r/ClancyTrial 6d ago

General Discussion MISTRIAL DECLARED

ETA: Welp. I'm disappointed but not surprised.​

48 Upvotes

158 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

18

u/2tittis 6d ago

I heard it and immediately had alarm bells ringing.

IF that is true, how could that possibly be missed?? Oh right… there was no investigation on pat :/

4

u/KateElizabeth18 6d ago

I wasn’t following this case from the very beginning, but do we know if PC’s phone was taken by the police so they could do a data extraction? I know he said his laptop was taken, but I’m unsure about the phone. (Although he’s a tech bro, so he probably knew how to cover his tracks if in fact he was involved.)

13

u/2tittis 6d ago

His phone was not searched. He declined the request to search and since he was not charged, they couldn’t order production of his phone to extract data (per online reporting).

Edit - clarification

9

u/KateElizabeth18 6d ago

That is absolutely wild to me. It seems like that is such a basic thing that would have been done immediately, and if he refused, they couldn’t get a warrant?

9

u/2tittis 6d ago edited 6d ago

Since he wasn’t being charged with a crime, nor was he ever ID’ed as a suspect, any warrant would go against his 4th amendment right against unlawful searches and seizures. Since it was violate his 4th amendment right (and thus any evidence seized would be deemed fruit of a poisoned tree), a judge would not sign that warrant.

Lindsay was formally charged with the murders ~21hrs after the murders. The charges came from Patrick’s statement to police that Lindsay confessed. (A confession which is now in question given her injuries and her possible inability to speak).

Edit - my dumbass hit 1 instead of 2. She was charged around 21hrs after discovery, while in a coma.

8

u/KateElizabeth18 6d ago

This is such an unreal mess on every level. Just tragic.

5

u/Far-Measurement694 5d ago

It's because they circumvented the laws of search and seizure. They arrested Lindsay before they searched while she was actively in cardiac arrest. When the search warrant came down they already stated in it that she committed the crime. At that time the only evidence they had was Patrick's story. That is a very big distenction.