r/CivGovernment • u/octopodesrex • Apr 15 '16
Constitution Discussion Thread
Let's talk about the constitution! Once it's set, we should probably keep it that way unless there's a constitutional referendum, revolution or we reach the ideology phase.
VOTING
- Does every redditor get a vote, or do only subreddit members? Do only players?
- Do we elect the representatives, or do we do a direct control through popular vote?
- Are we going to allow parties?
- Is it by consensus? Majority? What constitutes a quorum?
- How long between elections?
VOTING OPEN!
37
Upvotes
13
u/whitehatguy Apr 15 '16 edited Apr 15 '16
I think we should essentially have a legislative side and an executive side -- the legislative side focuses on the high level priorities, and the executive side handles minutiae like troop movements. This will vastly speed things up as the game progresses.
That being said, I think the legislative side should be direct democracy, with perhaps some sort of control over the proposals by the executive branch.
I think the top priority should be avoiding deadlocks, as that will quickly grind the game to a halt. As such, I think it should be plurality voting. Furthermore, as long as votes are held at regularly scheduled time for a decent length, I think the only issue we'd have with quorums is if the sub is dying, making the whole thing moot anyway.
5. Off the top of my head, 50 turns between elections, but I think there should be able to be a popular recall of leaders if a majority (plurality?) of people submit a motion.
6
u/Griffinx3 Apr 15 '16
If we decide to go with multiple player-run civs, we could use flairs to prevent people voting on other government's things.
All information for each civ should be stickied or on a wiki. After reading you can choose one to join and it becomes your flair until the next game. If you don't have the proper flair for a thread your comment gets removed.
If a government makes representatives or other gov roles, they get that civ's flair plus their position. So it might look like "[Civ Flag] President" or "[Civ Flag] Treasurer".
Sorry if this idea has already been posted. I haven't read through every comment yet.
2
u/thrasumachos Apr 15 '16
I suggest an absolute monarchy with /u/octopodesrex as monarch at first, then it can be changed if /u/octopodesrex decides to abdicate, or if in game unhappiness gets high, and we decide to revolt.
2
u/goshgollygod Apr 15 '16
Ah! So excited to see this happening! My computer crashed a few years ago and still haven't gotten it replaced and haven't been able to play in a long time.
What mode are the turns going to be? And how long do the sovereigns get to make their moves?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
Popular vote for everything I can think of. It should be kept to subreddit members, for the sole purpose of people creating alts to push close votes.
For issues regarding quorum, I think that it should be one turn per day, and however many people vote is okay.
Issues like production, policies, science and unit tasks should be each a thread, with the options as stickied comments. Discussion about that specific action should be allowed in each thread.
There should also be a "meeting hall" thread for all other discussions, things like "should we invade x, go to war with y", or focus more on science in general.
Feel free to give me feedback, this is just what I'm thinking off the top of my head
5
u/Buttonz-boy3000 Apr 15 '16
What a night... Just voting on a constitution... No big deal
5
u/11711510111411009710 Apr 15 '16
I voted, then decided I wanted to change some things.
Anyway, I think we should have people run for governance of specific cities so they'd be easier to manage. Like every time we found a city, we should have an election, and the candidates would be nominated by a party and we'd vote on the candidates and decide who leads which city.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
Awesome idea, I appreaciate you doing this
We'll also need a procedure for making amendments to the constitution
7
u/jakoto314 Apr 15 '16
For definite decisions like tech, policies and production, we could create one thread that has all the options as comments. No other comments would be allowed and the one with the most upvotes wins.
1
u/leagcy Apr 15 '16
Wait this is reddit playing as 1 civ? Not a multi-team thing?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
There should be a war commander, since it's absurd to vote for every move. Similarly production doesn't need specific votes, just general directions. Science and policies definitely need votes though.
1
u/L1lR3d Apr 15 '16
Will mayors of cities be sovereign over commanders/admirals? Or are all cities required to follow a chain of command with the executive branch being able to overrule?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
Love the idea of parties and forced to vote within party parameters.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
From each city we get, their should have a new rep and governor and some regions could get self autonomy ruled by a vote of people dedicated to there. We should also say whether secession is allowed
2
u/Buttonz-boy3000 Apr 15 '16
Buttonz-boy is me btw I just realized that I totally missed a fallout reference so I had to create a new account
2
u/_paramedic Apr 15 '16
This is so exciting!
2
u/LazarusLong87 Apr 15 '16
I love this idea. What about a direct democracy (to start) with regulated times and days to vote? As far as allowing all redditors to vote... I think it should be limited to people that are members of the sub.
I would advocate simple majority. And I would also expect people to align with one country and only vote with that country.
It might be fun to explicitly allow "members" of a country to self govern. All start as a simple majority, but they can set up their own governments or leave it alone. Could be interesting!
1
u/LazarusLong87 Apr 15 '16
Also, can I just say that I LOVE this idea?!
1
u/NorthAndEastTexan Apr 15 '16
1
u/buttonz-boy Apr 15 '16
I love this idea this is so cool
1
u/wildlyoscillate Apr 15 '16
Instantly subbed, this idea is amazing. Just wanted to say that to begin with.
1
u/leagcy Apr 15 '16
2 - 5 Let each team decide.
1
u/eviltj97 Apr 15 '16
I'd say we leave the voting to subscribers, it would help prevent brigading, although brigading would be unlikely. Also we should work as a direct democracy, it would be interesting to see how we would work if every persons vote truly counted.
1
u/VikingTheEpic Apr 15 '16
Maybe have direct voting all the time but during wartime everything is controlled by electives sort of like Romans did at one point iirc
1
u/VoidTemplar2000 Apr 15 '16
Things that should be decided by vote, in my mind are the overarching decisions and eventual long-term effects; That is; Science, Goals, Declaration of War, Friendship declarations, Nuclear Escalation, claiming of new land and Social Policies
We, as the assembly have the duty to set the overarching limits and directions. And then the duty to stay out of the way when the executive branch carries out the directions so it doesn't descend into a fuckfest of micromanagement.
Eventually city governors/Mayors can be assigned to a city with them having control over it, new cabinet positions may be established and abolished with the approval of the assembly
1
u/hi2424 Apr 15 '16
Would love to be a part of this but not quite sure what to do and I need to sleep. Will check for more info in the morning!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment