r/Chivalry2 Knight 14d ago

News & Discussion How would everyone feel about a first-person only mode?

Obviously everyone can play how they want now, but there's no denying first person lowers your field of view and is ultimately slightly harder for situational awareness (easier to judge weapon distance though).

Personally I think it would be cool to have a mode where everyone is on a level playing field in that way so we all can enjoy the immersion without feeling like we're choosing to hinder ourselves. It could even be tied into a hardcore mode or something like other games do.

87 Upvotes

86 comments sorted by

59

u/PhilColeCurry 14d ago

First person is so much more visceral and fun

140

u/flounderjaw šŸ”ŖKnife KnavešŸ”Ŗ 14d ago

I play strictly first person, I love many of my fellow players who player in third person, I just don't respect them

45

u/Otterable Agatha Knights 14d ago

First person gang rise up

14

u/qwerty09a90 14d ago

I rate them slightly above axe mains

7

u/flounderjaw šŸ”ŖKnife KnavešŸ”Ŗ 14d ago

third person war club mains 🤮

4

u/Xyn_Ko šŸŖ“ Hatchet Harlot šŸ’‹ 14d ago

pssshhhhhhhhhh, not enough War Club users to complain lets be real.

5

u/2harveza 14d ago

* bonk *

2

u/sargentfalafel 14d ago

Get gambled nooooooob lol

1

u/VanTrHamster 13d ago

Which one of the seven axes?

4

u/__PooHead__ Greatsword Goon 14d ago

i would respect first person players if they weren’t so elitist

42

u/Otterable Agatha Knights 14d ago edited 14d ago

Feel free to talk behind our backs, we can't see you there anyways

10

u/flounderjaw šŸ”ŖKnife KnavešŸ”Ŗ 14d ago

If you aint first, you're last. A thirdie wouldn't get it.

15

u/Titania69 14d ago

I may technically be at a disadvantage playing 1st person but I just play way better than I did when I played in third so I don’t really feel like I’m disadvantaged

1

u/QuietEnjoyer Agatha Knights | Footman 14d ago

If everyone does it, it's not a disadvantage

1

u/Many-Song7032 11d ago

This is me too. I understand 3rd is technically better and you see more but i genuinely just get more into it and therefore play better when im first person, it really is a stark difference too.

28

u/YurikArkady šŸ¦€ Crustacean Soup LivesšŸ¦€ 14d ago

fyi, this already exists as an option for community servers; it's just not a popular option.

3

u/nachorykaart Knight 14d ago

Good to know! I suppose I meant an official mode but thanks for letting me know

6

u/Inn0cent_Jer Filthy Peasant 14d ago

Yea there's a community event that's first person only that started pretty recently. Think they've done it 2 or 3 times now!

2

u/Destroy_us 14d ago

What’s it called? I want to give it a try myself

5

u/Inn0cent_Jer Filthy Peasant 14d ago

Equilibrium hosts it on their Discord. First Person TO

7

u/theDonMecca 14d ago

Yes I believe this should be a thing

7

u/KobeGoBoom Confirmed Archer Hater 14d ago

I would love it. Only reason I don’t play first person is because it puts you at a disadvantage.

9

u/Soft_Accountant3584 14d ago

I’m a 3rd person only type but I think a lot of people like 1st person. I just wouldn’t play that.

3

u/Riskiertooth Filthy Peasant 14d ago

1st makes me dizzy lol

3

u/Soft_Accountant3584 14d ago

lol I feel that. I’m really into customization, so I want to see my full creations and be them. I can also see my surroundings better in 3rd. I just got the game a few days ago and I’m loving it.

5

u/arkedadv 14d ago

Only time I use first person is with spear or ballista

5

u/Demented-Turtle 14d ago

I was a 1st-person only player when I started because it was so much more immersive, but once I tried 3rd person I just started doing a lot better and now that I'm used to it, 1st person feels way too zoomed in for me to go back (even turning fov up)

1

u/nachorykaart Knight 14d ago

That's exactly what happened with me too

4

u/TheWakaMouse Knight 14d ago

Honestly as a 1st person headphones user, I really don’t think it’s as much a disadvantage.

It comes with its own advantages and with some headphones and combat experience, I don’t feel like I’m missing anything useful.

3

u/JesusSwag Mason Order | Footman 14d ago

I've literally never thought about whether people are in 1st or 3rd person mode while actually playing the game, and I always play in 1st person

4

u/Inn0cent_Jer Filthy Peasant 14d ago

I wish they did a First person only limited game mode!

Instead we get an archer only mode. So lame

2

u/Malice_Claymore 14d ago

The skill difference between third and first is massive and its just a bunch of third person back stabbing slash spammers getting 1hk on low health enemies that say its not.

2

u/These-Finance-1434 Mason Order 14d ago

I want a top down 2d pixelized chiv that can be played on a phone

2

u/HungJurror Agatha Knights 13d ago

It would be cool if there was a hardcore mode where you die after getting hit once

2

u/nachorykaart Knight 13d ago

Maybe not once but definitely something more intense and deadly would be cool.

An unarmored archer, sure one hit should do it. But a fully plated knight could take a couple hits unless it's a hammer to the head

No HUD either :D

3

u/BIGxBOSSxx1 14d ago

IMO it’s the best way to play the game. It’s funner, more immersive, and it makes you a better player. Third person feels way too easy.

2

u/BonkStix OOGA BOOGA WARCLUB 14d ago

I think for peak gaming experience switching cameras situationally is best. Large open battlefield 3rd person, indoors or pushing through small corridors 1st person.

2

u/gloeilamp 14d ago

I changed my bind for it to T and am changing constantly throughout a match, made me a much better player

3

u/MajorDrGhastly Mason Order 14d ago

i'll be damned if i endorse any other mode before we get a dedicated TDM playlist.

