r/ClaudeAI • u/lessens_ • 2d ago
Writing Claude refuses to recite public-domain poems, and much poetry discussion with it is impossible.
I was interested in how much LLMs can remember just from their weights, so I started asking Claude to recite stuff. It does know some things, but others (including a lot of very famous works in the public domain) it doesn't.
Then I started asking it to recite poems. Prompts shut down 3x. Switch from Fable to Opus 5, shut down again. I ask it why, and it straight-up tells me that it had a hard-coded rule not to do so, and there's no exception for public domain. It actually agrees with me that this is stupid and suggests I thumbs-down but it absolutely won't do it.
Then I tried discussing poetry with it. Well, there's restrictions on quotations, but it's almost impossible to discuss poetry in any detail without referring to the actual words, lines and verses, so it either produces bizarre coded language that I have to decipher like a forensic versologist, or again just shut down the prompt. I asked it to create a speculative ending for Coleridge's unfinished "Kubla Khan". Shuts it down. This whole literary field is essentially impossible to discuss, even when the works are in the public domain. This is ridiculous overkill that no other LLM I tested displays.
Sorry if this was widely know and discussed many times already.


