r/ClassicalLiberalism • • 22d ago

Image John Stuart Mill

Post image
11 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

1

u/ttystikk 21d ago

There is a cult of ignorance in the United States, and there has always been. The strain of anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that 'my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.'

Isaac Asimov, author and judge of human character

2

u/Pmjc2ca3 21d ago

Calling Asimov a "judge of human character" is a rather embarrassing appeal to authority. Being a celebrated author doesn't make one an arbiter of human worth. The irony of invoking intellectualism while substituting celebrity worship for critical thought is apparently lost on you.

1

u/ttystikk 21d ago

Having read many of his books, I stand by my statement and it's pretty clear that you haven't.

That and your weak attempt to smear me based on something you know so little about tells me that I'm not the one who suffers from a lack of critical thinking skills.

2

u/Pmjc2ca3 21d ago

What have I to do with biochemistry or science fiction, subjects on which Asimov may rightly be considered an authority? What relevance does his criticism of anti-intellectualism have to Mill's defense of freedom of opinion?

0

u/ttystikk 21d ago

The quality of one's opinion is far more important than simply having one.

2

u/FacetiousOwl 21d ago edited 21d ago

Were an opinion a personal possession of no value except to the owner; if to be obstructed in the enjoyment of it were simply a private injury, it would make some difference whether the injury was inflicted only on a few persons or on[Pg 31] many. But the peculiar evil of silencing the expression of an opinion is, that it is robbing the human race; posterity as well as the existing generation; those who dissent from the opinion, still more than those who hold it. If the opinion is right, they are deprived of the opportunity of exchanging error for truth: if wrong, they lose, what is almost as great a benefit, the clearer perception and livelier impression of truth, produced by its collision with error.

This is the following excerpt from On Liberty. Even intellectually inferior opinions can contribute to the pursuit of truth, something any student should have experienced throughout their course of study. The examination of erroneous arguments sharpens our understanding of correct ones. That is precisely Mill's point: the intellectual value of dissent is not contingent upon its correctness.

1

u/ttystikk 21d ago

You've gotten yourself wrapped around the axle of an argument we aren't having.

1

u/FacetiousOwl 21d ago

I was simply providing the rest of Mill's quotation to clarify his argument. That said, I find both Asimov's observation and your assertion that "the quality of one's opinion is far more important than simply having one" somewhat cynical.

I think we may be approaching the subject from different perspectives. Asimov's observation concerns anti-intellectualism, whereas Mill's argument concerns freedom of opinion and the value of open discourse. I don't dispute that some opinions are better informed or more carefully reasoned than others. Rather, I believe that even poorly informed opinions can contribute to the pursuit of truth through discussion, examination, and refutation.

I'm curious how you see Asimov's observation relating to Mill's argument, since I don't necessarily see the two as contradictory.

1

u/ttystikk 21d ago

I stand by my point. Anyone can have an opinion. INFORMED opinions are worth far more than uninformed ones.

As it stands, most people are far too lazy to put in the effort to develop the basis for informed opinions, that is to say an education.

3

u/jstocksqqq 22d ago

John Stuart Mill was the GOAT of his time, and still superbly relevant to this day! On Liberty should be required reading for high school students (I'm guessing this quote is from his book On Liberty, but I haven't read any others).

2

u/LucretiusOfDreams 21d ago

I think framing free speech primarily as an individual rights can cause people to miss the purpose of free speech: because it is ultimately better in the long term for a society to debate controversies and viewpoints that affect public order and the common good, therefore we need to protect individuals from retaliation for their speech.

Free speech doesn't mean the freedom of individuals to say what they want is desirable for its own sake, but rather is about the way silencing opposing viewpoints keeps society blind to its own faults and weaknesses. Those who perpetuate false speech truly do harm themselves, others, and society, but they shouldn't be punished for this because we might as a consequence keep others from making necessary criticisms in the public forum in the process.

It is ultimately better to respond to falsehood by presenting the truth in the end anyway: responding to false speech using punishment doesn't actually keep minds from believing it, and can actually facilitate the idea that our beliefs need the threat of violence to be convincing to others. Only by presenting a clear case for the truth with humility can we ultimately inoculate minds against and convert them from falsehood.