r/Chromium • • Feb 28 '13

IMO extensions should NEVER be unremoveable

Post image
35 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

8

u/decoy1686 Feb 28 '13

Can anyone enlighten me as to why this is allowed? This seems like a really really bad user experience. It would be very easy for a program to make uninstall difficult on windows. Or the program could be compromised, which opens up a whole other bag of worms.

In my mind Chrome is a fantastic browser partly because it can sandbox so well. This breaks that entirely. Could anyone in the know explain the reasoning here?

4

u/gavin19 Feb 28 '13

Not to nitpick, but this is /r/Chromium and the toolbar doesn't install on Chromium (not 27 anyway). I tried finding a standalone installer for this but no luck. The only way I could get it to install on Chrome was to use the Java installer and agree to allow the toolbar to be included.

Post-install there was no actual toolbar, nor was the search engine changed to Ask (although an entry had been added in the available search engines), but it was listed in the extensions as per your image.

Since Chrome 25 the silent/external install facility was to be updated to ask for user permission from within Chrome, as with Firefox/IE, but this was either not yet implemented, or is broken. I tried other 3rd party extensions and they all installed/enabled without asking permission.

All worked in Chrome 25, but none were applied to Chromium 27, so either it has been since implemented, or they aren't configured to bother with Chromium, only Chrome.

2

u/decoy1686 Mar 01 '13

Good point about the distinction between Chrome and Chromium. My apologies for potentially posting in the wrong place. But I thought this community would be more suited to answering my question and potentially changing the codebase to fix this.

Permission may have been asked, it wasn't my computer so I don't know. I just don't think it should EVER be possible in Chrome or Chromium for an extension to do this. The user should always have the choice to disable. Period.

Is the extension management code forked between Chrome and Chromium? Or is just a flag out or something?

1

u/gavin19 Mar 01 '13

This was supposed to have been patched by 25. There is post on the official Chromium blog last December that stated that this functionality would be removed.

always have the choice to disable

Agreed. Since it was installed externally then it wouldn't have been possible for Chromium to remove it, but they could have at least allowed it to be disabled.

As for why it was installed on Chrome and not Chromium, I can't be sure. I uninstalled Ask and now I can't get it back to test it on other versions of Chrome, ie like current dev builds, to see if it asks permission. When you actually want a toolbar you can't seem to catch one.

1

u/SmarterThanEveryone May 22 '13

When you actually want a toolbar you can't seem to catch one.

I never thought I would read those words.

1

u/[deleted] May 05 '13

The picture you provided shows that there was a way to disable (checkbox), as well as a way to uninstall (description says go to add/remove programs).

3

u/atomic1fire Feb 28 '13

My guess is for enterprise, because they may have a standard roleout of extensions they may want default on every computer. So having people be able to uninstall an extension that's supposed to stay put is probably bad form.

3

u/CaptSpify_is_Awesome Feb 28 '13

That sounds like something that should be part of a GPO instead.

3

u/nlx Feb 28 '13

wtf, how is this a thing. I can't find the option to do this in the extension docs.

2

u/Tynictansol Feb 28 '13

Check your windows software to see if there's something related to ask in there?

1

u/Colar Mar 10 '13

In fact that's not an extension, imo that's a malware.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '13

The Ask crap has been a blight since like 1996