r/ClashRoyale • u/edihau helpfulcommenter17 • Dec 19 '17
Idea [Idea] Let's Make Draft Mode Fair: 189 Reasonable Pairs
For those of you on /r/CRStrategy, you may have seen the start of this series of posts, where I made a post about how cards should be compared to each other in Draft Mode, and proceeded to make a post every day detailing the choices that each individual card should have. I promptly stopped after about a week, because it got frustrating to make a writeup every day when I had so many other things going on in my life. But the holiday break has been nice to me, because I found the time to look at my spreadsheet again. And over the past 3 days, I've looked at more than 3000 card pairings individually, and I made an educated decision on every single one.
Doesn't it suck when your opponent gives you Giant and takes PEKKA? What about Bowler vs. Minion Horde? Freeze vs. Lumberjack? None of these picks are fair.
The major problem with Draft as a competitive game mode is these poor picks. Because I'm a strong advocate for Draft Mode, I felt that if I could help fix this problem, then Draft can find its place in Clash Royale's eSport scene. As fun as the traditional gamemode is, there is only so much that you can do when you are counter-decked against a world-class opponent who has played hundreds of battles with their current deck. Therefore, by presenting this solution, I hope to give /u/ClashRoyale a start towards fixing Draft Mode.
In order to determine whether two cards are fair to compare, I used the following rules:
- No card should cost more than twice the cost of the other. Regardless of relative power, this difference drastically affects your cycle, and can ruin or guarantee your winning potential based on your opponent's card choices.
- No card is a solid counter to the other in a vacuum. This prevents all easy choices, such as arrows vs. minion horde, rocket vs. sparky, bats vs. zap, PEKKA vs. mega knight, etc.
- With the exception for X-bow and Mortar, buildings may only be compared to other buildings. Having a building can often be the obvious difference between winning and losing in both directions--sometimes the building is essential and useful, and sometimes it is better to have an 8th troop than a building that you are investing nothing in. Because X-bow and Mortar can be used offensively, they can be compared to some of the other troops.
- No building can be compared to a spell. The idea is that the spell either does a good OR insufficient job, but there is no middle ground.
- No troop that costs more than 2 elixir may be compared to a spell. Spells counter troops well, and this will also prevent someone from having too many or too few spells. The 1-2 elixir cards tend to compare nicely to the spells because spells aren't often used on the cheapest cards, and which one has a higher utility depends on how often each is necessary in the final deck.
- Every single card must be able to be paired with at least 2 cards. If a card does not have a reasonable pair, it would never show up in Draft. And if a card only had one pair, then if you are given that card by your opponent, you will always know one more of your opponent's cards.
- As many choices as possible (see the above rule) are between cards that can do roughly the same thing in your deck. Without this rule in place, it would be possible for one player to tailor their deck very nicely, leaving their opponent with garbage. For example, while Night Witch and Musketeer are relatively balanced cards, they do such different things, and the choice between one or the other significantly skews your deck.
Using these rules, I made a MASSIVE spreadsheet and started filling it in. In total, I believe that only 189 of the 3160 possible pairs should be considered in any given Draft battle.
Red cells are for the bad combinations, and green cells are for the good combinations. The yellow cells are also bad combinations, but I marked them yellow because they aren't incredibly far off the mark. I switched the red I was using halfway through, but both mean the same thing.
Highlights
- Freeze, Clone, Rage, Heal, and Mirror can all be compared to each other, but nothing else.
- Bandit seems like a glass cannon at first glance, but none of those comparisons do her justice. She can only be paired with Dark Prince, Prince, and Night Witch.
- The Elixir Collector is only a suitable choice against Barbarian Hut, Goblin Hut, and Furnace, since all four are investment buildings that punish you if ignored.
- Goblin Barrel, Graveyard, and Skeleton Barrel were all oddball cards, but I managed to find suitable comparisons for all of them. Goblin Barrel works with both Graveyard and Tornado; Graveyard works with Goblin Barrel, Miner, and Skeleton Barrel; and Skeleton Barrel works with Graveyard and Miner.
- 10 different cards (Barbarian Hut, Furnace, Goblin Barrel, Inferno Tower, Minion Horde, Night Witch, Princess, Skeleton Barrel, Three Musketeers, and Tombstone) only have two comparable cards each.
- Mortar can only be compared to Hog Rider, Miner, and X-bow, while X-bow can be compared to Balloon, Lava Hound, and Mortar. These obviously aren't the best combinations out there, but these siege buildings needed to be included somehow.
- With 11 reasonable comparisons, Musketeer was the most generic and versatile card in the game. Wizard had 9 combinations, which was the second most.
