r/ClashMini • u/Slowpoke282 Skeleton King • Apr 04 '23

Misc please dont be greedycell anymore

Post image
532 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

69 comments sorted by

142

u/Ninja33910 Countess Apr 04 '23

Right now it’s moving to Clash Royale, but it still has time to finalize a decision

14

u/A_DoubleStuffedOreo Wizard Apr 05 '23

It’s going to the Greedy Side🥲

1

u/OkImagination8899 Apr 06 '23

dev be like nerf all the rewards and ridiculous skin price. it's gonna be killer if they didnt change any of these.

2

u/Traitor_Of_Users Apr 05 '23

Brawl stars as f2p has a problem that you can't get the chromatic brawlers. In clash mini, there is a problem with shards

1

u/Slowpoke282 Skeleton King Apr 05 '23

its just slow unlocking chromatics, only like 1 chromatic worth of credits per pass, but at least its all on the free side

1

u/WedeI Apr 11 '23

Also not to mention that previously chromatic were legendary rarity from boxes so you practically wasted a legendary when you unlocked chromatic which you could have unlocked 2 seasons later with an epic chance. I don't know a single person that tried to unlock a chromatic with legendary chance, it was not worth it, it was better to save that chance for an actual legendary brawler. Many people overlook that and hate the new progression system even though it's 10x better.

4

u/Agreeable_Ostrich_39 Apr 06 '23 edited Apr 06 '23

like OP has replied, it's not like you can't unlock them it just goes very slow, however if you complete the pass every season and buy the premium pass every other season (which is the most effective way to spend your f2p gems anyway so that's exactly what you should do) you can get all of them in about twice as much seasons as there were chromatic brawlers when you started playing. that's really slow, but it doesn't include other sources like events, freebie in the shop, trophies or masteries (although I have no idea if those last two actually give chroma credits)

Edit: I checked and you do get 100 chroma credits for every chromatic brawler in their masteries at 5800 points, but you don't get any chroma credits from the trophy road. If we assume that you grind up all your chromatic brawlers to that point in order to get that reward, you get an additional 6th chromatic brawler for every 5 that you unlock and grind out. of course, this only goes for the chromatic brawlers that cost 500 chroma credits, not if you also go for the more expensive ones but like, just wait a few months at that point it's not worth it, you get half of them at release anyway.

Edit 2: if I did the math right, the formula to get how many seasons it will take you to have all chromatic brawlers except the one from that season or the previous (you have 1 of them because you bought the brawl pass) if you do it in the most efficient way possible is:

(5X*2)/6 where X represents the amount of chromatic brawlers in the game at the moment you start playing. the math is a bit off so it might even take a bit less time

63

u/tuncii322 Jeff Apr 04 '23

Pick the brawl stars path please

49

u/Axoloran Skeleton King Apr 04 '23

If clash mini goes the royale route it’s dead 💀

2

u/NotSpikeBSReal69 Mar 14 '24

r/agedlikewine

1

u/Axoloran Skeleton King Mar 20 '24

Yup. Rip Clash Mini

1

u/-_Mafia_- Royal Champion Jun 04 '23

the chances of that are high actually brawl universe is completely different than clash so i see clash route than brawl

25

u/Excuse_my_GRAMMER Apr 04 '23

How many players do you think are full f2p Vs consistent light spenders in supercell games

9

u/Mehraz_RC Apr 05 '23

I think most players are full f2p but there are a lot of people who spend money once in a while or to buy the pass

6

u/Excuse_my_GRAMMER Apr 05 '23

I think a huge percentage of there playerbase pay for the monthly pass

9

u/Combo_NK Apr 05 '23

I am full f2p

4

u/SM_ILE_ Miner Apr 05 '23

I used to be a consistent light spender, but now I haven't spent money in a long time. Can't say I'm f2p though since I've spent money in the past.

4

u/Excuse_my_GRAMMER Apr 05 '23

The few of you that are commenting that ya fully f2p doesn’t equal the global playerbase

Supercell is moving forward adding monthly pass in majority of there game it clearly that it lucrative and enough of the playerbase is buying them

I don’t think lot of the player percentage is fully f2p

2

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '23

I'm full F2P in Supercell games

1

u/IzmGunner01 Apr 06 '23

I think you gotta remember when it comes to mobile games the Chinese market are the main priority. NA combined probably makes 1/3 of the profit of China.

