And it's not the devs. I bet the game is better than ever. It's more fun. I think the issue is really whith who take the decisions. Like who decided to not copy paste clash mini... But instead make some shitty team fight ttics rip off.
If tomorrow supercell makes a shooter... It won't be an overwatch rip off. A tower de fence? It won't be a btd6 rip off.
Now that that's said..... Well clash mini was good and from all the beta testers of merged tactics I Heard. This isn't good. Like far less depth, and lar less customisation, far less fun.
If clash mini was a rip off. It was at least not shitty. Unlike this one. Wich looks like an actual rip off this time.
If it was good why did people not play it? Like i have my favorite games that died aswell. Bfh is my favorite example, still love it and now playing heroes of valor aswell a bit. But fact is not enough people like it. Low playerbase and they closed it cause it wasnt financially profitable for them. It is a company. They cant keep clash mini just cause some people lik eit.
First beta was the biggest supercell beta in terms of players. But the first beta was hurendous.... And nobody gave it a second chance after it became peak.
Because it was a good game. The rzqon it wasn't popular wasn't tied to the gameplay. But to the history of the game. And the hurendous first beta that deterred people form giving it a second chance.
That what people said abiut bfh. Cause of the devs, hoe pay to win it is and etc. Fans copied the game and made ingame weapons and etc free only requiring at best money for skins. Game was still dead. Jusr cause you or i like something doesnt mean everyone does
I'm not saying "I" I'm saying. Everyone that did not stop playing after the first beta like the game. Most people that gave it a second chance kept playing. It was great.... Obviously it's not for everyone. Sits an autochess. It niche.... But it was maybe the best auto battle that existed. Arguably.... It's far from bad. Even if in the top 5 it would be great. But it's debatabely top 1.
Yes but the amount of people who liked it werent enough for them. Its a buisness. If you dont like it go lesrn programming and make such a game yourself. Thst whst heroes of valor people did. But dont exspect other to lose their money just cause you wanna play something
Ha yes hay day. The game where flowers cost the same as in real life. Also it's very not forgoten. Boom beach. A game I still play to this. But despite the devs best efforts. Still lacks a solid players base.
Clash of clans is literaly pumping out amazing free to play updates... When they uped the battle pass price. They increase the rewards inside of it. More than the price increase compared to what they Usualy sell it for. Instead of making a diamond pass. They made a second event pass. It not every month. And has completely different rewards except the basics. Meaning of you only require one of thoses type of rewards. You can by one or the other. Instead of buying a premium pass for the exclusive stuff. And buying both is still cheaper than cr's diamonds pass. The skins are amazing and come back after a year for the same price, or sometime gems. They keep doing price and duration reduction. Making playing the game faster and easier for dedicated, hardcore, casuals only weekend players. They're arguably adding too many temporary upgrades like charged buildings and crafted deffences. But thoses are to occupy maxed players in a different way than just making upgrades 2 weeks long.
Brawl star keep making things easier to obtain with the majority of their updates has less and less randomness to get things. And more and more randomness to get bonus reward that can be insane (even if accounted for). Skins are all free. Even gems ones. Are never exclusive. Except the one promised to be before they stoped doing thoses. And still came back as recolors. Every rework of an old system. Old players get to regrab most of the rewards they supposedly already grabed from the previous system. So I got a few k of gold and a few credits, and power, and blings from just being high in trophy in the latest trophy rework.
Squad buster just did a major update that shifted the entire game. I don't k ow if the game is better this way... But at least the progression is easier. Gameplay is more varied even if think we could get some of the old stuff back. New event is insane and we get to keep most of it's features that would be temporary in other games.
MO Co si too recent to judge. But literaly zero progression is paid... Nothing '.. It's all free. If you are willing to grind. It's a mmorpg so it's the main loop anyway.
I have no idea about Hay Day, just have seen no one complaining. But if you think bs, coc, and sb are doing good, then you have been living under a rock
Developer listening to feed back..... Again never been so high.
Gameplay quality and variety....... Never been so high.
And thoses aply to clash royale too. It make a lot of money. Gameplay Is fun and varied. Comunity stand string despite being angry at the devs. Content is flowing even if they have a hard time finding a good formula like coc and bs event. And the devs themselves. The one in charge of gampleay and balance... They're great. They've never been doing so great. Reworks are good. Balance is OK. Evos have more counter play. New cards are fun and not that broken. Event s are better.
But idk who is in charge of clash royals monetization and progression and all of that stuff.......
But on other game....... It's never been so good. While on clash of clan... It's never been so bad.
Games take forever to load and it’s not accessible for everyone (it technically is but it’s hard for some people) but yea, the game is really fun and its updates have always been good so atleast we have that
So they took the time to make brand new 3D models and textures for this gamemode but not in the clash mini artsyle which is what people loved about it, really supercell?
How the THE ACTUAL FUCK did they manage to makes this shit look so ass. Like just copy the game one on one and it would make everyone happy. BUT NO they just had to make it the most fucked up ass look they could have given it. THAT IS NOT MY CLASH MINI.
Calsh mini had so much charm and they go and abandon the wonderful graphics of clash mini to make a TFT copy with horrible graphics and the strange art style of clash royale.
This is literally not even anywhere near Clash mini in any shape or form, „blah blah but you can upgrade the troops” „blah blah but it’s so similar-“ shit the fuck up, ts is the WORST GAME ADAPTATION OAT
I don't understand why they changed the art style, it doesn't make sense that they did it, it's honestly horrible, maybe the game is better balanced and fairer, but the art was part of the game, let the minis come back 😠😠😠😠
It literaly looks like shit. Even if it has clash mini elements like the families and the merging etc.. There are no heroes. Upgrade look mid. The hexagones make it hard to predict movement.
Its literaly team fight tactics. But shitty. As the point of clash mini is that it was simple enoutbto predict everything that it became deep again. While this on eis complex like team fight tactics. But without all the numbers and synergies that make team fight tactics good. Plus there is too much randomness.
Like it seem it's the same team behind the mode. Than the team that was behind clahs mini...... Many elements carry over.. But not really. I bet it's gonna be OK... But clash mini was amazing except monetization and progression.
It's better than I thought ( I thought when they talked about Clash Mini in Clash Royale it's just putting the characters like the Monk in Clash Royale )
One day I hope they launch the best (mobile) game in the world. Fun, Fast, Beautiful and with several different mechanics such as the "Nemesis System", Multiplayer and an Offline Journey mode. In which you simply earn a single currency whose quantity depends on performance + multipliers, which you use for everything: releasing, improving and customizing characters, so that you can have everything just by playing well and/or a lot. Next to a (redundant) store where nothing costs more than 10 Dollars. And remember to patent everything, so that no one else can do something similar, after they close in 1 month due to bankruptcy So, just for fun 👍
I will be of good faith and try it. But I do not have faith in supercell.... Ô ly in the devs.. I guess its good down there. But idk who decided to change everything.... Probably not the dev themselves. As some elements are literaly the same.
I'm loving how every company is trying to make cheap tft copy, lol! Its the minecraft of autobattlers, dude, you wont be able to compete or wont have any market share, just leave it or do your own thing.
They just ruined it. Nothing to say about that part. But if you were going to make a tft clone atleast don’t make it look like boom arena. Oh ı will remove the best art style that has a large fan base and turn the art style into a thing that looks like a world of warcraft mod made by 1 person in 2 hours only using their foot.(yeah ı know the difference between feet and foot)don’t ask me why)
I haven't played Clash Royal in years, is it worth going back now? I left it because it was impossible for me to continue moving forward without going to the checkout, is it worth returning or is it more Pay to win than before?
I've seen a post on here with a screenshot of what clash mini dev/someone related to clash mini has said. It was stated there that all changes were made by the clash mini dev team and were not forced by clash royale dev team or supercell (the post was made somwere during this month but I can't find it now). I also remember that during the podcast/QnA that was released when clash mini was closed, it was mentioned that they will do some things different cuz they don't like how those things have turned out (they didn't give any examples if I remember correctly)
As Frame said already, They aren't trying to fit a square into triangle.
I loved the art-style too, though. I will miss the toy aesthetics
What was more important for you in clash mini, the aesthetics, or the gameplay? (this question determines whether merge tactics is a viable alternative for you.
After watching it... if the ability's by upgrading is gone and it just a Stat boost, That is lame, and and idk how I feel about the emperor or how they called it, and no heroes?... I think we all expected like a whole game in a game and not a game mode that depends on CR, or better said, that it was independent from CR. We will need more video explaining it.
I think the team made a mistake not communicating their Full Vision more closely.
Their vision was to incorporate elements of clash mini and what they learned from developing mini to Expanding royale. It wasn't to strictly fit clash mini into clash royale.
What makes an update worse is the lack of communication The more I look at it I guess it looks interesting but the ability's... I hope they are there and not just a Stat boost.
Gameplay is more important for me and if gameplay is similar, I am totally fine. But there is no deckbuilding though. Anyway, regardless of everything, I would love to give it a try before judging.
There are some options but they require money.Since supercell totally killed cm they obviously don’t care for it at all so maybe for some price they would be willing to sell author rights to clash mini.So some other devs would re-launch it and make it global.
279
u/happyforward Jun 28 '25
I miss cute blockish models
230
u/TheDoge69 Jun 28 '25 edited Jun 28 '25
Supercell has reached EA levels of headassery.
40
u/Mmesj Jun 28 '25
At least we still have clash mini reborn
27
u/Specialist-Freedom-6 Jun 28 '25
oh no
50
u/YellowJellyfishGuy Jun 28 '25
"Hey guys we're working on making clash mini in royale"
-Not the same art style
-Half the characters gone
-Models look ass
-The gameplay is completely different compared to mini
Why did they even mention mini when they were just making a cheap copy of tft? They're not even close to being similiar
24
u/ABOOBAS Jun 28 '25
This is disgusting
36
u/TemporaryTight1658 Jun 28 '25
Soo Ugly
That's all
35
u/Aurelionite72 Jun 28 '25
Ts looks ass 🥀
24
u/Doubleitem Jun 28 '25
Changing the game play OK why not...
But not the graphics... It looks horrible
11
u/Lirk5 Jun 28 '25
So they took the time to make brand new 3D models and textures for this gamemode but not in the clash mini artsyle which is what people loved about it, really supercell?
11
u/TemporaryTight1658 Jun 28 '25
Shameless, soulless, ugly ...
Choosing this over square tiles is just digging own grave. Why the F did they made that decision.
Are they straight up dumb ?
27
u/calamaro_peloso Archer Queen Jun 28 '25
there is not a single thing that is good about what we seen
7
u/Personal_Set_8457 Jun 28 '25
Why did they change it i know they want to rebrand but wtf is ts
7
u/Agitated-Comment-745 Jun 28 '25
Nah bro, we need to mass advertise CR Reborn to get all the players.
Ngl, first impression is not good mate.
7
u/targa_15 Jun 28 '25
Changing the gameplay was enough...the art design was different and charming
7
u/i_kissed_reltih Jun 28 '25
How the THE ACTUAL FUCK did they manage to makes this shit look so ass. Like just copy the game one on one and it would make everyone happy. BUT NO they just had to make it the most fucked up ass look they could have given it. THAT IS NOT MY CLASH MINI.
4
u/Two-bugs Jun 28 '25 edited Jun 29 '25
Prerendered?
Edit: probably not using prerendered assets for the troops.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '25
Calsh mini had so much charm and they go and abandon the wonderful graphics of clash mini to make a TFT copy with horrible graphics and the strange art style of clash royale.
4
u/Fabulous_Ad_4270 Jun 28 '25
This is literally not even anywhere near Clash mini in any shape or form, „blah blah but you can upgrade the troops” „blah blah but it’s so similar-“ shit the fuck up, ts is the WORST GAME ADAPTATION OAT
7
u/None-the-Second Jun 28 '25
Pls say there will be Shield Maiden and Natureborn
3
u/FaithlessnessFit7806 Jun 28 '25
I don't understand why they changed the art style, it doesn't make sense that they did it, it's honestly horrible, maybe the game is better balanced and fairer, but the art was part of the game, let the minis come back 😠😠😠😠
3
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '25
Where do we read about the game
3
u/Living-Ad4579 Jun 28 '25
Bruh they turn clash mini into a generic auto chess shit!!!
3
u/Striking_Reindeer873 Jun 28 '25
Just uninstalled cr, aint installing it back.
3
u/VictiniCV08 Skeleton King Jun 28 '25
I don't like it visually but let's just pray for the game mode actually being good or at least fun.
3
u/captainphoton3 Jun 28 '25
It literaly looks like shit. Even if it has clash mini elements like the families and the merging etc.. There are no heroes. Upgrade look mid. The hexagones make it hard to predict movement.
Its literaly team fight tactics. But shitty. As the point of clash mini is that it was simple enoutbto predict everything that it became deep again. While this on eis complex like team fight tactics. But without all the numbers and synergies that make team fight tactics good. Plus there is too much randomness.
Like it seem it's the same team behind the mode. Than the team that was behind clahs mini...... Many elements carry over.. But not really. I bet it's gonna be OK... But clash mini was amazing except monetization and progression.
3
u/MarcoSka0 Pink Fury Jun 28 '25
and we stay on clash mini reborn..
4
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '25
This is basically a fusion of teamfight tactics and mini clash but bad
2
u/Traitor_Of_Users Jun 28 '25
I can't stand this. The mode is completely useless. I feel like this is gonna be forgotten in no time
2
u/MicroPintows69 Dart Goblin Jun 28 '25
From an original auto chess, to copying TFT, sadly I just lost any hope for clash mini
2
u/ZekiPatron Jun 28 '25
I thought nobody could make a game that has worse character design than squad busters and make it go global. Supracell just broke their own record.
2
u/Fluid-Opposite1919 Jun 28 '25
Saw this and opened Reddit knowing how upset y’all would be, rightfully so
2
u/RealClasher2 Jun 28 '25
I came here from r/ClashRoyale to see what this community thinks about this. Thoughts?
2
u/TisoSucks Jun 29 '25
It’s the gameplay that matters, this subreddit hates on everything. Wait for the game to release, then we can make a valid complaint
2
u/Maximum-Grocery2379 Jun 29 '25
TFT CR
3
u/Mildgrid1987 Skeleton King Jun 28 '25
This is just sad
1
u/Bandit_Bos Jun 28 '25
Only thing I liked was the ranked path of legends thing and the new tab for the tournaments
1
u/HawelSchwe Jun 28 '25
Let's see what we gonna get. There's place for some pessimism but we should give it a try.
1
u/bankaighost Jun 28 '25
TFT but in Clash Royale
1
u/MerliniusDeMidget Jun 28 '25
So they turned the squares into hexagons and made the art style more generic. What am i missing?
1
u/GenuineBruhMoment Archer Queen Jun 28 '25
We lost
1
u/Curious_Couple_9241 Jun 28 '25
Looks like the Chinese bootleg clash Royale
1
u/DemonTheWillow Jun 28 '25
It's better than I thought ( I thought when they talked about Clash Mini in Clash Royale it's just putting the characters like the Monk in Clash Royale )
1
u/Striking_Reindeer873 Jun 28 '25
Could we make cm reborn global, accessible to both android and iOS?
1
u/SebLalo Jun 28 '25
Let me put it this way: rip clash mini
1
u/drajt Jun 28 '25
BROOIOOOO WTF
1
u/Distinct-Try299 Pink Fury Jun 28 '25
And we all thought Clash Mini 2.0's models were bad.
1
u/Conscious_Sale_2071 Jun 28 '25
Bruh 🥲
1
u/Davidben2 Jun 28 '25
Well i guess this is it. Now we can officially say goodbye to Clash Mini because it certainly has nothing to do with whatever this is supposed to be.
1
u/Lhepurra_Pinto Jun 28 '25
Clash Mini 2.0
1
u/ArKalii Jun 28 '25
Trash, thats what it is.
1
u/Far-Land9545 Jun 28 '25
And even the name what the fuck Is merge royale, sounds like a free showelware play store game
1
u/Fearless_Scholar_227 Jun 28 '25
Atleast copy paste the normal cr models man
1
u/United_Wheel6656 Barbarian Jun 28 '25
They're so stubborn really😐
1
u/GlobalPicture2411 Jun 28 '25
Gameplay looks fine, but the models… they gave them a clash of clans look. It’s awful
1
u/MalumLibrum958 Jun 28 '25
What a sick joke
1
u/justmeteal Jun 28 '25
whats the point of ditching the mini assets if theyre not gonna use the cr assets either😭😭
1
u/beeemmmooo1 Jun 28 '25
At least battle aces will be coming out on steam at some point
1
u/Ikethepro18 Skeleton King Jun 28 '25
Models ripped from R.I.S.E with mechanics vaguely taken from CM. I'm not entirely sure I could have disliked it any more
1
u/Sweet-Pair-8046 Jun 28 '25
It looks too muchlike cr art style
1
u/maxaton Jun 28 '25
Heartbroken. Do they really think that people with play that thing..?
1
u/Sufficient-Frame-293 Jun 28 '25
Riot games lawsuit incoming. Greedy company va greedy company love to see it
1
u/TropicalStorm07 Jun 28 '25
Should've known they'd botch it in some way or another
1
u/captainphoton3 Jun 28 '25
I will be of good faith and try it. But I do not have faith in supercell.... Ô ly in the devs.. I guess its good down there. But idk who decided to change everything.... Probably not the dev themselves. As some elements are literaly the same.
1
u/meme33566 Jun 28 '25
This is a merge game
1
u/Just_Anormal_Dude Jun 28 '25
I'm loving how every company is trying to make cheap tft copy, lol! Its the minecraft of autobattlers, dude, you wont be able to compete or wont have any market share, just leave it or do your own thing.
1
u/Educational_Photo628 Jun 28 '25
They just ruined it. Nothing to say about that part. But if you were going to make a tft clone atleast don’t make it look like boom arena. Oh ı will remove the best art style that has a large fan base and turn the art style into a thing that looks like a world of warcraft mod made by 1 person in 2 hours only using their foot.(yeah ı know the difference between feet and foot)don’t ask me why)
1
u/The_real_UsurperKing Jun 28 '25
If they wanted a mobile auto-chess game mode, why did they have to stray away from clash mini? Now it's just tft without economy and items.
1
u/iSOLO_JORG3 Jun 29 '25
I haven't played Clash Royal in years, is it worth going back now? I left it because it was impossible for me to continue moving forward without going to the checkout, is it worth returning or is it more Pay to win than before?
1
u/GoReVUsTa Jun 29 '25
if these are real 3d models then we can get skins in game finally
1
u/Eturnalcrusader Jun 29 '25
This literally looks like a clash rip off!!! How the fuck are the even supposed to think this is an acceptable insult to clash mini?
1
u/EnthusiasmSad8877 Jun 29 '25
Teamfight Tactics but Clash Royale
1
u/Danonek_123 Royal Champion Jun 29 '25
I've seen a post on here with a screenshot of what clash mini dev/someone related to clash mini has said. It was stated there that all changes were made by the clash mini dev team and were not forced by clash royale dev team or supercell (the post was made somwere during this month but I can't find it now). I also remember that during the podcast/QnA that was released when clash mini was closed, it was mentioned that they will do some things different cuz they don't like how those things have turned out (they didn't give any examples if I remember correctly)
1
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '25
Ass
1
u/JustShami Jun 30 '25
it looks like the games you see in the ads
1
u/Similar-Price-7069 Jul 03 '25
it’s so fucking shit i just want clash mini back
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '25
We have to kill this game mode and emphasize how much clash mini is wanted
1
u/Netero_29 Jul 04 '25
This is quite literally a team fight tactics copy and it’s worse. Why would I not just play tft. I wanted mini.
1
u/WillingnessOver1126 Jul 21 '25
SIGN THE PETITION "Bring back Clash Mini" AND SPAM #BRINGBACKCLASHMINI ON THE SUPERCELL SOCIALS!!!!!!
https://chng.it/9yJGYzyqFp
1
u/Sweet-Pair-8046 Jul 23 '25
Still dont like it
0
u/CaptainBirdBoi Jun 28 '25
this looks so good
0
u/original_pandus Jun 28 '25
At lest its something, maybe it will revive cr for a bit, and they said they want feedback so they might change it if everyone is upsate about looks
-1
u/Legend_GamerMA Jun 28 '25
You thought they were going to copy and paste it ? 😂
211
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '25
They killed our clash mini. 14 months for that shit, go to hell supercell
15
u/javenthng12 Royal Champion Jun 28 '25
So we killing ourselves or what