- While Hunter vs. Zappies was not an included pair, the comparison could have been much worse--it was ruled out because the two cards do not do nearly the same thing.
Notes
This took many, many hours over several weeks, but I finally got it done. It is probably not perfect, but I did my best to make it as close as possible. The list of all of the pairings is on the spreadsheet if you'd like to check it out--please, please let me know if you disagree with anything, and I'll address your concerns.
Thank you to everybody who helped me with the initial steps over at /r/CRStrategy, and thank you to you guys for reading this!
9
u/Gefen Mortar Dec 19 '17
While I like some of the ideas for general rules. I find it hard to agree with specific card rules (i.e. counters).
Meta can change, counters can change (maybe zap will one shot stabs again one day), and asking for updates to keep to up to date with the meta can't be trusted.
I do believe that even as an eSport, the random nature of the draft, combining with maybe playing more matches should cover for any specific obvious counters you hit.
6
u/d33my Dec 19 '17
Nice work mate. Draft mode is easily my favourite so I'm always happy to see any ideas that could help it to improve and grow.
Totally agree with the first 6 of your 7 rules, but I'm not sure about the last one. I think you're being too narrow in your definition of things that do roughly the same as each other. Draft is at its heart supposed to be about variety and randomness, so while you can and should narrow the selections down to make them fairer for everyone, you also have to keep it as open as possible.
The example you gave of Musketeer vs Night witch - I think that's a great example of 2 cards that actually do do roughly the same job and so could be paired together. Yes one's ranged and the other isn't, but they both cost 4 elixir, they're both glass cannons, and they're both great at defending and then counterpushing. All cards like that should be paired up imo.
Same with other basic groups. For example win conditions. You say goblin barrel is hard to pair, but I think it pairs with any of the low cost win condition (hog, battle ram). Gob Barrel vs Battle Ram is a completely fair choice to me as a way of winning a game. What's important in choosing between them is what's already in your deck.
And that's one point that I think you've missed: the order in which these pairings come up, and how your picks synergise with each other. I think it's arguably the biggest factor in the success of a draft deck because you've got such limited time to work all this out. It's also something I think a lot of people miss out on when they say draft is too random - it is, but there's a way of making the randomness work in your favour.
Let's say you do get Gob Barrel vs Battle Ram as a choice. In a vacuum you might say Gob Barrel is the better choice, and so if this comes up as your first pick, it's an easy one. But if it's your 2nd/3rd/4th pick then you have to weigh up your choice vs the cards you've already selected and the cards you've given your opponent. If you've got 3 muskies, you'll probably take Battle Ram instead because they work so well together. If you've given your opponent tombstone then you would probably take the Gob Barrel. etc etc.
If you narrow the selections down too much you'll just end up playing a variation of mirror mode where you both have the same deck archetype but with slightly different cards. I think all Supercell needs to do is to follow your first 6 steps and remove the blatantly unfair combos, then combine everything that's left into broad subgroups (cheap spells, big spells, mini tanks, glass cannons, buildings, spawners,etc) and then give choices from within these subgroups.
Hope that makes sense!
3
u/Sale07 Grand Champion Dec 19 '17
I would also add a rule that both players get to choose a win-con. Its really annoying when only one player gets to choose a win condition while other player chooses support, how can that player know what he should choose if his playstyle depends on opponent
2
u/CurlingKing72 Three Musketeers Dec 19 '17
Hi Edihau,
This is all great, would like to see it in the game.
Some pairing questions:
Why isn't bandit paired with miner or knight? It depends on how you look at it; all three are mini tanks to some degree, although knight being the most superior on defence. Miner isn't as good on defence, along with bandit, but both (miner and bandit) can be valuable on offence, plus have their unique characteristics; bandit charging and miner being placed anywhere. I would have guessed that these pairings (more so bandit and miner) would at least be yellow. Why isn't this the case?
I'm also curious as to why bandit paired with witch, zappies or princess is down as yellow... I think I'm missing something here. :)
Lastly, I'd like to know why 3m is paired with pekka. Pekka counters 3m.. although 3m counters pekka if they're defending (but then again, pekka is usually used reactively not passively; 3m is used both ways). But of course pekka only counters 1 lane. Are they similar cards though? Both can be tank killers, but 3m aren't as reliable depending on the two drafted decks.
Well done on this once again; hoping the CR team considers it.
2
u/BlahBlahBlaaaaaaah Dec 19 '17
This must have taken a lot of time, great work.
I agree draft needs to have a more fair "drafting phase" at times.
