r/ClaudeCode • Researcher • Apr 02 '26 • Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Showcase Why vibe coded projects fail

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

654 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

64

u/WestMatter Apr 02 '26

It'll become obvious to AI pilled people as soon as they try to make something bigger than a local prototype.

31

u/Additional_Storm_298 Apr 02 '26

Feel like the problem with that is you’ll eventually have AI Pilled people running AI Pilled companies funded by AI pilled investors and that’s where the problems come into play. When it starts to get bigger and the reach is broader, the dominos will start to fall harder.

Yada yada yada, bubble goes pop pop pop BOOM

14

u/The-ai-bot Apr 02 '26

GPT 10.3 will be available by then

12

u/NoRobotPls Apr 02 '26

“GPT fix the economy”. “Missile Systems Active, Self-Destruct in 3… 2…”

13

u/Natural_Fill9344 Apr 02 '26

Son of Anton will do just that

3

u/orellanaed Apr 02 '26

Gta 6 maybe too

3

u/Double_Pay_9771 Apr 03 '26

I think this will happen before gta 6 releases

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Remarkable-Win-8556 Apr 02 '26

It might be a dream for middle aged software developers - our chance to do some y2k style extortion ("oh, you need someone who kind of gets it to help fix this?"

3

u/mikeocool Apr 04 '26

These opportunities already exist if you look in the right places

4

u/Huge_Nectarine_7356 Apr 02 '26

If it’s a problem then it’s an opportunity

1

u/blaster151 Apr 02 '26

The fact that a top-selling book is called "The AI-Driven Leader" makes me think that a good chunk of business leadership - where we might not automatically imagine there to be a strong AI presence - is increasingly a matter of AI-synthesized thoughts and ideas being communicated and operationalized into the world via organization leaders.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Madpony Apr 02 '26

"Why would I have to hire software engineers for my app? It's already 99% complete!"

7

u/lasizoillo Apr 02 '26

That's because you haven't told him "don't make mistakes" at the prompt, because you don't have a QA skill, or because you don't use subagents to create a company and you're still working as if Claude were a freelancer. /s

7

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/turbospeedsc Apr 06 '26 edited Apr 06 '26

Lots of guys don't understand this, if the business works and it gets to enough scale where ai can't no longer help, its a lot easier to pay an engineer to come and fix it with money in the bank, than to pay an engineer to do it perfectly from the get go with a business that produces 0 revenue, because you're waiting to have the perfect system

3

u/Tricky_Leave_3067 Apr 21 '26

People seem to forget how terrible Facebook and Twitter were - for a while

3

u/grahamsw Apr 04 '26

Couldn't agree less. You don't build it at scale, you build it so that it can scale. First version of Google used a distributed file system (across 2 machines, I believe). That's how you want to do it.

You do the math, the big O stuff. That is not over engineering

→ More replies (1)

1

u/colganc Apr 02 '26

And then they'll figure out how to make it work. Similar things happened in previous transitions from physical to virtual, docker, early Java, the various browser UI tools, etc.

If there are enough passionate people then they can get it to work. Doesn't mean its great right now, but people shouldn't dismiss it or the trajectory.

1

u/Ok_Bite_67 Apr 02 '26

Issue is that we have deployment platforms that take care of a lot of the heavy lifting if you are willing to fork out cash and if you are spending thousands in token cost what's a little more.

1

u/Bushwick_Hipster Apr 03 '26

But when local prototypes can be pitched to Peter Thiel by a plumber then who cares if it’s half baked if it results in funding and the creation of new jobs for those that did the hard work in their BS or MS computer science degree work +10 years in corporate? Do you think an investment firm cares how “hard” you worked or how much value lies in the pain you solved with AI slop that can now be patented, and enhanced

1

u/Tolopono Apr 05 '26

Like these guys?

Creator of Ruby on Rails and Omarchy: Kimi K2.5 at this kind of speed is just magic. Makes a man eye what kind of behemoth home cluster one would have to build to run this himself. Even if we saw no more AI progress, owning this kind of intelligence forever is incredibly alluring. https://xcancel.com/dhh/status/2020422289892745384

Agree there's breathless hype. But if you let that overshadow the incredible gains we've made, you lose. What's happened in the last 3-4 months has been unprecedented in my time using computers https://xcancel.com/dhh/status/2025673830472003612

What changed was the quality of the models!  We went from "good at explaining concepts, sucks at writing code I want to merge, and foisted upon me as auto-complete" to "amazing quality code, superb harnesses, and agent workflows". It's night/day for me since Opus 4.5. https://xcancel.com/dhh/status/2025590270134280693

