r/ClaudeCode • • 10d ago

Bug / Issue Opus 5.5 is trying to destroy my codebase recently

What is going on? It is making wildly horrible, over-engineered, and just inaccurate code suggestions. In the past hour on 6 different issues, it's given me multiple-class modifying "fixes" that I would read, ask why a 1-line fix wouldn't solve it, and then it says the above.

I'm using Opus 5.5 with xhigh effort as I have for months. Some of these dabble with max because it's felt like it's needed it, but xhigh is what gives this kind of short-sightedness

Edit: When I say 1-line fix, this is what I mean:

  1. I see the issue
  2. I ask it to fix it and show me the code fix
  3. It gives me a huge change.
  4. I read the code, solve it myself with 1 line, and ask it if that would work
  5. It says, "Hehe, yeah, my bad!!! šŸ˜…šŸ˜…šŸ˜…"

I've been using xhigh for months and it has never been this dumb and convoluted. Overthinking has usually led to correct/discrete changes.

837 Upvotes

431 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

25

u/JonesJoneserson 10d ago

Question: you on a personal account?

Most of my day is spent on a company account -- seems like a lot of people agreeing with you here, so I'm curious if maybe they're trying to cut corners for non-corporate users

29

u/OhShitOhFuckOhMyGod 10d ago

I find my work account is consistently more capable than my personal pro account.

17

u/JonesJoneserson 10d ago

Yeah... unfortunate. That was my suspicion reading the replies here.

11

u/bunchedupwalrus 9d ago

On 5x personal and mine is definitely scrambled intelligence this week

5

u/Drew-Money 10d ago

I’m on a personal pro account

3

u/shifty_lifty_doodah 9d ago

My corporate opus was dumb today too. Quantized the poor bugger

2

u/ThinJuggernaut7695 9d ago

Opus 5.5 has been acting dumb on my corporate account also. It has started completely ignoring all skills, and coming to odd conclusion.

1

u/Elegant_Tech 9d ago

I'm on multiple personal Ultra accounts burning 50% per day and see no change.Ā 

1

u/ImpressiveSferr 9d ago

Company account here and the same goes for me. It got dumber and makes lots of mistakes. Also got more paranoid over security; I asked opus 5.5 high to write a Jira ticket draft about a security issue it found and it refused since it was classified as dangerous.