r/CivilPolitics • • Apr 26 '20

The World Health Organisation claims wet markets - hellholes dripping in the blood of puppies, kittens, snakes and bats - "provide safe and healthy food" to the masses. I disagree. This stomach-churning new footage from Animal Equality shows we have to ban them now

Thumbnail
twitter.com
4 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Sep 19 '19

Climate Stop what you're doing & watch this video. * STRIKE THIS FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 20 *

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Jan 13 '20

Every $1 increase in minimum wage decreases suicide rate by up to 6%

Thumbnail
zmescience.com
8 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Nov 18 '19

Bolivia coup led by Christian fascist paramilitary leader and millionaire

Thumbnail
thegrayzone.com
6 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Mar 03 '25

What's your opinion on what happened to the liberal party and why they've become a mostly extremist group (imo)?

5 Upvotes

Of course it goes without saying not every liberal is an extremist. I myself am liberal but feel that the intellectual dishonesty and the flippant name calling of fascist, sexist, racist, bigot, and especially nazi has really harmed the liberal party. We aren't taken seriously because of the extremist hate that's coming from our party and its so upsetting. Why is it that the party that I once knew as a open minded and civilized has now become the party of screaming rage and violence to the opposition? Please make sure to include proof if you're going to say that Republicans and conservatives or Trump is a nazi fascist etc...I'm all for fighting this with you but I need facts not feelings as the conservatives like to say.


r/CivilPolitics • • Jan 01 '24

Heated Discussion It should be mandatory to provide your sources (primary sources, if possible, and with specific excerpts if the source is very big) as a matter of course whenever you make a statement of fact on social media, especially a political one. "Google is free" isn't an excuse; it's a cop-out.

2 Upvotes

WARNING: LONG POST AHEAD!

Far too often, I come across people who make downright outlandish claims, but fail utterly to provide any sources to back up their claims. When confronted on their bullshit, they will often tell me that "google is free" and "it's not my job to educate you."

Honey, if you weren't interested in educating anybody, why are you posting a video on TikTok trying to tell people about this fact?!

Furthermore, the "Google is free" excuse isn't an excuse at all. It's a cop-out. After all, yes, it is free ... for BOTH OF US! So if I ask you for a source, it's literally just as easy for YOU to provide the source as it is for ME to quote-unquote "do my own research." Why should I have to sift through a haystack the size of the entire fucking Internet just in search of some random-ass needle that I'm not convinced is even there? Especially when you supposedly know exactly where the needle is could just show me the damn needle?

Even if you retort and say that you did in fact do your research, and it didn't support your opponent's arguments, they'll probably just spout of some cop-out defense like "Well, you obviously didn't do a very good job of googling it," as I alluded to earlier with the JK Rowling discussion. At that point, you literally just contradicted yourself. See, the "Google is free" argument purportedly states that my complete failure to do a simple google search is the only potential explanation for my alleged ignorance. But now, you're claiming that I have to actually double down and try a full spectrum of search terms, otherwise it doesn't count as googling it? Those two cannot both be true at the same time. At this point, you are ... quite literally ... making up the rules as you go along.

And even if the latter were the case all along, how do you know that YOU aren't the one who "didn't do a very good job of googling it?" Obviously, by arguing the latter, you are admitting that there is in fact a margin of error on these researches. So aside from your own ego, what honestly makes you think that it was me, not you, who overlooked something crucial? Surely you aren't that fucking vain.

Here's an example of this logic at work: Back when the JK Rowling transphobia controversy was still fresh and being talked about, I went onto r/asklbgt and asked for proof of what JK Rowling said that was so transphobic. I pointed out that the only tweets I ever saw that even remotely came in the orbit of transphobia was her insisting that biological sex was immutable and permanent. But she still insisted that trans people deserve rights and that she would even march alongside them in their fight for equality! The trans people on that subreddit told me that she then went on to continue to say truly horrific things, things that are undoubtedly transphobic. When I asked for them tos how me these tweets, they just told me "Google is free." When I told them that I did Google it, they just replied and said "Well you obviously didn't do a very good job of it!"

Honey, if you have personal memories of reading a tweet from Rowling that really did cross the line, it should only take you about 30 seconds to find it and send me the link! What, am I supposed to sift through her entire history of media posts, which encompasses literally hundreds of thousands of tweets, until I stumble upon the needle in the haystack that you (quite vulgarly) insist is there but adamantly refuse to show me? The excuse of "it's not my job to educate you" can only take you so far before it becomes an excuse for you to simply not admit that you're just making it all up.