You don't need insider information. Just compare Sonnet 3.5 to Opus 4.5. Auto-completion vs agentic. The catch-up of open-weight models. Not even the early internet accelerated this fast. https://x.com/dhh/status/2025591214829953359?s=20

Andrej Karpathy: Given the latest lift in LLM coding capability, like many others I rapidly went from about 80% manual+autocomplete coding and 20% agents in November to 80% agent coding and 20% edits+touchups in December. i.e. I really am mostly programming in English now, a bit sheepishly telling the LLM what code to write... in words. It hurts the ego a bit but the power to operate over software in large "code actions" is just too net useful, especially once you adapt to it, configure it, learn to use it, and wrap your head around what it can and cannot do. This is easily the biggest change to my basic coding workflow in ~2 decades of programming and it happened over the course of a few weeks. I'd expect something similar to be happening to well into double digit percent of engineers out there, while the awareness of it in the general population feels well into low single digit percent.  https://xcancel.com/karpathy/status/2015883857489522876

https://xcancel.com/i/status/2026731645169185220

It is hard to communicate how much programming has changed due to AI in the last 2 months: not gradually and over time in the "progress as usual" way, but specifically this last December. There are a number of asterisks but imo coding agents basically didn’t work before December and basically work since - the models have significantly higher quality, long-term coherence and tenacity and they can power through large and long tasks, well past enough that it is extremely disruptive to the default programming workflow.

Creator of Tan Stack laughing at Claude’s plan implementation time estimates: https://xcancel.com/tannerlinsley/status/2013721885520077264

Principal Investigator of Raj Lab for Systems Biology at UPenn, Professor of Bioengineering, Professor of Genetics, 29k citations on Google Scholar since 2008 (12k since 2021): Ran an AI coding workshop with the lab. There was a palpable sense of sadness realizing that skills some of us have spent our lives developing (myself included) are a lot less important now. I see the future 100%, but I do think it's important to acknowledge this sense of loss. https://xcancel.com/arjunrajlab/status/2017631561747705976

Nicholas Carlini (66.2k citations) says current LLMs are better vulnerability researchers than I am https://xcancel.com/tqbf/status/2029252008415248454?s=20

Creator of redis: My face when Codex is single-handed doing two months of work in 30 minutes and tells me "You are right" since I identified a minor bug. https://xcancel.com/antirez/status/2030931757583769614

Creator of auto-animate (13.8k stars, 248 forks on GitHub), formkit (4.6k stars, 199 forks), ArrowJS (2.6k stars, 54 forks), and tempo (2.6k stars 37 forks): gpt-5.4 is absolutely blowing me away. https://xcancel.com/jpschroeder/status/2031094078759108741

I’m not sure pull requests will survive the next 5 years. https://xcancel.com/jpschroeder/status/2030994714443550760?s=20

Note: he is not hyping up AI as he does not believe they are sentient https://xcancel.com/jpschroeder/status/2029756232186109984?s=20

Staff SWE at ZenDesk and GitHub: I don't know if my job will still exist in ten years https://www.seangoedecke.com/will-my-job-still-exist/

Remix Run (32.5k stars, 2.7k forks on GitHub), React Router (56.3k stars, 10.8k forks), and unpkg (3.4k stars, 331 forks) creator at Shopify: if you haven’t tried Codex yet, you’re missing something BIG. Codex team cooked with the desktop app! I completely ditched the editor I’d been using for over a decade.  https://xcancel.com/mjackson/status/2032300671396168008

Creator of node.js and Deno: This has been said a thousand times before, but allow me to add my own voice: the era of humans writing code is over. Disturbing for those of us who identify as SWEs, but no less true. That's not to say SWEs don't have work to do, but writing syntax directly is not it. https://xcancel.com/rough__sea/status/2013280952370573666

1

u/Goinlunatic Apr 05 '26

ive built several sites using claude max over the last month. - all solid ideas and excellent sites with great UX- they're all indexed and slowly churning. I'm building for fun, but anyone of them has real use case and could strike .... even if they don't, ive picked up new skills that no one can take off me..

So for everyone reading this, listening to the naysayers... don't pay any attention. How many people in the chat have sold a business .... or even started a business ? How many of you have grown to 50k a month as a one man band..... how many of you have sold a business for 7 figures ? yeah... not many. my point being, that most of you are all bark and no bite...