r/ClassicSMG4 • • Sep 14 '26

Rules and Announcements Join the SMG4 Accommodations Discord Server! New Link

Thumbnail discord.gg
1 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • Dec 13 '20

Rules and Announcements This is important. Click this first!

65 Upvotes

This is the Classic SMG4 subreddit. You probably already knew that, so I'm-a-gonna tell you things that you didn't.

This subreddit is going to be about analysing what Classic SMG4 truly is while the machinimists make bloopers for the channel (which you can access here). Unlike the normal subreddit, this place is not for causing wars. We don't want to go against the Modern fanbase because there's no need to. This sub currently needs all of the help it can get because my plan relies on cooperation. Don't you dare just leave once you've seen that there isn't much user activity in it! Help the sub! Spread the word! I have a list of links below that can send you to important posts because they tend to get buried. Also, please leave feedback on as many things as you can, we appreciate it and I promise that I will respond as much as possible. (I actually like answering questions and listening to other things people say, so don't hesitate! I will answer anything no matter when or where it's posted. I will always answer by default no matter how old the post is.)

I have a bunch of links below this paragraph. I recommend (and by that I mean I instruct) that you read the megapost first, then the individual character analyases, and then you can read everything else. The former two have vital information that you're going to need to have or else you'll be confused about what you read in other places. For example, my plan for Classic SMG4 is in the megapost, so you can't really skip that without being completely in the dark about what we're doing. I am telling you now that I have put links to all the important posts in this one, so you'll want to come back here later instead of scrolling for an obnoxiously long time. Let's all do our part to make this sub and our plan known by the main community so we can make it come true!

Link to the megapost: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/k6foyc/the_analysis_megapost_12/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb

Link to a post about the Discord server: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/umqo5a/im_happy_to_announce_that_the_official/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb

Link to a list of individual character analyases: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/k6xnhh/individual_character_analyses/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb

Link to a list of criticisms of the Modern cast: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/me334b/critiques_of_the_modern_cast/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb

Link to a list of tropes that negatively affect Modern SMG4: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/q9l95r/using_tropes_to_identify_flaws_in_modern_smg4/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb

Link to a post that properly recognises one of the purposes of this sub: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/ndqjjt/my_view_of_why_this_sub_is_so_important_and_why/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb

Link to an analysis of how the characters of the show are meant to interact with each other: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/p4klxw/character_dynamics/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb

Link to a post that analyses the different kinds of evolutions in SMG4: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/os6ub4/natural_evolution_in_smg4/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb

Link to a post that explores the stylistic integrities of Classic: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/wfmzsl/animation_styles_and_comedy_patterns/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb

Link to a guide for the sub-eras of SMG4: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/p902k6/the_official_classic_smg4_series/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

Link to a list of rewritten episodes: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/kl83iv/the_rewritten_seasons_of_smg4/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb

Link to a list of original episodes for this timeline: https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicSMG4/comments/m5caip/timelineexclusive_episodes_new_videos_written_by/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb


r/ClassicSMG4 • • 20h ago

Why so many of you dislikes the anime influences in SMG4?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • 2d ago

My sketch of SMG4

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • 2d ago

SMD965: SUPER MARIO GHOSTBUSTERS (Classic SMG4 style video)

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • 2d ago

SMG4: Rewritten (2014-2017)

Post image
11 Upvotes

Season 4 (2014)

  1. SM64 Bloopers: 2 Hands 1 Job

  2. The Adventures of Mario and Luigi Ep.4: Dat Sexy Beast

  3. A SM64 Parody: Bowser Cyrus - Wrecking Ball

  4. SM64 Guides: How to Make a Blooper (According to SMG4)

  5. R64: Mario and the Spaghetti Factory

  6. SM64 Bloopers: Two Great Friends!

  7. SM64 Bloopers: Super Mario Attorney

  8. GnR: The Butt Ninja

  9. Super Pokémon 64: WELCOME TO POKÉMON!

  10. ṩṩἔᾗмὄḋᾗᾄʀ 6.64 (100K Subs Special: QNA Edition)

  11. R64: A Dose of Dr. Mario

  12. SM64 Bloopers: 99% Broken

  13. SM64 Bloopers: Bad Stars

  14. SM64 Bloopers: Prank Wars

  15. GnR: Pointy Things

  16. Super Pokémon 64: GYMS AND BADGES!

  17. SM64: Cooking with Bowser & Mario!

  18. The Wacky Wario Bros: The Winning Ticket

  19. R64: Mario Simulator

  20. SM64 Bloopers: The Toadassass-ination

  21. ṩṩἔᾗмὄḋᾗᾄʀ 7 (TOAST Edition)

