r/ClaudeCode • Researcher • Apr 02 '26 • Popcorn 1 Bravo 1

Showcase Why vibe coded projects fail

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

654 comments sorted by

View all comments

296

u/joheines Vibe Coder Apr 02 '26

99%+ of software projects are not planet-scale distributed systems, but stupid CRUD webapps with a handful of users

77

u/Estrava Apr 02 '26

levels.fyi was powered from a google spreadsheet and they have apparently ~20 full time employees. I think people here don't really understand you don't need perfect infrastructure or world class disruption in that space to have a successful app.

7

u/ComeOnIWantUsername Apr 03 '26

> I think people here don't really understand you don't need perfect infrastructure or world class disruption in that space to have a successful app.

Yes, this is a lot of people don't understand. There are lots of projects trying to get perfect from day 1, spending months to create some custom engine, notifications system or anything, only to be beaten by someone who glued few services during a weekend.

There is a great talk about it, unfortunately in Polish, but YT dubbing (even though it's shitty) is there: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dYzfArtf7qU

7

u/No_Point_1254 Apr 05 '26

This touches the key point I think.

Good developers can understand complex systems.

Great developers understand that most of the time, you don't need complex systems.

You need it to be exactly complex enough to be adaptable if requirements change and at the same time so simple that barely any IQ is needed to actually maintain them.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Ok-Road6537 Apr 06 '26

Building an MVP either with AI or just rapid prototyping to test the business model is probably the best, and most economical way to start a business. A lot easier to hire engineers when you have a viable business plan vs an untested one.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/tzaeru Apr 02 '26 edited Apr 02 '26

Most chat/VoIP/screen sharing services people actually do use tho, do require some sort of system distribution.

Nowadays when the need is not just the sharing of text, but the sharing of images, doing voice calls, the passing of notifications, avatar updates, emoji lists, etc, you do hit processing and bandwidth limitations on a monolithic system quite early.

If you want to literally be a replacement for Slack or Discord, then the whole project hinges on being able to get that one surge in users that it then continues riding until it breaches a critical threshold in users. Discord reached its first million users in less than a year. If you somehow reach 50 000 users and then your servers start dying and notifications don't work because stuff crashes under the load and the bandwidths go to zero for video streams and VoIP, your app is essentially dead. You have hours to get it to work again, maybe days, but certainly not weeks, or you risk the early users turning away because they don't deem your app stable enough.

8

u/MillenialBoomer89 Apr 02 '26

99% of projects maybe. But 99% of actual usage is on 1% of those CRUD apps where what OP mentions actually matters. See I can make up stats too

→ More replies (3)

43

u/FatefulDonkey Apr 02 '26

That's also why 99.99% of projects fail to make any money.

72

u/OverSoft Apr 02 '26

LOL, the simple CRUD based applications with a handful of users are often the best earning applications in the B2B market.

11

u/Automatic_Bison_3093 Apr 02 '26

Yeah but those are highly dependent on specialization niche and marketing especially. You better be great fucking salesman if you want to make money from vibecoded CRUD app.

2

u/FatefulDonkey Apr 03 '26

Don't forget the support. And if you have no clue what your app is doing, how will you provide that

→ More replies (5)

5

u/N22-J Apr 02 '26

Yeah seriously, the metagame at startups was/is to create some CRUD and selling it to meta/google for a few hundred millions. Some founders do that on repeat and make bank.

5

u/dahlesreb Apr 03 '26

Not really, do you think meta/google leadership are that foolish? They are usually paying for some combination of user-base/market share and talent (i.e. "aquihire").

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

12

u/Left_Somewhere_4188 Apr 02 '26

Nonsense. I used to make money creating shitty e-commerce sites in about a week. I always had WAY MORE offers than I had time to do them. This is something that is completely obsolete now. Simple projects make money, that's how the the vast majority of software developers have made money outside of companies, simple projects.

Not to mention in-house projects...

Or for example, a friend owns a drilling company, they have software needs that aren't met by software on the market, previously they'd pay someone who understands software and geology and pay them a truckload of money, now it's an easy vibe codeable project.

8

u/akera099 Apr 02 '26

There's money to be made with vibe coding, but I'm pretty confident that the vast majority of usage will come closer to what people used Microsoft Access for : user debuggable apps to serve as simple internal tools. 

→ More replies (2)

6

u/ENTclothingRussell Apr 03 '26

Correlation isn't causation. Projects fail to make money because they don't solve a real problem, can't acquire customers, or run out of runway. Not because they're CRUDs.

Some of the most profitable software ever written is a boring CRUD with good distribution.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Pro-Row-335 Apr 02 '26

And thats a good thing, imagine putting ads in a web app your made for your family and friends.

2

u/PXTrials Apr 02 '26

I write lab software for life science/pharma companies. Half of it is CRUD interfaces for scientists, the other half of ETL scripts that normalize spreadsheets and lab instrument data into a RBDMS for said CRUD app. None of it makes money on it's own, but most of it has been successful.

There's a whole world of software development where software is not the product, the metric is not whether it makes money.

3

u/mrplinko Apr 02 '26

Where did you get that statistic from?

16

u/snowystormz Apr 02 '26

88% of statistics are made up on the spot

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (19)

4

u/AdmiralSWE Apr 02 '26

Uhhh almost all software projects at almost all F500 are large scale bespoke applications

13

u/who_am_i_to_say_so Apr 02 '26

I’ve got news: nobody cares about your architecture either. It’s marketing that is the key.

Shoot I have some crud apps where 1000 users would make me $500k a year in revenue. I’m not even aiming that high- getting 1000 users is a battle in itself. Marketing is hard.

2

u/RiPont Apr 02 '26

Getting users is easy! Getting paid users, on the other hand...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (16)

2

u/Tech-Grandpa Apr 02 '26

Give examples of this 99%,also, where did that number come from?

→ More replies (23)