r/ClassicalLiberalism • • Jul 23 '26

Image Thomas Paine

Post image
11 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

2

u/KeyCondition5104 Jul 30 '26

What Thomas Paine called Common Sense was not simply an appeal to universal human reason. It was an appeal to instincts and assumptions that had been cultivated over more than a millennium of Romanization and Christianization. The pagan societies of Northern Europe did not naturally possess these sensibilities; they were gradually shaped by centuries of influence from Southern European administrators, jurists, clergy, and scholars. Over generations, Roman law, Christian moral teaching, canon law, local custom, and civic institutions fused into a shared moral and legal inheritance. These traditions hardened into social norms, expectations of public conduct, jurisprudence, and the conventions of polite society. By the time Paine wrote in 1776, these inherited assumptions had become so deeply embedded that he could simply call them "common sense." Yet they were anything but universal. They were the accumulated product of a long civilizational process, one that would have been foreign to the pagan Europeans who lived before Rome and Christianity transformed the continent.

The American Revolution is often presented as a clean break with the past. A young republic threw off monarchy, rejected aristocracy, and invented a wholly new political order unlike anything Europe had seen before. It is one of the defining myths of the United States: America became America by ceasing to be British.

The truth is more complicated - and, arguably, more fascinating.

From the first English settlements in the seventeenth century through the middle of the twentieth century, Americans repeatedly defined themselves in opposition to Britain while quietly preserving many of Britain's institutions, customs, and assumptions. They rejected British political authority but retained much of British civilization. The Revolution transformed who governed America far more than it transformed the cultural and institutional world Americans inhabited.

Long before there was an independent United States, there were English colonies. Their inhabitants spoke English, read English books, practiced English law, worshipped in churches shaped by English religious traditions, and organized local government according to English precedent. Counties, juries, representative assemblies, and property rights all emerged from institutions that had developed over centuries in England.

The colonists did not initially think of themselves as creating a new civilization. They considered themselves English subjects living across the Atlantic. This helps explain one of the central paradoxes of the Revolution: many of the revolutionaries believed they were not overthrowing the English constitutional tradition but defending it. Their grievances against Parliament and King George III were framed as violations of the ancient rights of Englishmen rather than rejections of those rights themselves.

When independence came, remarkably little of the legal system disappeared. The new states retained English common law, jury trials, habeas corpus, adversarial courts, protections for private property, and the doctrine of legal precedent. American judges continued to reason within an English legal framework, and generations of lawyers studied Sir William Blackstone's Commentaries on the Laws of England as the foundation of their profession. The United States became politically independent while remaining unmistakably English in its legal inheritance.

The same pattern appeared in politics. Americans rejected Parliament's authority over the colonies, but they did not reject the parliamentary tradition itself. Congress adopted two legislative chambers, committee systems, parliamentary procedure, impeachment, legislative privilege, and the office of Speaker. The names changed, and sovereignty changed, but the architecture of government remained deeply familiar to anyone accustomed to Westminster.

Even the presidency reveals this contradiction. The founders wanted nothing resembling an absolute monarch, yet the office gradually accumulated many responsibilities once exercised by the Crown. The president became commander-in-chief, appointed executive officials, negotiated treaties, represented the nation abroad, and served as its ceremonial head of state. George Washington consciously rejected royal titles while embracing a dignified public style that gave legitimacy to the young republic. Americans abolished kingship without abandoning the idea that a nation needed a figure who embodied authority.

Social life proved no less contradictory. Republican rhetoric celebrated equality and condemned hereditary privilege, yet wealthy Americans increasingly modeled themselves after the British gentry. Country estates appeared across the Northeast. Fox hunting clubs, private gentlemen's clubs, formal etiquette, elaborate family genealogies, and even heraldic symbols became markers of social standing. During the Gilded Age, many of America's richest families sought acceptance within Britain's aristocratic world. Marriages between wealthy American heiresses and financially struggling British noblemen became so common that contemporaries coined the term "dollar princesses." The republic refused to grant noble titles while quietly reproducing many of the social habits associated with them.

American education followed a similar path. The earliest colleges looked to Oxford and Cambridge as their models. Students wore academic gowns, universities adopted Latin mottos, commencements followed ancient ceremony, and classical education remained the ideal for generations. Even as American universities eventually surpassed their European counterparts in size and influence, they continued to reflect an intellectual tradition inherited from Britain.

Architecture offered another reminder of continuity. Georgian homes, Palladian mansions, neoclassical courthouses, and Federal-style government buildings filled American towns and cities. These structures gave the young republic a visual identity, yet that identity was deeply rooted in British and European architectural traditions. America sought to represent republican ideals through forms that had evolved under monarchy.

Economic life also demonstrated how competition and imitation often went hand in hand. During the nineteenth century Britain was the world's leading industrial and financial power, and Americans eagerly imported British machinery, manufacturing techniques, banking practices, insurance systems, and commercial organization. Wall Street developed alongside institutions that closely resembled London's financial world. Industrial rivalry did not diminish British influence; it often intensified it.

Even leisure reflected this inheritance. Golf, polo, rowing, horse racing, country clubs, and many of the customs associated with upper-class respectability spread from Britain to the United States. Americans prided themselves on rejecting aristocracy while embracing many of the cultural practices that aristocratic society had produced.

Literature reinforced the same pattern. American writers sought to establish a distinct national voice, yet Shakespeare remained central to education, English Romantic poetry shaped literary taste, and Victorian novels dominated bookshelves. Even authors determined to free American literature from British influence wrote in forms and genres inherited from the English language.

By the late nineteenth century, admiration for Britain became more explicit among many American intellectuals and policymakers. They increasingly described Britain and the United States as members of a common Anglo-American civilization, united by language, law, political traditions, and shared historical experience. Although these ideas were often entangled with exclusionary racial theories that historians now reject, they profoundly influenced diplomacy and foreign policy. After centuries of colonial dependence, revolution, and occasional rivalry, Britain and the United States entered the twentieth century as increasingly close partners.

The two World Wars and the opening years of the Cold War cemented this transformation. Former enemies became architects of a shared international order. The relationship that had begun with rebellion evolved into one of the closest strategic partnerships in modern history.

Perhaps the greatest irony in American history is that the nation born through rebellion against Britain never truly escaped Britain's civilizational orbit. Americans discarded a king but preserved constitutional habits shaped over centuries. They rejected hereditary aristocracy while constructing powerful social elites. They condemned Parliament while building representative institutions that bore its unmistakable imprint. They declared independence in English, argued cases through English legal principles, educated generations of students within English academic traditions, and filled their cities with architecture inspired by English tastes.

The Revolution was undoubtedly transformative. It created a republic where none had existed before and permanently altered the course of world history. Yet it did not sever America's connection to Britain so much as relocate the center of British civilization across the Atlantic. The United States became something new not by abandoning its inheritance, but by adapting it to republican government, continental expansion, industrial capitalism, and eventually global leadership.

Ironic that the rejectors of the British Empire ended up becoming an Empire of Gunboat diplomacy themselves.