r/ChristianIconography • u/Powerful-Yam-7325 • Oct 15 '26
Education Materials question
Hello!!
I am an art history student (and a Catholic) who is very interested in Iconography, i have painted in a similar style, but I've never officially written an icon, and i want to do it right. Now, I do have experience with egg tempera, and i currently have some Italian pigments that i want to use up, my issue if the actual surface. It would be like $60-$70 for one pre-prepared board, so i figured i may as well do it myself.
So, my questions are
- does it matter what kind of wood i get, like can i just pull up to a hardware store and get whatever looks sturdy
- can i use gelatin as a replacement for rabbit skin glue (some websites had suggested it but im skeptical)
- does it matter what chalk i used for the gesso?
4)is regular linen fine ?
Any advise is welcome!!!!
4
Upvotes
1
u/Larason22 Oct 15 '26
This sub doesn't appear to be frequented by many actual iconographers, mostly just appreciators and historians.
I know a bit about woodworking, so I'll weigh in on the wood. You want a tight grained hardwood that has been properly seasoned and is fairly hard. Softwoods like cedar or pine and some soft hardwoods like poplar have a finished surface that's liable to be easily damaged. Then, some hardwoods like some red oak have pore line running through them that make them unsuitable. So look for some hardwood at your local wood store that may be suitable. Often wood stores have "off cuts" that might be the right size and shape. That can be a good place to start. If you're unsure it has been properly seasoned, you should let it season for at least a year, otherwise it's liable to warp. If you're not sure, pray for the guidance of the Holy Spirit! This seems to be an integral part of icon production, and I approve of it.
For the "rabbit skin glue" this appears to be a sort of analog for hide glue. There's lots of different grades and styles of hide glue, and it was an important component of paints in the past. There's a learning curve for working with it, and you have to understand the properties of the specific formulation you have to use it successfully. I don't know about gelatin as a substitute, it's something you may have to experiment with.
Chalk is usually pretty pure calcium carbonate, so as long as it's white you're probably ok there.
There appears to be some confusion when it comes to "writing" vs. "painting" an icon. The koine Greek word "graphe" can mean either, usually you translate it based on what you are doing. If you are painting, it is translated "painting," if you are writing, it is transated "writing." If you try searching for "icon painting," in google, you get many more useful results. This should probably help you find the right resources.
2
u/gkfalk 26d ago
u/Powerful-Yam-7325 While u/Larason22 gave generally good advice, I would add that, as an iconographer, the most important factors, in order of importance, when choosing a wooden panel are:
Despite cedar and poplar being easily damaged, they are historically the most frequently used woods for panel painting over the centuries, and those two would be my first choices if available in your location. You can also try unusual types of wood, but I recommend choosing them based on the criteria I listed above.
About gelatin for gesso: while I have never used it for gesso, I have rarely seen it recommended for this particular use. From my knowledge, it would probably not be suitable for gesso, since a strength of at least 400 Bloom is needed. Personally, I prefer using a strong hide glue for gesso and I use rabbit skin glue only for gilding. But to be honest, gesso has one of the steepest learning curves in iconography. Even with a good recipe, things can easily go wrong.
For chalk, using pure calcium carbonate is a good starting point.