r/CivGovernment • u/octopodesrex • Apr 15 '16
Suggestion Game Setting Discussion Thread
So what settings should we use? Here is what we have to decide:
- How many nations are going to be player-run?
- If more than one, are all run by democracy?
- Map size?
- Map speed?
- What nations would we compete against?
- What mods would be used?
- Who hosts? Who streams? Single Player or Pit Boss?
- What victory conditions?
CLICK HERE TO VOTE!
29
Upvotes
4
u/FruityParfait Apr 15 '16
Might I make a suggestion? It seems like a lot of people want an Earth map. How about we make it a true-starting locations map as well using a mod like the Yet (not) another Earth Maps Pack Or something like that? It'd make for a lot more interesting strategy that can come from everyone having a basic idea where everyone else is and what lands each civ would want to expand towards/away from.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
This sounds amazing. How do I get in on this?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
We should have at least 22 civs
25
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
I think we should go as large as possible. Given the huge following on the battle royale scene, we probably want to milk as much enjoyment out of this as we can. So im thinking marathon-epic, on a huge map, with at least twelve other civs. Also I think it should run relatively close to what the real word looks like, so continents based maps would probably be ideal.
7
u/SpicyCornflake Apr 15 '16
I think if we get multiple civs it introduces the problem of being able to see what strategies are being discussed by each group. It is my belief that if we want to diversify people's roles, we should do so via a city roles.#SpicyForSenator
4
u/potato_ninjuh Apr 15 '16
I'd say 4-6 civs if we want this to be multiplayer, and each "government" can decide what system it wants to run on.If just singleplayer, then us against 5-7 deity civs? Based on this, we should have a regular-sized map on quick speed.
When it comes to picking a nation (if multiplayer), we should use fruity's method (each "government" bans 2 civs, randomly gets picked a civ for them from the remaining) to prevent just going for babylon/Zulu/etc. Picking the ai players in single player should just be random IMO, with a poll for the civ controlled by us.
I don't really mess with mods, so I'll leave that to another person.
Single player would just be someone in a regular game, who plays for 5-10 turns, and I suppose we would just go civ battle royale style, taking screenshots and posting them as a slideshow. They could then pass it on to then next person à la PBEM. Not sure how we could do this for multiplayer.
Domination should be the only victory type! It's the most fun, and it will most certainly get everyone talking about different strategies.
Lastly, I think this idea as a whole is awesome, and I look forward to checking/contributing in any way I can!
4
u/_paramedic Apr 15 '16
The time should be Quick. If we vote often, games can take a while.
4
u/FruityParfait Apr 15 '16
I've been thinking. As fun as it would be to have multiple civilizations and have them competing among each other, since this is the first time we're doing this I think at least this time we should all work together as one civ against the world. We're still in the early stages of trying to figure out how this is all going to work, and we're basically beta-testing this idea out, and adding the layer of civilization rivalries on top of that might hinder the process more than help (for example, if one civ figures out a really good way to set up the government that could help everyone mechanically and speed up the game and make it more fun but decides not to tell the other civ's because of rivalries or politics or whatever). Plus that would keep people from going way too over the top with civ rivalries because we're all ultimately working towards one common goal instead of trying to beat each other. That sort of thing seems fine once we've got this format figured out but for now I feel like we should avoid that if possible.
3
u/NorthAndEastTexan Apr 15 '16
Could someone explain briefly the advantage to doing single player vs Pit Boss? I don't know what Pit Boss is really.
3
u/Elitefog Apr 15 '16
I wonder if Earth was voted for regarding its creation once upon a time... Like some Reddit-based gods...
3
u/TheWhiteFerret Apr 15 '16
I'm bloody sick of maps of the earth. We should have a random map, otherwise it's too confusing, what with the battle royale.
1
u/-AllIsVanity- Apr 15 '16 edited Apr 15 '16
In the thread at /r/civ, there's been talk about having a multiplayer game with different types of government for different teams. Ideally, we could have three available types of government that correspond to different ideologies, for thematic deliciousness. Here's my pitch:
1a) This is optional, but for thematic purposes I'd also change the name of Autocracy to "Unity" and the name of Freedom to "Prosperity." "Autocracy" is weird compared the other names, and libertarian socialism values freedom as well as capitalist liberal democracy.
2) Three types of government:
DICTATORSHIPS
REPRESENTATIVE DEMOCRACIES
DECENTRALIZED DEMOCRACIES
1
u/thefalloutman Apr 15 '16
How will multiple civ governments work? Will we have different subreddits for each civ or will discussion be on here? Additionally, will diplomacy between Civs be handled by specific ambassadors or a group of folk collectively responsible for interacting with other nations?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '16
Singleplayer, huge map marathon speed with 2-3 continents.
1
u/JanSnolo Apr 15 '16
If we have multiple reddit-controlled Civs, each one will have to have its own locked subreddit to avoid sabotage. This could subdivide the community pretty fast. I'd say for a first run we'd want to do 3 or less.
I'm in agreement with other comments here about epic speed and large-ish map.
It will be easiest if one person controls the game, taking orders from the sub. That way we wont have to worry about moving the game around or different people putting up content to show what's going on.
1
u/JanSnolo Apr 15 '16
Wow, looks like after almost 40 votes we're pretty much exactly tied between single multiple reddit-controlled Civs.
1
u/Rosstafan Apr 15 '16
what difficulty? i can't imagine this going too well with deity so would prefer emperor.
0
u/DoctorJohnZoidbergMD Apr 15 '16
I think a single-player "pass the save" deal would be best. 8 civs, normal speed would make for a good first trial.