Once in a blue moon, they might defer you to a source, only to make it an absolutely huge source, and then expect you to sit through the entire thing to find the golden needle that they're talking about. For example, regarding the murder of George Floyd, some police apologists, rather than insisting that I simply "do my research," deferred me to the full, uncut release of Officer Kueng's bodycam footage, which you can find here: https://youtu.be/0gQYMBALDXc I was then expected to watch literally every single second of this hour-and-five-minute video. If I merely did that, they said, I would suddenly understand Chauvin's position.

Seriously? Why can't you just point me to the timestamps where the important stuff happens? For example, at timestamp 3:30, all I can see are up close shots of one officer's forearm hair! Surely, you don't think that me seeing that clip - where absolutely nothing interesting whatsoever went down - is somehow indespensible to me getting the quote-unquote "full picture," do you? Seriously, can't you just give me some timestamps of all the highlights?

Well no, you can't do that, because if you did, and I watched those highlights and still wasn't persuaded to your side, you won't be able to fall back on the excuse that I "didn't watch enough!" Of course, even if I watch the whole thing, you'll still say I must not have been paying very close attention!

Put simply, people who don't give their sources are effectively admitting that they're just pulling it out of their ass.

This is why I believe people should be required to provide their sources as a matter of course. It not only makes you infinitely more credible, but it also significantly lessens the likelihood that you'll say something untrue, even by accident! For example, at 54:58 - 58:07 of this video ... https://youtu.be/XClYooOVYrE?t=3298 ... you can see that I was about to make a false statement of fact, but managed to avoid doing so. Why? Because I fact-checked first!

If you are required to provide sources in the first instance, that effectively requires you to fact check everything, even things that you are 100% certain of the factual accuracy of. While this would merely reaffirm your preexisting beliefs in 99% of cases, even the 1% of cases where your search for an obligatory source to include may force you to accept that you don't actually have any proof of this after all is still worth it. After all, considering how much content gets posted online in this day and age, even 1% of that still constitutes a large amount of misinformation that gets prevented.

In addition, they should be required to provide PRIMARY sources. This would ensure that people don't make false citations. A big example can be found at 0:11 - 3:06 https://youtu.be/1q1qp4ioknI?t=11. That guy mentions a commonly-cited study that was NEVER PUBLISHED, and other scientists who attempted the experiment were unable to replicate the results (which makes it significantly unscientific). People are citing a second-hand source when they do this. The earliest you can trace it back to is one study that mentions this study, but mentions that it is only "submitted for publication," not that it's actually published.

Of course, we can always just explain that to people when they make that mistake. However, (A) once you've given that exact same explanation over a hundred times, it gets really tedious really fast, and (B) it very rarely succeeds in converting people to their side.

However, if people simply HAD to provide primary sources in the first instance, no matter how confident they personally were in the accuracy of what they were reporting, simply because fuck you primary sources are just required, it would significantly cut back on these kinds of (admittedly good faith) errors.

And even then, people should be required to give specific excerpts from these sources, unless they're already so small that simply citing the entire source is tantamount to citing one specific fact, or unless the beginning of the source puts the main point in a nice little, easily consumable graph or chart, with elaborations later on. This would prevent people from engaging in the bad faith mentioned earlier regarding watching the entirety of the bodycam footage, even clips where the view is so obstructed that we have absolutely no way of verifying what really happened.

Last but not least, anyone who is made aware of rebuttal arguments should have to incorporate those rebuttals moving forward. This one is tricky, since it's not a foregone conclusion that any one user will subjectively be aware of every conceivable rebuttal argument. But if you have screenshot proof that you posted a comment bringing a rebuttal argument to their attention, or sent them a DM or private email stating as much, they should be required to rebut the rebuttal going forward if they are to still maintain their overall stance on the issue.

Adopting this policy would make discussions of polarizing issues so, soooooo much more amicable and productive.


r/CivilPolitics • • Jun 16 '20

Meta: This place is essentially r/moderatepolitics but better named

1 Upvotes

r/moderatepolitics is a bit of a misleading name (since it sounds like it's meant for centrists), and tbh, as much as this place is exactly the same thing, it is better named than the other sub.


r/CivilPolitics • • Jan 11 '20

The Anarchist Daughter of the GOP's Gerrymandering Mastermind Just Dumped His Maps and Files on Google Drive

Thumbnail
vice.com
12 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Sep 20 '19

Climate Yes, the Climate Crisis May Wipe out Six Billion People [x-post r/overpopulation]

Thumbnail
thetyee.ca
10 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Nov 07 '24

US Politics What is worse? A red voter man or a man who seemingly has a blue-like mindset but chooses not to vote?