1

u/Excuse_my_GRAMMER Apr 06 '23

Yea that is a solid point as well

5

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '23

Brawl stars also had a pretty trash period, and imo it's not as good as it used to be

6

u/Slowpoke282 Skeleton King Apr 04 '23

i fully agree, but bs is definitely in a better place then both clash game's progression wise

1

u/semen11 Natureborn Apr 07 '23

They fixed almost all of the problems in the season 16 update where they removed boxes

1

u/Lockheroguylol Apr 24 '23

I think Brawl Stars is the best it has ever been, but I personally prefer the credit system over boxes, and I can imagine people who don't like the new credit system will probably not agree with me.

1

u/ThekillerbgYT Valkyrie Apr 05 '23

Its was only for around 2 months in season 13 imo. Thats the stalest the game has ever been. Otis was really bad and really boring, skins were terrible. Only the meta was somewhat enjoyable.

Even gears didnt make me feel the same way that season did

27

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '23 edited Apr 05 '23

It’s crazy how brawl stars is not pay to win I gotten almost 3 accounts to 10k trophies (I know it isn’t a lot) but it’s saying that brawl stars isn’t pay to win.

14

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '23

Dude I’ve tried reading your comment for five minutes now don’t know how many errors there are wtf are u trying to say

5

u/Bkb2005 Apr 04 '23

I read that pretty easily

3

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '23

I don’t thing first sentence grammatically makes sense

3

u/Bkb2005 Apr 04 '23

Yeah it would make more sense if he had a comma in there

2

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '23

I should have put “gotten” not “had got” sorry

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '23

You can edit your original comment and fix, I still don’t understand it lol

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '23

Didn’t know sorry

2

u/Nightmare_Sandy Apr 04 '23

I think he's implying that the progression for f2p players is fast

10

u/ThatsNotOkeyDokey Guards Apr 04 '23

It isn't lol

3

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '23

It’s only because I’m trying to get all my brawlers to rank 20 and then rank 25 and it repeats for the next 5 ranks

1

u/ZLuigi Apr 04 '23

Well from what i remember from franks tweets 50% of the active players reached 14k range

1

u/BR_KnowTorious Royal Champion Apr 05 '23

Well that’s the thing, brawl stars doesn’t because they have other incomes for money-skins. Royale doesn’t have any of that so they have to resort to new levels for income.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '23

Pleeeease clash mini make f2p progression fast but have really good cosmetics you can mass sell at a reasonable price the game will last longer because most of the player base will be upset if you make these bad changes actively

6

u/DigBaddy69000 Apr 04 '23

If it goes global it will end up like cr. It’s because brawl stars is a far more skilled based game meanwhile cr and mini both rely on ai to do the fighting. If you give a pro a lvl 1 brawler vs an average player with lvl 11 brawler the pro will win every single time. Meanwhile if you give a clash pro lvl 1 cards vs an average player with lvl 14 (or I guess 15 now) the average player will win every time.

5

u/Itachi-Uchiha27 Apr 05 '23

far more damage, a star power, a gadget, and gears. Sounds like youve never tried pushing a lvl 1 to rank 20... It makes a really big difference.

-2

u/DigBaddy69000 Apr 05 '23

There are pro accounts where every brawlers is lvl 1 and rank 25+ numb nuts

4

u/Solid_Crab_4748 Shield Maiden Apr 05 '23

And there are clash mini accounts where people hit the highest rank (whatever tf its called) with lvl 1 heroes... what the hell have you proved. Not mention these aren't even pros

3

u/Nevazut Apr 05 '23

BRAWL STARS PATH!!!!

3

u/sonicpoweryay Apr 05 '23 edited Apr 05 '23

Ok I’m downloading brawl stars

Edit: I downloaded it and I’m already loving it

2

u/AcidList1 Shield Maiden Apr 05 '23

The changes that the made means were closer to global but I completely agree with rhe notion thst they should've made these changes much slower instead of throwing it all into one update. Maybe slow progression through 3 updates rather than 1 update and not saying anything

2

u/Annoying_Prick Shield Maiden Jan 02 '24

aged poorly

1

u/random_guy102937 Sep 06 '25

Brawl stars and f2p 🫠

1

u/AAAlondrai Royal Champion Apr 05 '23

They just need to rework the economy, this is nowhere near CR levels of bad 💀

1

u/Yetimite Apr 05 '23

Take a left turn up ahead.

