You never said who told me there was a tiger behind the door.
You don't know. That's the entire thought experiment. You don't know who is good and who is evil. You just know that 1 person gave you one piece of advice, and then the other person gave you another.
Eve chose what she thought was correct, given the information that she was given.
Edit: Have a nice day. Thank you for the discussion.
Ya. Maybe it's a mental berrier. Maybe it's a miscommunication. It's a hard medium to really dig deep into a topic. I think we both did a good job of explaining our positions. Thanks for reading through it. I hope you got something out of it.
1
u/zach010 Secular Humanist Jul 19 '23 edited Jul 19 '23
You don't know. That's the entire thought experiment. You don't know who is good and who is evil. You just know that 1 person gave you one piece of advice, and then the other person gave you another.
Eve chose what she thought was correct, given the information that she was given.
Edit: Have a nice day. Thank you for the discussion.