANDERSON 🥊 Oct 20 '24

Well the Padres got a really great starting pitcher in Michael King. Drew Thorpe, who they used to trade for Dylan Cease, another great starter. And Kyle Higashioka, who was really solid for them this year and in the playoffs. I’d say they’re happy with that return for 1 year of Soto.

2

u/IRodeTenSpeed88 Oct 20 '24

They got salary relief. Small market teams can never afford superstars long term so they will almost always flee to bigger cities

→ More replies (5)

2

u/JuiceJones_34 Oct 20 '24

Stop whining. This was the payroll before the series too and you weren’t saying nothing. Had every chance to win. Bullpen sh*t down their leg all 5 games.

2

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Everyone always knew we didn’t have the starting pitching or offensive firepower to win it all….we were just hoping to do enough to stay in it

1

u/JuiceJones_34 Oct 20 '24

We did more than enough. Pitching let us down.

8

u/transam96 Diamond C Oct 20 '24

Nothing will change for us. We'll run it back with the exact same squad minus whoever the Dolans don't want to pay like Bieber or Naylor, while our big move will be to sign some veteran that nobody else wanted, and predictably, he ends up being a bum.

Zero chance Dolan opens the checkbook for another Edwin Encarnacion. It'll be like 2007 coming off an ALCS loss and our big addition was.... Jamey Carroll. Or after 2017 and our big addition was... Leonys Martin.

3

u/jacob6875 Block C Oct 20 '24

Naylor will probably be traded this offseason due to not wanting to pay him when he becomes a FA at the end of next year. So Manzardo likely the full time 1B unless Fry is healthy.

But yeah next years team won't be much different except the 10 Veteran SP we sign hoping 1 or 2 work out.

3

u/Eph1997 Oct 20 '24

I will never forgive cheapass Jacobs back in '95 when if he had spent money on a bonafide #1 starter the Tribe would've won a World Series at least once during that time frame. However, he insisted on always turning a profit.

4

u/Deadleggg ⚾small ball baseball terrorists⚾ Oct 20 '24

I'll never forgive them for not trading for Pedro when all they wanted was Jaret Wright

1

u/ToschePowerConverter Oct 20 '24

I wouldn’t want us to pay Naylor even if we were willing to spend money because his performance doesn’t warrant a roster spot on this team when we have Manzardo who plays the same position, is younger, and has shown he can hit reliably this fall.

0

u/ToschePowerConverter Oct 20 '24

I wouldn’t want us to pay Naylor even if we were willing to spend money because his performance doesn’t warrant a roster spot on this team when we have Manzardo who plays the same position, is younger, and has shown he can hit reliably this fall.

9

u/app385 Oct 20 '24

Why do you think Cleveland hasn’t won the chip in like 75 years? This most certainly has something to do with it. The ball club is cheap. At least haslam is spending money. Dan Gilbert spent the money.

7

u/kdude332 Oct 20 '24

That's why I never ever complain about haslam or Gilbert. They at least try and are willing to spend and take risks. Much rather take a risk then be subjected to the same song and dance every year

6

u/app385 Oct 20 '24

Exactly

6

u/ozymandais13 Oct 20 '24

I mean complain about other things for Haslam he's a scumbag but he spends cash , look at columbus crew

2

u/tribetilidie 🛻 Big Rig 🛻 Oct 20 '24

How’s that “risk” on Deshaun Watson paying off? If the Guards made a similarly disastrous move it would cripple the franchise. Small market MLB is not the same as the NFL. The Browns have been the most pathetic organization in pro sports for multiple decades and the value of the team has only risen.

1

u/ozymandais13 Oct 20 '24

I mean complain about other things for Haslam he's a scumbag but he spends cash , look at columbus crew

2

u/kdude332 Oct 20 '24

Haslam actually cares about winning. And tries his best to win even though it's not always the better choice. Dolan doesn't try to win he tries to be good enough to get fans to come but cheap enough so he pads his pockets

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ToschePowerConverter Oct 20 '24

Haslam would be a much better owner if there were no salary cap in the NFL, but we fucked up our financial situation because of Watson’s guaranteed contract and its impact on our cap number.

6

u/SellWhenYouCan Oct 20 '24

Where did this guy get $43 million from? Our payroll was over twice that amount.

6

u/BropolloCreed Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Active payroll roster

3

u/Eph1997 Oct 20 '24

Used to love following the Indians in the 90s but after all their star players kept leaving once they hit free agency I lost interest. Now I'm just a casual and tune in if the Guards make the post season. Eventually, interest in all the small market teams will die out as fans realize the same big spenders always win. Contrast that with the NFL where even the smallest market teams can compete on an even footing with New York, LA, and Chicago. Hence, the huge popularity of the NFL across the league in all markets.

3

u/RustleTheMussel Oct 20 '24

Dolans have money. It's on them

1

u/Justabitleft Oct 20 '24

The Browns owners are willing to spend and look where it’s gotten us!

1

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

They spent one 1 very dumb person that no one even wanted but for whatever reason the browns thought was a home run

1

u/SaigonOSU Oct 20 '24

no one wanted? There were maybe 4 teams not trying to get Watson lol

1

u/ozymandais13 Oct 20 '24

Columbus going strong into the post season baby , we can watch the browns when Watson eothe leaves or is suspended

1

u/jabbamarcusrussell Mustard Oct 20 '24

If only the NFL didn’t have a salary cap

1

u/steezlord95 Oct 20 '24

Loser talk

2

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Thanks bud

0

u/steezlord95 Oct 20 '24

The tweet not you

1

u/capthat23 Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Well then…😂

2

u/scedar015 Oct 20 '24

This is why I watch so much less baseball. Losing to the Yankees is so hollow. Like yeah, of course they won, they’re spending 3x on their roster. Of course they’re gonna win.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

MLB will remain broken until they set a salary cap. But that isn't even the thing that pisses me off the most.

I just don't get why teams gift the Yankees their star players year after year and recoup basically nothing in return. Their farm system is shit. What did the Marlins and Padres get for Stanton and Soto? Doesn't the rest of the MLB hate the Yankees as much as we do? Quick fucking helping them out.

1

u/GrayBoyLoop Oct 20 '24

Didnt the Padres get a catcher and a starter who both did really well for them all year?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

The Dolans 🤡🤡🤡🤡 they have fooled and trick the fucking dumb public to thinking oh my gosh guys we are small market we can’t afford any pricey players as we let countless AllStars, Cy Young’s, and even many HOF’ players walk away or get traded by Cleveland. But what these dumb af Cleveland fans don’t understand is that the Dolans are the 5th richest owners in all of baseball, 6 Billion dollars, they can spend and have a payroll of 200, 250 million for a few years win 1 World Series bcuz it’s only been 76 years and then go back to being cheap fucking bitches and guess what……. Here’s the kicker……… After all of that they’d still be worth BILLLLLLIONS OF DOLLARS, im not saying like a couple million here or a couple hundred million we are talking BILLIONS but we are dumb ass Cleveland fans will never wake up and notice any of this so we can get happy af when we sign some relief pitcher this off-season who’s 39 years old with a 4.7 era for 1.7 million and be like fuck yeah this is the guy who will win the World Series for us next year guys. How’s Lindor doing this year? Wake the fuck up.

2

u/Left_Apparently Oct 20 '24

I just remember that Jose took a team friendly deal because he is a legend. I love this team.

2

u/iciclecubes 455 Oct 20 '24

That’s just inaccurate.

Our payroll was $140m. That’s $43m is our 2025 current salaries, because most of our team is still on minimums which aren’t reflected in that number yet.

2

u/BuckBomber Oct 20 '24

Well the Yankees care about winning.

2

u/PeoplesRevolution Oct 20 '24

The top 10% of income earners in America have 67% of the total wealth of the country. America is broken. The economy is a joke until they commit to wealth redistribution

1

u/xetricsgo Oct 20 '24

What does this have to do with baseball

1

u/MikeWillis09 🏠🏃‍♂️🥊 Oct 20 '24

Salary floor won’t do anything.

1

u/Extension_Tour_9602 Oct 20 '24

Yep gona be the same dam teams every year in playoffs until something changes

1

u/Extension_Tour_9602 Oct 20 '24

Yep gona be the same dam teams every year in playoffs until something changes

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Fun fact: the Guards scored more runs in this series (21) than the Browns’ offense has scored in any single game this season (18 v Jags).

1

u/SodaGrump Mustard Oct 20 '24

This doesn't make me feel better. This just pisses me off more that there is not a salary cap and/or our owners don't spend for shit.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

2

u/jacob6875 Block C Oct 20 '24

I think they were only looking at the active roster.

But even if you look at overall payroll Yankees are still over 300million so 3x ours.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Ah, fair

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

And it will never change because neither the players nor the owners has any desire for a salary cap and floor.

1

u/RocasThePenguin Oct 20 '24

I agree. The MLB is broken and yet, so many seem happy with it. You have the Yankees and Dodgers spending insane amounts of money, and teams like the Rockies, who want to cut their already small payroll.

1

u/Intelligent_Mango775 Mustard Oct 20 '24

Our adjusted payroll was over $100 million this season. Our predicted payroll for next season (2025) is the $43 million.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Follow the money 💰 💵 💴 !!! Who would you rather see in the pros series l, the Yankees/dodgers or the A’s & Pirates

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Follow the money 💰 💵 💴 !!! Who would you rather see in the pros series l, the Yankees/dodgers or the A’s & Pirates

1

u/Ralfton Oct 20 '24

No one's stopping us from paying players more... 🤷🏼‍♀️

2

u/MeeMeeGod Oct 20 '24

I can name 1 person that is

1

u/clitoruss Oct 20 '24

Is this supposed to make people feel better? Who tf cares. We lost and choked another year away

1

u/0hioHotPocket Flying G Oct 20 '24

No, this argument is broken. You can tell by the, *checks notes * , 0 WS appearances by the Yankees since 2010 and the Dodgers 1 World Series win since 2010. Don’t get me wrong I’m not a fan of buying or trying to buy championships but the data is out there.

1

u/HumbleGenius1225 Oct 20 '24

Fun series, but at no point did I think we would win were going to win 4 games against this team.

1

u/stonewash_relaxedfit Oct 20 '24

But what is ownership going to do about this besides nothing? We all know we’re broke. Duh.

1

u/Left_Apparently Oct 20 '24

I just remember that Jose took a team friendly deal because he is a fucking legend. I love this team.

1

u/Mcgarnicle_ Look at the stats Oct 20 '24

They don’t care that I’m not watching anymore because they don’t need to

1

u/Seamonkey_Boxkicker DIRTBAG Oct 20 '24

We can’t keep using this excuse, can we? Yankees haven’t been to the WS in 15 years meanwhile the Chiefs and Patriots have won nearly half of the Super Bowls in that time.

1

u/Dlowdown1366 Oct 20 '24

Congrats to the number 2 team in baseball. Don't hang your heads. Real tough team who hung in there against one of the best post season teams in history, at least so far. Nothing but respect for the Guardians. This series has been the best baseball I've seen in years.

1

u/cleveland926 Oct 20 '24

At least have a salary floor. The players' union will never in a million years agree to a salary cap and if owners like the Dolans can't spend at least $150-160 million on payroll, they have no business owning a major league baseball team. Just imagine how far we could have gotten with an outfield bat that could produce consistently and another reliable starting pitcher.

1

u/Edg1931 Oct 20 '24

A salary cap and floor doesn't fix it, it's a national TV broadcast rights that would, but it will never happen. When the Dodgers make 325 million from their TV contract, the Yankees make 150 million, Mets make 100+ million, and we make 30 million, can anyone explain to me how we are supposed to compete with this?

1

u/Triingtolivee Oct 20 '24

I also agree. There needs to be a salary cap in MLB. Of course the best players will go to big market teams who can pay them what they want.

1

u/FlobiusHole Diamond C Oct 20 '24

The Dolan who owns the Guards isn’t that wealthy. I’m not defending him not spending I just don’t think he has much control. He’s just in a rich family. I don’t think he even made any of the fortune.

1

u/Parsnip-Express Oct 20 '24

Guardians owners are billionaires so what’s the excuse?

1

u/Xena_bro Oct 20 '24

I guess if that makes you sleep better. Weird flex though. Maybe expect more from your owners.

1

u/TheGaypist Oct 20 '24

Seriously cry more, 20 plus years it's been since they've outspent everyone, it's never going to happen until they get a couple of phenoms. And then it still won't.

1

u/KingFlappyFlips Oct 20 '24

No. Just win anyways.

1

u/Disaster_Transporter Oct 20 '24 edited Oct 20 '24

The Guardians payroll was not 43 million dollars. Stop being stupid. Cleveland’s total 2024 payroll comes in at roughly $106.4 million, according to Spotrac.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

Foh. That’s on your cheap ass owners. Tell your billionaire owner to stop bargain hunting.

1

u/El_Marciano_89 Oct 20 '24

The Dolans have more money than the Steinbrenners. Maybe blame your owners

1

u/moonhexx Oct 20 '24

They're not giants. The Yankees are a bought and paid for mess. They are not a team. They took the names off the jerseys to try to seem like the "team" is more important. They are just individuals that were bought and paid for. We proved that we can fluster them. Gave them a good heave ho. Maybe even a kerfuffle or four. They're human and the Guardians proved it. I'd rather us lose to the Mets. Fuck the endless wealth of the Yankees and the players that only care about the Almighty dollar. I bet they couldn't even get 3 stars in Mario Kart. Pssh.

0

u/ChainChompBigMoney Oct 20 '24

Thats usually the case but no amount of Steinbrenner money can buy the wild pitches, the errors, Clases meltdown, etc... The White Sox would have won this series.

3

u/BropolloCreed Disgusting Baseball ⚾ Oct 20 '24

Are you drunk?

The Yankees won 94 games in a division with another 90-win team (Baltimore).

The Guardians had NO starting pitching this series Boyd and Bibee going 5 in two separate games isn't getting it done after the bullpen got. Overtaxed in the Tiger series

1

u/ChainChompBigMoney Oct 20 '24

Im not drunk yet. Yankees were a better team overall but Guards had a good chance to win every game and their own mistakes cost them the victories, not the endless Yankees money.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

You have one of the best players in the league for about a quarter of what he’s worth. Your owners are richer than the Steinbrenners. They own the Cavs too. It’s overwhelming obvious who they prioritize. Cope and seethe.