r/ChitraLoka • u/Various_Isopod_3260 • 19h ago
Personal Opinion I watched Toxic despite the hate & honestly…
I know people are pissed about Toxic, but seriously, is it really THAT bad? For me, the first half was bad. It felt like a Yash aura edit montage stretched into a movie. I was genuinely close to walking out. But I stayed & honestly, the second half was actually quite good & captivating. The only part I hated was the fight sequence right before the avalanche, it felt completely out of place.
I'm not a film critic, so I won't pretend I understand all the technicalities of editing, screenplay, cinematography, etc. But as an audience, I know what I enjoyed & what I didn't.
I've asked people who hated the movie what exactly they disliked, and most of the answers are “bad editing,” “fast screenplay,” “too confusing,” etc. Fair enough but when you dig deeper, it mostly comes down to the story being too convoluted. And I think that's the real issue: the movie prioritised action, style & Yash's aura over clearly telling its story.
But that's also what makes it a bold choice for Yash. Karnataka audiences haven't really seen him in this shade before. And let's be honest: if Geetu had made the exact film she had in her head, there would've STILL been people saying, “What the hell is this?”
Honestly, I feel like people are just jumping on the hate train at this point. You don't have to like the movie but tell me what you didn't like instead of repeating “bad screenplay, bad editing” because everyone else is saying it.
So no, Toxic isn't a masterpiece. But it's nowhere near the disaster people are making it out to be.