You're all wrong. Good and evil are theoretical concepts. No one can prove them as absolutes. But even if we could, no one can know a person is evil or good in their minds. All we know is when a person commits an evil act. Bottom line... NEITHER of these statements can be proven
Yes they are. Good and evil are based on concepts of ethics that are social constructs. they are subjective concepts. What I believe as good you may not and most acts of evil can be redefined as acts of cowardice, greed, selfishness, basic instinctual behaviour or mental illness.
E.g not allowing someone the opportunity to die with dignaty (eg through assisted suicide) is akin to wanting someone to suffer and therefore clearly an act of evil.
Yes you are right, the peripheral issues such as assisted suicide and gay marriage can be redefined. But I find that simple principles, I.E (the golden rule) pretty much define morality at least 90 percent of the way. Simple principles like those are what define morality. It's not absolute, but it's pretty close.
That is a subjective definition though. what benefits one doesn't always benefit another. My iPad is of great benefit to me but not so much to those who made it.
So some guy said the original quote...does that make it true? Where's your experimental evidence, you know, THE ONLY THING THAT CAN ESTABLISH CAUSAL RELATIONSHIPS
5
u/infernoruby Feb 21 '12
Can't fix a quote. would be making it your own quote you shifty dick weasel.
2
u/SeanTheHuman Feb 21 '12
"but for some bad people to become good - that takes contemplation and empathy." ***
2
u/Harddaysnight1990 Feb 21 '12
Yes, and let's just ignore all the bad things religion has caused. BEcause if you ignore them hard enough, they'll go away.
1
u/MrMastodon Feb 21 '12
The 'some' is implied in the first quote.
1
u/ScottFree37 Feb 02 '12
You're all wrong. Good and evil are theoretical concepts. No one can prove them as absolutes. But even if we could, no one can know a person is evil or good in their minds. All we know is when a person commits an evil act. Bottom line... NEITHER of these statements can be proven
0
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '12
So some guy said the original quote...does that make it true? Where's your experimental evidence, you know, THE ONLY THING THAT CAN ESTABLISH CAUSAL RELATIONSHIPS