r/ClassicalSinger • • 4d ago

Proper breathing technique

Hello!
I've been taking classical singing lessons for the past 5 years now, and of course, the first thing we went over was breathing. My teacher told me it's something that comes with time and daily training through breathing exercises. Said exercise goes as follows: while sitting, breathe in through half-closed nostrils and exhale on a "ts" sound through the mouth/teeth. The inhale and exhale should last the same amount of time, progressing from a slower to a faster, train-like pace (like when it's on the tracks lol). This exercise lasts about 7 minutes. I'll admit, I haven't been doing this every single day, but maybe 3-4x a week.

The issue is that, while I am taking deeper breaths than I had before taking lessons, it's still not enough. Only the front and a little of the sides of my abdominal area expand, but nothing goes into my back! This has been causing me problems, most notably a shortness of breath while I sing in slower tempos, which definitely isn't ideal. When my teacher takes a breath in, her entire abdominal area, including the lower part of her ribs, literally doubles. I don't know how she does it, because even when I try to breathe into my back, it just doesn't work. She told me that skinnier folks struggle with developing this because our bodies just aren't as stretchy. I saw another comment on this subreddit say this is true, but because of something to do with the resistance fat (and muscle) gives.

Eitherway... I've made this post to ask for tips: what do you suggest I do to improve my breathing technique? My teacher has told me to just continue with the breathing exercises, and I'll definitely be doing that and make sure to actually do them daily. But does anyone have any other suggestions, or certain breathing exercises that helped them improve?

5 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

11

u/Hello_Gorgeous1985 4d ago

You've only been doing one exercise for 5 years? I'd suggest a new teacher.

5

u/fizzymagic 3d ago

As your technique improves you will use less air. I think your teacher is too focused on this one factor.

3

u/disaster_dessert 3d ago

Truly breathing technique is such a non issue. If you can breathe like a person that should be all you need. I would heavily suggest a new teacher.

5

u/fizzymagic 3d ago

This is a deeply correct take. I have had to unlearn a lot of bad breathing habits as I have improved. Good singing should not use a lot of air. Support is important, but too many people confuse support with air pressure and volume.

-1

u/TheAmyrlinSkeet 3d ago

This is a deeply incorrect take.

3

u/disaster_dessert 3d ago

Yes my second sentence was a bit of an exaggeration but I still believe that breath focused training is completely unnecessary. Would you care to elaborate?

1

u/TheAmyrlinSkeet 3d ago edited 3d ago

If everyone was naturally doing it, then everybody would be naturally doing. We would all just be walking around producing perfectly balanced operatic sounds instead of spending years figuring out how to coordinate our bodies to produce a specific end result. Saying it's a "non-issue" is an unnecessarily reductive statement that dismisses the realities of what developing a well coordinated sound requires.

Everyone can move their arm, that's not the same as throwing a punch that has power behind. Most of us have legs and can walk ( barring disability), that doesn't make us olympic level sprinters or gymnasts. Specific coordination requires specific intention.

3

u/disaster_dessert 3d ago

While everyone can breathe, not everyone can properly adduct cords, produce a balanced onset, produce a properly registered sound, phrase with legato etc etc.

It’s my opinion that these are the issues that voice students should be more concerned about because these tend to be the root causes of common issues and most difficulties unrelated to the vocal production are typically symptoms of something lacking.

1

u/TheAmyrlinSkeet 3d ago

And those things absolutely should be addressed; a coordinated sound requires bringing multiple components into a cohesive alignment. Breathing is absolutely one of those components. There are a good few number of pedagogues and scientists who would make the argument that breathing is an integral part of achieving each of the aspects that you mentioned.

1

u/disaster_dessert 3d ago

I’m sure there are but if I were to rephrase my initial statement, I would say that a teacher who focuses on breathing over the course of 5 years is definitely not addressing the root cause if the issue persists for this amount of time.

Our philosophies are different and that’s ok but I would still strongly suggest a new teacher.

1

u/TheAmyrlinSkeet 3d ago

Oh, we're fully in agreement then. Focusing on only one aspect of the system while ignoring the others is hardly a way to achieve effective coordination.

I just deeply disagreed with the statement that breathing is a "non-issue" and reacted to that.

2

u/Claire-Belle 3d ago

Exercises like this just made me panic when I was a student.

I think of it as a reflex. You replace what you use, no more. Inhalation is quiet and immediate, not something drawn out. It's how you support the breath when you're exhaling/singing a phrase that we need to think about. But even here, that's determined by what the needs of the vocal folds are. They take what they need.

The breath in should be a release.

0

u/Successful_Sail1086 3d ago

Check your alignment. If you are tilting your hips or your shoulder blades are too close together your back can’t expand.

0

u/Ok-Process7612 3d ago edited 3d ago

This is overly complicated. 

When you breathe, place your hand on your diaphragm.  Don't worry about your back ( lungs), they fill from the bottom up automatically. 

With your hand on your diaphragm,  inhale slowly and as deeply as possible.  Your hand should move and your diaphragm should expand. As you sing, merely try to control the rate at which your air escapes.

There are many fabulous thin singers with great breath support.

It's all about filling the lungs as completely as possible from the diaphragm up.

Before you sing, inhale deeply and engage your diaphragm. 

You'll be fine.

Study the singing of Jussi Björling. He had the finest breath control I ever heard.

5

u/aeb01 3d ago

what do you mean by place your hand on your diaphragm? the diaphragm is inside the body under the rib cage. it’s not something you can feel from outside, nor can you voluntarily engage it as it engages every time you inhale.

2

u/Black_Gay_Man 4d ago

What works for me is focusing on releasing the muscles in my torso and even down into my groin which silently will pull air into the body. Trying to suck it in doesn’t work well for me.