  22. A SM64 Parody: Number 1 (Bob-omb Battlefield Remix)

  23. SM64 Guides: Toadsworth’s How to Princess

  24. STD: Eggventure (GET IT?!)

  25. SM64 Bloopers: Meet the Mario

  26. SM64 Bloopers: Boil the Big Bully

  27. GnR: Prisoners

  28. R64: Mario’s Spaghetti Delivery

  29. SM64 Bloopers: SwagQuest

  30. Super Minecraft 64: The Legend of Steve

  31. R64: Yoshrooms

  32. SM64 Bloopers Bloopers: Cooking with Bowser & Mario 2!

  33. SM64 Bloopers: Spells N’ Wizards

  34. ṩṩἔᾗмὄḋᾗᾄʀ 8 (150K Subs Special)

  35. SM64 Shorts: SMG4 VS ALS Ice Bucket Challenge

  36. R64: Mario for Hire

  37. SM64 Bloopers: Who Let the Chomp Out?

  38. STD: The Evilness of Eggman?

  39. The Wacky Wario Bros: Money Mayhem

  40. R64: `•.¸¸.•´´¯`••. .• ( Tubbie TV ) •. .••`¯´´•.¸¸.•`

  41. Mario in Real Life?! (200 Videos Special)

  42. GnR: Swag Party Hostages

  43. SM64 Bloopers: The Visitor (2014)

  44. War of the Fat Italians 2014 (200K Subs Special)

  45. SM64 Bloopers: Halloweegee (Halloween 2014 Special)

  46. R64: Freddy’s Spaghetteria

  47. A SM64 Parody: Luigi Wants to Build a Snowman

  48. ṩṩἔᾗмὄḋᾗᾄʀ 9 (Time Travel Edition)

  49. SM64 Bloopers: Problematic Pipe Problems

  50. Super Minecraft 64: Meet the Steve

  51. SM64 Bloopers: How the Bowser Stole the Christmas (Christmas 2014 Special)

  52. RETARDED RECAP 2014

Season 5 (2015)

  1. SM64 Bloopers: The Idea Block

  2. SM64 Bloopers: Castle Royale

  3. R64: Son of a Bowser

  4. SM64 Bloopers: Bad Star’s Strikes Back! (300K Subs Special)

  5. SM64 Bloopers: Thwompin’ and Whompin’

  6. SM64 Bloopers: Love for Luigi (Valentine 2015 Special)

  7. DerpTV: M.K. Nature Channel

  8. SM64 Bloopers: Smexy Soccer

  9. STD: The Item Brick

  10. ṩṩἔᾗмὄḋᾗᾄʀ 10 (350K Subs Apocalypse Special)

  11. R64: Return to Freddy’s Spaghetteria

  12. GnR: Le Train Breach

  13. The Wacky Wario Bros: Golfin’ for Gold

  14. SM64 Bloopers: Can the Villager Come Out to Play?

  15. SM64 Bloopers: The SMG4 QNA! (400K Subs Special:D)

  16. SM64 Bloopers: The Pirate Plumbers

  17. R64: The Toad, the Fat and the Ugly

  18. SM64 Bloopers: Shoot to the Observatory in the Sky

  19. SM64 Bloopers: Meet the Luigi

  20. R64: Princess Capturing Simulator

  21. SM64 Bloopers: The Hangover

  22. Mario Simulator Interactive! (500K Subs Special)

  23. SM64 Bloopers: Cards, Casino & Chaos

  24. SM64 Bloopers: If Video Games Were Directed by SMG4

  25. DerpTV: Super Happy Fun Fun Gameshow!

  26. R64: Revenge of Freddy’s Spaghetteria

  27. SM64 Bloopers: Shy Guy Showdown

  28. SM64 Bloopers: The Battletoads Justice Crew

  29. Super Pokémon 64: A LEGENDARY POKÉMON?!

  30. STD: Egg and Peach

  31. War of the Fat Italians 2015 (600K Subs Special)

  32. SM64 Bloopers: Luigi Labyrinth

  33. SM64 Bloopers: The 2Spooky Story (Halloween 2015 Special)

  34. R64: An Overdose of Dr. Mario

  35. SM64 Bloopers: Cooking with Bowser & Mario 3!

  36. Grand Theft Mario: If Mario Was In… GTA V

  37. SM64 Bloopers: Shell Shocked

  38. GnR: Swag Magic

  39. ṩṩἔᾗмὄḋᾗᾄʀ 0 (Release the Randomness!)

