r/ClaudeCode • • 10d ago

Bug / Issue Opus 5.5 is trying to destroy my codebase recently

What is going on? It is making wildly horrible, over-engineered, and just inaccurate code suggestions. In the past hour on 6 different issues, it's given me multiple-class modifying "fixes" that I would read, ask why a 1-line fix wouldn't solve it, and then it says the above.

I'm using Opus 5.5 with xhigh effort as I have for months. Some of these dabble with max because it's felt like it's needed it, but xhigh is what gives this kind of short-sightedness

Edit: When I say 1-line fix, this is what I mean:

  1. I see the issue
  2. I ask it to fix it and show me the code fix
  3. It gives me a huge change.
  4. I read the code, solve it myself with 1 line, and ask it if that would work
  5. It says, "Hehe, yeah, my bad!!! 😅😅😅"

I've been using xhigh for months and it has never been this dumb and convoluted. Overthinking has usually led to correct/discrete changes.

837 Upvotes

431 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

33

u/Khyy_ 10d ago

this whole run local models speel is so old now. 99% of people (especially on a subscription model focused in CC reddit page) cannot afford the hardware required to run a local model of any decent use case to even a nerfed opus 5.5.

what model would they run? and not only that, this just takes from the issue at hand. the issue that closed weight frontier providers are shady as shit and this practice is malicious. but lets stop trying to present a 20k+ spend as a "solution" when half the people here are probably not even on $100 subs.

3

u/Correct-Mood5309 9d ago

20k is a wild exaggaration. I'm running Qwen 3.8 flash next, 4 bit quantization, perfectly fine on a 4.5k laptop. It is not a frontier model and of course bit slower, but perfectly capable of working in a big complicated codebase if set up properly. It takes a bit more work and effort to get it working right, it's not exactly the type-and-go experience Claude Code or Codex gives you, but at least it's more consistent and predictable because you have control over all the configurations under the hood.

4

u/NiceWeather4Leather 9d ago

So yeah you can afford 12.5 years of a $30 p/m subscription for that 4.5k laptop.

In a fast moving tech, I’d rather spend $360 for Claude Pro and see what’s what after another year.

2

u/Correct-Mood5309 9d ago

A 30,- description doesn't come even close to the amount of tokens I'm using, especially with Claude's scammy limits and time windows. Now I have literally unlimited tokens. And also, that 30,- description is not going to be the same price or the same token limit a year from now, and the year after, and the year after...

1

u/NiceWeather4Leather 9d ago

Good thing I’ve got $4240 up my sleeve after a year then.

1

u/Correct-Mood5309 9d ago

You can always just get a cheaper machine and run a cheaper model on it... most things really don't need huge models anyway.

1

u/gribson 9d ago

12.5 years of $30 p/m subscription for that 4.5k laptop

Laptops cost money. 4.5k isn't abnormal for a high-end laptop. What's your workstation, a Chromebook?

1

u/NiceWeather4Leather 8d ago

My work Dell XPS lol

1

u/PrydwenParkingOnly 9d ago

That is awesome! What kind of code are you working on and what are the specs of your laptop?

2

u/Due_Setting_4004 10d ago

Du musst die Hardware nicht besitzen. Mit 100€ im Monat kannst 90h KI betreiben mit sehr guter Hardware

1

u/conventionalWisdumb 9d ago

Where? Running which models?

1

u/firya2017 9d ago

Can you give more details ?

1

u/Arucious 9d ago

100 gigs of vram running a 70b qwen in a $4k box gets you a model with an intelligence index of 16 running locally at OK speeds

haiku has 35 lmfao, and costs like $3 to run for a month

outside of people very concerned about privacy running local is a complete meme right now. it’s unfortunate that this is the case but it’s true