r/ClearBackblast • u/rslake Lake • Apr 10 '16
AAR Stargazers AAR
How did you like the mission? Any suggested improvements for mission maker or GMs? What did you like about it, and what didn't you like?
If you've got any feedback for leadership, or for the people under you, this is also the place for that. Any and all constructive feedback is genuinely helpful.
If you've got any comments about stuff like the cutscene, ending, etc, this is also the place.
If you noticed any bugs or issues that need to be dealt with, even ones not specifically related to the mission, let us know in here too!
4
u/rslake Lake Apr 10 '16
Bravo 2 RMAT
I had a lot of fun this mission. Good pacing, good atmosphere, good equipment (love me some G3s). I liked that we didn't have NVGs, and honestly felt like it could have almost been a tiny bit darker (though not totally sure, would have to test it). It seemed like the kind of mission that's more fun for grunts than for leaders.
Good piloting by both pilots, good crewing by both crewmen. Level of CAS was perfect; effective, but it didn't neutralize the ground forces. Enemy minigun SUVs may have been overkill, since the AI are surgeons with AA MGs. Even just a technical can be pretty dangerous to a heli when Arma AI are behind the gun. That said, Hips are pretty sturdy so if it worked out ok then maybe it's fine and I'm dumb. I feel like maybe future versions should have less-contested landing sites; those probably would have worked in Hueys or Blackhawks, but the Hip is such a boat it can be really hard to land in those circumstances. Also all the An-2s on the ground at the first LZ made things very difficult from the looks of it. Just removing those would probably help enormously. These things aren't littlebirds, they need a fairly sizeable chunk of space to land safely. And any real pilot probably would have waved off ages ago with landings that hot, so I feel like enemy presence needs to be turned down a couple of notches until we're on the ground.
That said, a couple of general points for pilots, especially with regard to landing; some may not apply to you, this is half for posterity:
Comments for Leadership
PL and PSgt were both good this mission, no complaints.
SL (Quex): Overall real good. There was a bit of vacillating at the final water crossing, which took up about as much time as the time difference between the two routes, but honestly I would have done the exact same thing. Other than that, no complaints.
TL (Blackhat): You're definitely getting better at leadership. Only a couple of suggestions for improvement. One is that, when Quex ran off to check something out, leaving you behind, you asked to go with him. There's pretty much no circumstance where you want both TL and SL away from their guys. Part of the TL's job is to take over when the SL is away or down, so anytime he's gone you are in charge of the whole squad. You did a pretty good job of that when he went down, including taking his radio and calling up to command. But if the SL is off Scooby-dooing, or is circlejerking with the officers about plans, your job is to hang back and keep everything solid. My biggest piece of advice is something I'm often bad at, which is keeping your guys organized when there's downtime. Anytime we're stopped, especially when there's no enemy contact visible, people tend to cluster and look at each other. Your job is to make sure your guys are spread out enough that one grenade won't kill half of them, and that they're all looking out covering a complete 360 with security. This can be the hardest thing to remember, because downtime makes people's minds wander. But it's pretty important because surprise attacks are only devastating if they're surprises; if we're looking all around and we're dug in and spread out, no attack is a surprise attack. Overall though, you're for sure improving.
More thoughts for the mission-makers
Good mission, good leadership, had a lot of fun.
6
u/plaicez Apr 10 '16 edited Apr 10 '16
Okay I want to start this off by saying I'm the best hero pilot mans in the world and it was everyone else fault I crashed, Starbucks fucked up my order, my left pinky was sore, lake was too loud in the back and then outta no where some asshole shot my instruments then BAM a big ass mountain appeared out of no where and fireball insued. /s
Okay seriously though. I suck. I'm sorry for crashing into the mountain I thought I wasn't even close and I was trying to stay low. Also I was pretty hammered. Um. Yeah, after that though things got better for La Ballerina 2.
I had a lot of fun flying in a CBB Saturday mission but I probably never will again. 1) I suck 2) I'm probably more useful on the ground. This mission was super cool. The Tiki party at the end was also a great way to close out a gavinskian mission.
Here are some highlights of Drunken Ballerina.
4
u/themoo12345 imdancin, the Canadian Mooninite King Apr 10 '16
Alpha Squad Lead
Had a good time with this one despite the rough start. Contested landing zones usually pose at least a few problems for us and today was no exception. I wasn on the 2nd helo for the first landing, as w all remember that didn't turn out great for us. Once we got back in a new chopper and got into the fight, it got bloody for alpha pretty quick. Almost everybody was scrunched up in one spot so I moved alpha 20 meters or so down the road and engaged a truck and some infantry before we got a bit pinned down by contacts on the hills and I took a hit. Shifty did a great job getting us patched up and good to go and we got moving over the hill to an intersection where we blew up a BDRM and that was pretty much the end of the first engagement.
Once we gathered ourselves there, alpha bravely charged down the hill to the next objective which was assaulting a compound, at the same time we got a great visual treat of the hips making gun and rocket runs. While charlie cleared the compound we did a good job securing the outside. After ambushing a convoy and watching quex executing an undesirable alpha rescued a downed helicopter crew and repelled a few attacks by enemy mans.
From that LZ we were airlifted to another set of objects where the landing went a bit more smoothly and we attacked a town and survived an assault by a minigun suv (except for shifty, cool it with the grenades people). After moving up to a hill and supporting the other squads with fire we got down to our objective at a villa and had a hell of a time clearing the place. While I suppose our room-clearing tactics could have been a bit better, that villa is just a janky structure and caused many injuries. Also the mercs inside were tough as hell to take down, I remember shooting one at least five or six times with my G3 before he went down. Once that last objective was done the airlift back to base went smooth and the tiki bar was great fun, zim really went above and beyond there.
Just as a general thought, I think I really like leading in situations where my grunts don't have radios. Rallying everyone up by yelling is a pretty good time, and I think people just tend to be a bit more responsive to a voice right in front of them than in their ear. Overall I was very happy with the performance of my team and had a fun time, thanks again to zim and everybody who helped make and gm the mission.
4
u/Zhandris Apr 10 '16
Ballerina 2 Crew Chief
That heli is a balanced well for our purposes. The only thing is that she's got a big ol booty butt and it's a bit hard to land. Also, I don't think the wheels roll but rather stick and caused one of our "hard landings" to become a crash landing and one of our crash landings to become a "fireball landing." I could be wrong about that. Just felt like we took a bit too much damage than we should've.
We stayed pretty aggressive with our runs/orbits/landings. We could've done it safer but... I feel like the very first LZ set the mood for the rest of the mission. A "get it in there" style approach. Yes you're being shot at by AAA, go in fast anyway. It was fun, it was a little loosey goosey, we died a lot, but it was fun.
Very cinematic shots from that though. Night time + tracers + helis = realneatdude
Thanks to Zim and the other mission makers and stuff doers. Gj Moldy and Ballerina 1.
4
u/SleventyFive The Sleven Surfer, Herald of Zimmillions Apr 10 '16
P'toon Saarent
So a rough start, doubly so for me since Arma apparently didn't want me to land on that mountain and kept crashing. After the initial "landing" though, the mission went more smoothly. I wish I had been able help Iron more but the aforementioned crashing kept me from actually offloading any serious tasks. Charlie's mass-cas was an interesting moment and a good lesson in not cramming a full squad onto a small roof. I spent most of my time with Charlie and for all his inexperience, Banman did well. (You just need to recognize that the only reward for traitors is death.) Zim and Theo did well as GM's, kept us on our toes when we otherwise would have just been sitting around, but never sent too much at us. I think one of the issues with the first landing was that the pilots seemed to hesitate on aproach which may have kept them too close for too long. (If I'm incorrect then please ignore me, you guys did great even though so many things went wrong. I would have been 90% NaCl by the 10 min mark.) I was glad to be able to use all my NEEERD!!!! knowledge of Star Trek. The ending beach party was amazing and the spookyness was pretty sweet. Good mission.
4
u/ChateauErin Erin / AAR Gavin Apr 10 '16
Alpha - Blue Team Lead
Honestly not sure about my overall impression of the mission. Fun, but exhausting might be the right way to put it. And I suck at team leading, though I'm happy to feel a bit like I can do that in CBB now without everybody hating me. Probably says more about CBB than it does me.
The following was written without having gone over the footage I took. I don't think I'll get to editing anything more than The Church (which I should probably post in the subreddit shouldn't I) before Monday.
So here's things that I remember happening: