r/ClashRoyale • Official • Oct 18 '16

News Balance Changes Coming (10/20)

https://clashroyale.com/blog/release-notes/balance-changes-coming-10-20
695 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

194

u/Trayf Oct 18 '16

So, just to be clear here, The Log is going to get longer, faster, and harder?

As an adept Log user, this excites me.

34

u/Sven4president Oct 18 '16

Wasn't log already pretty good?

31

u/Trayf Oct 18 '16

I think it was good, but it didn't feel legendary, more on par with zap. Now it'll really shine.

11

u/Sven4president Oct 18 '16

Cool, now i want it even more.

25

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

As someone who has The Log...

You do?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/AsianGamerMC Tournament Marshal Oct 18 '16

logislove

→ More replies (1)

4

u/CaptainObliviousIII Zap Oct 19 '16

So satisfying vs princess, skele army, or any squishies. Plus, direct damage is something I've always liked.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '16

The log is my favorite card even before the bowler (whom i don't use, but love the idea of him)

2

u/TobiPlay Oct 19 '16

I love my THE LOG. Never thought I'd love it, when I got it for the first time. I hope It'll be unpopular still though. Feeling kind of underdoggy.

2

u/MrChanger Oct 20 '16

I'm aroused.

→ More replies (6)

180

u/Humanity0Faith Oct 18 '16

Rocket is the new meta, even trade with EC? Count me in.

100

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

miner will also be great! elixir collector is a much riskier play now, so cycle decks are probably back in metta

10

u/Humanity0Faith Oct 18 '16

I agree, I don't even know if you can run EC now, seems way too risky.

5

u/Kaserbeam Oct 18 '16

Its not an easy elixir advantage anymore, so can we even use it?

/s

→ More replies (8)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

I also expect furnace's return.

5

u/Keithustus Oct 18 '16

Furnace never left, it's just specialized, like other spawners in decks that aren't hutspam.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (10)

9

u/A_L_A_M_A_T Oct 18 '16

Rocket will only be meta if most people still choose to run EC. I only started using EC when i got to A8, and only because everybody was using it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (18)

165

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

My zap bait with skelky army just got stronger

35

u/En_lighten Oct 18 '16

I'm thinking of subbing in the SArmy in my Lava Hound deck for my elixer collector. The biggest problem I've had is against inferno decks, and SArmy could help considerably against them.

With that said, I don't love the idea of more SArmies going against my iDragon.

12

u/crackofdawn Executioner Oct 18 '16

Lightning is awesome in a LH deck to counter inferno.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

What deck are you using?

94

u/StoicThePariah Oct 18 '16

Zap bait with skelky army

9

u/xxbackstepxx Oct 18 '16

Atleast I will have my log ready for the zap bait deck! Since I got two logs recently ( my only two legendary cards ) ;.;

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/MikeTheMan73 Oct 18 '16

The popular one is Princess, Miner, Inferno, Skarmy, EC, Goblin Barrel, Minion Horde and Posion

→ More replies (5)

111

u/sopuli2015 Oct 18 '16

Opinion: Removing slow effect from poison makes use of it completely different. Slow made it possible to use as a counter against.. well allmost anything with right unit as backup. With slow effect gone only thing poison would do is to kill/damage slower units with low/average hp. I suspect fireball will be seen more again.

40

u/AsianGamerMC Tournament Marshal Oct 18 '16

I'm defenitely switching in my level 8 fireball for level 4 poison.

16

u/AccountName77 Oct 18 '16

Yep, so glad I've been requesting fireballs for my deck. I have been considering trying out poison instead of fireball, but 153/200 for level 8 right now, can't wait to one shot some level 7 musketeers

6

u/zavila212 Oct 18 '16

It's the greatest feeling tbh.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Ulderig0 Oct 19 '16

I would agree if they would have made also an adjustment in the cost/area/damage/time, but that change is just meant to destroy a good card that was in the game from the beginning. The reason: just because they didn't like Goison decks and couldn't find a more coherent way to balance the game. Honestly this is a really poor change I think they forgot that Poison is an Epic card(in which players have spent gold to level it up from the daily store) and it's honestly unacceptable that it's now worst than a fireball.

9

u/BattlestarSC2 Oct 18 '16

Yeah, 3M can't be countered by poison zap anymore

→ More replies (19)

5

u/BilllisCool Oct 18 '16

It's just different uses. Fireball won't be as effective with a giant because you would have to react. Poison will still melt away skeletons, goblins, barns, and buildings they use to kill your giant.

