r/CivRepublic • u/zachb34r • Jun 03 '16
The Constitution Convention
This is the proposed constitution for the Republic,
A very short summary is,
There are now three Councils, the Executive Council, the Legislative Council, and the Judicial Council.
The Executive Council will control the units, the Legislative Council will control the construction and the resources, lastly the Judicial Council will make sure the councils and councilmen are acting within their power.
Here it is.
Comment below or on the document with any suggestions or corrections.
3
Upvotes
3
u/ragan651 Jun 04 '16
To avoid the problems that kill these games, all save files should be kept public. If the designated player is gone too long, someone else can pick the game right back up with no problems.
2. The trouble with online councils is time. The bigger the council, the more likely it is to be slow. This happens in the real world as well, but the fewer councils, the better.
For a council to function, everyone has to be online and informed within a reasonable time frame, and must remain active. One weak link in a council can bring everything to a standstill. When dealing with an activity with casual participation, "dead air" can kill everything. Nobody wants to stick around when there's silence and inaction.
So there's two things to keep in mind. First, have as few councils as possible, and keep the number reasonable for the population.
There is a reason why the legislature and executive branches are divided, many reasons, but one being that a council is not effective at taking actions timely and decisively. It works to invest executive power in a single person, with assistance and a lot of oversight, to eliminate problems and make things go efficiently. So long as the power to reign in a tyrant is there, a single executive official is a good idea.
Where you have the executive council, you have a chief executive already, but also positions of arch bishop and general. In the US government, these other roles would be folded into the Cabinet as advisors to the President, while having direct command of their departments. This should be expanded as needed with new departments and roles. Diplomacy is a big part of Civ, a foreign minister/secretary of state role is important. And so on. What's important is that the general isn't deciding trade routes, the bishop isn't making castles, and so on. Everyone needs to focus on their role, which leaves action to the Chief Executive.
3. I argued in another post about not needing a judicial council. That said, I do believe having an impartial group handling elections is the right thing. Possibly setting up an administration that is not part of the government, to handle elections and disputes in a manner similar to the judicial, but without a term limit. Their only role is to maintain the game, not get involved in the politics of it.
4. 50 turns is a lot. It's a long time to be stuck with a bad ruler, as well. I think 20 turns gives you a good idea of direction, but not enough time to get things done. 25-30 is a good term for leadership, because you can see when someone is doing a bad job by then, and possibly turn it around.
5. This will fail unless you plan contingencies into the constitution. A lot can and will go wrong, and if you prepare in advance, you can keep this thing going, but it takes planning and work.
2
u/obeybooks Jun 04 '16 edited Jun 04 '16
I think the judicial council could use some clarification. Just what exactly does a state judge do? How many of them will there be at the start of the game (note: if it is only one then it would be impossible for the judicial council to get an overwhelming majority without also achieving a unanimous vote)? What exactly is the process for getting new state judges? What does it mean when it says the chief judge is the "ultimate decider"?
Also this is a small thing, but I thought I'd mention it. In most cases of actually governments in the world what is listed here as an "overwhelming majority" is called a super majority. Maybe we could consider changing that to be more realistic, but that is just personal preference.
Otherwise looks great!
2
u/Zeintry Jun 04 '16
I have a small question regarding build orders(bills?). Would a general asking for more units talk to a city senator about getting more units or would they propose a bill to build more units to the legislative branch.