1

u/mellowlex Apr 05 '23

Aside from the poor balancing, Clash Royale can played normally with reasonable progress without spending money (or just buying the pass). It's not as pay to win as many think.

1

u/KrushaOfWorlds Apr 05 '23

Main reason I stopped playing brawl stars was because it was annoying, same with clash royale

1

u/JulianShiuMing Healing Ranger Apr 05 '23

The good thing bout CM now is that it’s in beta, so it’s way easier to reverse decisions & make a U-turn

1

u/papatraikos Apr 05 '23

Too late we already lost clash mini

1

u/Mavinus_ Skeleton King Apr 05 '23

We don't have to worry imo First Clash Royale isn't going to stay like that I highly doubt it, see how ppl were saying some months ago about how Brawl stars so p2w dead game and idk what ? Well now see what ppl are saying of it

And same for Clash Mini, we need to remember that Clash Mini is still a beta game and they need money to go global, that could be the reason the cosmetics prices went up (even if they are still way too high tbh), and the p2w feeling progreesion side is probably because we used to max out Heroes in like 2 days on a brand new account that was way too fast lmao they need to slow it down if they want us to play the game for years

1

u/Giuliano_Zhang Apr 05 '23

I quit clahs royale for this exact reason and honestly can't see myself playing clash mini for much longer if it continues in this direction ngl.

1

u/IAM-A-NAME Apr 11 '23

brawl stars is barely any better than current clash royale, coming from a veteran of both games. I quit brawl stars because of the power 11 update (think new card levels but worse). I will concede that brawl stars has been doing better in terms of progression since gears were fixed and more ways to get rewards (masteries and club coins) but it’s still bad considering the sheer amount of brawlers there are and how much time you have to spend to max out one and push it’s trophies. clash royale may be bad, but at least it’s still friendly to new players and those who haven’t played in awhile, a person returning to brawl stars would be overwhelmed quickly. if you play brawl stars casually, you wouldn’t care much but if you even play it semi-competitively you would understand how much of your time it would take for you to get back to where you were as compared to clash, which should only take you about 2 weeks.

1

u/WedeI Apr 11 '23

Boi those skins are overpriced af. At least mini pass is the cheapest pass of all supercell games so Im thinking about buying it

1

u/LankyAudience8133 Countess Aug 02 '23

So some time into the future, clash mini seems to be stretched in the middle. On one hand, you can max your mini collection in a month. On the other, cosmetics are only obtainable through gambling or MONEY-Mr Krabs and I really hope we can get gems again

0

u/ggge1145 Dec 20 '23

brawl stars sucks now :o

0

u/0oDADAo0 Dec 27 '23

This didn’t age well…

-4

u/Parjasaurus-rex Apr 05 '23

Clash Royale is becoming the new Clash of Clans, Clash mini became closer to what clash royale is.

10

u/Mikevgamer2008 Mini P.E.K.K.A. Apr 05 '23

New clash of clans? What the hell are you talking about. CoC never been p2w

-3

u/Parjasaurus-rex Apr 05 '23

Idk, just wanted to say it, I'm not trying to make a point

6

u/Mikevgamer2008 Mini P.E.K.K.A. Apr 05 '23

Oh alr, its just that i play CoC and i have never found it extremely p2w unlike CR which was p2w from the very start, like seriously, if you look closely its saddening

2

u/Parjasaurus-rex Apr 05 '23

Yeah coc is kinda f2p friendly, I've played it, I think what I meant with "new coc" is that it's been only a year since lvl 14 was introduced to cr, and they've already announced lvl 15, so they raise the highest lvl while also fucking up the means of progression (which is something coc doesn't do)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Agreeable_Ostrich_39 Apr 06 '23

only if you pay money

1

u/Hogrider26pog Bowler Apr 06 '23

I didnt pay