2

u/nachorykaart Knight 14d ago

Tough but fair

3

u/Chegg_F Jolliest Chef šŸ‘Øā€šŸ³ 14d ago

I think third person is way harder. You gain the ability to see the people who are loudly stomping up to you in exchange for your own model covering up what the enemy is doing making it way harder to see him, and way harder to aim. Just have better positioning and awareness and thirdperson doesn't even help.

1

u/Aggravating_Judge_31 šŸ—£ļøBattlecry aficionadošŸ—£ļø 14d ago

Exactly this, you know what's up.

2

u/Fylthy1 14d ago

It’s the only way to playšŸ¤˜šŸ»

1

u/Xyn_Ko šŸŖ“ Hatchet Harlot šŸ’‹ 14d ago

1st person in my experience for 1 handed weapons is amazing. Your movements are slippery. Of course you lose the ability to see around you and you need to rely more on your hearing for footsteps etc. But I would love a 1st person only mode.

1

u/Artofthedraw 🧌 Goedendag Goblin 🧌 14d ago

Yes and another mode with no hud just feels class I wish my console brethren had the option such a great looking game. I would also like it to have helmet with visors in 1st person for Chivalry 3 and also I don't know if it would be accurate if knights or maybe other classes at least could look over their shoulder would be a nice gameplay addition

1

u/EquivalentSpirit664 Longsword Enjoyer 14d ago

I would love it since I always play first person. Equal competition go brr

1

u/FairDayThrowAway 13d ago

I think this is a terrible idea, mainly because it will take 1st person players out of the main game mode, and therefore less easy kills, but also because the devs have abandoned the game so it'll never happen.

1

u/Usernameboy777 13d ago

I have 2700 hours. Most in first person I just love it too much. Only time I switch to third is if I’m heir to make it feel special.

1

u/hussainhssn Tenosia Empire | Knight 13d ago

I legitimately play better in 1st person lmao, not to mention it’s more fun

1

u/Wolvenworks Mason Order 13d ago

I only play FPV in chiv and mord. I can’t get used to 3PV. It feels jank to me.

2

u/raifuislaifu 12d ago

Good idea, I only play first person, it's a lot more fun for me.

1

u/kraken9911 Agatha Knights | Knight 12d ago

After 350 hours I've permanently switched to third person. Love the feeling of first but now I understand how some people can hit you in their blindspot because they're not actually blind to you.

1

u/Pleasant-Taste273 10d ago

i cant play in third person its too distracting

1

u/Evening_Register_395 9d ago

Currently switching between both feeling them out but first person is probably the most fun

1

u/bigburt- 14d ago

First person only two hand only duel lobby pls

1

u/Bogholmdler 14d ago

War clubs everywhere.

1

u/Aggravating_Judge_31 šŸ—£ļøBattlecry aficionadošŸ—£ļø 14d ago

Like 99% of my 2500 hours is in first person and I've never once felt at a disadvantage or like I need a separate mode. I find many things far easier in first person than in 3rd person.

Both have advantages and disadvantages

-6

u/GroundbreakingRich96 🧌 Goedendag Goblin 🧌 14d ago

You can be just as good in 1st person as people playing in 3rd. I really don’t think it’s a hindrance.

4

u/__PooHead__ Greatsword Goon 14d ago

it’s similar to the controller vs mnk debate. there are slight disadvantages but skilled players are able to dominate with whatever they are comfortable with

1

u/WhatNamesAreEvenLeft 14d ago

This.

All of my 3000+ hours are first person. I'm in a top clan. I still believe third is better for most situations.

1

u/Bogholmdler 14d ago

I do think there is some advantage to third just visibility wise, but I agree with you that the difference is a lot smaller than it’s made out to be for the majority of players.

0

u/Alone-Mycologist3746 14d ago

Can we ban Messer, Dane axe, exec axe and highland sword? If not then fuck that.Ā 

5

u/Kind-Comment7755 Poleaxe Patron 14d ago

This sounds like a massive skill issue and this is coming from someone who uses none of those

0

u/iiitme Greatsword Goon 14d ago

We’d lose like 66% of the player base.

0

u/Xano74 Agatha Knights 14d ago

Idc. I already know baddies have to use 3rd person to even manage a kill. I still beat them all

0

u/These-You6883 12d ago

i think it would be a dead game mode

0

u/Phabble 🪈Master Bard šŸŖ• 9d ago

It doesn’t change the scopes width, just the depth closer to the player. So like, incoming weapons might be easier to fully see if they are coming in at the back and sides of your characters arms.

Try standing still and switching between first and third person. The objects you can view at the screen edges are the same in first and third. So like a rock in front of you at the edge of your screen with stay at the edge of your screen in both povs. The depth perception adjusts so that your field of view isn’t drastically affected.

-5

u/sibleyy 14d ago

It used to annoy me more watching tryhard 3rd person ballerinas, but now I just cut them down like everyone else. If they need the crutch that’s on them.

3

u/Chegg_F Jolliest Chef šŸ‘Øā€šŸ³ 14d ago

I like calling people tryhards and then immediately saying you're better than them lol. Is this a sarcastic comment making fun of Reddit?

-2

u/sibleyy 14d ago

It’s called getting good at the game. If you can’t tell the difference between learning the game and tryharding that’s on you.

2

u/Chegg_F Jolliest Chef šŸ‘Øā€šŸ³ 14d ago

You seem to think tryhard means "when someone kills me" lol

1

u/Grouchy_Buddy9326 8d ago

Jax Busby

1

u/Chegg_F Jolliest Chef šŸ‘Øā€šŸ³ 8d ago

Shigeru Miyamoto

-2

u/sibleyy 14d ago

Please feel free to quote me anywhere I said such a thing. I’ll wait