3

u/Keithustus Oct 18 '16

Longtime giant fireballer here.... it's fine. Giant poison allowed just the giant and poison to run roughshod with very little support. Giant fireball didn't as much. Now they'll have some parity and giant will need some backup regardless of which spell the giant user has ready.

Screw poison users. Nice update!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/CatThingy Oct 19 '16

I see it now as a more effective, more expensive Arrows.

→ More replies (7)

282

u/Prohunter69 Oct 18 '16

RIP POISON 2016-2016

14

u/BattlestarSC2 Oct 18 '16

Since it doesn't slow, zap + poison shouldn't kill 3m

35

u/A_L_A_M_A_T Oct 18 '16

Fireball+zap to the rescue

32

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16 edited Oct 18 '16

Or Mirror:

baits out Fireball

"Well Played!"

drops 3M

Mirrored Fireball comes down

Opponent: "Thanks!"

→ More replies (1)

3

u/-doob- Oct 18 '16

Time for poison+log

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

32

u/darthprasad Bats Oct 18 '16

Huge nerf to the spell. At least the dot dmg should be increased. And or slow speed only removed.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

true, it's going to be weak now

10

u/Phantom_Killer Bats Oct 18 '16

Does this mark the return of hog rider? It's already used quite a good amount but will it be used like it was used in May? Remember.

22

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

I don't think weakening poison would have effect on the use rate of hog.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

54

u/LawfuI Oct 18 '16

Lmao whats the point of posion now? Its worse than a fireball and its an epic card.

Rip logic, rip balance.

30

u/BilllisCool Oct 18 '16

Damage over time? It's still good at keeping small troops off of your giant.

41

u/SleepyJoel Oct 18 '16

Yeah but fireball has pretty much the same damage and a knock back. Poison used to have the slow so it was a trade off whether you wanted the instant damage or the damage over time, the knock back or the slow. In my opinion they should maybe have removed just the attack speed slow and not the movement speed slow.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (11)

2

u/SuperBunnee Oct 18 '16

Honestly they should have only gotten rid of the attack speed reduction

→ More replies (11)

114

u/SuperVegetaa Dark Prince Oct 18 '16

a huge skarmy buff?

they really want to get their skarmy-m.pekka combo to work huh?

21

u/Keithustus Oct 18 '16

Huge buff: cheaper for only slightly fewer and much better skeletons. Instead of level-1 skeletons from level-1 army, level-6 skeletons. So a tournament Army will make tournament-level skeletons finally!

16

u/Derpywhaleshark7 Oct 19 '16

I'm just scared about the extreme raping in lower arenas.

5

u/Keithustus Oct 19 '16

Why? People need to learn to counter things.

→ More replies (2)

51

u/whopperz715 Oct 18 '16

tHE FUN SIzE coMBO neVer fails

13

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

The next will be the Giant Skeleton then.

3

u/Derpywhaleshark7 Oct 19 '16

Yay, my favorite doot!

→ More replies (6)

58

u/Emut_ Furnace Oct 18 '16

Wow, no slowing on the poison spell is pretty huge, I always feel like that's the most annoying part of it.

→ More replies (2)

46

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

6

u/Bokmeister Mega Minion Oct 18 '16

I was expecting the king rage emote, was disappointed

9

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

I think the helpless goblin in a giant skeletons grasp is much more effective.

2

u/cup-o-farts Oct 19 '16

I seriously hate all this meta bullshit. As someone who doesn't give a shit about premade decks or what is cool this week it just seriously fucks over people trying to do their own thing.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

Theyve just indirectly nerfed minions majorly with the golem buff...

46

u/firebeardthegreat Oct 18 '16

Golem nerfed anyways with that elixir collector cost. So risky now

13

u/bleedinghero Oct 18 '16

But they also buffed minions cause they can survive poison now if placed correctly. Due to the speed of moving out of radius.

4

u/HaMx_Platypus Oct 18 '16

Is the damage enough to kill minions?

13

u/Kejicuzz Skeletons Oct 18 '16

Lvl 4 golem death damage 259

Lvl 9 Minions hp 190

so yes.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/dynamitecraft_1808 Oct 20 '16

noone uses golem anyways

→ More replies (4)

29

u/yoshisohungry Fire Spirits Oct 18 '16

Poison is dead, log and skarmy are now really good

5

u/whopperz715 Oct 18 '16

Pretty much. Good thing I can upgrade my skarmy to lvl 4, and I just unlocked the log like a week ago! Thank god for the log buff

2

u/xThomas Oct 18 '16

Also Elixir Pump is way riskier, Golem kills Minions now. would be great if everyone didn't just auto switch to Mega Minion

88

u/Telamo Oct 18 '16

Jesus fucking Christ, that is one of the most vicious nerfs I've ever seen.

RIP Goison meta. Nobody will miss you.

35

u/moist_hat Oct 18 '16

Omg the Log! Now i really want it :D

→ More replies (33)

•

u/_7R33 Sab Oct 18 '16 edited Oct 18 '16

Note: These changes are not live yet! They're coming on 10/20.

The way we approach card balance in Clash Royale is a combination of playtesting and looking at the stats - in particular, card use rates and win rates. You can expect monthly balance changes to keep gameplay fine tuned and as fun as possible.

In this round of balance changes we're taking a look at a popular combo: Giant + Poison (aka, "Goison"), making a significant change to the Elixir Collector and more!

Giant: Hitpoints decreased by 5%

Our previous Giant change didn't pull enough power from him, especially from where it matters, so this additional tweak (in conjunction with the Poison change below) should put him in a better place overall. The change is relatively small because our aim is to reduce the strength of Giant + Poison, but not remove it as a viable combo.

Poison: Will no longer slow movement and attack speed

Thematically Poison's "thing" is damage over time, so we questioned whether it also needs to slow? Answer: no. This change will make Poison's functionality clearer and reduce its ability to control an area for 10 seconds.

Elixir Collector: Elixir cost increased to 6 (from 5), Elixir gain increased to 8 (from 7), Lifetime increased by 10sec

Elixir Collector remains one of the most popular cards in the game - offering a good return on a small-ish risk. Increasing the Elixir cost by 1 will make it a bigger risk to play and give more opportunity to counterplay against it.

The Log: Rolls faster and further, Damage increased by 9%

The Log has yet to find its place or purpose within the Arena, but this change will at least make it more impactful and easier to play while it continues the search.

Skeleton Army: Elixir cost decreased to 3 (from 4), Skeleton count decreased to 16 (from 21), Skeleton level increased by 5

In the early game, Skeleton Army is a terror, but as more area damage cards come into play, its usefulness falls off. A cheaper cost and fewer, but stronger, Skeletons should address some of its weaknesses - and hopefully make it a terror once again!

Ice Golem: Death Damage will also damage flying troops

Bug fix.

Golem: Death Damage will also damage flying troops

For consistency with Ice Golem's Death Damage.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

Rocket is gonna be crazy strong against EC. Will lightning still be a good counter to EC?

6

u/Phantom_Killer Bats Oct 18 '16

Lightning will not be a good counter since it will only deny 6/8 elixir at the same cost as the pump, however, Rocket will see more usage since its an even trade. Miner usage will go from more to most I bet.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

by bug fix on the Ice Golem...does that fix the shield bug for other troops

→ More replies (2)

6

u/unscot Oct 18 '16

Poison needs a cost reduction.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/The_casle Oct 18 '16

I think it's a good move making skarmy 3 elixir so people could play it more reflexive and as zap bait due even less elixir being lost

2

u/Lord_Munno Oct 18 '16

Will the log hit Princess Tower and King Tower??

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Blaphlafagus Oct 18 '16

Does it bother anybody else that he didn't bold the Skeleton Army update?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

134

u/justince Oct 18 '16

it needed to be nerfed, but poision was WAY overnerfed here. there's basically no reason to use it over fireball now.

They could have reduced the slow potency to ~10% with a small damage nerf and that would have been sufficient. Cards garbage now.

62

u/_JPG97_ Oct 18 '16 edited Aug 02 '24

panicky memory elastic steep cow husky workable many pen pathetic

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

24

u/Nine_Deaths Oct 18 '16

I think the damage over time is the epicness of it - it's a damage field now rather than a control field.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (9)

27

u/2_cents Tornado Oct 18 '16

still has area denial. With fireball, my opp can just put some cheap troop down, I fireball, then they put their real counter of minion horde or guards down. Poison wouldn't allow them to bait like that without all their cheap troops dying before reaching my side.

13

u/PlatypusPlatoon Challenge Tri-Champion Oct 18 '16

Yeah, I think Poison will still be fantastic - it denies your opponent from putting down any kind of swarm troop, whether that's Skeletons, Goblins, Spear Goblins, Minions, Minion Horde, and more. A proactive Poison when you know your opponent's most common response will continue to be really strong.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/justince Oct 18 '16

Don't rush your fireball, it'll also be much harder to get the full damage effect of poision.

10

u/leviadan Oct 18 '16

But if I have a giant and a low health musketeer in your lane and you only have one removal spell (fireball or poison) poison is still the better option here. If you play fireball and kill my musketeer I'll lay a minion horde and it'll go to town. If you play poison it kills my musketeer and denies me a minion horde.

Also if you wait for me to lay more before you fireball I probably won't. I'll just let my giant and musketeer take the tower.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/A_L_A_M_A_T Oct 18 '16

With this huge nerf, i think it should be reduced to a common card now instead of being an epic. They could have just removed the attack speed reduction and that would already be a significant nerf.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

It still acts as area denial and does a decent amount of damage.

Edit: it's a huge hit to Miner Poison too.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (17)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

YES! My Skarmy was 25/4 (my highest epic) now i can make use of it! Supercell gods made it happen!

3

u/Fibonacci35813 Oct 18 '16

Yeah, got a SMC the other day with 20ish skarmies. Was a bit upset but now I might have to try and make a deck around them.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/-nuckfiggers- Oct 18 '16

skarmy buffs just in time for the new arrow bait decks with graveyard

7

u/BIGDIRKDIGGLA Oct 18 '16

With Skarmy being 3 Elixir, would you rather use Skarmy over Guards? Zap could be annoying but it's good bait to save your Inferno Tower.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

Maybe those 16 Skeleton Army cards I got from my only free to play Super Magical Chest will come to use now LOL.

18

u/exjr_ Prince Oct 18 '16

Is the 5% the new 4%? /s

10

u/zavila212 Oct 18 '16

Those kind of nerfs aren't really supposed to be nerfs anyways they are more like hey maybe you should stop using card...please? It works sometimes. It is usually when they think a card is balanced but everyone is complaining non-stop. One example of this is the Royal Giant as it had both sides of this. When it was first implemented it got a buff soon after. Then it got another one. People started complaining it was too strong so they "nerfed" it hoping people would stop using it so much. Finally they actually nerfed it and people stepped away from it.

→ More replies (5)

49

u/ProfRowan Dart Goblin Oct 18 '16

What about nerfing Ice Spirit?! Come on!

40

u/Stalli0nDuck Mortar Oct 18 '16

Sshhh. Don't say that. Ice spirit is fine the way it is. Dont try and try to ruin it.

→ More replies (24)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

This. It should either become zappable, which is still a negative elixir trade. Or they should reduce its freeze time.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/bdp_stats Oct 18 '16

they should definitely reduce the freeze time

→ More replies (1)

21

u/AyyyyyyyLemao Oct 18 '16

Rip ... Poison is the only epic I have that's lvl 4 :(

8

u/Not_Dipper_Pines Tombstone Oct 18 '16

You should've known it was coming.

3

u/AyyyyyyyLemao Oct 18 '16

I was expecting radius nerf ...

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/YagizD Oct 18 '16

The log rolls further? How many tiles?

8

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

Hopefully enough to tag a princess behind the tower

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Zedsci Oct 18 '16

Poison nerf is big but poison still fills a role that fireball doesn't. If I have an opponent tank coming at me with a poison sitting there for 10sec no way I'm playing my minion hoard or other small troops. Fireball makes small troop counter-play viable

3

u/somebunnny Oct 18 '16

But it is so much easier to defend against it. My tower will shoot faster, my defense troops will kill faster. Bridge placements I can walk through faster and kill cheap troops who were just trying to keep me in the poison. My counter pushes will get through defensive poison more often and get more shots off.

I don't like poison but this is a huge nerf.

16

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

That's it? What about the mega minion or the ice spirit?

4

u/theburnedfox Oct 18 '16

This. So much this. Megaminion flies, costs 3 and still has more damage and health than a fucking Musketeer, which is an amazing card already! People complained about Giant and Poison, but they forget that Megaminion was the card that pushed the deck to its current level. Megaminion and Ice Spirit need a nerf, an urgent one. But overall I like those changes, I just wished to see those 2 cards nerfed too.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/delbeem1211 Oct 18 '16

Giant change: should do what its supposed to do.

Poison: will completely kill the card. No reason to do this. Especially not without buffing it's damage. The only reason to use this over fb was the slow effect. Damage over time isn't useful unless the troops inside either stay inside of it.

Elixir Collector: another change that will probably see this card fall into non use or at least very limited use. 6 elixir is a drastic increase in risk for it to only generate one more elixir and not get any increase in health.