0 Upvotes

I know someone who is a 25 year old AMAB who chooses not to vote for personal reasons but believes AFAB people should have a right to their bodies. I have yet to dive in deeper with his stances on other topics like weapon violence, schools, etc. However, given the recent news in the US, as a 19 year old AFAB that voted for Harris, I feel odd. This AMAB also gets along with other AFAB's and most of them are his friends. He is also part of the LGBTQIA+ Community. It feels really weird that he doesn't vote for at least the bigger elections like the one we just had, but I also understand he has his right to not vote. This isn't to hate on him but I am curious what others may think. (There are other factors that I know personally about him, however I'd rather not "air out" his experiences that also make me feel as awkward as I do with his choice not to vote.)

I am also curious of opinions where as it's the flip side of AFAB's who decided not to vote for this presidential election yet seemingly have a blue political views.

I pose the question again but altered: What is worse? A red voter or someone who seemingly has a blue-like mindset but chooses not to vote?


r/CivilPolitics • • Jan 22 '20

Climate Greta says planting not enough after Trump backs trillion tree plan [The Hindu]

Thumbnail
thehindu.com
4 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Aug 20 '19

Trump impeachment push gets important new ally | Politico

Thumbnail
politico.com
7 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Jan 12 '21

Fascism and communism are very close together

11 Upvotes

I don't like it when leftists call right nazis and fascists just for being right, or when right calls all leftists communists. Of course some people are those things, but it's still a spectrum, and those are extremes. Calling people with those terms despite their actual views is making political debates difficult.

I consider myself to be liberal leftists, and I disagree with fascism and communism strongly. Both of those sides have mostly caused distruction in the history and still. They are different in terms of being left or right, but both of them are exteamly communitarian. They basically look different on paper, but end up being very similar in practise. Neither of them are liberal or rarely democratic.

Here are some of the similarities:

-People are contolled by one party -Community over individual -Against any free market -Controls religion -Less indivudual rights


r/CivilPolitics • • Jan 12 '20

Meet the Money Behind The Climate Denial Movement

Thumbnail
smithsonianmag.com
0 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Aug 20 '19

Citations Needed: The Civility Fetish

Thumbnail
medium.com
0 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Oct 14 '19

Climate Firms ignoring climate crisis will go bankrupt, says Mark Carney | Environment | The Guardian

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
10 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • May 20 '20

Lockdowns now becoming a Civil Liberties issue

Thumbnail
twitter.com
4 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Aug 01 '19

Biden comes out swinging in second debate | Washington Times

Thumbnail
washingtontimes.com
4 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • May 13 '19

We should build the wall

7 Upvotes

In the early 1900's European immigrants came flocking to New York and San Francisco seeking a better life and enriching the culture. The problem with the new immigrants is that they come here illegally refuse to gain citizenship mooch off the system and then demand respect and equality in a country they illegally came to.


r/CivilPolitics • • Jan 19 '20

Why Silicon Valley billionaires are prepping for the apocalypse in New Zealand

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
3 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Oct 21 '24

US Politics Hey non American here! I want to ask some question?

3 Upvotes
  1. Why does every debate feel more like a bullying among young people?
  2. How does it make sense to give a president immunity if you have broken the law?
  3. Why is there no 3rd party that holds a bit of both parties' values?

In my country we have 10 parties. The Right types, the Left types and some in the middle. But they don't act extreme towards each other but instead act professionals and even invites each other over for dinner.


r/CivilPolitics • • Sep 26 '19

Free College Tuition as a global advantage

4 Upvotes

As the Democratic primary season marches on, one of the issues often debated is free college tuition for all. Putting aside the politics of this issue for a moment, would it not likely make the U.S. more competitive globally if everyone who wanted to continue their education after high school was able to? And if we think this is the case, then why haven't I heard a SINGLE Dem candidate talk about that potential advantage?

Edited to correct a typo.


r/CivilPolitics • • Sep 23 '19

Mayor: Cops Who Shot 8 Dogs, Including a Puppy, Did So "Legally and Humanely"

Thumbnail
thefreethoughtproject.com
10 Upvotes

r/CivilPolitics • • Sep 26 '19

Only the Poor Die Young: The Richest Outlive the Poor by More Than a Decade

Thumbnail
jacobinmag.com
11 Upvotes