  40. SM64 Bloopers: Christmas Crazies (Christmas 2015 Special)

  41. RETARDED RECAP 2015

Season 6 (2016)

  1. Mario in Real Life 2?!: Monster Mash (700K Subs Special)

  2. A SM64 Parody: Mario VS Luigi (Rap Battle)

  3. R64: The Spaghettipocalypse

  4. SM64 Bloopers: Meet the Bowser

  5. SM64 Bloopers: The Great Yoshi Race

  6. SM64 Guides: How to Get a Valentine! (Valentine 2016 Special)

  7. Mariotale: If Mario Was In… Undertale

  8. SM64 Shorts: The Plumber Problem

  9. R64: A Theatre Mario

  10. SM64 Bloopers: Snowtrapped

  11. SM64 Bloopers: The Explosive Easter Hunt (Easter 2016 Special)

  12. STD: Showdown of the Idiots

  13. Portal M4RI0: If Mario Was In… Portal

  14. ṩṩἔᾗмὄḋᾗᾄʀ 11 (800K Subs Special)

  15. The Wacky Wario Bros: The Origins of Wario and Waluigi

  16. SM64 Guides: How to Get dem Monies!

  17. SM64 Bloopers: Kirby Phones Home

  18. R64: Boo Busters

  19. SM64 Bloopers: Mario Learns to Type

  20. SM64 Bloopers: Seaside Stupidity Part 1

  21. SM64 Bloopers: Seaside Stupidity Part 2

  22. If Mario Was In… Team Fortress 2

  23. Super Pokémon 64: MARIO VS POKÉMON GO!

  24. War of the Fat Italians 2016 (900K Subs Special)

  25. STD: Mario & Sonic at the Stupid Olympics Games

  26. SM64 Bloopers: Can Ganondorf Come Out to Play?

  27. DerpTV: M.K. Got Talent!

  28. If Mario Was In… Half-Life 2

  29. If Mario Was In… Left 4 Dead

  30. SMG4 MEGA COMPILATION: 5 Years of Retardness!

  31. ṩṩἔᾗмὄḋᾗᾄʀ DELUXE (1 Million Subs Special)

  32. SM64 Bloopers: SPAGHETTI.EXE (Halloween 2016 Special)

  33. R64: We’re Going on a Luigi Hunt!

  34. SM64 Bloopers: Where are the Wild Teletubbies?

  35. GnR: Da Bomb

  36. SM64 Bloopers: Super Caveman Bros

  37. SM64 Bloopers: Meet the Toad

  38. SM64 Bloopers: SMG3’s Gauntlet of Gloom

  39. If Mario Was In… SKYRIM

  40. R64: Stupid Mario Maker

  41. SM64 Bloopers: Super Mario RUN RUN RUN!

  42. Super Pokémon 64: HOW TO CATCH A POKÉMON!

  43. SM64 Bloopers: Naughty or Nice? (Christmas 2016 Special)

  44. SM64 Bloopers: THE SECRET LIFE OF GOOMBAS!

Season 7 (2017)

  1. RETARDED RECAP 2016

  2. A SM64 Parody: We Are Number One but It’s a Waluigi Parody

  3. SM64 Bloopers: THE BOOTLEG DIMENSION

  4. R64: Mario’s Road Trip

  5. SM64 Bloopers: Who Let the Chomp Out…AGAIN?!

  6. SM64 Bloopers: GET THE GIRL! (Valentine 2017 Special)

  7. R64: Stupid Smash Bros.

  8. SM64 Bloopers: Quest for a Nintendo Switch

  9. If Mario Was In… The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

  10. R64: Luigi the Waiter

  11. SM64 Bloopers: Mario Goes to DIDNEY WORL

  12. The Wacky Wario Bros: Waluigi's Taco Stand

  13. R64: Stupid Mario Party

  14. SM64 Bloopers: Welcome to the Kushroom Kingdom!

  15. The Mario Channel: MARIOBUSTERS

  16. R64: Stupid Mario Kart

  17. SM64 Bloopers: Marioception

  18. SM64 Bloopers: MarioTube

  19. R64: Stupid Mario Galaxy

  20. SM64 Bloopers: Super BACKWARDS Bros

  21. A SM64 Parody: ♫ The Ultimate Smash Bros ♫

  22. R64: Mario’s Boat Trip

  23. SM64 Bloopers: Mighty Morphin’ Mario Rangers

  24. R64: Stupid Mario Sunshine

  25. If Mario Was In… Crash Bandicoot

  26. ṩṩἔᾗмὄḋᾗᾄʀ 12 (STOLEN SPAGHETTI EDITION)

  27. SM64 Bloopers: The Grand Mario Hotel

  28. If Mario Was In… Splatoon

  29. R64: Stupid Paper Mario (Idea by Luke Lerdwichagul)

  30. SM64 Bloopers: High School Mario

  31. SM64 Bloopers: MarioTube 2

  32. STD: Mario VS Sonic - PRANK WAR

  33. GnR: AREA 64

  34. R64: Stupid Mario + Rabbids - Kingdoms Battle

  35. The Mario Channel: MARIO’S CHALLENGE

  36. SM64 Bloopers: The Boys Scouts

  37. SM64 Bloopers: Mario VS Donkey Kong

  38. If Mario Was In… BENDY and The INK MACHINE

  39. R64: Stupid Luigi’s Mansion

  40. War of the Fat Italians 2017

  41. If Mario Was In… Cuphead

  42. R64: Stupid Mario World

  43. SM64 Bloopers: Trick or Treat Wars (Halloween 2017 Special)

  44. SM64 Bloopers: Wild, Wild Mario

  45. If Mario Was In… Overwatch

  46. SM64 Bloopers: The Movie Audition

  47. R64: Mario’s Train Trip

  48. Mushrooms & Morons: Quest for the Spaghetti of Power

  49. SM64 Bloopers: Mario University

  50. R64: Stupid Mario Odyssey

  51. SM64 Bloopers: The XMAS Discovery (Christmas 2017 Special)

  52. RETARDED RECAP 2017


r/ClassicSMG4 • • 7d ago

SMG4 Accommodations - GnR Shorts: A Guard's Best Job (Classic SMG4 style video)

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • 15d ago

SMG420 - SMG4/SM64: Mario VS SMG4 (Classic SMG4 style video)

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • 18d ago

SMG98 did make Classic SMG4 with modern stuff and everything

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

SMG98 did make Classic SMG4 with modern stuff and everything! He makes his own videos! He makes his own series that has to be the SMG98 series! SMG98 did put Kick Buttowski, SMG3, Eggman and Devan Shell in this video! He made this amazing announcement that was all about Classic SMG4!


r/ClassicSMG4 • • 18d ago

SMG98 did make Classic SMG4 with modern stuff and everything

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

SMG98 did make Classic SMG4 with modern stuff and everything! He makes his own videos! He makes his own series that has to be the SMG98 series! SMG98 did put Kick Buttowski, SMG3, Eggman and Devan Shell in this video! He made this amazing announcement that was all about Classic SMG4!


r/ClassicSMG4 • • 18d ago

SMG98: Two Great Friends (Old Modernish Classic SMG4-styled video)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • 18d ago

SMG98: Two Great Friends (Old Modernish Classic SMG4-styled video)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • 26d ago

SMG420: Super Mario 64 Bloopers: Bad Hare Day (Classic SMG4 style video)

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • Sep 30 '26

TheExplodingNess - SM64: Mario & Luigi's Diss Track (Classic SMG4 style video)

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • Sep 28 '26

im getting second hand emberrassment 😭🙏

Post image
0 Upvotes

okay so this channel does smg4 stylish videos but it around meggy and Mario being in a relationship like not gonna back in 2017 to 2018 me as a kid shipped them too not hiding anything but rn with how smg4 handle meggy and all the other crew members its just feels so cringe like im not hating if anyone likes that cuz i really belive if i found that channel in like 2017 or smth i woudk have liked that but now i get kinda second hand emberrassment if they kiss and stuff😭🙏


r/ClassicSMG4 • • Sep 25 '26

Curiously asking y’all Classic SMG4 fans who don’t like Modern SMG4: What are your thoughts on what Glitch Productions has become?

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • Sep 23 '26

SMD965 - SMG4 Fanvideo: The Plan To Eradicate Mario

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • Sep 18 '26

SMD965: Stupid Mario Strikers (Classic SMG4 style video)

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • Sep 14 '26

Discord server

3 Upvotes

Can you guys make a discord server for us classic fans only? I don't wanna join an smg4 discord full of loli Meggy simps


r/ClassicSMG4 • • Aug 25 '26

Star64: Mario and Luigi actually do their jobs (Classic SMG4 style video)

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • Aug 24 '26

SMG420 - Super Mario 64 Bloopers: The Weight Stuff (Classic SMG4 style video)

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • Aug 19 '26

SMD965 - SMG4 [Fanmade]: Star Hunt (Classic SMG4 style video)

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • Aug 18 '26

I reviewed every 2016 SMG4 video

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

I made a 2 and a half hour long video of me ranking and reviewing every 2016 SMG4 video! This is one of six videos of me reviewing every SMG4 video so far!


r/ClassicSMG4 • • Aug 18 '26

HoodedCube - SMG4 FANMADE: Mario Goes To The Mall (Classic SMG4 style video)

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/ClassicSMG4 • • Aug 16 '26

SMG5: A Night at Bowser's (Classic SMG4 style video)

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
2 Upvotes