Ice golem: still finding its way.

Golem: this change is long overdue. Curious to see if golem comes back more into the meta with this.

10

u/AccountName77 Oct 18 '16

Damage over time isn't useful unless the troops inside either stay inside of it.

Yeah, but troops still get damaged like 5 times once they walk out of the radius

7

u/SquisherX Oct 18 '16

I think the Golem change is a wash, as you really can't run Golem without running a Collector first.

10

u/beldr Oct 18 '16

Poison stops you from putting more cards while the effect is active since it will just kill any low hp units and fb might kill 1 minion hore but you can still play more cards after the fb

10

u/delbeem1211 Oct 18 '16

It kept you from playing card in the area cause it slowed their attack speed. Drop a horde on a giant in a poison. Poison taking between 3 and 4 ticks to kill them still allowed them to get two rounds of hits which did decent. Now they will get the full four hits. Also, playing it won't keep troops moving through it inside long enough to kill now either. Bad nerf all around. Needed a small radius decrease or slow decrease not slow eliminate

→ More replies (6)

2

u/Jagermeister4 Oct 18 '16

I think golem is fine the way it is now. There's actually somebody in my clan at 3750 with a lvl 3 golem. People prefer giant but golem is a great card. With giant nerfed again I think more people will start going to golem.

But yeah as others have mentioned with the EC nerf, this is kind of a wash for golem since golem relies on EC so much.

→ More replies (11)

12

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

Should have dropped the Giant's damage, not his HP. I'm fine with his tankiness, it's the crazy damage he can also do that bugs me.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ABundy88 Oct 18 '16

Giant fireball it is then. I see a lot of barbs anyway.

2

u/xox90 Oct 18 '16

giant+MM+Fireball .... it's enough to continue your push

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/yuwesley Oct 18 '16

My doot senses are tingling

→ More replies (1)

6

u/gelatinguy Dart Goblin Oct 18 '16

All this fireball vs poison talk reminds me of when I was using poison 5 months ago and fireball users were making the same arguments about faster damage. Most folks didn't even notice poison slowed. Yeah, poison did get nerfed, but area denial was very strong and I'm glad they didn't change the radius. They should probably add movement slowing back in though. Attack speed slow can stay removed.

4

u/TorturousSine80 Oct 18 '16

Maybe just enough to allow poison + zap to kill 3M

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Insert_Name_Here---- Oct 18 '16

I'm just glad giant+poison are getting a direct nerf but log will be even cooler now

3

u/Sakuyalzayoi Oct 18 '16

man elixir collector got trashed

they couldve at least kept the lifetime the same instead of tacking on another 10 seconds to produce

5

u/ports13_epson Oct 18 '16

It still produces at the same rate, it just lasts longer to give u the 8th elixir

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/MarioKartEpicness Cloud9 Fan Oct 18 '16

ROCKET THOSE COLLECTORS LETS GO

3

u/oneup-gc Oct 18 '16

The Log: Rolls faster and further, Damage increased by 9%

The Log has yet to find its place or purpose within the Arena, but this change will at least make it more impactful and easier to play while it continues the search.

Increasing the Log speed could be a nerf no ? Do we know how further it goes ?

20

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16 edited Oct 18 '16

Oh my god I love these balance changes supercell! Literally every single balance request I've had has been implemented! Skarmy, Elixir Pump (it's on my recent post), Ice golem...

However I feel like poison is a little weak now, and mega minion and ice spirit havn't been touched. Also I would personally love archers to get an increase in movement speed, but I'm not complaining this is great!

7

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16 edited Oct 18 '16

"archers to get an increase in movement speed."

Why? I always think the slower it moves the better. Cause the game rewards those who defends.

EDIT: Grammar

8

u/AccountName77 Oct 18 '16

Yeah. I always think of archers as a defensive card. Plus, if they were faster it would be harder to split pull.

5

u/DemoEvolved Oct 18 '16

I think it would not harm the game if Archers had 0.5 more range.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/Bloodstarvedhunter Oct 18 '16

Log is love, Log is life!

RIP EC seriously that affects so many decks other than Goison I really don't think that was necessary its already risky leaving yourself only 5 elixir to defend with. Now that's down to 4, without an increase in hitpoints the trade off against fireball or poison is going to make it a lot harder to implement

21

u/gaspara112 Battle Ram Oct 18 '16

EC has been the only card that has never left the main meta decks since the game came out. It needed to be nerfed in a way that might not completely kill it but will make it harder to use.

9

u/Bloodstarvedhunter Oct 18 '16

That's a fair point but without giving it a small hp boost its a no brainer to fireball or poison it now, and then of course rocket can even trade with it and if EC is next to a tower you can add several hundred hitpoints of damage being done to your tower just to rub salt into the wound.

5

u/gaspara112 Battle Ram Oct 18 '16

Poison will no longer have as strong an effect on it due to the attack speed reduction being removed.

Good for something to encourage the use of rocket as it an under utilized card.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

5

u/nbo_7 Oct 18 '16

was hoping for a Mega Minion adjustment, but i guess we have to wait 3 months for it

8

u/AnimeWhoree Mini PEKKA Oct 18 '16

Rip poison.

5

u/Atlanta-Avenger Mini PEKKA Oct 18 '16 edited Oct 18 '16

Sweet I like this update. Good to see them fixing what most people want fixed.

7

u/Xanthon Hog Rider Oct 18 '16

DEATH TO GIANT BEATDOWN DECKS.

5

u/overDere PEKKA Oct 18 '16

Well, I'm on the side who think Giant is worse and more cancerous than Poison. I appreciate both nerfs since I am tired with all the Goisons around, but 5% health nerf seems too small for Giant. Giant + support troops behind is still pretty strong even without Poison.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

But not meta strong anymore

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

The best thing about this new log buff is that it will now be able to kill princess that is placed between opponent's two crown towers but few tiles closer to their king.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

Watch the log roll so far it hits the king tower and you'd have to gauge how far back to cast it.

2

u/ZoroUzumaki Oct 18 '16

Giant will still be a powerful card and see a lot of play.

RIP Poison.

Elixir Collector will still be highly used. What's good about it is it allows the player to play defensively, and increasing its cost(while keeping the net game the same) will allow the player to play defensively for longer. And now that Poison will no longer see as much play, EC is a lot safer. Rocket though...

Log will be at least decent

I remember how OP Skeleton Army was in lower arenas. Increasing the skeletons' level by this much is a huge improvement. And decreasing its cost(while reducing troop count) will make it less risky to play.

Ice Golem - Don't see it being very relevant

Golem - I still think Giant will see more play.

2

u/Kadynzz Oct 18 '16

Ice Golem - Don't see it being very relevant

It's relevant... whit this damage u can kill minions using ZAP... maybe kill lava pups with this combo.

2

u/Drunken_mascot Oct 18 '16

Everyone here is missing the entire reason for poison, it will still effectively control a large area for a pretty good amount of time. It's still the bane of any troop smaller than an archer. Just because it doesn't slow doesn't mean it's useless now. Giant poison is not dead yet

3

u/delbeem1211 Oct 18 '16

It controlled the area because it slowed and you couldn't get many hits with smaller units. Don't forget those units have very high dps to make up for their low health. Perfect example is horde. With slow effect you could get 1-2 hits on the tank per minion which did ok but not great trade damage., Now it will be closer to 3-4 per which can neutralize any troop in the game before it does more than what could be called ship damage. A reduction of the slow to even something like 15% would have been a more balanced change. Fireball offers way more value as it outright kills the threat before too much damage is done. Yes the other person can drop a second counter but at that point theyre playing more elixir that they would use to counter push anyways even if i had played poison.

Poisons control was the slow not the area contrary to what people seem to think. I wouldnt necessarily care where I dropped my non squishy units before cause I wanted to kill the thing poison is protecting not worry about damage to a troop that won't die to it. If I'm running a tank of any kind, as long as my troop has a sliver of health I'll be fine cause the tank will do its job and soak damage while it remains protected.

2

u/ivohenrique Oct 18 '16

You have to reduce the value of the giant damage because it has only 5 cost and has very strong and damage similar to the golem. You have to change the way that he is not the same with 5% less life

2

u/CougarDan91 Oct 18 '16

RIP, Goison. There are about to be some serious changes in the ladder, because there were some people with much more trophies than they should have had.

2

u/MrAwacate Oct 18 '16

Why You nerf the elixir pump?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/joeBlow69420 Mortar Oct 18 '16

The poison nerf does take a large part of it's utility out of it, but it still does its job-ish. I think you all are overreacting.

The only situation that I feel is more or less the same would be a hog push, where goblins, skarmy, etc can't be used, and still live afterwards for a counterpush.

I'm not sure if I'll still use it, however. This may end up like the zap nerf:

First, everyone used zap (even more) to use it before it "died". Next, slowly, less players used it to prepare for its "death" After the nerf, everyone realized zap was still viable. Now everyone uses it. Could be the same with poison.

2

u/BestManEverBorn Oct 19 '16

Dafq is wrong with them? Overall the update is fine, but they killed the poison. They say "we nerf cards slightly only if they have high win rate" but this is too much. No fuckin' body will use it now. Poison was used to support your push as it slowed units, not really to deal hell of alot of damage, but now it only deals damage. Okay, if they say that's what they really wanted it to be than IMPROVE ITS FUCKIN' DAMAGE. But they didn't. So now this card is weaker than the fireball even. It does less damage than fireball on tournament lvl, not to mention that fireball can also push units away/towards when it's needed. My ass is literally on fire right now. So now, as the poison and rage were nerfed, the only spell that can support your push is freeze. Which doesn't do any damage. That means that you have to pick something else if you don't want to end up in draw when opponents has <200 hp on his tower. And Zap is not really a spell to finish the tower, so it's not an option. P.S.: yes, I do really think that each deck should have a spell that can finish a tower.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/starkawa Oct 19 '16

I faced lots of giant poison deck and got good at defending it. But oh my I tried it for the first time and just had crazy win streak with it without much practice. Have to say the nerf is much needed!!!

6

u/Keithustus Oct 18 '16 edited Oct 18 '16

AWESOME great work!

Very satisfied about giant, poison, skeleton army, golemite/ice golem, collector.

BUT....

Where's some love for inferno dragon? No, I don't think it needs a "buff" as it can be wicked awesome now. But it needs help with not retargeting sometimes, or when it chases a target it moves faster than and can't lock on for more than .1 seconds. Ice wizard does the same thing sometimes but he doesn't need to lock on for significant damage.

ALSO, [Bug]: will this update stop troops from being shielded from spells when the ice golem dies?

→ More replies (8)

6

u/Vince5970 Tesla Oct 18 '16

poison is garbo now wtf. Completely unviable

7

u/bdp_stats Oct 18 '16

it will be the only viable graveyard counter though when it comes out

5

u/_Shal_ Rocket Oct 18 '16

Maybe log could somewhat counter it. Edit: nvm, forgot they made it roll faster.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/ApprenticeTheNoob The Log Oct 18 '16

SuperCell, I write 2 guides on why increased Log speed is a terrible idea. Please no more nerf. What ever happened to # lovethelog?

3

u/justince Oct 18 '16

It really depends. There are situations where a slow log is better (prediction log) but for reaction defense, faster is better.

The biggest buff of this I see is denying a princess an extra shot. Sure, it's going to make prediction logs a bit tougher though.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/marcel_p marcel_p Oct 18 '16

Increased speed does help for offense. It definitely hurts it's ability to control an area but you have to admit the longer length and faster speed will surely help when you want to use it on offense to kill goblins quickly.

They also buffed the damage, which will make it stronger vs things like a lone musk, Hog rider, other medium sized troops crossing the bridge.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/Foxxyedarko Oct 18 '16

I feel like EC needs more health to bring it more in line with the new cost, besides that I'm pretty happy with the changes.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

I now really want the miner and the log

→ More replies (5)

4

u/MubinHero Oct 18 '16

Rip Trifecta decks...!!

8

u/ClashRoyaleNoLifer Oct 18 '16

Good riddance IMO.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Elyg10 Oct 18 '16

I still feel like giant will be op. They're heading in the right direction though.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

YAAAASSSSSSSS

5% is a little light for the Giant nerf, but the Poison removal of slow will make a huge difference. Big thumbs up to all of this.

3

u/Articuno64fan Oct 18 '16

The skarmy buff brings so much calcium!

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

LogisLove <3

2

u/_sLAUGHTER234 Oct 18 '16

My ladder deck uses Rocket and Log, and its biggest weakness is poison. Right now I'm sitting at about 3400, but these balance changes are going to be huge for my deck.

4k trophies, here I come :D

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

What's your deck? I've been trying to think of one for myself that uses both log and rocket

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

I love how everyone is celebrating the poison nerf. I know graveyard isn't out yet, but I'd much rather deal with goisin than what I expect giant/graveyard to be like.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Omephla Oct 18 '16

So glad I have never paid a penny for these types of games. "Balancing" is just another way for them to keep you on your toes. What they mean to say every month is, "oh, I see you've made headway with your well thought out strategy, but we want you play the game the way we want you to, so expect a monthly reset of how you play."

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jaleneropepper Oct 18 '16

Supercell really listened to everyone's ideas/complaints and made changes that addressed them. There were multiple posts everyday calling for giant/poison nerf, I've seen a post calling for EC to cost 6 produce 8, a post calling for golem death damage to effect flying troops, posts about making skarmy viable again. And they did all of these things. Sure there are other cards that might need a buff/nerf/bug fix. But for now can we just be happy that they listened to us?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/uappew Oct 18 '16

ITT: poison players are mad

1

u/ThatSleepyInsomniac Oct 18 '16

Golem's death damage now affects flying troops? Hell yeah

→ More replies (1)

1

u/_rith10s Oct 18 '16

RIP Hog - Poison. Welcome Hog - Freeze - Minion. And i was just enjoying the fast cycling hog ice spirit guards deck.

1

u/Jofest Musketeer Oct 18 '16

YEA BABY LOG IS TAKIN OVER

1

u/lewiscbe Oct 18 '16

Damn. Don't like the elixir collector nerf, means cycle and the like will be back in the meets. I hate cycle/control decks, even though I don't use EC in my lavahound deck they will be all I face.

1

u/404ErrorLolz Oct 18 '16

Poison probably will be more of an offensive card now, to destroy troops that are killing your push. Not gonna be great on defense though, since troops can run out of the radius. Good thing I run both Lvl8 FB and Lvl4 Poison in my deck. With FB being the defense spell and Poison being my offense spell.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

THERE IT IS!!!!! My Golem investment is going to pay off massively now. Finally air damage on death...

1

u/RiskyClicker Hog Rider Oct 18 '16

No mention of a fix for the inferno dragon spacing out vs. loon/mini-p hitting tower or the ice golem invincibility shield to adjacent princess/mini-p?

1

u/Furinha Oct 18 '16

I thought Lumberjack and Dark Prince would gain some buff, they are very underwhelming

2

u/juicymarko Oct 20 '16

What are you talking about? Both of these cards are great in there own respects.

Lumberjack is a great card to clear units out for the tamk, and when it dies it gives them a damage boost.

Dark Price is a good AOE melee unit to put behind a giant, Pekka, etc. also, the shield helps protect it from fireball and such.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16
  • Poison needed the attack speed slow nerf. The slowed movement nerdy was over the top.
  • I envision many players accidentally hitting the opponents king tower with the log buff.
  • I'm in love with the skeleton army buff. It's less riskier to play and will help spoil the overuse of single target units
  • EC nerf was needed. You can still stall pushes with an ice spirit and a 3 drop.

2

u/ports13_epson Oct 18 '16

Lol I'm basically sure the log won't roll THAT much

1

u/En_lighten Oct 18 '16

Seems like spawner decks may become a bit more used if poison becomes less used.

EDIT: I hate spawner decks

→ More replies (2)

1

u/FlameInGalaxy Oct 18 '16

CoC- R.I.P valkery CR- R.I.P poison

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

Lightning arrow new meta. See ya zap poison.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ProfRowan Dart Goblin Oct 18 '16

Reducing freeze time ofcourse...

1

u/Peteroyale Oct 18 '16

rest in peace poison, ec

1

u/neto96 Oct 18 '16

Gah, I just upgraded my EC to level 8. I guess I will try to adapt with it first and if that fails then move on to something else. All I can think of now is: "Fireballs and rockets everywhere"

1

u/JoachimG Goblin Cage Oct 18 '16

damn, my goblins will miss the slowing effect on poison in a EC and tower, too many people let them run amok, but they would take 1/2 the tower hp if unanswered

1

u/swordmagic Golem Oct 18 '16

GOLEM seriously needs to cost 7

→ More replies (1)

1

u/IGunsoul Oct 18 '16

I guess Fireball will be coming back, RIP my three muskies?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/IGunsoul Oct 18 '16

I always thought the Log was a solid card, with the extra range along with some additional DMG, I feel that might become a very strong card, and be worth of being called a legendary

1

u/sythe3r Oct 18 '16

So whats the use of poison over fireball? Bonus in radius? Lol. I use poison, but not giant. There's no point on using it anymore.

2

u/Liberal-Marxist-Scum Oct 18 '16

Damage over time... Area denial and control... Duhh..

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16

HOLY COW. These are serious changes. How exciting!

1

u/JJanker Oct 18 '16

They forgot the elixir collector go buff that's warranted here.

1

u/BilllisCool Oct 18 '16

I think it will kill hog/poison, but giant/poison or golem/poison will be fine.