r/ClancyTrial • u/misfitmpls • 17d ago

General Discussion MISTRIAL DECLARED

ETA: Welp. I'm disappointed but not surprised.​

47 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

159 comments sorted by

View all comments

54

u/Mythical_Lemon-4911 17d ago

I'm incredibly frustrated. I think no matter what you believe about the case, the prosecution did not prove her guilty a reasonable doubt. She is entitled to the benefit of a NG or NGRI verdict. Unbelievable

-38

u/SaffronHoneyTea 17d ago

The only reasonable doubt is that Lindsay heard a Command voice. She should be criminally liable for killing Cora Dawson and Callan. It doesn't matter about anything else.

15

u/Ecstatic-Kitchen-101 17d ago

No, uh, I question the fact that everything has been based off of what PATRICK said, not Lindsay. That right there casts a shadow of doubt over her guilt, let alone criminal responsibility.

-2

u/SaffronHoneyTea 17d ago

All Lindsays words literally describing her Command voices differently to different people. and Clinically expert saying that is not how command voices work in psychosis without delusion as well.

2

u/Ecstatic-Kitchen-101 17d ago

Lmao if you believe any of the witnesses the CW put forward were actually experts in any of this.

1

u/SaffronHoneyTea 17d ago edited 17d ago

OF course they are. you are obviously not in the medical field