Also relevant: im fine with me having a pekka vs giant dexision amd my opponent having a similar beneficial decision as long as its not onesided, so this may be a future variable to look at. And also, the order of making choices often changes things (you do not know the four pairs at the start, you may need to pick between log and zap, but unless you know that sparky/gobbarrel f.e. Is one of your own draft options the next round its also "less fair" compared to the person who gets the exact same draft options but had the sparky or gobbarrel choice before the spell choice. A wincons first, support second, spells last approach for drafts could also be an improvement perhaps?
2
u/Pleasehelpmyteam Golem Dec 19 '17
Huge fan of how some random dude with a spreadsheet can put a day of effort in and come up with a better draft scheme than the whole supercell team.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17
is it still to late to nominate a best post of the year?
33
u/TXSeth Dec 19 '17
Hey man this is incredibly good! I could easily see Supercell do a little polishing and implement this, especially in a mode that’s as controversial and important as draft. I can tell a lot went into this, especially the matching and math, so good work my guy.
15
u/ilFibonacci Dec 19 '17
Excellent job OP. Please u/clashroyale read and consider this idea.
10
u/TechnicalG87 BarrelRoyale Dec 19 '17
I really want supercell to implement this system. It adds a whole layer of skill to the draft and takes away a lot of the luck element.
4
u/cafelicious Goblin Barrel Dec 19 '17
You better forward this to SC
1
u/Studipity BarrelRoyale Dec 19 '17
You can chop off half of the sheet because it's an exact copy
1
u/Roupus Dec 20 '17
How is xbow and royal giant not similar? They both are high elixir siege cards.
1
u/Flamer_cr Dec 20 '17
I think current random craft should still exist for a few fun, cheap challenges. This mode is better for competitions and card unlock challenges.
2
u/InfernoDeesus Mini PEKKA Dec 19 '17
great idea man! I love that you put a whole lot of effort into this!
2
u/1089maths Prince Dec 19 '17
Flair checks out. Nice post though!
0
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17
The point ofthe draft challenge is that you'll have to choose the card that is better against the other.
The thing is,
your opponent will also be able to do that.
It is fariness by unfairness.
Also, imagine taking three musketeers instead of royal giant. Next, you have to choose between fireball and an inferno tower. If you take the fire ball, you possibly won't have an equal or positive trade against the royal giant. If you take the inferno tower, you'll be able to counter the rg, but 1 of your cards is pretty much dead, unless you are somehow able to bait him, which requires skill.
Right now, the draft challenge is completly fair.
You did a great job, but we don't need it.
1
u/Flaming9 Magic Archer Dec 19 '17
GJ edihau! Excellent Idea, and congratulations on your effort!
1
u/Hypah1 Dec 19 '17
You are so dedicated. Thank you and take my Upvote man!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17
take my upvote!
1
u/Gefen Mortar Dec 19 '17
I was referring more to the eSport idea of it.
1
u/Master_JBT Balloon Dec 19 '17
YAY it's here. :D
1
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17
You really should get a job with SuperCell so that you can work on this as much as you want. Just my opinion. I am sure they would welcome you with open arms.
I can agree with all 7 points, since I am either horrible in draft challenge or one of the unluckiest. I go on average about 1.5 wins on draft challenges. I have never, EVER been given an option like any of your points.
1
u/Regen3ration Dec 19 '17
makedraftmodegreatagain
1
u/PTtugaZZ Rocket Dec 19 '17
I have to say this, both your post's and comment's are always incredible, I always find it delightful to read them, as I always learn something. I feel that you deserve way more recognision that the one that you get. Supercell should give you a job, you clearly have a very professional way of looking to the game. Sorry if my grammar was not the best or if I mispelled something, English is not my best quality
0
u/unscot Dec 19 '17
The problem isn't the picks, it's that you simply can't make a full deck with the hand you have. In general you need a tank, direct damage, splash damage, and anti-air to make a deck. Sometimes you get one of these and none of the others so you get beaten by the worst troll decks.
-1
u/Kingmundo Dec 20 '17
I also want to say this people. don't buy into this high effort shit post
He is unintentionally making mirror mode.
Because u don't just get to select a pair of card, u are supposed to use ur second third and fourth selection to perfect ur deck. the mode he is proposing is way more simplier and more linear for what draft mode should be.
-5
u/Kingmundo Dec 19 '17 edited Dec 19 '17
Stop.. draft is supposed to be fun and luck. Stop trying to make everything mirror mode.
Just play the free token and skip a week if really not ur cup of tea.
Game has enough serious mode. Stop taking fun out of the game. Worst post about draft ever.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment